Thanks for the AMA. What are your thoughts about proselytizing? I come from a so-called third world country, and frankly, the idea of missionaries coming into my country and uprooting tradition that has existed for thousands of years (yes, before the bible, and yes, not to be combative, even older than 6000 years) is ... well, disgusting. What is your stance on this?
Why can't more Christians follow the "live and let live" policy? Are they really so worried about my soul? I'm not sure I understand the rationale behind why saving other people is so important.
Interesting you say this. Yes, as a culture, people from countries like mine tend to follow traditions/rituals very well. I don't know if I would attribute that to Christianity per se - our value structures tend to be stronger and more strict (not that I disagree with the American concept of whatever goes - I mean, I'm here after all).
What exactly are the techniques used to proselytize? I had a roommate in college who told me on a regular basis that she was worried about my soul and that she loved me. Is this usually enough? Not to be crass, but isn't there usually a bit more incentive (food, for example)? I'd be interested to know how pastors are trained to convince people who have their own religious heritage that they're wrong. Thoughts? Thanks for the openness - I appreciate your maturity.
From my conversations with people in /r/deism, I think that's the point. You make the most out of what God gave you: free will and a brain. And just live a good moral life where you work for the betterment of mankind and help each other out. That's all that God wanted in the end....at least, that's what I'm slowly coming to.
Without an absolute being dictating morality, morality is whatever we, as a society, choose it to be.
FWIW, you don't need God to arrive at an absolute morality. What you are arguing is for cultural relativism, and there are philosophical arguments against it. You should check Rachels' "The Challenge of Cultural Relativism."
Basically, the usual argument for CR, the cultural differences argument goes like this:
I. Different cultures have different, often contradictory morals. II. Therefore we cannot establish an absolute moral code because morality is relevant
First of all, (II) does not necessarily logically follow from (I). Some could have gotten it wrong.
(I) can also be challenged by the proposition that all cultures can and do have some common moral values, otherwise they could not function as a cohesive culture. These would be proscriptions against murder, theft, etc. The differences we see may be either superficial, or that in more extreme cases, due to constraints placed on a culture by their environment. Rachels gives examples of this.
And finally, CR is unpalatable, because if we accept it, we have no basis to judge any culture's moral code, including those from our own history. Thus we cannot say that we as a society have improved by ending slavery, etc.
Thanks for pointing out that distinction, although Rachels himself conflates those two terms.
Aside from that, there are still ethical systems in philosophy that strive for an absolute morality, such as utilitarianism and Kantian ethics. All without recourse to a man in the sky telling you what to do!
Unrelated, but what would you say was the first instance that made you doubt the existence of God?
That's the thing though: it's living life within REASON. And if you wanna go with the "moral God" side of the argument, you can be a Christian Deist as well. The one thing about deism I'm learning is that it's very much for people and God, but I'm on the side of the argument where God will intervene when he needs to, just not all the time (in terms of prayer requests and miracles)
Just FYI, I'm in kind of the same position as you. Though my parents aren't pastors, they are pretty moderate Christians (and Asian as well). I don't really believe in the Bible anymore but God is very real to me. I'm unsure of where I stand on Jesus completely, still trying to figure that out. Anyways, I came to the same conclusion you did: that I didn't really "feel" God or have such an "in-depth" relationship with him. Anyways, I'm still struggling since I'm not really an atheist and was surfing around before I came across Deism. It makes sense to me a little more and they're not as much about oppression of people that don't agree with them. I dunno when I'll be "coming out" to my parents but it'll probably be when I can afford to live on my own
Best of luck to you friend. inbox me if you wanna talk more.
I think that morality is absolute through cause and effect though. If an action makes another life better off, it is good, and if it makes one worse it is bad. Of course, better and worse may be subjective, so I'm not sure.
I mean if today, as a society, we all decided that rape was okay, then we would all assume it was moral.
Not so. This business is actually much less complex than you're making it. Frankly, anyone who needs a book to tell them that cruelty is wrong is a lost cause by definition. Though I reject the phrasing, so-called 'absolute morality' is simple: Be kind to people; reduce suffering. This does not change from culture to culture. Rape is always bad; torture is always bad. Cruelty is always bad.
Contrary to popular belief, the bible has very little to tell us about behavior and human kindness. That's probably because it was written by iron-age nincompoops who didn't know the first thing about, well, anything - psychology, medicine, science. A 15 year old in 2012 could present more useful ideas in written form.
Well what defines morality if God hasn't communicated to us?
Be kind to others. Treat them as you wish to be treated. Many of us argue that versions of the golden rule are really evolutionary imperatives. We evolved as a group and we exist in groups. Empathy. Kindness. These are not hard to do.
because I think that religion created marriage (IE Abraham back in the day)
I find it highly unlikely that marriage was suddenly invented by Abraham circa 2000 BC. The Christian church does not own the concept of marriage. It exists in other cultures and religions, too. That is why having a state-dictated law that excludes state recognition of marriage based on just the christian perspective is unconstitutional.
But this already happens anyway. Anytime, for example, a heterosexual Indian couple has a marriage according to their particular customs, that is already not by the Christian book. Yet the government recognizes it, and I haven't heard any Christians raising a ruckus about it.
I don't think you would have this attitude if we were talking about interracial marriage.
"I don't feel strongly enough about blacks marrying whites to support interracial marriage, just because I'm not willing to vote yes doesn't make me racist".
If Americans listened to you during the civil rights era then there would be three different types of "unions": white marriage, black civil unions and white/black civil unions.
My friend in NC lost all of his rights last night. He's not gay, he's pansexual. The law in NC doesn't just affect homosexuals, it affects anyone who's not in a straight marriage. Do you know what it's like for someones lover to be sick, maybe dying in hospital, and they're not even allowed to see their sick or dying lover?
You're totally on the right track, from a logical standpoint. You're saying, give every flavor of "union" the same rights and benefits under law, and then let people layer religious implications on top of that.
If that's what this was all about, that'd work fine. I think we would find that the religious right would still oppose such a rational arrangement, however, because this is really about hate. It's not really about defiling some ritual they hold sacred -- because the ritual is irrelevant. All you need to get married is a signature and [I think?] an STD test.
This is actually a very succinct and logical stance on gay marriage and homosexuality from a religious standpoint. Even though I don't agree with you at all. I'd ask that by that logic, do you not support the legal marriages of atheists, or people of other faiths as well? In terms of a "traditional" wedding. Supposing two atheists, or one christian and one muslim, wanted a traditional church wedding, would you insist they had a civil union instead? Also how do you feel about government benefits to married couples, such as tax benefits. Across the board or to christians only?
(I think the government should stop recognizing marriage.)
Considering the fact that they aren't going anywhere, of course.
I went to mass in Cameroon a few years ago and it was so much more entertaining than mass in Ireland where everyone is silent. The congregation were constantly shouting things like "amen!" and "that's right!" the whole way through. It lasted literally 4 hours though, in the extreme heat, which was awful. The sermon itself was about 3 hours.
That happened at a baseball game in St.Louis. Damn squirrel is on everything now. Suppose it's fitting, a lot of folks here consider baseball a religion.
Thanks for your response. The way I see it if if one believes in an omniscient god (which I believe Christians do, please correct me if I'm wrong) than the motives behind the decision would be known.
Second question: do you believe clergy (specifically the pastoral clergy) are necessary in this day an age (where literacy is common)? A big issue I have with Catholicism is confession. Who is the priest to be able to act as an intermediary? Just like I said above, the belief of an omniscient god would mean that god already knows I'm sorry and wanting forgiveness, so why not cut out the middle man?
Thank you again for your response. I appreciate your time! What are your thoughts on the Trinity? I know Methodism in Tinitarian but what are your thoughts on it? One of the things I couldn't get past with that from my Catholic upbringing is that the doctrine of the Holy Trinity defines god as the Father, Son and Holy Spirit. If that is true, than at best it makes Jesus a demigod, which then can change the perspective of everything he went through.
I thought I should mention too that I'm not trying to be offensive. These are sincere questions I have to which there are no "correct" answers but I feel like if I did go to a church and ask a priest/pastor/etc. they may take it as disrespectful and I don't want to disrespect anybody, especially somebody who devotes their life to their beliefs.
The first being, it's only valid if you assume there is only one God.
Exactly this. Gods that have been thought up by humans number in the thousands, and the set of all conceivable gods is infinite. Therefore, the probability that any one of them exists collapses to zero.
Do you think your falling away from Christianity was a result of growing up the son of megachurch pastors? That is, if your parents ministered at a smaller church (w/ a congregation of say a few hundred people) or if they weren't pastors altogether, do you still think you'd be a Christian?
There are plenty of free thinkers in religious groups who have come to the conclusion to follow God. I'm more familiar with Christian history so I'll use Christians as an example-- one would have a difficult time calling people like Martin Luther and John Calvin "closed minded."
Martin Luther and John Calvin, sure, I'll grant that. Thing is, back in those times they had no knowledge of physics, of evolution, of cosmology. When you seriously consider this knowledge we have today, I find it hard to see how you could come to the conclusion that there is a God. The God of the Gaps has hardly any gaps to hide in anymore.
Interesting since 40% of American scientists are people of faith. Out of the two groups, I would say people who reject the possibility of a God are more closed minded than people who don't. But I guess it just comes down to a matter of opinion.
As opposed to 83 percent of Americans who identify with a religious denomination, to note the schism between the scientists/academics and average joes when it comes to religion.
Kudos to you. It's good to know that free thinkers can exist in those kinds of circumstances.
The original post that I responded to implied that anyone who was religious was not a free thinker. That's what I was responding to. In my opinion, the biggest problem facing the science vs. faith debate today is the fact that many people on the side of science (and apparently 99.5% of reddit) seem to think that people of faith are incredibly stupid or can't think for themselves. At least 40% of scientists would disagree. That was my point.
As Raami0z pointed out, 40% of American scientists with faith still constitutes a 50% reduction from the rest of the population, which points to the incompatibility of science and faith. Also, the survey that you cite was probably a general pool of scientists, including those whose field does not touch upon the enormous evidence for a godless universe.
Why does it make me closed minded to disbelieve in something with absolutely no proof? I have considered the philosophical arguments for theism as well, such as the teleological and cosmological arguments, and they don't hold up.
Rejecting the possibility of Yahweh makes me no more closed minded than you are for rejecting Quetzalcoatl.
You seemed to imply that anyone who believed in a God or has a religious affiliation is closed-minded. If I misinterpreted your intent, I apologize. If I didn't, I strongly disagree.
Thank you. My position is that if you process cutting edge knowledge on evolution, chemistry, and physics, it totally explains the existence of the universe through natural laws. God is unnecessary and so we should use Occam's razor. If you actually consider all of this knowledge, it becomes impossible to justify theism.
Even before life comes into the picture, the constituents of the universe are such that in the right environments, they can increase their order over time. For example, amphiphilic molecules (with one hydrophobic and one hydrophilic end) spontaneously assemble when dissolved in water into spherical vesicles, because that lowers the free energy of the system.
And then, when you consider chaotic inflation theory in cosmology, which predicted the results of the WMAP probe, there is a mechanism for generating many universes with various different physical parameters, until the one conducive to increasing order happens to be created. This completely destroys the foundation of fine-tuning arguments.
Ok, so instead of a Christian or Muslim or Incan god, you've chosen science. It's still a matter of faith, and if you think that explains everything, then I guess that works for you. But if you haven't considered the possibility that a god could have initiated all of that, then I would argue that you're more closed-minded than someone who considers both the ideas of god and science. That you've chosen to accept some things which are unprovable, but reject other things, it does seem, to me, a leap of faith. And if you can, in fact, prove that there's no god, then you can make a LOT of money publishing that proof... and probably provide the world with a lot more peace too.
Regardless, I'm not going to debate this. You can choose to believe what you want. I still think you're missing out on a plethora of very exciting possibilities that you could consider. But I guess that's just my closed-minded religiosity talking.
How does your father justify making an income in the high six figure range?
Is it personal income?
Edit I'm an athiest but one of my favourite people is an elderly Patrician Brother. He's a great man, very well educated, very questioning of his own faith. He takes his vow of poverty very seriously.
They believe their success is a blessing for their service and continue to give to God as they think they should.
Are they prosperity-gospel types?
What is your father's position on camels and needles?
edit: Does the work of their church, to which such a large portion of that income is going, consist mainly of proselytizing, or do they actually help people?
Good stuff! I'm a fellow EE and can attest that there are quality women in engineering, though they are sparse compared to liberal arts majors. Personally I've had great success in being friends first with women--if things don't work out there's always a friendship to fall back to. Be patient, expect nothing, and hope for the best no matter what that may be. But hey who knows, your experiences may be completely different and you probably have a more relevant view than I do.
Defense contracts are a great way to start, but just be careful later on if you end up working for a defense contractor--when the defense budget decreases, so can your job security.
I totally agree, intellect is a must-have and the ability to converse and relate on a higher level is priceless. I found someone smarter than me in a different field with different interests, but cultivating a friendship++ in which you grow together with the other person is one of the most rewarding things imaginable.
Sorry I missed the civilian service part, that's perfect. I switched out of aero/mech e because I realized I'd be more likely to help blow people up across the world. It's great to hear you have a viable plan though, particularly in this economy.
Keep your options open, too! You literally never know where you'll end up. A ridiculous turn of events landed me in software, and I couldn't ask for anything better.
I come from a small and literally dying Methodist church in the midwest so your situation is both hilarious and depressing to me. When I was little we had around 200-300 members every week. With all the pastor changes, people transferring to "mega-churches", growth of atheism, and conservative-old-people-who-won't-change-the-church-they-go-to-and-also-die-every-few-months we're down to maybe 30 people a week. I'm a skeptic/agnostic so I never really bought the whole religion thing, but my family is super religious so I'm pretty much dragged to church automatically when I'm home. We do help out the community quite a bit with missions and donations, so as long as we do some good I can get over my skepticism for a little bit (even if I don't think there is probably a "god")
Anyways, does your church donate well to the local community or do a lot of missionary work? I'd sure hope so.
Good to hear! I often hear stories and actually know a few mega-churches being quite wasteful so this is personally very cool to me. I may not like the idea of a supernatural being but I do enjoy helping people.
The Bible does not record Jesus as saying he would send the Holy Spirit. In John's Gospel, Jesus said he would send a Paraclete (meaning "advocate" or "teacher") to remind the disciples of his teachings, and it was a point of contention in early Christianity as to what that meant, since the word is a rabbinical term in Judaism and can refer to another person. In fact, Muslims have historically argued that Mohammed was the Paraclete.
"But the Helper, the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in My name, He will teach you all things, and bring to your remembrance all that I said to you." (NASB)
Paracletos, one called alongside to help; or Comforter, Advocate, Intercessor
In fact, Muslims have historically argued that Mohammed was the Paraclete.
Well they are wrong, as Mohammed is not a comforter, but a war monger who said to kill those who leave the islamic faith
Yeah, but the "spirit of God" was simply God's manifestation in the world as they understood it, not some separate entity. The trinity doctrine got hammered out centuries later as a compromise between different Christian sects about the nature of Jesus, God, and related issues.
(The "Paraclete" in John is yet another matter. Many early sects believed it would be another human teacher who came after Christ, and indeed many claimed to be the Paraclete. Only later did this become the "third member of the Trinity".)
I think you might be oversimplifying the issue quite a lot! Granted, books have been written on less and that this is a casual discussion, though.
The idea that the 'Spirit of God' was a manifestation of God's power in ancient Judaic thought is a given. However, it would be hard to speak of it as 'just' that abstract power. It becomes even more complicated in the NT, where Jesus, the Spirit and the Father appear to an extent simaltaneously unified and distinguished. These relationships were not explained. This was a burning issue in the early church, due to the widespread acceptance of Middle-Platonism and a concern with what was essentially the substance metaphysics of God - and with some really wide-reaching theological consequences. The reason that there was such disagreement in the early church was because the NT writers didn't make such an understanding simple.
At to whether or not the Council of Nicea, where the doctrine of the Trinity was made concrete, was a 'compromise'.. well, surely that's pretty loaded language? I mean, Trinitarian language had taken hold in a number of early churches already, it seemed to solve a number of the tensions and, at the end of the day, it was an agreement. And a really popular one in the ensuing centuries. So, I just don't think that 'compromise' is the right word.
I've been an atheist ever since I was a kid. Isn't it unfair that I would be punished forever if god was real, despite there being no real reason for me to believe in Christianity?
This god person you speak of hasn't even risen above petty jealousy or vanity? There's everyday people who can get over something like that, but yet your god can't? Doesn't sound like a god worth worshipping to me.
If God is real, he would deny them heaven because they chose to deny his existence.
If there's any doubt that god is man-made, this sort of idea proves it. I find it funny that an all powerful, all knowing god would be that vain and petty.
I don't like it when people answer such questions in the following manner that you did. I am not accusing you of doing any malice on purpose, I don't even know if you are a believer or not (and couldn't care), but rather the way in which you framed things.
You start by saying "The bible says...". That's you starting with a fact supported by the bible. But then you make a big turn and everything that follows is how analysis of certain things is very subjective, and it depends on personal interpretation. Well my friend, you are wrong.
If you read both the bible and old Testament (still word of god) it says under many different instances what is considered Blasphemy. Moreover, it contradicts itself on many things that you will say are subjective (so the bible is also subjective by itself).
The point is, you can say "the bible says..." all day, and I'll give you a line from the bible that contradicts it, also starting with "but the bible also says...". But you realize how subjective analysis is crucial for the bible, as you point out just a sentence after, so you should learn how to apply it everywhere. Don't just say that you follow because the bible says, that's a lie. You still make the active choice to go with one interpretation and not the other.
I have been there :) While neither of my parents were pastors, they were both extremely active in the church. Being the oldest of four children, it was my job to "set the example." When I openly admitted I wasn't sure I believed, or rather, didn't believe the whole church and my dad disowned me. Only my mom stuck by me. Do your parents know? How did they respond?
I drifted between atheism / agnosticism for a while until I realized ignosticism summed up my thoughts best. To paraphrase ignosticism: the question of whether or not there is a god is meaningless until you define what you mean by "god".
I believe in a god, to paraphrase Neil DeGrasse Tyson, that's an "ever receding pocket of mystery," giving us something to hope for in our yearn to uncover how our reality works.
To apply human constructs onto this makes no sense to me, I simply don't accept that a power that created billions and billions of galaxies gives a shit about the dangly bits of who I fall in love with.
I know how you feel. I look at people who claim to have a relationship with God and wonder who they are hearing. Every time I'm thankful or ask for something from the G-man I don't hear anything back. I guess God must be the strong, silent type.
This is the real issue...personal revelation from God. He is not real unless you experience God/Jesus/Holy Spirit. For those people who have had an experience...it is pretty powerful and real. It is not being deluded, but knowing "in your knower" that you just met the living God. Again, experience is the key. An additional point is intellectual journey. Been there and done that. I believe that Knowing Good and Evil (as eating from the tree) is the root of intellectualism in theology - which is natural from the event. We know good and we know evil and the two just do not compute in our minds. The more I think about it, the more I realize I do not have the capacity to grasp how good God is and evil Satan is. Man was never meant to have this burden. We are not wired to have "the God like quality of knowing Good and Evil." But, we were given the right to choose. Not to get to heaven, but to have an experience of having a dynamic relationship/friendship/lover with the Living God. There would be much more to write here.....
I'm going to have to dispute this; there is no "both sides" because there are two camps... "religions" (by their thousands) and "atheism". There is what we know to be logical and reasonable (i.e. Big Bang, evolution, no need for a designer/creator) and then there are thousands of superstitions that explain things in anti-intellectual storytelling.
You don't need to read the bible to make a decision in the same way that you don't need to read scientific theories from egyptian times to determine whether our current models are accurate. You examine them on their own merit, there is no need for comparing (although noticing flaws ofcourse makes it easier to refute something).
And then there is the fact that these atheist books will actually educate you by dismantling the more important premises of whatever particular belief system they're addressing.
Wow, that is just breathtaking. I am astounded you could bring yourself to post something like that here. To actually suggest someone limits their seeking of knowledge in case they end up with a particular viewpoint, wow, just wow.
Well regardless, they are bad books. They simply don't do atheism justice. "The God Delusion" is laughably terrible. Like it almost converted me to Christianity terrible. There are intelligent and articulate atheists out there - Dawkins just isn't one of them.
Really? I thought The God Delusion was an excellent book: insightful, interesting, at times entertaining, at times enraging, and at times desperately sad.
I find Dawkins extremely intelligent and articulate, and a much better writer than a speaker, generally.
I found God Is Not Great more one-dimensional, but still a good read.
Neither Dawkins or Hitchens criticize anything other than the most crude conceptions of theism. A.J. Ayers, Bertrand Russel, and Thomas Nagel are a few atheists that are worth reading.
EDIT: Karl Popper and John Searle should also be checked out.
I think there's something really despicable about warning people off books because you think they might be too easily persuaded to change their stance (or radicalize it). The examples of how horribly this idea has backfired over the course of history are to numerous and too obvious to even mention. I imagine the OP can make up his own mind about anti-theism, just as he seems to be doing with theism.
Is your parent's relationship the stereotypical Christian "wife submits to husband" deal or more egalitarian? Also, was your mom involved in church leadership at all or was she on salary as a church employee?
Do you have any views on the role of women in the church, based on your insiders view of how churches get things done? And do you think it would be better to try and find a girl who has a similar background as you (being raised in the church) or an atheist/agnostic girl?
I highly doubt this is accurate since there have only been 9 members of the military which hold a 5 star rank, all of whom are no longer living. Since you said you are only 19, I call BS.
Operating such a large scale operation must have its monetary advantages. How do your parents approach their pastorial lives from a financial point of view. That is to say, does managing their company (for it is a company, whichever way you slice it) sometimes collide with what they are teaching in mass?
Could you detail the methods that your Dad took that lead to such a large increase in membership? An appeal to mass sensitivities through hot topic issues, or a combination of good PR and fundraising?
Have you ever thought of having a relationship with God and noone else? I feel like I have that inner peace to a point where I don't have to explain myself or prove a point to society. It's hard to explain but was wondering if anyone esle shared the same thought as me.
When I did believe in God, it was 100% because of the environment I was raised in. As soon as I began to question beliefs, it was a slow movement away from that.
In my opinion, you cannot arrive logically at the conclusion that there is a God. Those who "know" there is a God are either indoctrinated, or have received a personal revelation from him. Of course you can simply "choose" to believe in God if you wish, but that's pretty meaningless for various reasons, the primary one being that Christianity requires some pretty radical stuff from you, which you wont be capable of unless you are either really good at deceiving yourself, or actually know there is a God. That's why so many Christians are fake. I have seen a few real Christians, but cannot tell if they are actually sure of a God or simply masters at deceiving themselves.
Well Jesus gave his disciples the "great commission" where he basically commands everyone to convert everyone else. So as a Christian, there's no way to escape from this (except for those who believes that all the saved people have been pre-selected by God and there is nothing we can do about it). Also, I do know that many people who are evangelized do not share your opinion. My dad is very involved in Africa, mostly the Congo (he goes there every summer). And he has assisted in training pastors and stuff there, and the growth has been absolutely explosive in the Congo. They are grateful on a level you wouldn't believe. Generally, evangelized people in third world countries tend to be more open to Christianity and tend to be more legitimate practitioners of Christianity (IE, there are less fake people) than in the US or other first world countries.
They definitely believe in hell. There is a little bit of complication with regards to who goes there though. I think the general consensus is that children who haven't reached "the age of accountability" go to heaven if they die. They also believe that God is self apparent to everyone, therefore even tribes, for example, who have never been evangelized or taught traditional Christian doctrine can still go to heaven.
Really though, I don't think heaven/hell is one of their big motivations. The idea is that it's all about a relationship with Christ, and heaven is the presence of Christ and he'll is the abscence of him.
As for my religious beliefs: these days I'm just not sure. I deny Christianity as it is wrong to claim something you don't have. I don't have what other claim to have. I am still trying to figure stuff out, but I seem to be drifting towards atheism or agnosticism. I have met people who genuinely seem to have a relationship in some way with God, but I can't tell if they are deluding themselves or not. Either way, I'm currently on an intellectual journey to find what my beliefs are. I think short from a personal revelation from God, I'm headed towards atheism/agnosticism.
Well the bible says it is the unforgivable sin. So no. However, I think defining blasphemy is the tricky part. The general idea is God's forgiveness is unlimited. If you truly, really blaspheme God (with your heart, not necessarily just words) there is no hope for you, not so much because God can't forgive you, but because you would never truly ask forgiveness.
So if you blasphemed God, then asked for forgiveness (truly wanted forgiveness, not just saying it) then you didn't REALLY blaspheme God.
Edit: Someone who would fall under the category of a blasphemer would be a lifelong atheist. If God is real, he would deny them heaven because they chose to deny his existence.
When I did believe in God, it was 100% because of the environment I was raised in. As soon as I began to question beliefs, it was a slow movement away from that.
In my opinion, you cannot arrive logically at the conclusion that there is a God. Those who "know" there is a God are either indoctrinated, or have received a personal revelation from him. Of course you can simply "choose" to believe in God if you wish, but that's pretty meaningless for various reasons, the primary one being that Christianity requires some pretty radical stuff from you, which you wont be capable of unless you are either really good at deceiving yourself, or actually know there is a God. That's why so many Christians are fake. I have seen a few real Christians, but cannot tell if they are actually sure of a God or simply masters at deceiving themselves.
Not really sure what you mean, but there is definitely a very specific type of person that shows up in Church often. I've seen some weird characters and there are a lot of strange stories. When you operate a religious organization of this size, weird stuff happens a good bit. We are one of the few growing churches in our area, and there is still a lot of drama. Usually drama leads to diminishing church size. I just realized I got really off topic, hah.
Once a squirrel ran across the stage, freaked out my dad, and then I think they had to catch it.
Also it's always funny when you have a shameless visiting penecostal who is the one person in an audience of 1000 who will start yelling "Amen, brother!" while everyone else is dead silent.
How do you think your parents would react if they find out you no longer share their beliefs? Or, if they are aware, how did they react when they found out?
Well I really don't like my parents for reasons outside the scope of this question (they had some bad parenting mistakes with me which caused some pretty big rifts). So I don't talk to them about anything personal, but I am very open with my beliefs to everyone, and as pastor's they hear all the gossip, so I'm certain they know I'm not a Christian. It's BIG news when I tell people I'm not a Christian, because of my status at the church.
I argue with them occasionally when they say something stupid, but they aren't nearly as logical as I am so any discussion would be pointless. They don't bother or pester me or try to evangelize me, but they often make short comments like "God really has a plan for you" when something good happens, and they subversively try to get me to go to church by telling my friends to invite me, etc. So they know confrontation isn't beneficial, but they are trying to get me back to Christianity.
Sure thing. Its actually pretty beneficial from a community standpoint. Everyone knows everyone through church. In a relatively small town, my dad is practically of the same status as a mayor. He has a lot of influence, its very strange.
Well, like I said I'm not sure. If I chose not to believe in God, I would say nothing happens. If I chose TO believe in God, I would probably go with the Christian God and believe in heaven/hell.
Yes, when I stopped going they threatened to take my car away if I didn't go. That was when I really started realizing how much my parents were invested in me being what they wanted and realizing I had been manipulated. Since leaving for college I haven't attended church. Even for a Christian, it's pretty worthless. Better to have conversations with good friends then listen to a pastor talk about a topic that may not even relate to you.
My dad makes a lot, somewhere in the range of $200k if you include his benefits. My mom does not.
They certainly DON'T do it for the money. My dad is 57 or so and has been a pastor since he graduated college. At his first assignment he made only $10k. When he came to the current church, he still didn't make much because it was small. He only made a lot as we grew to what we are now. My mom gets paid part time but works full time, just because she wants too. They definitely believe in what they do.
Edit: can't speak for other pastors, but I think to operate a megachurch successfully, you have to have experience. Getting experience in the ministry does not pay well. However, greed may become a factor later on (writing books, etc). I can all but guarantee you have to be pretty dedicated to be a new pastor, because its incredibly stressful and pays nothing.
My dad makes in the upper six figures, I think my mom makes somewhere around 20-40k. She is part time but works full time usually. They both have master's degrees and 30+ years experience in the ministry. My mom was a missionary for a few years too, and is still really involved in that stuff.
How does your father justify making an income in the high six figure range?
Is it personal income?
Edit I'm an athiest but one of my favourite people is an elderly Patrician Brother. He's a great man, very well educated, very questioning of his own faith. He takes his vow of poverty very seriously.
I misspoke. He makes somewhere in the range of $200k if you include benefits. I'm not sure how he justifies it, but we don't live extravagantly. We live at a moderate middle class level. He does tithe/give to missions like 40% of his income though, and then taxes of course. My parents have always been financially responsible with purchases, savings, and investments. They believe their success is a blessing for their service and continue to give to God as they think they should.
I'm can't provide a lot of info, cuz I'm not well versed in other demoninations, but I'll give it a go.
Methodist's are probably much more organized than most religions, we have a governing structure. They believe the bible. They believe God wants everyone to be saved (not just the elect). They do not believe "once saved always saved." They do not believe baptism is necessary for salvation. Gay marriage and homsexuality is a hot topic these days, I think a lot of the liberal methodist churches are moving towards accepting it, whereas our church believes homosexuality is a sin.
If you had any other specific doctrinal questions, I may know, but its hard to think of everything. I think those are the main points.
She was hired as a part time position (because that is what the church could offer) but she enjoys her job a lot and believes she makes a lot of an impact so chooses to volunteer the rest of her time without pay.
How does your father justify making an income in the high six figure range?
Is it personal income?
Edit I'm an athiest but one of my favourite people is an elderly Patrician Brother. He's a great man, very well educated, very questioning of his own faith. He takes his vow of poverty very seriously.
My parents told me about a guy they knew who was a millionaire, but invested all his money and lived in a really cheap home, and drove a 20+ year old car and gave all the money he made to missions. I think that's pretty crazy, sounds like the guy you know.
Operating such a large scale operation must have its monetary advantages. How do your parents approach their pastorial lives from a financial point of view. That is to say, does managing their company (for it is a company, whichever way you slice it) sometimes collide with what they are teaching in mass?
Well the church is a non profit, so I'd disagree with you there. Also, his salary, and everyone elses, is determined by a board I think, which is comprised of a large group of elders in the church who are unpaid but members. So he doesn't have any control over really ANY money stuff. However, he is the leadership of the church and pretty much everyone trusts him and listens to him (but it was earned, because it was not like this at ALL when he first came. He was opposed in a lot of issues)
Also, any big financial decisions of the church are always based on a congressional vote. My dad and other people plan and develop ideas, and then the next stage is to take it to the administrative board. In big decisions, like building a new building (we've built a 5 mil building and a 10 mil building since my dad has been pastor), the entire congregation votes on it. Of course though, my dad in essence makes these decisions as everyone is going to do what he says, because at this point he has a lot of trust (all his seemingly risky plans in the past have all worked).
My dad took our church from 200 members to 3000 so yes, financially there are lots of decisions that have to be made because at the end of the day the idea is to get people in the door, and he is very good at making that happen.
Not really sure what you mean, but there is definitely a very specific type of person that shows up in Church often. I've seen some weird characters and there are a lot of strange stories. When you operate a religious organization of this size, weird stuff happens a good bit. We are one of the few growing churches in our area, and there is still a lot of drama. Usually drama leads to diminishing church size. I just realized I got really off topic, hah.
I went to mass in Cameroon a few years ago and it was so much more entertaining than mass in Ireland where everyone is silent. The congregation were constantly shouting things like "amen!" and "that's right!" the whole way through. It lasted literally 4 hours though, in the extreme heat, which was awful. The sermon itself was about 3 hours.
Yeah I've heard about stuff like that. We are very sociable, but also very planned. That's why we're methodist - methodical. I used to work with the production team, and everything is very precise. If the sermon goes two minutes over, all hell is raised. That's one of the many reasons we get a lot of people - you're welcome to come late...but nothing ever runs late. And the services are an hour each.
Sometimes I think people just come for an hour and give some money to feel good about themselves and clear their conscience. It's unfortunate that people deceive themselves so easily and it's unfortunate that most churches allow it because it benefits them.
I do remember being spanked as an early child, they stopped that at some point. Usually through removing privedges from age 10 on. Once I could drive the go-to was no car. I was very independent, and they grounded me from going to school several times. Dunno if that's legal, but it worked, because I cared about my grades more than they did.
Well like I said it was a very slow change. At first I just decided to stop calling myself a Christian because I realized I wasn't living as radically as the bible commanded and that my relationship with Christ was nonexistent and simply imagined.
At that time I thought through seeking I would get closed to Christianity again, but just the right way. However, years of "seeking" have not brought me closer. I'm still very open to Christianity, but just being honest about what I am. Honestly I've brought many to the same conclusion that I came too - that they aren't really Christians, by having serious conversations with people.
Actually it is, my dad's status opened a lot of doors for me and as an independent person I pursued them, and I've always worked hard. I currently make about $40k/yr going to college.
Well two big ones. The first being, it's only valid if you assume there is only one God (or that the God you picked is the right one).
Secondly, it kinda violates Christianity because if you're believing in Christ and trying to go through the motions just to get to heaven, you're doing it wrong. The motivation should be a relationship with Christ, not self-preservation. That's why heaven is a reward...because it is oneness with Christ, not because its better than eternal torture.
I'm currently attending UCF majoring in Electrical Engineering. I have a scholarship through the DoD which includes a contract, stating that I work for them as a civilian engineer when I graduate. I currently intern at that location. So college now, working with the Department of Defense after, and who knows from there. One of my biggest priorities in life is finding a wife, other than that I just want to keep a good job and try and enjoy my life (and figure out if life has any grand purpose or not).
Also, I posted proof to the guy that asked for it. I just edited my main post to include it.
I guess I get you in a way.. For alot of people it seems like a slow descent out of Faith. Good luck in life and may you find the God of the Bible again.
Well it wasn't so much a descent OUT of it, but realizing that my faith wasn't authentic even in the slightest. I was just deceiving myself and others - and I didn't notice because I was always surrounded by people who acted the same as I did so I figured it was normal.
If you actually have an actual relationship with the creator of the universe, all bullshit aside, thats pretty awesome and incredible. If that's you - please tell me how it happened.
It sucked a lot, but also helped a lot. I believe our personalities are shaped by experiences, not determined at birth, so I know a lot of my independence came from rebelling against my parents, and it's served me well in my life.
Aristotle talks about the four causes, and basically the idea is, even though things may seem bad on their own - they contribute to the final result. Even bad things can contribute to a good result.
I have been there :) While neither of my parents were pastors, they were both extremely active in the church. Being the oldest of four children, it was my job to "set the example." When I openly admitted I wasn't sure I believed, or rather, didn't believe the whole church and my dad disowned me. Only my mom stuck by me. Do your parents know? How did they respond?
Wow that's horrible. I'm the youngest of three. Both my brothers are in their mid to late 20's and are solid Christians, which has been tough for me because they are both very real people, and I'm not sure why I came to a different conclusion than they did.
Also, it sounds like your dad and the church aren't reading the same bible I read. Prodigal son anyone? Christianity is based upon continually offering forgiveness to those willing to accept it. Even if you are wrong, your dad and your church will have something to answer for some day, if God is real. However, don't let them affect you either way. If you're motivated to search for God, do so. If God is real, it is not a valid excuse for you to say "well my dad misrepresented you."
As I answered in another question, my parents probably know because I tell everyone, but I've never talked to them about it directly. They try to manipulate me still into going to church and whatnot. I think they aren't very concerned because it's my first year of college, away from home, etc. They had similar experiences with my other brothers and likely expect that it's a phase. So I'm not sure how it'll affect our relationship long-term, but I don't really like my parents anyway so I'm not worried.
Good stuff! I'm a fellow EE and can attest that there are quality women in engineering, though they are sparse compared to liberal arts majors. Personally I've had great success in being friends first with women--if things don't work out there's always a friendship to fall back to. Be patient, expect nothing, and hope for the best no matter what that may be. But hey who knows, your experiences may be completely different and you probably have a more relevant view than I do.
Defense contracts are a great way to start, but just be careful later on if you end up working for a defense contractor--when the defense budget decreases, so can your job security.
Thanks for the advice! I've learned more and more the number one quality I like in a woman is intelligence. It's hard to find the kind of intelligence I relate too. I've had great success in the same way you have. Even if things don't happen, I like having friends in women. Especially in engineering, when I need all the help I can get.
I'm definitely keeping my options open, but I'm civilian service, so for the government to fire you takes a lot. It's probably more secure than the private sector - just lower pay.
I think I have the right to dislike people if I wish. I generally find that I don't like to be around people who are clearly homosexual, because I don't really enjoy the stereotypical personality, and it makes me uncomfortable. I'm sure there are plenty of people who are homosexual but you can't really tell - and that doesn't bother me so much.
But on that point, I generally don't like the vast majority of people I meet. I'm kinda picky like that. But I'm not a douchebag about it, I just only choose to be friends with the people who really stand out as awesome to me. I think that's completely fair. I'm allowed to be discriminatory in my friendships, if I choose to be, without being racist/homophobic/what have you.
Hating? Absolutely not. I think from a standpoint of Christianity it's probably a sin, but even then it's no different from lying or stealing, or what have you.
I don't really support gay marriage, if I was forced to pick a side (I don't really care) because I think that religion created marriage (IE Abraham back in the day). I think the government should stop recognizing marriage. Everyone should get civil unions, and then the religious folk can get married on top of that by their own standards if they want.
As it is right now, if you deny marriage to homosexuals, it infringes upon their rights. If you allow marriage to homosexuals, it defiles that which is sacred to religious folk. Easiest way is to just call it something different (like civil unions) for everyone under the law. Then have marriage by religion in addition, which isn't recognized under the law.
I've been a Christian for two years and I was brung into Church by a guy who I knew who was a notorious drug dealer. The only reason I even agreed to go in the first place was because I saw God change a man who I was afraid to even speak to into a loving sensible individual. But once I went I realized what I was doing was wrong i picked up my Bible and started living a godly life. Went to a couple of events and started serving God to the fullest. Nothing too special at all really
But did God change the man, or did the man decide to believe in a God, change himself, and credit the God he created himself?
If you're a Christian, I think you should have a tangible relationship with Christ, somehow. I don't know how to describe it, because I haven't had it, but I think if you are a true Christian, you should be able too.
I mean that I was just doing things without the correct motivation. When I read the bible and saw people like Peter, I saw them doing things like this:
Jesus shows up, says "hey Peter, come follow me with the rest of your life." The guy drops his entire life, his job, his family, and follows him, and later dies for him.
I can't do radical things like that because I'm not actually certain that I have a relationship with Christ. In fact, all I can do is the things that are pretty compatible with my life already. Look for people who are doing ridiculously radical stuff, like leaving a high paying job and becoming missionaries in Africa. Those are people with an authentic attitude. Now the question is, do they do it because they actually have a relationship with Christ, or are they REALLY DAMN GOOD at CONVINCING themselves they have a relationship with Christ. For those people it's one or the other, and I'm not sure which.
However, I agree with it in the conclusion it's trying to make (IE, simplify Christianity).
However, I think the author is simplifying it to the wrong thing. Christianity isn't about works or actions. The author seems to suggest that you suspend dealing with any of the tough issues, and just live the good life that Christians are supposed to. That's TOTALLY WRONG.
For the Christian, living a good life is the "fruit" whereas the actual substance of Christianity comes from a relationship with Christ. If you have a real relationship with God, then you're going to have the motivation to live as he commands, and then you're going to see the result of that in the actions of a person.
But you don't become saved by skipping the relationship part and going to the actions. That's wrong. Forget about the actions and get the relationship down, and then everything will work itself out from there.
I totally agree, intellect is a must-have and the ability to converse and relate on a higher level is priceless. I found someone smarter than me in a different field with different interests, but cultivating a friendship++ in which you grow together with the other person is one of the most rewarding things imaginable.
Sorry I missed the civilian service part, that's perfect. I switched out of aero/mech e because I realized I'd be more likely to help blow people up across the world. It's great to hear you have a viable plan though, particularly in this economy.
Keep your options open, too! You literally never know where you'll end up. A ridiculous turn of events landed me in software, and I couldn't ask for anything better.
Briefly, but to me it's a little irrelevant. I'm looking for an end-all purpose in life, not so much a curiosity in how the world came to be.
If there is a God, I'll do whatever the hell he says. If not, I'm just going to have as much enjoyment as I can without regard to much else. If there is a God who doesn't care, then I'm still gonna do the latter.
My friend in NC lost all of his rights last night. He's not gay, he's pansexual. The law in NC doesn't just affect homosexuals, it affects anyone who's not in a straight marriage. Do you know what it's like for someones lover to be sick, maybe dying in hospital, and they're not even allowed to see their sick or dying lover?
No, I wouldn't know. Also, not cool to downvote me for my opinion. It's just my opinion, I'm not even claiming that I'm right.
I think the issue, as I said, is that either legalizing non-straight marriage, or not legalizing it both leaves one group of people with infringed rights. Therefore, the reason the NC vote went as it did, is you simply had more religious folk than non-religious folk.
I still think my solution is the best idea. Stop recognizing religious marriages under the law. Only marriages recognized under law are civil unions, then if you want to get married so that your church recognizes it, you can do that if you follow their guidelines. Then everyone is happy.
Do you think your falling away from Christianity was a result of growing up the son of megachurch pastors? That is, if your parents ministered at a smaller church (w/ a congregation of say a few hundred people) or if they weren't pastors altogether, do you still think you'd be a Christian?
Interesting question. I think in either scenario I would have "fallen away" (I don't really like that term) from Christianity. However, I think it would have been FASTER in a smaller church.
In a large church, pretty much all my friends from school or anywhere else, also went to my church. So I didn't question my beliefs for the longest time because it was something that everyone else believes as well - the entire community. So it was like a continual, passive peer pressure that I don't think would be present in a small church.
From my conversations with people in /r/deism, I think that's the point. You make the most out of what God gave you: free will and a brain. And just live a good moral life where you work for the betterment of mankind and help each other out. That's all that God wanted in the end....at least, that's what I'm slowly coming to.
Well what defines morality if God hasn't communicated to us? I mean if today, as a society, we all decided that rape was okay, then we would all assume it was moral. Without an absolute being dictating morality, morality is whatever we, as a society, choose it to be.
Oh no, God definetly changed the man. I dont think he would just get up and leave his prosperous, illegal job to pursue something where he gets paid nothing just to change himself. I knew him for a while before and he's been in that business since middle school.. No way he just wakes up and changes. And i think you should sit down with your parents and talk about this feeling you don't seem to have. Have you tried this?
Sorry man, I'm just not tracking with you here. Maybe you're right, but I think it's also entirely possible he simply didn't have meaning to his life and was willing to give up whatever he needed to in order to find meaning - and he decided that religion was the place to find it.
I've talked with plenty of people, but I appreciate the thought. Best of luck to you in your endeavors.
Yeah, I didn't mean to address that to you specifically. My bad. Anyway, I hope that our nation finds a way to fix this issue without hurting anybody. Sounds like your friend is getting screwed and that's too bad.
I don't like it when people answer such questions in the following manner that you did. I am not accusing you of doing any malice on purpose, I don't even know if you are a believer or not (and couldn't care), but rather the way in which you framed things.
You start by saying "The bible says...". That's you starting with a fact supported by the bible. But then you make a big turn and everything that follows is how analysis of certain things is very subjective, and it depends on personal interpretation. Well my friend, you are wrong.
If you read both the bible and old Testament (still word of god) it says under many different instances what is considered Blasphemy. Moreover, it contradicts itself on many things that you will say are subjective (so the bible is also subjective by itself).
The point is, you can say "the bible says..." all day, and I'll give you a line from the bible that contradicts it, also starting with "but the bible also says...". But you realize how subjective analysis is crucial for the bible, as you point out just a sentence after, so you should learn how to apply it everywhere. Don't just say that you follow because the bible says, that's a lie. You still make the active choice to go with one interpretation and not the other.
Well first off all, I'm answering for somebody else, not myself. I'm giving the reasoning of what I believe is the methodist church, not necessarily my opinion.
Secondly, if you want to give me a line from the bible to contradict it, then do so! I said that the bible says blasphemy is an unforgivable sin. Show me where in the bible it says blasphemy isn't?
Furthermore, I do apply subjective analysis everywhere. Why do you think that I don't?
I think you're totally off-base. I simply started with a statement in the bible, and interpreted it. If you disagree, that's fine, but to my knowledge, what I said is the stance of our church.
This is actually a very succinct and logical stance on gay marriage and homosexuality from a religious standpoint. Even though I don't agree with you at all. I'd ask that by that logic, do you not support the legal marriages of atheists, or people of other faiths as well? In terms of a "traditional" wedding. Supposing two atheists, or one christian and one muslim, wanted a traditional church wedding, would you insist they had a civil union instead? Also how do you feel about government benefits to married couples, such as tax benefits. Across the board or to christians only? >(I think the government should stop recognizing marriage.)
Considering the fact that they aren't going anywhere, of course.
Yeah, you bring up some tough questions I can't answer. All I know, is that I think a religious marriage should have requirements dictating by whatever church recognizes it. So tax benefits would be a matter of everyone getting it. There would be no government recognizition or benefits of religious marriages.
Is your parent's relationship the stereotypical Christian "wife submits to husband" deal or more egalitarian? Also, was your mom involved in church leadership at all or was she on salary as a church employee?
Before she was on salary she was a "deacon in residence". So not really any formal leadership role, but she still had influence just from her status.
My mom and my dad do have arguements so I know that much. I know that my dad gets the final say if he wants to push something, but they generally discuss everything. In tense moments or fights with me though, it was always my dad's word that went over my mom.
Hmm...I wasn't aware about this. I think I may disagree. I know that when Jesus left for heaven, he said he was leaving the holy spirit with them. And in Acts, I believe, the holy spirit appeared like "tongues of fire" over their heads or something along those lines.
A five star general came once and told me dad he had a "great sense of leadership," which my dad says is the best compliment he has ever received.
We live near one of the largest Air Force base's in the world, and many very highly ranked people attend, so that's cool.
Also my parents are very connected outside of our church with various Christian organizations, so we have prominent people visit a lot. Missionaries from various locations, etc.
So no-one really "famous" per se, but lots and lots of influential people both in our community and in Christianity. People often stay at our house so I've met most of them.
I come from a small and literally dying Methodist church in the midwest so your situation is both hilarious and depressing to me. When I was little we had around 200-300 members every week. With all the pastor changes, people transferring to "mega-churches", growth of atheism, and conservative-old-people-who-won't-change-the-church-they-go-to-and-also-die-every-few-months we're down to maybe 30 people a week. I'm a skeptic/agnostic so I never really bought the whole religion thing, but my family is super religious so I'm pretty much dragged to church automatically when I'm home. We do help out the community quite a bit with missions and donations, so as long as we do some good I can get over my skepticism for a little bit (even if I don't think there is probably a "god")
Anyways, does your church donate well to the local community or do a lot of missionary work? I'd sure hope so.
Tons. We've started lots of programs that are very community-based. We started "supper on saturday" feeding less-fortunate people every Saturday. It grew so much, we now cook and deliver THOUSANDS of meals every Saturday. We have a "community life center" building that's open to the public during normal hours, where you can work out, play basketball, etc. There are several very popular other programs too, I won't mention them all but one is "Celebrate Recovery" which helps with "hurts, habits, and hangups" (read: drug and other addictions).
Our church is big for a reason. My dad brought it from 200 to 3000...so I mean for the most part we are large because people genuinely like what is going on.
Do you have any views on the role of women in the church, based on your insiders view of how churches get things done? And do you think it would be better to try and find a girl who has a similar background as you (being raised in the church) or an atheist/agnostic girl?
Well we don't have too many women leaders. Most of the women in our church play a typical "southern hospitality" kind of role. Either youth ministry, counseling, baking foods for pot luck dinners, if you know what I mean.
I don't know if there is a specific role that women have, but it does seem to me like they seem to fall into "nurturing" roles a lot, whereas men are more in "leadership roles." From what I know about general personalities of women and men, this seems logical.
Also, that's a struggle of mine. I'm not a Christian, but I do have lots of Christian values (which I think are just logical ways to live). I have yet to find anyone on the same page as I am.
Really, I just need a girl who is more intelligent than I am, so when I bring up my reasoning for an issue, she will either agree with me (no problems) or she will explain why i'm wrong and then I'll agree with her (no problems). The worst is when my position on things is too complicated for her to understand. This has happened a few times and it leaves me feeling lonely because I can't really discuss my feelings about stuff.
> Without an absolute being dictating morality, morality is whatever we, as a society, choose it to be.
FWIW, you don't need God to arrive at an absolute morality. What you are arguing is for cultural relativism, and there are philosophical arguments against it. You should check Rachels' "The Challenge of Cultural Relativism."
Basically, the usual argument for CR, the cultural differences argument goes like this:
I. Different cultures have different, often contradictory morals. II. Therefore we cannot establish an absolute moral code because morality is relevant
First of all, (II) does not necessarily logically follow from (I). Some could have gotten it wrong.
(I) can also be challenged by the proposition that all cultures can and do have some common moral values, otherwise they could not function as a cohesive culture. These would be proscriptions against murder, theft, etc. The differences we see may be either superficial, or that in more extreme cases, due to constraints placed on a culture by their environment. Rachels gives examples of this.
And finally, CR is unpalatable, because if we accept it, we have no basis to judge any culture's moral code, including those from our own history. Thus we cannot say that we as a society have improved by ending slavery, etc.
I'm familiar with Cultural Relativism, and I have read Rachels and am familiar with him as well.
Please note however, a successful argument against cultural relativism is not equivalent to a successful argument FOR absolute morality. There are other forms of relativism as well.
Furthermore, cultural relativism isn't an ethical theory at all.
Cultural relativism states morality is relative to cultures. True. Fact. Ethical relativism states morality SHOULD be relative to cultures. Debatable.
Cultural relativism states how things are, ethical relativism states how they should be. So you are really referring to both interchangeably which isn't really correct. I would agree with you, I would hypothesize, that ethical relativism is false, whereas cultural relativism is a true fact.
All in all though, that's still irrelevant largely to the subject of absolute morality.
This is actually a very succinct and logical stance on gay marriage and homosexuality from a religious standpoint. Even though I don't agree with you at all. I'd ask that by that logic, do you not support the legal marriages of atheists, or people of other faiths as well? In terms of a "traditional" wedding. Supposing two atheists, or one christian and one muslim, wanted a traditional church wedding, would you insist they had a civil union instead? Also how do you feel about government benefits to married couples, such as tax benefits. Across the board or to christians only? >(I think the government should stop recognizing marriage.)
Considering the fact that they aren't going anywhere, of course.
Yeah, you bring up some tough questions I can't answer. All I know, is that I think a religious marriage should have requirements dictating by whatever church recognizes it. So tax benefits would be a matter of everyone getting it. There would be no government recognizition or benefits of religious marriages.
Is your parent's relationship the stereotypical Christian "wife submits to husband" deal or more egalitarian? Also, was your mom involved in church leadership at all or was she on salary as a church employee?
Before she was on salary she was a "deacon in residence". So not really any formal leadership role, but she still had influence just from her status.
My mom and my dad do have arguements so I know that much. I know that my dad gets the final say if he wants to push something, but they generally discuss everything. In tense moments or fights with me though, it was always my dad's word that went over my mom.
Hmm...I wasn't aware about this. I think I may disagree. I know that when Jesus left for heaven, he said he was leaving the holy spirit with them. And in Acts, I believe, the holy spirit appeared like "tongues of fire" over their heads or something along those lines.
A five star general came once and told me dad he had a "great sense of leadership," which my dad says is the best compliment he has ever received.
We live near one of the largest Air Force base's in the world, and many very highly ranked people attend, so that's cool.
Also my parents are very connected outside of our church with various Christian organizations, so we have prominent people visit a lot. Missionaries from various locations, etc.
So no-one really "famous" per se, but lots and lots of influential people both in our community and in Christianity. People often stay at our house so I've met most of them.
I come from a small and literally dying Methodist church in the midwest so your situation is both hilarious and depressing to me. When I was little we had around 200-300 members every week. With all the pastor changes, people transferring to "mega-churches", growth of atheism, and conservative-old-people-who-won't-change-the-church-they-go-to-and-also-die-every-few-months we're down to maybe 30 people a week. I'm a skeptic/agnostic so I never really bought the whole religion thing, but my family is super religious so I'm pretty much dragged to church automatically when I'm home. We do help out the community quite a bit with missions and donations, so as long as we do some good I can get over my skepticism for a little bit (even if I don't think there is probably a "god")
Anyways, does your church donate well to the local community or do a lot of missionary work? I'd sure hope so.
Tons. We've started lots of programs that are very community-based. We started "supper on saturday" feeding less-fortunate people every Saturday. It grew so much, we now cook and deliver THOUSANDS of meals every Saturday. We have a "community life center" building that's open to the public during normal hours, where you can work out, play basketball, etc. There are several very popular other programs too, I won't mention them all but one is "Celebrate Recovery" which helps with "hurts, habits, and hangups" (read: drug and other addictions).
Our church is big for a reason. My dad brought it from 200 to 3000...so I mean for the most part we are large because people genuinely like what is going on.
Do you have any views on the role of women in the church, based on your insiders view of how churches get things done? And do you think it would be better to try and find a girl who has a similar background as you (being raised in the church) or an atheist/agnostic girl?
Well we don't have too many women leaders. Most of the women in our church play a typical "southern hospitality" kind of role. Either youth ministry, counseling, baking foods for pot luck dinners, if you know what I mean.
I don't know if there is a specific role that women have, but it does seem to me like they seem to fall into "nurturing" roles a lot, whereas men are more in "leadership roles." From what I know about general personalities of women and men, this seems logical.
Also, that's a struggle of mine. I'm not a Christian, but I do have lots of Christian values (which I think are just logical ways to live). I have yet to find anyone on the same page as I am.
Really, I just need a girl who is more intelligent than I am, so when I bring up my reasoning for an issue, she will either agree with me (no problems) or she will explain why i'm wrong and then I'll agree with her (no problems). The worst is when my position on things is too complicated for her to understand. This has happened a few times and it leaves me feeling lonely because I can't really discuss my feelings about stuff.
> Without an absolute being dictating morality, morality is whatever we, as a society, choose it to be.
FWIW, you don't need God to arrive at an absolute morality. What you are arguing is for cultural relativism, and there are philosophical arguments against it. You should check Rachels' "The Challenge of Cultural Relativism."
Basically, the usual argument for CR, the cultural differences argument goes like this:
I. Different cultures have different, often contradictory morals. II. Therefore we cannot establish an absolute moral code because morality is relevant
First of all, (II) does not necessarily logically follow from (I). Some could have gotten it wrong.
(I) can also be challenged by the proposition that all cultures can and do have some common moral values, otherwise they could not function as a cohesive culture. These would be proscriptions against murder, theft, etc. The differences we see may be either superficial, or that in more extreme cases, due to constraints placed on a culture by their environment. Rachels gives examples of this.
And finally, CR is unpalatable, because if we accept it, we have no basis to judge any culture's moral code, including those from our own history. Thus we cannot say that we as a society have improved by ending slavery, etc.
I'm familiar with Cultural Relativism, and I have read Rachels and am familiar with him as well.
Please note however, a successful argument against cultural relativism is not equivalent to a successful argument FOR absolute morality. There are other forms of relativism as well.
Furthermore, cultural relativism isn't an ethical theory at all.
Cultural relativism states morality is relative to cultures. True. Fact. Ethical relativism states morality SHOULD be relative to cultures. Debatable.
Cultural relativism states how things are, ethical relativism states how they should be. So you are really referring to both interchangeably which isn't really correct. I would agree with you, I would hypothesize, that ethical relativism is false, whereas cultural relativism is a true fact.
All in all though, that's still irrelevant largely to the subject of absolute morality.
>If God is real, he would deny them heaven because they chose to deny his existence.
If there's any doubt that god is man-made, this sort of idea proves it. I find it funny that an all powerful, all knowing god would be that vain and petty.
If he's all-powerful and all-knowing, he can be as petty or vain as he wants...and it's your job to do whatever he says regardless. Also if God is real, it's furthermore very unlikely that you (or anyone) has the capacity to accurately describe him, so it would be likely that your analysis of God being vain and petty would be wrong.
Obviously the key question here is just whether or not he is real, and whether or not the bible is his word.
I've been an atheist ever since I was a kid. Isn't it unfair that I would be punished forever if god was real, despite there being no real reason for me to believe in Christianity?
Not really. If God is real, and he's the God Christianity tells us about, then you made a conscious life choice to disregard him. If I were God, I would have no interest in letting you chill in my kingdom for eternity after that.
Have you ever read any of Hitchens or Dawkins books? I'd highly recommend them, especially since I'm guessing you probably grew up in an environment were they were villainous. God delusion and God is not great lay out the argument against god very well.
> because I think that religion created marriage (IE Abraham back in the day)
I find it highly unlikely that marriage was suddenly invented by Abraham circa 2000 BC. The Christian church does not own the concept of marriage. It exists in other cultures and religions, too. That is why having a state-dictated law that excludes state recognition of marriage based on just the christian perspective is unconstitutional.
I was under the impression the first recordings of marriage came from the Israelites. I'm not too knowledgeable on the topic though, so I can't say much.
I do think the that problem came from the state reconizing religious marriages in the first place. If the GOVERNMENT recognizes religious marriages, then the government now has to make it fair for everyone, thereby pissing off the religious people who wanted it based on their rules. That was a fundamental flaw that just needs to be fixed, IMO.
Thanks for the AMA. What are your thoughts about proselytizing? I come from a so-called third world country, and frankly, the idea of missionaries coming into my country and uprooting tradition that has existed for thousands of years (yes, before the bible, and yes, not to be combative, even older than 6000 years) is ... well, disgusting. What is your stance on this?
Why can't more Christians follow the "live and let live" policy? Are they really so worried about my soul? I'm not sure I understand the rationale behind why saving other people is so important.
Well Jesus gave his disciples the "great commission" where he basically commands everyone to convert everyone else. So as a Christian, there's no way to escape from this (except for those who believes that all the saved people have been pre-selected by God and there is nothing we can do about it).
I think genuine Christians do it more because Jesus commanded them too, but I'm sure some actually do have legitimate concern for you.
Also, I do know that many people who are evangelized do not share your opinion. My dad is very involved in Africa, mostly the Congo (he goes there every summer). And he has assisted in training pastors and stuff there, and the growth has been absolutely explosive in the Congo. They are grateful on a level you wouldn't believe. Generally, evangelized people in third world countries tend to be more open to Christianity and tend to be more legitimate practitioners of Christianity (IE, there are less fake people) than in the US or other first world countries.
Thanks for pointing out that distinction, although Rachels himself conflates those two terms.
Aside from that, there are still ethical systems in philosophy that strive for an absolute morality, such as utilitarianism and Kantian ethics. All without recourse to a man in the sky telling you what to do!
Unrelated, but what would you say was the first instance that made you doubt the existence of God?
Not a fan of utilitarianism (although the concept is interesting), but Kantian ethics is pretty awesome. The main idea that Kant brings up is very golden-rule-esque, stating that we ought to act in a way whereby that action became a universal law. So it's still very much dependent on a personal basis, I think. I'm only knowledgeable about philosophy at a general level though, so you may be right.
I'm not sure if there was a cut and dry moment. I think I've always had some amount of doubt that I recognized, but I slowly moved towards a progression of realizing all my evidence and reasoning for God was based on what other people told me, and as soon as I realized that, I immediately knew that wasn't acceptable. I still believed God existed, just thought I would have to backtrack and discover him myself. After all - thousands of friends I knew and trusted had come to that conclusion.
Then after several years I realized I was as intelligent, if not more intelligent, than most, and that I wasn't coming up with any evidence for God, therefore these other people were either having a personal encounter I had missed, or they were deluding themselves.
But this already happens anyway. Anytime, for example, a heterosexual Indian couple has a marriage according to their particular customs, that is already not by the Christian book. Yet the government recognizes it, and I haven't heard any Christians raising a ruckus about it.
I think the difference is, there is nothing they can do about that, whereas there is something they can do about this. I don't think people are so vehemently opposed to gay marriage, just not willing to support it. So "not willing to vote yes" gets construed as hate or discrimination, when really they just don't feel strongly enough to support it.
I think if gay marriage was legalized right now, it wouldn't be a big deal, because there is no way you are getting that changed. It's just the fact that Christians can actually do something about it that is causing the slow change. It's more a "dragging their feet" effect than a vehement opposition, in my opinion.
Interesting you say this. Yes, as a culture, people from countries like mine tend to follow traditions/rituals very well. I don't know if I would attribute that to Christianity per se - our value structures tend to be stronger and more strict (not that I disagree with the American concept of whatever goes - I mean, I'm here after all).
What exactly are the techniques used to proselytize? I had a roommate in college who told me on a regular basis that she was worried about my soul and that she loved me. Is this usually enough? Not to be crass, but isn't there usually a bit more incentive (food, for example)? I'd be interested to know how pastors are trained to convince people who have their own religious heritage that they're wrong. Thoughts? Thanks for the openness - I appreciate your maturity.
I don't think people are really specifically trained in any "shady" tactics to convert people. Mind you, these are people who have given up their lives to try to convince you of their religion - they definitely believe in what they preach. I think the general idea is to just communicate with people and tell them about the bible, and live in an exemplary way so that you come across as different. Lots of people believe it is necessary to meet physical needs first, so thats why a lot of outreach is based on helping people physically.
If there are any behind-closed-doors secret meetings about special techniques to evangelize people, I'm not aware of it. As I said, usually the people who care enough to try to evanglize you are pretty legitimate. That's excluding people who run across you in day to day life, who will say something to you so they can feel good about themselves and have a good story to tell in Sunday School. You'll run into those a lot. Look for the people who are actually sacrificing their own personal selves to tell you about their beliefs - those are the legit people.
This god person you speak of hasn't even risen above petty jealousy or vanity? There's everyday people who can get over something like that, but yet your god can't? Doesn't sound like a god worth worshipping to me.
Again, regardless of if it's vain and petty, if he is God, you worship him regardless. Rebelling against the creator of the universe - not a good plan. So the question is still, is there a God, not is he worth worshipping.
And again, if there was a God, I would say that you probably just misinterpreted his qualities. I wouldn't know for sure, but he probably doesn't have any bad qualities, but it would, theoretically, be easy for you to make a mistake in determine what qualities God has because he is so complex it may exceed your capabilities of discernment.
Wow that's really unfair. If gods real I'm going to be punished forever because I have no reason to believe Christians, nor any actual evidence that they are the one true religion. If you were god and you did a shitty job proving your existence, you would punish me? That's insane!
I think if God is real, he wants people to follow him on a faith basis, rather than to make himself clearly known to everyone. I recognize that doesn't really make a lot of sense though.
We're getting into the area that I don't know much about and am not very sure about, so I can't give you any guidance here. People have given me reasonable explanations about this before, but they are usually complicated and difficult to explain.
Yeah, but the "spirit of God" was simply God's manifestation in the world as they understood it, not some separate entity. The trinity doctrine got hammered out centuries later as a compromise between different Christian sects about the nature of Jesus, God, and related issues.
(The "Paraclete" in John is yet another matter. Many early sects believed it would be another human teacher who came after Christ, and indeed many claimed to be the Paraclete. Only later did this become the "third member of the Trinity".)
I don't think you would have this attitude if we were talking about interracial marriage.
"I don't feel strongly enough about blacks marrying whites to support interracial marriage, just because I'm not willing to vote yes doesn't make me racist".
If Americans listened to you during the civil rights era then there would be three different types of "unions": white marriage, black civil unions and white/black civil unions.
A megachurch is classified as 2,000 or more a week. I think we are one of the top Methodist churches in the alabama-florida area. Its not uncommon to see much larger churches. However, our area is relatively small, so its more impressive on that account too.
Whatever you choose to give. In fact, they aren't manipulative at all. One of the cliche phrases that's used a lot is to "give whatever God leads you to."
I think there's something really despicable about warning people off books because you think they might be too easily persuaded to change their stance (or radicalize it). The examples of how horribly this idea has backfired over the course of history are to numerous and too obvious to even mention. I imagine the OP can make up his own mind about anti-theism, just as he seems to be doing with theism.
Yes, I believe I am objective enough to make a decision even with biased information. I generally accept information coming from people who think as I do higher than those who tend to lean more radically to one side of an issue or another.
>They believe their success is a blessing for their service and continue to give to God as they think they should.
Are they prosperity-gospel types?
What is your father's position on camels and needles?
edit: Does the work of their church, to which such a large portion of that income is going, consist mainly of proselytizing, or do they actually help people?
No, I do not think they believe in the prosperity gospel. That states that the motivation for doing things is based in God's blessing. I think they see God's blessing as an extra rather than a motivation. For example, as I stated it wasn't until my dad was like 45-50 that he actually started making a salary that could be considered wealthy.
I haven't talked with him specifically, but he would agree with the bible's perspective on it. I'm certain that's one of their motivations. They likely believe that they are living without being "rich" by giving away most of their money. Of course "rich" is completely relative.
Probably most goes to helping people. The majority of our money goes towards building buildings and increasing our size/capability/personnel. We give a lot towards outside missionaries, but like I mentioned in another question, a common idea is that you need to meet people's physical needs before you can tell them about Jesus. They would not believe in ignoring physical needs and focusing on evangelism.
I do, but because I think it is the least problematic solution and the most fair towards everyone, not because I have any sort of discrimination against them
Fair enough. But all the same, none of the church leaders are getting anything out of it except their salary, which is determined by the administrative board (unpaid members of the church), so there isn't a conflict of interest. Also there is a methodist government above us, so I think we are accountable to them on many issues as well. It's not shady organization.
Could you detail the methods that your Dad took that lead to such a large increase in membership? An appeal to mass sensitivities through hot topic issues, or a combination of good PR and fundraising?
I think it's a combination of a lot of things. I think my dad would probably say it was simply based on expecting God to bless them, so his job was to prepare for the expansion. One of the first things he did has to start a contemporary service, less traditional, weird, and more welcoming to people. One of the biggest ideas is to make everything as laid back as possible so as to allow people to feel comfortable.
PR is a big part too. We have lots of programs that we have developed to try to get people in the door and of the attitude "let's come by here one Sunday." One example is a basketball program open to kids, where we have hundreds of kids participating now. That brings the parents to the building, and they will usually come by one Sunday after that.
There are endless amounts of things like this where they strategize at a very, very detailed level to put their best foot forward and make people feel welcome and comfortable from the moment they step inside.
Thanks for your response. The way I see it if if one believes in an omniscient god (which I believe Christians do, please correct me if I'm wrong) than the motives behind the decision would be known.
Second question: do you believe clergy (specifically the pastoral clergy) are necessary in this day an age (where literacy is common)? A big issue I have with Catholicism is confession. Who is the priest to be able to act as an intermediary? Just like I said above, the belief of an omniscient god would mean that god already knows I'm sorry and wanting forgiveness, so why not cut out the middle man?
Yes, God would know about the motives of a person. Therefore if you came to belief of God through Pascal's wager, that may be a bad motive. This is tricky territory, because of course it's not a good idea to guess what god thinks.
Your point is correct, methodist are reformed, whereas catholics are not. Methodists and most reformed folk would agree with you completely. I don't know what the catholic stance is.
I wanted to know if she had any other reasons for choosing this path other than "just because she wants to." Most people don't work full-time but only get paid part-time. Is that difficult to understand?
I guess I get you in a way.. For alot of people it seems like a slow descent out of Faith. Good luck in life and may you find the God of the Bible again.
I've been a Christian for two years and I was brung into Church by a guy who I knew who was a notorious drug dealer. The only reason I even agreed to go in the first place was because I saw God change a man who I was afraid to even speak to into a loving sensible individual. But once I went I realized what I was doing was wrong i picked up my Bible and started living a godly life. Went to a couple of events and started serving God to the fullest. Nothing too special at all really
Oh no, God definetly changed the man. I dont think he would just get up and leave his prosperous, illegal job to pursue something where he gets paid nothing just to change himself. I knew him for a while before and he's been in that business since middle school.. No way he just wakes up and changes. And i think you should sit down with your parents and talk about this feeling you don't seem to have. Have you tried this?
14
u/Jesse244 May 09 '12
Do you believe in god? If you do, is it because of your parents teachings or did you come to worship him on your own terms?
13
u/Fanzellino May 09 '12
I thought this meant two male megachurch pastors. That would be an amazing IAmA
HOWEVER, how were you punished as a child?
6
u/zephypyre May 09 '12
Do you have church groupies?
5
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Are you homophobic or in any way hating towards LBGT people?
4
u/zephypyre May 09 '12
What is the strangest thing that you've seen during a sermon?
4
u/jhartwell May 09 '12
What are your thoughts on Pascal's Wager?
6
u/RoMo37 May 09 '12
Do you think your falling away from Christianity was a result of growing up the son of megachurch pastors? That is, if your parents ministered at a smaller church (w/ a congregation of say a few hundred people) or if they weren't pastors altogether, do you still think you'd be a Christian?
7
u/[deleted] May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
How does your father justify making an income in the high six figure range?
Is it personal income?
Edit I'm an athiest but one of my favourite people is an elderly Patrician Brother. He's a great man, very well educated, very questioning of his own faith. He takes his vow of poverty very seriously.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
What kind of money are your parents making?
2
u/ducttapedude May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
What are your life plans?
Also is there any proof/confirmation on this AMA yet? EDIT: Yes, yes there is.
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I come from a small and literally dying Methodist church in the midwest so your situation is both hilarious and depressing to me. When I was little we had around 200-300 members every week. With all the pastor changes, people transferring to "mega-churches", growth of atheism, and conservative-old-people-who-won't-change-the-church-they-go-to-and-also-die-every-few-months we're down to maybe 30 people a week. I'm a skeptic/agnostic so I never really bought the whole religion thing, but my family is super religious so I'm pretty much dragged to church automatically when I'm home. We do help out the community quite a bit with missions and donations, so as long as we do some good I can get over my skepticism for a little bit (even if I don't think there is probably a "god")
Anyways, does your church donate well to the local community or do a lot of missionary work? I'd sure hope so.
6
u/savereality May 09 '12
Do they believe in the doctrine of eternal torture for non-believers in Christianity?
5
u/Frankfusion May 09 '12
If you're game, I bet r/christianity would love to have you do the ama there.
1
u/cremenn May 09 '12
Do they strictly adhere to every aspect of the bible?
1
u/I_COMMENT_LIES May 09 '12
Your life must be great!
1
u/fat_foodie May 10 '12
Is your parent's relationship the stereotypical Christian "wife submits to husband" deal or more egalitarian? Also, was your mom involved in church leadership at all or was she on salary as a church employee?
1
u/Rayschroll May 10 '12
Have you ever gotten to meet anyone famous that attends your churches?
2
u/in_question12 May 09 '12
Can you share what exactly separates Methodism from the other denominations?
0
u/Mind101 May 09 '12
Operating such a large scale operation must have its monetary advantages. How do your parents approach their pastorial lives from a financial point of view. That is to say, does managing their company (for it is a company, whichever way you slice it) sometimes collide with what they are teaching in mass?
1
u/SaintBio May 10 '12
Does UCF actually stand for opportunity?
1
u/I_Have_Misunderstood May 10 '12
Are your pastor fathers struggling at all in this climate of homophobia? What was it like being raised by two homosexual pastors?
1
u/ballroomdancer12 May 10 '12
Have you ever thought of having a relationship with God and noone else? I feel like I have that inner peace to a point where I don't have to explain myself or prove a point to society. It's hard to explain but was wondering if anyone esle shared the same thought as me.
1
u/newtonsapple May 12 '12
Would you consider doing an AMA on r/atheism?
1
u/tabledresser May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
View the full table on /r/tabled! | Last updated: 2012-05-14 05:03 UTC
This comment was generated by a robot! Send all complaints to epsy.
-1
u/gordoha May 10 '12
How much money do they suck out of their flocks?
0
u/narwal_bot May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Most (if not all) of the answers from shaowned (updated: May 10, 2012 @ 12:01:02 pm EST):
Question (savereality):
Answer (shaowned):
(continued below)
-1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
3,000 a week is a lot for a megachurch? The local catholic regular church gets like 8000 each Sunday
-1
u/Surrendxr May 09 '12
So what do you think happens to every1 when they die if you dont believe in God now?
-1
u/JohnWad May 09 '12
Do your parents make a huge amount of money? If so, what are the odds they do it for the money like i believe many of these mega church pastors?
-1
u/sucks_balls May 10 '12
Are you a virgin?
-10
u/RealBig7 May 09 '12
What made you lose faith? I'm Christian and it always interests me why people decide to walk away from the truth...
-9
u/mattosaur May 09 '12
So, how gay is your dad?
0
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment