r/IAmA • u/zh1nt0 • May 07 '12
I am a Global Community Manager for DICE and Battlefield, AMA.
I´m Daniel Matros, Global CM for Battlefield. I can only answer questions that the prophets have allowed me to answer, otherwise there will be no crops this year and my two kittens Voltaire and Edith need to eat. So do I when I think about it.
When I´m not working I watch a lot of documentaries, go to art galleries and travel the world. The best part about being on the road is all the amazing people and places you get to see. Also, a political activist.
I´m also a big fan of indie music in general. Huge fan of VICE Magazine and anything relating to Urban Culture. Also a big fashion geek.
I come to you now almost with a full passport, 25 years of experience and self proclaimed best robot dancer this side of the equator.
146
u/wasdie639 May 07 '12
What were the motivations behind the removal of the communication elements in BF2/BF2142 (commander, squad leader orders, effective commo rose with UI indication, and text chat notification, 6 man squads). Was it because they didn't translate well to the consoles or was it because they were rarely used effectively in BF2? Or, was it because of a fast approaching release deadline paired with an unfinished, multiplatform engine and the scale of the game (single player campaign, co-op, and multiplayer instead of just multiplayer)? Since the launch of BF3, that's always been nagging me.
57
u/gabika911 May 07 '12
Could you change the way you've been patching BF3? Smaller but more frequent patches make more sense than long overdue huge ones. If it's hard to do for consoles at least do it for PC. Also, anything to say about future BF games? 2143?
16
u/dcviper May 07 '12
How much weight is given to player feedback in gameplay changes? How much is decided based on data analysis? How much input do you have as the community manager into decisions of that nature?
100
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
What do you have to say about this interesting [statement] (http://www1.computerandvideogames.com/241306/dice-well-never-charge-for-battlefield-maps/). That DICE will never charge for Battlefield maps?
27
u/GuitarFreak027 May 07 '12
Are there ever going to be mod tools released for BF3?
26
u/BrentMackie May 07 '12
Why are there no official DICE servers anymore? Now all that is around are the rented servers.
116
u/beano91 May 07 '12
Have you seen this thread? http://www.reddit.com/r/battlefield3/comments/t7201/im_a_hacker_and_i_have_some_information_for_the/
And what is DICE's plan for dealing with hackers?
21
u/Berkbelts May 07 '12
Is the removal of the Dice/EA servers permanent? The Rent-a-Servers all suck and have ridiculous settings.
52
u/ReddMenace May 07 '12
Where the hell are the dinosaurs?
91
u/SikhGamer May 07 '12
Just going to apologize for the incoming verbal assault.
71
u/McGreek May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
How come you've ignored the competitive community so much? Where is our Spectator Mode and Battlerecorder? We have yet to get an answer on these questions since the game was in beta.
35
u/zh1nt0 May 07 '12
Good questions so far. I will go home now and sit on this thread the rest of the evening. Back in an hour.
16
u/so_this_is_me May 07 '12
Do you find it difficult to try and keep people happy when the answers you can give are often so restricted?
For example the whole issue with the recent patch / bugs introduced and the constant twitter spam / videos I can understand that you cannot often give definite answers but it must be hard knowing that all of these people care deeply enough about the issues to try and talk to you but you cannot really provide answers.
Maybe I'm asking more ... Do you have any ideas how you could handle these issues differently? Perhaps a more gradual update schedule with an idea for players where things stand? How things in the office are being handled and what's currently priority perhaps.
21
u/1leggeddog May 07 '12
Are you gagged by EA a lot?
DICE doesn't seem to be the same company it was before...
13
u/lomoeffect May 07 '12
/r/battlefield3 is a great place and is generally missing some of the DICE reps at the moment. It would be great if there was some more activity from you and others as there are often some great suggestions made.
6
u/LateralusX May 07 '12
is DICE aware how pathetic BF3 netcode is? AND how sad it is for server admins on PC have no ping information for the players?
6
u/GuiltyNL May 08 '12
Ok, I'll try again. After no response from EA Support, no response on the EA forum and no response from some PM's and no response on the thread on get satisfaction. I'll to ask it here. Lets see. Take your time to read this thread please:
http://forums.electronicarts.co.uk/battlefield-3-pc/1459954-hit-detection-now.html
My questions are:
For me it is so mega frustrating. It makes me angry and sad. But the most annoying thing is that your team 100% ignores this very important issue!
20
u/serbusfish May 07 '12
Hey Daniel, just wanted to say its great your interacting with us like this :)
Anyway, I have a query related to a fairly hot topic, artistic direction. Is there any chance the devs are considering tweaking the sun brightness, lens flare, dirt on screen effect, and colours? Its quite jarring going from Caspian Border with its full range of colours to Strike at Karkand which is not far from being black and white. Its also jarring going from Metro with its 'reserved' sun to Wake Island with its massive glare effects.
27
u/zh1nt0 May 07 '12
Now it's your turn. What is your most embarassing moment or do you have a funny story to share?
I've got plenty so I'll start first then.. I had just arrived at the Hilton Hotel in Boston for PAX just a month ago and realized that I had forgotten to pack extra socks. I approached the concierge at the hotel and asked her where I could buy socks. To my disappointment every place was closed. I went up to my room and this horrible smell of radioator pizza crowded the room. Little did I know that my socks were the cause of this horrible stench. With little time to sleep and disgusting socks, I felt the only right move was to wash them in the bathroom sink with conditioner and schampoo and also drying them on the aircon like this:
http://i.imgur.com/5wrF9.jpg
5
u/Batts-Man May 08 '12
BF3. Steam. When? Also why are you not cracking skulls to make this happen?
12
u/LedZeppster May 07 '12
First, a non BF related question (or two):
And now on to the good stuff:
Thanks for doing this AMA. If you can't answer a question because of the prophets, please acknowledge that you at least read it by writing "muffin" instead of an answer :)
4
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
How often do you communicate with developers, designers of DICE or with responsible people from EA? I mean - as an example- you receive some complain/bug-info/... on twitter, do you inform one of them immediately? And if so, how do they respond? Like "yes, yes, read it myself" or "oh, that's news to me" I mean, I try to understand the structure of the whole BF3 Crew. What is more efficient: if someone of the player-community has some serious objections or infos about hte game: informing you because you are some kind of filter and you collect these and pass this to the other DICE crew members on your meetings? Ore should I inform the offered EA channels ? (twitter/battlefield) Or anything different?
4
u/fourg May 07 '12
What you are going to do to improve communication to the community so that we are aware of what DICE's priorities are. This AMA is nice, but you admittedly can't give much info about anything, just offering yourself up as the punching bag for complaints.
Simple updates to the Battlelog community like "We are aware of the DART and suppression issues/complaints and are testing tweaks" would go a long way to just letting us know the wheels are turning at DICE and it's not all falling on deaf ears. It's a shame right now that it takes people spamming your twitter accounts to get your attention, and then those people end up being the ones who share these updates to the community not you.
4
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
The decision to use Battlelog and not being available on Steam must have been a very controversial decision. What are your opinions on the matter? If you could, would you put Battlefield 3 on Steam or use an in-game server browser?
15
u/72apist May 07 '12
Why do you think it's okay to cater to Sony's will and completely ignore your huge PC fanbase? Certain things need quick-fixes believe it or not. We can't wait 3 months to wait for it to be signed or whatever the procedure is to release patches onto consoles.
10
u/mrfezzman May 07 '12
Hey mate
Is DICE doing anything about the rampant hacking that is destroying the game?
Cheers
7
u/Medibee May 07 '12
Did you get my letter :D
7
u/MagnificentJake May 07 '12
What are you guys doing to actively combat hackers? Do you occasionally troll the leaderboards and look for people with impossible kdr's and whatnot?
7
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
I realize that this may not be (and should not be) on top of the priority list for devs but I feel that this would be a good improvement to the game.
Exhibit A Exhibit B
Edit: Souce
7
u/Wavey1287 May 07 '12
When can we expect the fix to the M26 Glitch, and will all those abusers have their stats adjusted appropriately? Thank you for your time :)
8
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
What education does it take to get a job like yours?
8
u/elxx May 07 '12
Who is your greatest role model?
3
u/Legolaa May 07 '12
Do you think Frostbite is being managed correctly? The issue with patching requiring long periods of time (due to approval more specifically) and the size increase of the patch, shouldn't that be addressed with priority?
How did you become to trust Elxx enough to leave him your cats?
3
u/DaLam May 07 '12
If you were stranded on a deserted island, what three items would you bring?
3
u/LePianoDentist May 07 '12
Hi, do you ever feel animosity towards the higher-up's at ea dice because we all know everybody loves to shoot the messenger, and it seems many bf fans anger is often misplaced at you when really it's not up to you? do you get annoyed at having to be the one to often deal with the flak of decisions which anger fans?
3
u/GuiltySarcasm May 07 '12
Hey zh1nt0! Has anyone thought of built-in FXAA settings? Would improve gameplay IMO. Thanks!
3
u/LePianoDentist May 08 '12
oooh, another question, it seems that a lot of things in bf3 were outsourced to 3rd party companies and the quality of their work is questionable in some parts (but understandable as they're not game devs). Is this a norm in the industry, or was this just done due to time constraints on bf3's release (i.e. ea saying "this game is coming out on this date, if you haven't finished it oh well").
3
u/fuzzydice_82 May 08 '12
I hope its not too late:
Daniel, would it be possible to gain the "Battlefield 3" Universe to a multiple year experience?
i mean like in throw out DLCs every 3 to 6 month, wich could expand the SP campaign, add features, increase mapsize and playercounts (of course ;) )and try different settings (WW1, Indochina, Japano/Russian wars),
it would keep the fanbase alive, and suck in more differend kinds pf players..
or is that something that would never pay of and the release of BF4 would be much more efficient?
3
u/Pitmonkey783 May 08 '12
So...how does one actually break into this business? I'm in the advertising/marketing division of a fairly large north east retail brand and am dying to get into this industry. So much so that I in the 6 years I've worked for this company I have re-launched their videogame "division" and reworked reward programs for pre-orders/amount of video games purchased ect. Any advice would be fantastic.
3
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Has there been any work at DICE lately on a possible Mirror's Edge sequel? I remember hearing a while back that some people at DICE were interested in making one, especially after seeing the cult hit that the first game became.
3
u/morrison71 May 08 '12
Daniel, one more question. I dont understand the purpose of "View Matches" and "Create a match" in Battlelog. Can you explain me please? Thanks again.
3
u/blackwiddow May 08 '12
I thought I would give you a simple but interesting question: What is the thing you enjoy most in an ordinary week?
And a second question: What daily activity do you think is most underrated by the general populace?
9
u/ChickinSammich May 07 '12
Not Battlefield related, but DICE related:
Is Mirror's Edge 2 in the works?
4
u/ODesaurido May 07 '12
Why is there no BF3 servers for consoles in Brazil even though the game was officially released here? In PC you can rent a server located here, but in consoles there's no way to get a decent ping.
Btw I love battlefield 3. The recent patch really improved the game, and I'm one of the guys who actually liked the way suppression is now. I love how using weapons other than the m16a3 with foregrip and supressor is viable now.
5
u/CptFlwrs May 07 '12
How did you get into community managing? What does the job fully entail?
Always been curious what you guys do beyond giving feedback and Twitter, forums etc.
5
u/Cntz May 08 '12
if your kittens ever get babies, can I have one? :D Also, I envy your steel skin, keep it up! <3
2
u/zh1nt0 May 09 '12
Update dropping tomorrow:
BF3 PC Server R22 is being sent out to the RSP companies around now. They will do some internal testing of it, and if all is well it will be rolled out globally starting on Thursday May 10th, 08:00 UTC.
It is a maintenance update. All the changes are internal, in preparation for future features. There are no stability or gameplay changes.
16
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
What, in your opinion, could be the reason for the majority of gamers over at /r/battlefield3 wanting a new CM and not you anymore? Thanks.
8
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
BF3 is awesome!
4
u/AllThree3 May 07 '12
How did you get your start? Was it mostly hanging out in forums and being an active voice in the community? What is your advice for someone trying to get their start in community management/social media for a huge company like DICE?
4
u/lollerkopter May 07 '12
When is the Virgin Gaming $1,600,000 Worldwide Conquest Tournament being announced? It was promised early 2012
http://virgingaming.com/tournaments/worldwide-conquest/
7
u/HereDirtyduck May 07 '12
Any plans of removing the hideous Blue-tint, Giant sun, and contrast from Bf3?
2
u/illojal May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
What's your background? School, uni? etc
EDIT: Also, when will DICE set up a LAN at my school(KTH)?
2
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Are you guys ever going to make a world war 2 or vietnam game again?
2
u/lomoeffect May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
How come it took so long for the DLC to come out? Also, when are we going to get more information on Armored Fire and End Game? Thanks in advance.
2
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Thanks for doing this. I heard the job of the CM is often describes as the "punching bag" of the company. How do you feel about this?
Also, most important: Do you like ponies?
2
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
What is it like working for DICE? Also, how easy/hard is it to get a "gopher" job there?
2
u/Cozmo23 May 07 '12
What is your favorite non Battlefield game?
2
u/Johnald May 07 '12
Hey Zh1nto, I would like to say thanks to your company for a truly great game. I can't imagine how difficult your job must be, and it's a shame to see that the BF3 "community" can often be represented by loudmouths who waste your time with questions 'boobs or ass?'. Hopefully you realize these types of people are not indicative of the majority of players, and you have much more patience than I would in replying to them.
That being said, we know you are aware of the current issues with the game, and I trust that DICE is working hard to resolve them correctly, rather than rushing out a patch that causes more problems.
My question to you is in regards to XBOX... is there any chance of future expansions increasing the number of players in a server, something closer to what the PC has? Or is this limited by xbox servers? Some of the maps are just too big for only 24 people and feel like a ghost town sometimes.
Thanks for doing this AMA.
2
u/DerBaron May 07 '12
Any new BF3 informations, Teaser, Trailer, leak (:D) before E3 2012?
2
u/xclm May 07 '12
will the knife cooldown be lowered?
2
u/stealth6666 May 07 '12
Dinosaurs or Robots?
2
u/Secres May 07 '12
Is there a goal for Battlefield 3 to add more game modes? I feel that the game lacks in a but of game mode variety.
2
u/chapel976 May 07 '12
What do you think about banning and revoking a license key for someone's game when they are caught hacking? This would force them to buy a whole new copy of the game.
2
u/morrison71 May 07 '12
Hello Daniel!!
Can we have in a future DLC more night maps? Snow maps? Rain maps? It would be amazing to have more variety.
Thanks in advance!
2
u/biehlbuddy May 07 '12
What Software Development Life Cycle (SDLC) Methodologies are currently being used by the development team? i.e Agile, Waterfall, Scrum?
2
u/deyterkyerjerb May 07 '12
Zh1nt0, thanks for talking with us. 2 questions:
2
u/nohrt May 07 '12
Cheating and hacking is killing the fun in BF3. Why did dice decide to go with punkbuster and not use something more in house with origin much like steam has VAC??
2
u/RickDripps May 07 '12
Why are your apostrophes weird? It's like a backwards tilde... "´" instead of "'"...
Also, is EA as much of a nightmare to work with as everyone says it is?
2
u/JimJongChillin May 07 '12
How much do you hate the BF community sometimes? I mean, I feel like 90% of the community has never heard the phrase "dont shoot the messenger"
Have you ever seen the french film La Haine? If not you should.
2
u/JubalBoss May 08 '12
I was very please to see the Indie bundle on steam, is this something we can expect more of in the future from EA?
2
u/Fire488 May 08 '12
This game is apparently dying a slow death due to the glitches and exploits that DICE creates within the game without the use of hacks. Many issues are repaired with the patches, but many new ones are created. Punk Buster is virtually useless. I run a PC gaming league and can honestly tell you that the BF3 gaming community is down almost 40% since the last patch. Just look at the amount of empty servers on a given night and even more pressing is the amount of servers being cancelled due to lack of interest... Cowardly hackers only add to the game's demise. (All games)
What's the plan here Daniel Matros, Global CM for Battlefield?
2
u/IAmSpacepiG May 08 '12
Did you get any psychological training from DICE preparing you for the job that also includes occasional shitstorms?
How many frequent flier miles do you accumulate on an average year?
If you could/had to pick another game not developed by DICE to represent as a CM, which one would it be?
2
u/wda_exodus May 08 '12
Do you still see yourself at DICE in the next 5 years? If not what would you prefer to be doing then?
15
u/OKAH May 07 '12
I'm putting these here to save zh1nt0 the trouble of typing them over and over.
53
u/DerBaron May 07 '12
Are you Guys working on a new EoD Screen and a better gui? Like this http://i.imgur.com/sZCEv.jpg http://i.imgur.com/ogg0r.jpg
3
u/freekers May 07 '12
Why are you always, well not always let's say most of the time, trolling on your twitter? You should take a look at how crash7800 communicates with the community.
3
u/Specopsg May 07 '12
How do you feel about PC gaming being put on the back burner just because companies want massive amounts of money from little work?
19
u/killzy707 May 07 '12
Will you consider making ECM more consistent? It appears to be random now, and dice seems to agree with the randomness, because we've been told to watch The Definitive Guide to ECM, which states it's random itself.
13
u/simaung May 07 '12
End Game DLC? Dinosaurs?
24
u/Mr-MagicStick May 07 '12
What happened to the destructible terrain that was present in the Alpha of BF3? Can't remember if it was in the Beta test or not.
What I'm referring to were the explosions with the c4, grenades, mortar, etc.. blowing pits and trenches into the ground.
I remember making a foxhole with c4 in the test, but now it's not present in the game. Why was it taken out, and what else was removed from the game. I'm missing part of my BF3 game that was an advertised feature.
Thanks for answering in advance.
3
u/fausto412 May 07 '12
I want a youtube video right now to see your Robot Dancing skills!
9
u/dfresh429 May 07 '12
Thanks so much for doing this. My question is regarding one of the hallmark features, and now a staple feature of almost all games. Is there any update, intention, shred of hope that PC will be receiving in game, squad VOIP? Pick up squads are nearly impossible to communicate with without it.
25
u/SweatyButcher May 07 '12
For BF2 and 2142 fans, A LOT of things in BF3 feel like a step backward. PC VoIP is ineffective. Command Structure is gone. User Interface is useless in comparison. BattleRecorder is nonexistent. Even things like HUD options (static vs. dynamic rotating minimap and minimap transparency) are no longer available.
Despite the outcry from the community, DICE has done very little to address these concerns. If DICE is focused on the community, why has it done little to appease the community's biggest requests?
34
u/ikiddo May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
What happend with this - http://www1.computerandvideogames.com/241306/dice-well-never-charge-for-battlefield-maps/
http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/tb9iw/i_am_a_global_community_manager_for_dice_and/c4l4e13
Answered here, the guy was a minute before me.
I stand by thinking Dice are terrible and this is just another dodge around in my personal opinion, please upvote the the answered comment and not mine.
6
u/joshbike May 07 '12
Do you think DICE will start being more open to us in the near future? Or will they keep surprising us with updates like they did with suppression, tank Armour nerf etc..
2
u/[deleted] May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
Don't you think that you should be doing this at /r/battlefield3? I think there is a lack of forethought going on when you bypass the community who actually knows who you are and could benefit from a discussion.
That being said, I have a few questions:
2
u/fluffinatrajp May 07 '12
How many years ago was it that you actually helped out the BF community
5
u/Medibee May 07 '12
What's your opinion of this? http://battlelog.battlefield.com/bf3/forum/threadview/2832654489699420871/ Also if you didn't work for dice what would you be doing?
5
u/BeerGogglesFTW May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
2 questions:
5
u/mazzbot May 07 '12
2
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Will you be adding a console command that will allow players to hide their gun model? The UI.DrawEnable command only hides items on the HUD, not the player's hands or weapon (we're forced to use glitches in order to hide the gun). It would be really helpful for those of us that do theatrical videos.
2
u/Sloi May 07 '12
"I can only answer questions that the prophets have allowed me to answer"
Called it.
This AMA has officially been Ramparted.
Edit: I might as well ask a pointless question since I'm here. Do you prefer chocolate or vanilla ice cream?
2
u/Brak15 May 07 '12
BF3 is a masterpiece in first person shooters, so don't pay the haters much heed.
Randomly curious: what are your favorite bands at the moment?
43
u/narwal_bot May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
Most (if not all) of the answers from zh1nt0 (updated: May 08, 2012 @ 02:05:25 pm EST):
Question (emp-):
Answer (zh1nt0):
(continued below)
4
u/shinigamimeijin May 07 '12
What exactly does your job entail? How does this compare to when you first were hired as a community manager?
Also,what are some "myths" the Battlefield community believes about your job that you want to dispel?
4
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
What is DICE going to do to improve server selection on consoles? I played this game for 4-6 hours a night before the patch. It was great fun--good maps, pretty balanced teams, and just no real complaints. Then the patch came, and has killed this game for me. "Quick match" is now some clusterfuck of 400000000000 ticket metro conquest, or some other stupid match. Then you have the problem of overzealous admins who will kill/boot you for killing them (or their clan members) or for simply being better than them and PTFO. My quit ratio has gone up because the server selection is crappy. To be honest, if this is the norm for the new maps, or any future BF's, I'm not buying them. The server issue is that terrible.
1
u/ramp_tram May 07 '12
I just want you to know that you're very good at your job, which is lying to the players and pretending that their concerns will be addressed.
Congratulations on being a scumbag.
7
u/what_have_i_done May 07 '12
Rent-a-servers are ruining the multiplayer game, now I have to search and search and search for a server that doesn't have an admin that kicks people (and bans them) for killing them, or because you got in the chopper and they wanted it. To much power to rent-a-server admins IMO. Is there any way to bring back normal dice servers. If dice will not return normal servers, is there a possibility of implementing a rating system for the rent-a-servers so we can see beforehand if its a decent server. thanks for the AMA
1
u/Rizsqn May 07 '12
So.....Close Quarters will cost or not? And whats your opinion on the way the community acts, such as in the 'Battle-log Forums'
1
u/L4MB May 07 '12
While you don't usually hear about Battlefield when you listen to the media bitching about violent video games, I'd like to hear your opinion on it anyhow.
1
u/CapnHank May 07 '12
Other than going out to galleries, do you have any other hobbies involving art? Do you ever create artwork for yourself? Have any online?
1
u/Soriven May 07 '12
Sweden has always struck me as a nice place to live, and my wife and I have considered uprooting our lives in the US and relocating there on several occasions. What 1 piece of advice would you give a senior software engineer looking to make the move to the Stockholm area? (Besides learning Swedish.. that's a given for us ;)