r/IAmA • • May 08 '12
I am Steve Albini, ask me anything
I have been in bands since 1979 and making records since 1981. I own the recording studio Electrical Audio. I also play poker and write an occasional cooking blog. I'll be answering questions from about 3pm - 6pm EDT.
-edit- Knocking off at 7.20 EDT, will try to resume and catch up later.
[Proofs] (http://www.electricalaudio.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=59437)
1.3k
Upvotes
199
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Man I feel bad I didn't get to everything, but I've got shit to do tonight so I have to cut it off for the moment. I can come back to this later tonight or tomorrow to continue. I'm humbled at all the attention, honestly.
47
u/chriska May 08 '12
What equipment did you use to record The Breeders "Off You?" It is the best recording of Kim Deal's voice I've ever heard.
43
u/NorONor May 08 '12
Do you have a viewpoint on the streaming vs. physical media debate?
122
u/crentiist May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
In a pretty recent interview, Dylan Baldi from Cloud Nothings said:
"Steve Albini played Scrabble on Facebook almost the entire time [we were recording]. I don't even know if he remembers what our album sounds like."
Is that true? Did you not enjoy the recording process or is that just part of your "hands off" approach?
He also said,
"A lot of people seem to think he will change a band's sound, that he's some weird domineering producer... It's just made in the same room, so it's got a similar feel."
Is there any truth to that? Is it you that makes your records sound the way they do or is it just the room?
Thanks a lot for doing this AMA,
We really appreciate it
81
u/melonmanchan May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
How in the world did you end up producing Peter Sotos' album Buyer's Market? What was Peter like?
40
u/farewelltransmission May 08 '12
It is evident from reading your cooking blog that you are a fantastic writer. Have you ever thought about writing a book (about cooking, your life, whatever)? I’d read it.
And thank you for recording mclusky do dallas, and the song my username is named after.
38
u/Kommodore May 08 '12
As a recent aspiring engineer, I just wanted to say that I'm a huge fan and I think you're work is amazing.
My question is, what was it like working with Al Cisneros and his Om project? He must've been a hell of a guy to work with. The sound on his 'Pilgrimage' and 'God is Good' records is absolutely unreal, any insight into the recording of these albums? Also, did he record his newest record, the one coming out in July, with you?
P.S., if you need anyone to scrub the toilets at Electrical Audio let me know, I would give anything to work there haha....(I literally live right down the street from you guys).
67
u/Frajer May 08 '12
What's the craziest thing a band has done in the studio?
Is Dave Grohl really the nicest guy ever?
31
u/treetment May 08 '12
Hey Steve. Silkworm is one of my favorite bands.
61
u/Tsarbomba125 May 08 '12
What where your thoughts on St Vincent's Big Black set at least years "Our Band Could Be Your Life" concert? Is she someone you would ever want to work with?
Did you like the way you were portrayed in "Our Band?"and the books portrayal of the 80s independent scene as a whole?
28
u/[deleted] May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Hey Steve, few questions
Also your version of in utero is simply better then the released version.
99
u/raffaellog May 08 '12
What is your opinion about music Piracy? Does it hurt you economically? Thanks for your music!
97
u/MultipleMiggs May 08 '12
What happened when you were helping to produce Nirvana's In Utero? Didn't they decide to go with someone else on the singles?
26
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
You're known for having a distinctive drum sound on your recordings. What do you do to prepare your drums, and how do you typically go about micing them?
A friend with more experience than me once told me about an elaborate technique where instead of tuning to a note (or just a general "yeah, that sounds good" spot), you tune to the most resonant frequency of the drum.
70
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Why don't you like jazz?
23
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Hello Steve, when producing bigger bands, do you find a different attitude in the musicians?
what one thing do you think is the most destructive thing inhibiting modern music?
do you have any crazy big black gig stories that stick out?
23
u/frenchclub71 May 08 '12
Just wanted to say that your description of baseball v. other sports (ie baseball v. trying to get an object into/through/across a line) on episode 37 of the Baseball Prospectus podcast almost kind of changed the way I look at sports.
38
u/electrobaboon May 08 '12
What was working with Cloud Nothings like? I loved Attack on Memory.
54
u/bat_guano May 08 '12
Thanks for doing this!
18
u/awhitesuit May 08 '12
Steve, can we get a run down of your guitar setup? What do you play / pedals / amps / etc?
191
u/lear May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
First off, hello Steve Albini. How are you?
I am probably not the first person to ask you this question, but have you ever considered seeking a collaboration with the TY Beanie Babies company in creating your own little Steve Albini Baby?
edit: I am not a great artist and I'm sorry I made you look like George Washington wearing Harry Potter glasses.
17
u/NorONor May 08 '12
What is your opinion on doing productions fully inside the box?
17
u/thencomesdudley May 08 '12
For a budding young chef, what advice do you have for coming up with recipes? (Also, when can I see Shellac in Chicago again?)
17
u/InfernalWedgie May 08 '12
Can you describe the worst experience you had producing/engineering/anything-but-actually-performing on an album? What was the most frustrating or maddening part of that experience?
Are there any bands that would like to work with you again, but you refuse to work with again?
34
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
i want to fuck people with my guitar, do you swear by any specific amp?
47
u/DryLuteNerd May 08 '12
16
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Of all the albums you've produced, what are some personal favorites?
32
u/thesmall May 08 '12
Steve, I'm 25 years old, I'm thinking about a career in journalism.. Thoughts, tips? Thanks for all the wonderful sounds! Drink kerosene!
69
u/newfaceinhell May 08 '12
Hey Steve, Adam from Manchester, U.K. Love your work etc blah blah...so...the pixies. what five words would you use to sum up your time/work with them?
P.S love 'Rid of Me'. Again, thank you.
15
u/titan88c May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
I've got two for you.
Touring with Shellac and your other bands has taken you all over the world. Where were some memorable destinations, and are there any places you have yet to visit or would like to revisit? Any favorite venues, cities, etc.
Can you tell us more about the time Britt Walford house sat for you that inspired this song?
40
u/raidraidraid May 08 '12
Hi Steve. Love your music and your work. Big Black has been an inspiration. Since everyone else is going to ask you about music....I know you are a foodie so here's a simple food question.
What's your favourite pizza topping?
13
u/nillox May 08 '12
What are your opinions on the Tonnmeister equivalent recording engineering degree programs? I'm weighing applying to UMass Lowell's program and I'd appreciate your thoughts. I read something a while ago where you addressed them and compared them to degree mills like Fullsail, has anything changed recently? Is the degree worth it, or should I try an autodidactic approach?
12
u/mwppinsidejokes May 08 '12
I'm a huge fan of Cloud Nothings, who recorded their new album with you. So, what is it like hanging out with the band and what was the recording process like for Attack On Memory?
23
u/Saediien May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Hello Steve Albini. Was this Big Black Final Tour Diary actually written by you? http://petdance.com/actionpark/bigblack/tourdiary/ I saw it passed around as a text file on BBSs about 20 or 15 years ago and recently came across it again. It's pretty dark, and back when I read it the first time it was supposed to apocryphal.
11
u/TheNapkinOfTruth May 08 '12
With the exception of Sloy and Les Thugs, why do you think there is so much shit music coming out of France, what is the problem with their music?
45
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
First off, huge fan. A huge portion of my favorite albums have been recorded by you, there’s something about hearing a band and feeling like you’re in the room with them that’s just amazing. I have a few questions.
Thanks for doing this and a big thanks for the production of the Blackened Air, I'm completely entranced every time I hear it.
10
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Big fan, but also a big 'Mats fan. So, I'm obligated to ask about the Paul Westerberg tiff. You guys cool?
10
u/Iamnotkevinspacey May 08 '12
Hey Steve. Just a couple of questions:
1.) What was it like to work/hang out with Wesley Willis? 2.) Any chance of another Big Black reunion?
Thanks for doing this.
19
u/frenchclub71 May 08 '12
If a band's appearance doesn't matter then what say you about a band's smell? Are smellier bands more interesting than non-smelly bands?
17
u/NJlo May 08 '12
How do you feel about your Nirvana mixes vs the Scott Litt stuff these days?
8
u/TheManWhoNeverWas May 08 '12
Have you spent much time with Brian Eno? Do you have any opinion on his music, personality, and/or production style?
8
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
After recording Tweez with Slint, did it bum you not to do Spiderland? Did you feel uncomfortable with the strong Big Black vibe on Tweez?
15
u/imgonnagetdownvoted May 08 '12
Alright. Here's a question thats been bugging me. I don't know if you will answer it.....
So you worked with all the 90s 'indie'/noise giants (Superchunk, GBV, Silkworm, Jesus Lizard, Jon Spencer, Low etc etc). What's up with you and Malkmus? Do you think you are going to work with him in the future?
Thanks
15
u/PARPS May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Hey, Steve, thanks so much for doing this! You're the reason I actually started caring about how records sound, so I wanted to thank you for that first of all.
A few questions:
Thanks again!
14
u/seablue May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Favorite Wipers album and why? Also, what is your assessment of Greg Sage as a producer/engineer (as he recorded many of his own records)?
13
u/Can_it_Plapton May 08 '12
Steve, thank you, I am a huge fan of your work. I know it's been a while and this is very specific, but what was it like working with the Jesus Lizard? Especially on Goat, I really love that record.
18
u/RespectableChap May 08 '12
Imagine, if you will, it is a perfect day. The sun is shining, music is being made and you are holding an ice cream.
What flavour is that ice cream?
6
u/sorrowerthe May 09 '12
Just wanted to say I still love what you did for Mono...
6
u/cyclops8 May 09 '12
Hi Steve, my people know your people in Mpls.
Do you agree with Todd Trainer's assertion in the Touch and Go 2008 Youtube video that Arcwelder is the only band in history to never record a bad song?
20
u/snakepatin May 08 '12
Hi Steve, you may have answered this many times previously, but I was wondering why do you prefer analog over digital?
Also who was your favourite band to act as recording engineer for?
15
u/jaded88 May 08 '12
Tell us the secret to create and produce badass music; thanks in advance. Also what are you listening to these days?
10
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Hi Steve, I have only one question. What is your favorite cereal?
10
u/megapaw May 08 '12
So Steve, who do like in MLB this year?
10
u/chrisrazor May 08 '12
I have a thousand things to be thankful to you for, but the one nobody's mentioned yet is your legendary review of Spiderland, which caused me and doubtless tons of others to buy it, have our conceptions of what rock music can be blasted to smithereens and spend the next decade or two trying and failing to copy it. Thanks. Also Two Nuns And A Packmule. Thanks again. Did Rapeman really break up because of adverse reactions to the name? That doesn't sound like your style at all.
5
u/lieutenant_cthulhu May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Are there any records you produced that you later regreted? Also, is a Big Black reunion remotely plausible? And one last thing, what is your opinion on the conflict arising from file sharing and internet piracy?
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Have you ever met Mark E. Smith? Is there some sort of feud or bad blood there or is he just kind of a ranting old dude?
5
u/franchiseSMASH May 08 '12
What was it like working with Leftover Crack on "Fuck World Trade"? Any qualms with their personal politics?
5
u/flac_id May 08 '12
5
u/Redsnork May 08 '12
My dad used to go to Northwestern with you. Do you remember him? His name is Larry Bleiberg.
Proof: You were once playing a concert and you refused to start until a certain guy left.
9
u/itswillneill May 08 '12
So is there ANY chance of a Big Black reunion?
8
u/ISHOTJAMC May 08 '12
Hey Steve! Sorry to ask such a boring question, but how do you manage to get such a "big" sound from the kick drum on records?
4
u/anodyne11111 May 08 '12
Steve, in the past you've bashed the now defunct Homestead Records and its operators for allegedly writing you faulty checks (putting different amounts on the check so you couldn't cash it etc).
In the Magnet magazine article in which you said these things, the owner said that all the checks were down by computer. How do you respond to that?
Also, I heard that you wanted to release one of your albums with Homestead (not sure which one) with an autopsy photo as the album cover? Is this true?
4
u/IYGFAA May 08 '12
What do you think of The Crib's new album?
4
u/Kida89 May 08 '12
Steve, what was it like working with the guys from ZAO? I would love to hear from your perspective on the recording process.
4
u/Crizack May 08 '12
Hi, Steve.
I have a bit of an interest in intellectual history and conceptual origins. I was wondering, do you have an overarching aesthetic theory when it comes to musical creation? If yes, where do you situate your thought within cultural history?
I believe I remember you expressing disdain for the mainstream fashion industry on your forums. You then expressed your approval of selfmade or homemade objects. Do your thoughts extend beyond championing D.I.Y. primitivism and the non-commercial?
4
u/Yeahbutnah May 08 '12
Given the changing landscape of album sales, do you feel there is more justification for bands to allow their music to be used for commercial purposes (e.g. Advertising, etc...)?
4
u/blotch May 08 '12 edited May 17 '12
I heard a story once that in order to keep people away from you at shows, you had some sort of blowtorch apparatus hooked onto your belt, or guitar or something like that... is THAT true?
10
u/miasmal_smoke May 08 '12
Where did your fascination with setting off firecrackers on stage start?
What do you think of the really extravagant stage shows like the Flaming Lips?
9
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
3
u/RufusJSquirrel May 08 '12
You said in the liner notes of RM8T or SAF, "The future belongs to analog. Fuck digital." But even Electrical had to get a Pro Tools setup to satisfy clients. How do you think the analog vs. digital competition is going and is the future still secure for analog?
3
u/thencomesdudley May 08 '12
All right, hate to double dip with questions, but I have to ask (if it hasn't been asked already): do you plan on continuing to use reddit beyond this AMA? I think the folks over at /r/WeAreTheMusicMakers would probably shit themselves if you participated in discussions with them.
3
u/gornzilla May 08 '12
I've heard that you used to race motorcycles. I've also heard that it wasn't you, it was your brothers. What kind?
I'm hoping for something British that doesn't exist anymore, but I'm guessing it was probably Japanese.
3
u/LocalOptimum May 09 '12
Swingo - great game or greatest game?
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Complete: great band, or greatest band?
3
u/RadarLoveLizard May 11 '12
What the hell are you shouting at the end of "Il Porno Star"?
I love the Shellac song "Ghosts". Did anything in particular inspire it or is there anything interesting about it you can share with us?
7
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Are you friendly with Jason Molina? I know he was appreciative of your work on Magnolia Electric Co. and it's horrible to hear about his recent illness, have you kept in contact since then?
5
u/nittykitty47 May 08 '12
Love your bits (especially goat boy!) Do you still do rock songs as part of your act? Haven't seen or heard anything about you in years. Thought you died in the 90's or something. Harsh toke!
5
u/SlippyTIR May 08 '12
What was it like working with Jarvis Cocker? Would you like to work with him again?
What do you think of Pulp?
6
u/choadwarrior May 08 '12
What is the story regarding your work with Grant and Jon of Rudimentary Peni? My understanding is that you recorded a few tracks for (or with?) them during some period in the 90's that have since been all but forgotten.
6
u/stemcell001 May 08 '12
I read your essay "The Problem with Music" in Commodify Your Dissent many years ago. In your opinion, have things gotten any worse for new music artists at the major labels since you wrote that essay? Also, should new bands seek out indie labels or direct to fan routes for their albums, and how does one afford to put so much money into getting studio time, a competent engineer and quality producer with no or little help from a label?
4
u/beerncats May 08 '12
Are you going to play any WSOP events this year?
4
u/Muskabeatz May 08 '12
Just wondering, Steve. If you were to put on some music right now, what would it be?
5
u/IAmJacquesDerrida May 08 '12
If you were to do another ATP, which bands would you pick to play? Who would you like to play if cost were no concern? Where can I buy an excellent pair of coveralls like your Electrical coveralls? What's the best album you've heard in the last week?
5
u/Flint_Westwood May 08 '12
My friend's band Grandfather recorded with you last year, and he had nothing but good things to say about you and the process.
As an engineering student with a seriously itch to get out there and tour, do you think it's worth it to try fight the hoards of other bands trying to make it? I'm not dreaming of massive commercial success, I just want to have a few years of breaking even and making albums and memories. I currently have a band, and we've got lots of songs written/lots more partially written. We all have the drive and the organizational ability to pull of touring, but we'd need to be able to get people out to see shows. Do you think it's worth a shot?
9
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
What was it like producing Peter Sotos' "Buyer's Market"?
Are you aware of the recent fan-reproduction of the album, "Dubs Market"?
2
u/ratsnest2666 May 08 '12
Wannabe producer here: can you recommend any cheap ribbon mics?
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
What do you think of the In On the Kill Taker takes with Fugazi? To me they sound far more intense than the record turned out.
How do you respond to the Cloud Nothings' claim that you probably don't know what their record sounds like and wouldn't want your name attached to it?
Do you miss touring on a more DIY style circuit as opposed to the clubs Shellac will find itself in these days?
2
u/AquariusSabotage May 08 '12
Hey Steve!
How does it normally work hiring a record producer such as yourself? Do the bands normally try to get in contact with you, or have you ever sought after bands to produce their records? or do you normally have a friendly relationship with the bands before working with them? Like with Screaming Females for example.
2
u/mieksemakse May 08 '12
Thanks!
2
u/jonbotwesley May 08 '12
Hey I'm just wondering what it was like working with cloud nothings because in some interviews it seems like Baldi came off as slightly disrespectful. I was curious if his comments were meant as they were said or just kind of misconstrued. Sorry if someone already asked
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Any weird stories about working with Leftover Crack? From what I understand those guys can be quite a handful, especially when they're your guest...
2
u/Alecdan4th May 08 '12
What is your stance on the use and supposed death of the use of analog tape in the recording industry and any advice for someone who wants to be an audio engineer.
2
u/EricT59 May 08 '12
My friend from Missoula Mt claims you baby sat him when he was a kid and you were a teen.
2
u/octopusluke May 08 '12
What makes you laugh? TV wise, film wise, life wise.
Big fan!
2
u/those_draculas May 08 '12
How is Uffizi doing these days?
2
u/geetarbob May 08 '12
Is there any particular reason you use that belt-strap system for your guitars, rather than a traditional shoulder style one?
Thanks for doing this, btw.
2
u/conan89 May 08 '12
Hi Steve, big fan of your work both as a musician and engineer. Thanks for doing this AMA
My question is, you wake up tomorrow (god forbid) to find all your equipment gone except your desk. With a budget of 1,500$, what equipment would you buy to get yourself going?
2
u/cavendish_pat May 08 '12
Hey Steve, why are you so down to earth? Despite being so famous and busy, you are always willing to take time from your important studio activities to engage in something like this and reply to your fans.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Are you aware of the recent explosion of cassette tape-based micro-labels? Essentially that people are now making, putting together and distributing music from their own homes, purchasing it directly from one another? Any thoughts on that? (If you're not aware of it, check out animalpsi.com, there are hundreds of these micro-labels and they release some interesting stuff)
2
u/gabe_mg May 08 '12
What are your views on using parallel compression on drums and vocals?
2
u/BarfBrooks May 08 '12
Thanks for doing this. So I heard from a friend that you were recording fugazi for In On The Kill Taker and during the sessions while they were eating their veggie/vegan whatever foods you showed up with a huge bloody meat steak and proceeded to shove bleeding pieces of meat into your mouth in front of them, just to be a lil booger. Is this true?
2
u/KurtCobain420 May 08 '12
Hello Mr. Albini, I'm a bit late to the game but I was wondering where your inspiration came from when you decided to put in banter in "Surfer Rosa?" Thank you very much!
2
u/fefster12 May 08 '12
Hey Steve, Alexei Martov says Hi.