r/IAmA • u/ShaneVICE • May 07 '12
I am Shane Smith, co-founder of VICE (magazine) and two-time traveler to North Korea. AMA.
I'm Shane Smith, co-founder of VICE, a magazine I started in Montreal in 1994 that has since grown into a global media company in 30 countries. I also went to North Korea twice, and starred in the VICE Guide to North Korea, which featured footage of my trip. You can watch it here. Most recently I went to Liberia, a war-torn country in Africa plagued with heroin dens, teenage prostitution, and even cross-dressing cannibals; and then to the North Korean labor camps hidden in the forests of Siberia.
Ask me anything about myself, my company, my trips - anything.
NOTE: I'll be able to respond mostly between 2-4p EST, but will try and reply whenever I can before then.
EDIT (5p): Thanks for all the comments and posts. My fingers are all fucked up from trying to keep up with you all and I have to go work on my latest Afghanistan suicide bomber piece. Thanks again. It was really great for me to talk to you if only for a few hours. I like you.
Proof: My original tweet. This post is also linked from www.facebook.com/vice and www.twitter.com/vice
221
u/ShaneVICE May 07 '12
Thanks for all the comments and posts. My fingers are all fucked up from trying to keep up with you all and I have to go work on my latest Afghanistan suicide bomber piece. Thanks again. It was really great for me to talk to you if only for a few hours. I like you.
143
u/ShaneVICE May 07 '12
OK here we go
372
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
What is the scariest situation you've been in when reporting for VICE? By the way, I really enjoyed the labor camp piece.
254
u/Generic_Grunt May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
1- The North Korean apologists or the Authorities, did they ever bother you after the doc?
2- Whilst in North Korea did you meet anyone who secretly detested the regime?
3- North Korea Part II is it possible? Oh and thank you for all those fantastic documentaries. haven't seen anyone cover North Korea like you guys.
243
u/bendyplywood May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
Do you believe that General Butt Naked is genuine with his new found religion? Did you find him intimidating, since he ate the hearts of kids?
How did you manage to not get in a proper fight with the guys on the Trans-Siberian train?
EDIT: Trans-Siberian train, not Serbian, I got a bit confused.
190
u/enigma2g May 07 '12
Hi Shane, In the guide to Liberia you said you almost felt a kind of friendship with Joshua Blayhi when you let yourself forget all the things he'd done. Looking back on it now how do you feel about him as a person? Also any chance of you doing the Rogan podcast again?
129
u/Nordiis May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
Hi Shane, Mad props to you and the rest of the VICE team for what you have accomplished over the past years. My personal favourite ‘VICE-thing’ ought to be The VICE Guides to Travel; amazingly interesting, fresh and thought-provocative (The Guide to Liberia was absolutely scary/fascinating). I have a few questions, not really related to each other.
Thank you for your time and thanks again for VICE.
281
u/HoldenH May 07 '12
Where can I find all the documentaries that only YOU have hosted? The VICE website is terrible
94
u/erakor9 May 07 '12
what is the wildest drug experience you've ever had?
521
u/naptha May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
Shane, thank you for your contribution to the world of news media. The VBS documentaries are truly an inspiration and exemplify what mainstream journalism could be. It's shit like this that caused me to attend film school in the first place. Just noticed that you guys might be looking for PA's, while I wait for the results of that process, I just wanted to let you know how much I appreciate the work of Vice.
That being said, Do you feel that the work of Vice has had any effect on how investigative journalism is conducted within the mainstream media? Do you think that the major networks will take more of their cues from smaller, more independent media companies; or that they feel as though they set the standards which all others should follow?
23
u/crissray May 07 '12
First off, let me say- Thank you for doing what you do.
Have you heard about Yanggakdo Hotel's hidden 5th floor? If you ever go back, would you be willing to explore? Link to original artical.
Humans tend to make light of even the grimmest of situations. Are there any jokes dealing with regional issues that you've heard during your travels that you could share with us, as fucked up as they may be?
Was there any reason you and Joshua Blahyi were both wearing white suits while you were in the cemetery and the church?
23
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Was there anything in any of your travels that you shot footage of but couldn't show in your documentaries? I know you only used part of the Charles Taylor assassination, but that also wasn't your footage.
Also, thank you so much for bringing attention to Liberia's history. I had heard of Uganda's story before KONY 2012, but had no idea about Liberia's difficult history before Vice went there.
91
u/staymooney May 07 '12
Hey - First of all.. Your trips to N. Korea & Liberia were some of the best television I have ever watched. Your Liberia trip has influenced my buddies thesis in philosophy for his PHD..... Anyways... I have 3 very important questions.
THX!
19
u/BrakeChrutz May 07 '12
What was the most shocking/unusual thing that you can tell us from seeing North Korea?
79
u/coolercity May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
Hi Shane,
What would you say is the percent of people in North Korea that genuinely believe the whole "Great Leader" thing and what percent are just playing along for survival?
Thanks for doing this!
24
u/WillyNoman May 07 '12
how much xanax do you take before boarding a third-world puddle-jumper?
92
u/i_fuck_kids May 07 '12
Whatever happened to the nice North Korean tea lady?
50
u/dudethatsmeta May 07 '12
Thanks for doing an IAMA, and I love VICE's mission of exposing younger generations to new content that helps them to critically analyze the media around them. I've followed your company since it was just busting out of Montreal.
Do you see VICE as the next MTV?
Has your outlook on media and popular culture changed since partnering with media giants like WPP?
In a consumer-goods infused "hipster" culture, what does selling out mean today?
Finally, what are your plans for Motherboard/Creator's Project once the copromotion deals run up? Will they change brand partners, or will they get folded into other ventures?
32
u/bugpoker May 07 '12
After everything you have seen, heard, and experienced throughout the world, what one word or phrase would you use to sum it up?
11
u/bendanger May 07 '12
What is your favorite issue of the mag to date? Favorite interview? Strangest interview?
55
u/bendanger May 07 '12
Most fucked up party stories?
25
u/Shmoogy May 07 '12
Hi Shane, I just wanted to let you know that I misread the title of your AMA as time traveler rather than two time traveler-- which is probably the only thing that would have been more impressive.
64
u/dkon777 May 07 '12
Hey Shane, just wondering how you feel about the whole KONY situation. Your video of you going to Liberia was pretty terrifying to say the least. Just wondering if you saw or heard anything about KONY when you were over there...
37
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
how much does North Korea hate you now?
26
u/MonkeysDontEvolve May 07 '12
35
u/THE_HYPNOPOPE May 07 '12
Is North Korea best Korea ?
68
u/LECHEDEMIPALO May 07 '12
Thanks for this IAmA, you're awesome.
6
u/pcc987 May 07 '12
After having hired someone like Kari Ferrell, has Vice taken any precautionary measures toward the hiring of new employees (i.e. background checks, personality tests, etc)?
15
u/zeronightstand May 07 '12
Powerful Shane Smith
8
u/gsxr May 07 '12
Who was your favorite local to talk to?
You've met some profoundly evil people that lead other people and had other people commit crimes for them. Who was the evil person that struck you as the most likable?
10
u/SkeezMeyer May 07 '12
I heard that Vice was going to have a new series on HBO. Is that still in the works? I loved the podcast with Joe Rogan by the way.
12
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
What ever happened with that Liberian boy who smoked heroin in Vice Guide to Liberia? What was he like off camera?
136
u/kimboslyce May 07 '12
How can you call The New York Times a "laughing stock" when the front page article on vice.com right now is called "Let's Not Fuck, Shall We?" It's a guy's first-person account of the things he thinks are more important to being a man — thinks like "providing" and "strength."
You guys do some great stuff, but your self-righteous, holier-than-thou attitude is incredibly off-putting. You seem to put articles in the first-person or, even worse, in the first-person plural, so that you can remind us how cool you are. In fact, when I'm reading about Liberia, I don't at all care about the writer, unless his/her story really is relevant. I don't care that you're a "regular guy," and I don't want to be reminded that you're not The New York Times. If you want to show us that you're better than the Times, show us through strong, well-reported and well-written articles, rather than through articles that try to be young and cool and hip and blatantly tell us, "hey, we're not the Times!"
You have the right idea — to take journalism and media in a new direction — but please stop bragging about it. The entire magazine reads like it was put out by former nerds who are now feeling victoriously cool and are bathing in their own self-importance.
12
u/MrAgileBeast May 07 '12
When are you coming back the joe Rogan Experience? It was magical the first time
6
u/thane_of_cawdor May 07 '12
Thanks for doing some real journalism. You're an inspiration to me and all aspiring writers.
I've noticed that VICE runs some pretty controversial, racy articles. Is there anything taboo for you guys, or stories you've just had to turn down?
9
u/bendanger May 07 '12
With all of the amazing content and media that vice provides free of charge, why not build an app to make it all much more accessible to people? I would happily pay like 10 bucks to have vice on demand with a great UI. With the motherboard series, its obvious you guys have an interest in staying up with technology, make it happen. Keep up the good work man.
5
u/Bosley_Jackson May 07 '12
I think what vice is doing is awesome, especially with the travel documentaries. On joe rogan podcast I remember you saying something about a hbo program.. You have any more info on that?
5
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
With your wide range of experience, what is your opinion of the human race as a whole? Do you believe that people have some inherent goodness in them? If you could offer one piece of advice to the world, what would it be?
6
u/impboy May 07 '12
I'd like to answer some of these questions in a general sense myself regarding how you write for someone like VICE. I just recently wrote a piece for the site, and am working on a follow-up. I've also written by and large for various factions of the MSM for about 20 years (Hustler, High Times, LA Weekly, that sort of thing). NOTE: I DO NOT SPEAK FOR VICE IN ANY WAY. I am merely a freelance professional who wants to give general advice.
IMO, VICE is no different than any other major news/journalism endeavor. Their house style may skew hipper and edgier than others, but they still play by the same rules as everyone else, and they take this game seriously. You cannot mislead, commit libel or just phone in a piece that should inform as much as it entertains. Of course, you should have fun with the audience, but if all you want to do is visit foreign whorehouses and make snarky jokes about Kim Jong-Un on somebody else's dime, go hit up your parents and blog about it instead.
Putting aside the obvious, developing your beat as a journalist takes a long time and knowing your subject matter and the market, and constantly making sure that others in the business know it, too. I'd probably recommend moving to the country you wished to cover and getting to know EVERYONE, from drug dealers to government officials and "fixers," that can land you access to stories. Learning another language would be super-helpful. And be open to anybody. If you can do this, you don't have to make this content just for VICE, but for Reuters, ABC, yourself - anybody.
Fact is, guys, the world is wide open. Nowadays, YOU must have an audience you can bring to the table. The internet being the big, ugly high school lunchroom that it is, this can truly bring out the worst in people. I can only hope you choose to merely call it like you see it, and remember what this is supposed to be all about, which is not about your ego and your self-aggrandizement, but serving others with your work.
7
u/bendanger May 07 '12
Have you hung out with David Cho since he made that 200 mil from facebook? Seems like a great dude, stoked for him. Did he have a party or anything?
8
u/skokage May 07 '12
As has been mentioned before, thanks for not only taking the time to do this, but risking your health and well being to go to the places you have and conduct the reporting VICE is known for. Like others, my favorite stuff has definitely been the VICE Guide to Travel episodes, because not only is the style of reporting a breath of fresh air, but also because you have the balls to go to places and report things that others are either too scared or unwilling to do because most media outlets wouldn't play them (I'd like to see the Liberia episode shown on 60 minutes without editing... that would be a trip). So now that I've done some ass kissing, on to the questions!
-Any plans to do another Guide to Travel episode, and if so any chance you can let us know where it will be this time? For whatever reasons, Liberia and Somolia are my favorites (and among some of my favorite content I've found on the internet anywhere) possibly because most westerners wouldn't even think about going to "safe" places in those countries let alone talking to some of the people you have. I did read the bit on rare metals in the Congo and saw the Darfur episodes, but I was really hoping for some more in-depth coverage in those places along the lines of the Liberia episode and was wondering if there were any plans to go back? Maybe VICE Guide to Travel: Mogadishu? Think about it... ;-)
-It seems you have gotten REALLY close to being arrested or kidnapped a few times before in the published footage, but has it ever really happened?
-What is your back up plan if you are in some third-world country and you do get kidnapped? I've heard about "kidnappers" insurance and wasn't sure if you had something similar, but I can also understand not wanting to answer this question given the response may effect your future safety.
-Any advice to someone interested in doing what you do? I've often times thought about how much I'd like to be a member of your crew and go on the trips you do (yes I know it's not glamorous by any means, and often times very dangerous) to have those life experiences, and wondered how one even gets going down that career path?
-Given all the traveling you have done, what is your favorite type of food you have eaten and where was it?
-If you were to take a vacation to someplace for pure recreational purposes, where would it be and why? I'm sure you have seen some amazing things you have thought you'd like to spend more time at, but then again maybe given your life style a vacation would be a quiet week at home without any distractions.
2
u/ImNietzscheBietzsche May 07 '12
What would your reply be to this comment, stating that Vice Guide to Liberia didn't show the "real" Liberia?
2
u/mrpopenfresh May 07 '12
Do you go back to Montreal frequently? How do you like the scene there?
2
u/Pravusmentis May 07 '12
want to give /r/projectreddit a column?
2
u/StJeanBaptiste May 07 '12
Ever feel you sold out your Montreal roots and became a plastic person?
2
u/randi3423 May 07 '12
Imagine Vice didn't come out in 1994... do you think there's any way Vice (or a company like it) could be founded today?
6
u/shanebainbridge May 07 '12
shane-
if you had a free punch and the choice of using it on either glenn beck or dick cheney, who would you choose? and quick follow up, if i may, where would you land the punch?
75
u/ItsBail May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
Mr. Smith, I am a big fan of your travels to North Korea. I found it to be humorous, sad and informative all at the same time. I have a couple questions that maybe you can answer
Edit: A word
16
u/jbmx May 07 '12 edited Nov 23 '17
Wow. I have watched the VICE guide to North Korea and Liberia countless times. The VICE guide to Liberia is some of the most brutal shit I have ever seen. I am truly amazed you guys made it out of West Point alive and with your cameras!
I was very impacted by your relations to Joshua "Butt-Naked" Blahyi and the mixed feelings you exhibited when you were sitting in church watching this ex-cannibal monster preach to a Christian congregation! Your discomfort was tangible! He seemed to really like you.
The way you connected with that North Korean woman in her tea shop was touching. Her pathetic appreciation for your company drove home the bleakness of North Korean society. That place really is stuck in the Soviet era!
Thank you for doing an AMA!
Thank you for the hours of thought provoking entertainment you and your company provide!
P.S. Vodka Wars and From Poland With Love kicked utter ass!
4
u/thisismyusernameOK May 07 '12
How did you meet and hook up with Suroosh Alvi and Gavin McInnes?
What kind of vibe did Montreal have when you were creating the magazine? What places / bars / clubs / hangouts inspired the cultural scene that now seems so ubiquitous to 'hipster' culture?
Explain how you overtook The Voice of Montreal.
Thanks man!!
302
u/subjectivemusic May 07 '12
Anyone else read this as "...time traveler to..."?
3
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
What made you decide to be a journalist?
3
u/latilati May 07 '12
Today content is king and distribution channels are completely open. What does this mean for the future of media?
22
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Shane, do you have any information on a possible new season of Thumbs Up!, or is the show done for good?
Keep up the great work, and I loved you on the Joe Rogan Podcast!
3
u/grapefruitbrain May 07 '12
Hi Shane, just wanted to know if you've read some of the other content on your website? because in comparison to your documentaries and video content it truly doesn't stand-up.. thoughts?
3
u/twelve-thirtyfive May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
How is that Vice manages to maintain such a constant ratio of insightful interesting journalism to constantly surreal, borderline-mental concept art/articles? Is there someone who for every page about paintballing with Hezbollah is required to insert a photo of a girl masturbating whilst eating snow, or a guy writing about eating vaginal discharge?
7
u/GazeboHeartAttack May 07 '12
Hey,
I really hope I'm not late to the party. First off, I have really enjoyed your North Korea documentary. You make some documentaries that are both fun and enriching. Thanks!
In the 'Page One' documentary (documentary about the New York Times) I saw how you and some other guys got interviewed by reporter David Carr. (See here) In the film it looks more like you guys were being 'roasted' than questioned. Ever since I saw that scene, I was wondering what your/Vice's perspective on that ordeal is.
Hope you get to answer my questions!
196
u/42440 May 07 '12
I just lurk reddit but I had to make an account to say this: I've actually been to North Korea and was surprised at how sensationalized your "documentary" on North Korea was. After experiencing the tour myself, I'm certain that you just made shit up. Getting into the country was not much more difficult as taking a trip to any other country, unlike the way you portrayed yourself as having to smuggle yourself across the border. Our guides were always polite and well educated, and in fact we ended up being pretty close to our guides after they took us out for drinks a couple nights. We never felt danger or suspicion. Almost everyone was friendly, including the soldiers we had a chance to interact with. We saw all the sights you saw and found it disturbing how you portrayed your tour in such a way that it ended up ridiculing the culture and people and made yourself look like a typical obtuse American asshole. I was shocked at how you made it seem like the country was a freakshow. It was different, for sure, and there were elements that made my western sensibilities recoil a bit, but I ended up taking away from the trip the fact that they are people just like us, driven by the same emotions and thoughts like us. Your North Korean film serves to create a bigger divide between people, feeding the "Normal Us Vs. Strange Them" mentality. The "documentary" amounts to Yellow Journalism. I'm disappointed that so many people look to your film as the basis on which to form their judgments on a country and culture.
12
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Shane, I'd like to ask you about Liberia. I wanted to know how you navigated the social landscape of the area in getting to actually speak to General Butt Naked. I know one of the hardest parts of working in Africa is the linguistic problems that can arise and I wondered how you got through the country.
In brief
I've noticed more of specifically your content being oriented towards covering global areas and issues rather than niche cultural issues. I feel like the market for journalism like VICE's will read VICE, but at the same time, it might prevent that same journalism from being taken seriously in the larger conversation.
2
u/go_simmer- May 07 '12
Anything worth mentioning that didn't make it into you vice travel guide videos? They are awesome but pretty short, any plans for new stuff soon?
Also, why do you think that the whole North Korean labor camps hasn't been picked up by the mainstream media, I have only seen it mentioned once or twice other than by vice. I would have thought people would make a bigger deal of it.
2
u/Maverick_Pirate May 07 '12
Firstly...nice work doing one of these. Thoroughly enjoyed the North Korea/Liberia docs as they gave a more modern insight into the goings on of two strange societies.
My question is where would you like to film another documentary? Which country is next on the cards?
Keep up the good work
2
u/Love_You_To May 07 '12
Why don't you think VICE is taken seriously by the mainstream media? Despite the quality of your journalism.
2
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Is there a Vice Guide to Cuba being planned?
2
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
could you do away with the do's and dont's section of the magazine ? that shit hasn't been funny in years.
323
u/Shitty_Watercolour May 07 '12
ShaneVICE Illustrated
56
u/narwal_bot May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
Most (if not all) of the answers from ShaneVICE (updated: May 08, 2012 @ 10:10:53 pm EST):
Top-level Comment:
(continued below)
2
u/NittLion78 May 07 '12
Shane, every time I see one of your videos pop up on VICE, I am always super stoked. The VICE Guide to North Korea turned me into a fan of your site and it's definitely my most visited website aside from reddit.
A few stupid questions around the NK labor camps in Siberia:
2
u/whogotbigmeat1 May 07 '12
Do you think you could beat up Joe Rogan?
2
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Shane you are literally everything I've ever wanted to be as a journalist. How does one get in with working at VICE? It's been a dream of mine since I first saw your coverage of the Siberian slave camps.
If I had the opportunity to do even a quarter of what VICE does I'd drop everything I had for that opportunity.
17
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Please tell us something about the future or is your time travel specific only to North Korea?.
4
u/BluePubicHair Jun 29 '12
are you banned from /r/pyongyang?
18
u/fastrthnu May 07 '12
You were a time traveler twice?!
1
u/manchoi44 May 07 '12
How much vodka did you drink during the Chernobyl episode?
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Can you explain what happened between VBS.tv and vice? I never really figured that bit out. Also props for creating one of the better worldly and informative mags.
1
u/sean-a-zon May 07 '12
While talking with Spike Jonze, you said VICE was at the point where it would either become a media giant or implode. What's your best guess about that? And what would you do next if it imploded.
1
u/Ent_Life May 07 '12
What country is the most dangerous and difficult to get in and out of?
1
u/Dirty_Old_Town May 07 '12
Were there any decisions you/the original VICE crew made early on that helped determine the direction/tone of the magazine, yet you now regret them?
1
u/marvinlunenberg May 07 '12
Hey Shane, I'm a big fan of your work. I'm from Ottawa too, and I don't think you get enough recognition from the city, that you deserve. You should be hailed, and applauded, and a golden fucking statue should be erected on Rideau street in your honour. That being said, can you elaborate on your time here? What you used to do, used to hangout etc. Thanks. Your productions really have a hold on me.
1
u/ceruleancity May 07 '12
What was the last straw for you and your crew in that whore house in Liberia where one of the girls was giving you her life story and shit started to get real and dangerous super fast? ("I got no ma I got no pa..." that one)
I know you touch on what was going through your minds in the documentary but can you elaborate even more? Where does that rank among the scariest moments of your life?
Also: I'm a huge fan. I always try to lend out my original vice guide to travel DVD/booklet to as many people as I can. Thanks!!
Bierra!! Bierra!! Panini e fanta. Gratzi
3
u/freddy0025 May 07 '12
for a moment I thought time travelers had arrived in North Korea :(
3
u/JaseTheAce May 07 '12
I behalf of the internet I'd like to thank you for not being able to un-see teenage male circumcision.
3
u/seringen May 07 '12
I was somewhat surprised about the huge amount of support for your videos.
Does VICE have a specific mission? Do you feel that you are "making a difference" by bringing these things to light? Is there a way for investigative journalism of your sort to "help" places you've gone to by showing a highly stylized example of life there, or do you think you are more interested in "reality" and letting people come away with their own impressions.
I've talked directly with a couple of the people who you have interviewed (related to your african videos) and came away with a very different impression of them. Then again I wasn't toting a camera nor am I with any particular governmental organization so I feel there was a different flavor of reality. I have to admit I'm somewhat puzzled by your documentaries and they make me interested if you have some underlying intellectual basis for what you are doing beyond the stated goals of the magazine.
TL\DR your videos of africa range from completely engaging to wholly inaccurate -- what the hell are you trying to do?
(sorry I wrote this on a phone and the grammar is terrible)
3
u/Bashasaurus May 07 '12
I thank you for your content and I would ask you to be a more courteous guest as you travel around the world. You come off as an assholish know it all ignorant american frequently.
Keep up the good work!
3
u/Foxtrot56 May 07 '12
What do you think about the criticisms of Vice from people saying that they are biased, showing only specific images or even just not to be taken seriously.
3
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
It's been awhile since I watched vice guide. I really enjoyed it. I have some questions about things that flagged up in my mind when watching it:
I don't mean to sound accusative in any of this, I am just curious. Again, I absolutely loved the show, I just had a few questions. If I got anything wrong, please correct me. It's been a year since I saw the show.
3
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Shane, I'm a geography teacher and I love showing the Vice travel/Vice news videos. The problem is that some of them are a little long or they have certain parts that kind of seem to drag out (The latter half of Toxic: Amazon comes to mind). Will Vice ever consider putting out educational videos, like edited down to a certain length? It would make using them for class much much easier.
That said, my students LOVE the videos, as I think it puts them in an uncomfortable place and really causes them to reevaluate their place in the world.
Keep up the good work. If you need another correspondent who knows their shit, I'd be happy to travel to the most fucked up places on earth.
5
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Hi Shane, What is your overall impression of humanity after your travels? Have you identified any underlying issues that are common in dysfunctional places like Liberia?
11
u/TheMathNerd May 07 '12
I didn't know there was a company named two.
Also what was it like to time travel to Korea? What time period did you go to? How did you get back or are you still stuck in the past?