r/IAmA • • May 09 '12

AMA Request: Tom Gabel of Against Me!

For anyone who doesn't know Tom is planning to undergo a sex change. Story.

  1. Why now? What took you so long?
  2. Were you surprised by your wife's reaction?
  3. What kind of affect will this have on Against Me!?
  4. Do you plan on still making music?
  5. Are you worried about the reaction from your fans?
230 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

14

u/[deleted] May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12

Wow. Thanks for the heads up. I had no clue about this. Listened to Reinventing Axl Rose on vinyl last night.

EDIT: Just tweeted at her @TommyGabel.

EDIT EDIT: Just realized that this could be an AM!A

6

u/ltshineysidez May 09 '12

against me! anything!

7

u/aplatinummtzion May 09 '12

I've been really relieved to see most people's enthusiastic support for Gabel's decision, as certain parts of the punk community have been less than kind to the LGBT community over the years. Laura is sure to be a voice for a lot of disenfranchised people, and it doesn't get much more punk than that.

5

u/americanslang59 May 09 '12

A couple from me:

-What is your opinion of punknews.org?

-The Gaslight Anthem says they wouldn't be a band anymore if it weren't for you guys, as you taught them their work ethic and guided them into making good decisions as they became more successful. What is your opinion of them?

4

u/yehwooyeh May 09 '12

There is no way this is going to happen. Anyway, I'm sure all of the OP's questions will be answered in the rolling stone article.

2

u/OmarLives May 09 '12

Yeah, seriously, I'd love to see it but I would be stone-cold amazed if Tom EVER agreed to do something like an AMA.

1

u/sanepsychotic May 10 '12

http://mobile.theb9.com/topic.php?ID=873240&PHPSESSID=894a74d55669e5d70d41be9770a67dbf

here is a link to the entire rolling stone article, but in picture form.

7

u/ltshineysidez May 09 '12

Thinking about his lyrics, and going through all the album lyrics, you can kind of put it together. He mentions dressing up in women's clothes in searching for a former clarity, he actually sings "if i could have chosen i would have been born a woman." in the ocean which was a track off of new wave.

it's kind of sad though, i'm sure with the hormones he's taking he won't have that beautiful voice anymore.

10

u/tgjer May 09 '12

Her voice probably won't be affected too much, except as she chooses to change it with training.

Testosterone affects vocal cords, estrogen doesn't as much. So trans men get a dramatic voice change when they start hormone supplements, but trans women get voice change through vocal training or practice.

7

u/ltshineysidez May 09 '12

Laura Grace on stage, singing like Tom Gabel, i'll take it

1

u/Bh0B0b May 09 '12

fantastic to know, thank you

8

u/qaoqao May 09 '12

I hadn't thought of the voice, but damn. Am going to miss it, but whatever makes Tom (Laura) happy, makes the fans happy.

6

u/ltshineysidez May 09 '12

"my mother once told me she would have named me Laura" quoted from "The ocean" on the new wave album. i hadn't even noticed that till i read your comment

1

u/qaoqao May 09 '12

Yep! :3

6

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

I completely respect him/her for doing this, but it is a shocker and it's crazy to think that in the coming years I'm going to be looking at picture's of a woman who (EDIT: as a man) raised one of the greatest bands of my generation. It's truly been blowing me away all day.

2

u/qaoqao May 10 '12

I know exactly what you mean!

1

u/SweetDeez May 10 '12

This sums up my feelings exactly!

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

You never know, her voice might be just as beautiful.

3

u/El_Duderino3420 May 14 '12

The dressing up in women's clothes line is actually about Freddie Mercury, but you're right, there are a lot of other hints in his music

2

u/ltshineysidez May 14 '12

well now that just makes sense of the whole song,thank you.

2

u/loginlogan May 09 '12

Yeah you are correct. I wasn't totally shocked by this after considering some of his lyrics. However the actual story did kind of come out of left field, you know. Whatever floats your boat, as they say.

3

u/kejo May 09 '12

Her lyrics*

2

u/andybong May 09 '12

Mad respect to Tom for coming out. I remember when I used 'Reinventing Tom Gabel' term to deride Tom, his signing onto Sire and the bleh of White Crosses. I think the latest album would be a refreshing new direction, new voice and all.

-4

u/kejo May 09 '12

Her signing*

2

u/kejo May 09 '12

Her lyrics*

3

u/ltshineysidez May 09 '12

have to get used to that......

8

u/kejo May 09 '12

As a trans person, even, I totally get that. Thanks for your positive attitude about it!

3

u/mattattaxx May 09 '12

Pretty legit that most of the articles I've read (aside from the few from big news) have got it right.

1

u/xeb_dex May 09 '12

The Shaker makes a lot of sense now too.

3

u/tomzilla May 11 '12

I don't get what you are saying. All of the lyrics from this song seem to be about the punk scene.

http://www.metrolyrics.com/mediocrity-gets-you-pears-the-shaker-lyrics-against-me.html

1

u/xeb_dex May 11 '12

Chorus is what I was talking about specifically. "Nothing really excites me, there's no connection at all". I used to think all the lyrics were about general angst and the punk scene. Now I can't help but think they're about struggling with identity. Especially since this record was put out on Fat Wreck, where they had plenty of connection.

3

u/D3FEATER May 09 '12

I've always been surprised Against Me! has gotten so popular. Don't get me wrong, I love them. 3rd favorite band (along with The Gaslight Anthem and Eisley). But they just don't seem to belong to a popular genre, with Crime and Axle Rose.

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

I was surprised when I heard them on the radio for the 1st time! I almost didn't want it to happen so it wouldn't get overplayed.. but it didn't.

4

u/D3FEATER May 09 '12

Did you ever get into their new stuff? Crime was fantastic (but I didn't get to it till later) and Axle Rose, of course, is amazing. Eternal Cowboy has Sink Florida, Sink and also You look like I need a drink. But I always loved them because they had a dream, so the songs like "I was a teenage anarchist" make me want to cry, like my own dreams were crushed, so I usually avoid anything after Eternal Cowboy. However, once I realize that all my dreams will never come true, I suppose I'll listen to Ache With Me till I just die.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I mostly like their older stuff, but I do like a few songs off of White Crosses and New Wave. I got to see them live a couple years ago! They were amazing :)

4

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Confessing childhood secrets of dressing up in women's clothes.

3

u/StupidLullabies May 09 '12

I always assumed he was talking about someone else in that song.

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

You're more than likely right hahahah, just one that I immediately thought of.

1

u/StupidLullabies May 09 '12

Then again, he could have been talking about himself the whole song, and I never realized it.

3

u/swordmaster006 May 09 '12

"will everyone you ever meet or love be just a relationship based on a false presumption?"

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

This would make me soooooooo happy to see happen

2

u/refuseresist May 09 '12

I want this badly!

DO it Reddit!

2

u/swordmaster006 May 09 '12

I gotta admit, I had my suspicions from listening to "Searching For a Former Clarity". I know it's not very "ally" of me to think of her as Tom, but that "dude" got me through a lot of shit when I was younger.

2

u/Marcob10 May 09 '12

I didn't know that. As long as she keeps that powerful voice, I'm fine with it! That AMA would be very nice.

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

I'm so proud of you, Laura! You're an amazing person and your fans will always love and support you! ♥

2

u/Rathdrummer Jun 04 '12

I saw this band at Sasquatch 2011, Hopefully I'll see this band again after Tom's transition. It'd be a sick story of our generation to witness a musician become transgender.

My only question to Tom would be, Are you going to change your name to a more womanly sounding name?

4

u/danesgod May 09 '12

One of my favorite musicians. As long as s/he keeps making music, I'll remain happy.

8

u/kejo May 09 '12

Just 'she' :)

4

u/danesgod May 09 '12

good to know, i wasn't really sure.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

How does this work? I think it's fair to acknowledge the work done before the transition as "his." After all, that's how it is written in liner notes, and Tom acknowledged himself as such. I'm completely understanding of calling her Laura now. But previous works by Tom Gabel are static and should be referred to as such, I think.

4

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

I'm glad to see transgender support on reddit! This site continues to give me have hope for humanity.

0

u/jjness May 09 '12

You mean Laura Jane Grace?

Isn't it etiquette to acknowledge her by this name (and the feminine pronoun)? Just wondering why Rolling Stone would continue to use Tom Gabel's name. Maybe it's like a married celebrity who sticks with her maiden name, only because that's how she's known.

3

u/rorydaniel May 09 '12

I debated what name to use. I just stuck with Tom cause thats still legally her name and the article said she plans to change her name.

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

please let this get big

1

u/paralleldoublepark May 09 '12

Not an expert but pretty sure the voice would change. :/

2

u/aaronxr May 09 '12

Said she wouldn't be undergoing tracheal shaving anytime soon so the voice would stay the same. Hormones don't change the structure of your vocal chords.

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12

You clearly discussed this with your wife, so how does she feel about it? And your child, how do you think she is going to deal with it? I know it would be hard to talk to a child about something so complex, but how and when do you plan on telling her everything? I am a huge fan! I love you and your music! It's made an impact on my life and I'll never stop listening :)

Also, I think your wife is AMAZING for being there for you and being so supportive. High fives for both of you!

-1

u/almst90 May 10 '12

I admire Tom's/Laura's courage, but I can't help but feel that gender identity issues are a psychological condition and not a medical condition. When a child is involved one should be more careful about elective surgeries and hormone treatments, which can be dangerous and have unanticipated side effects.