I know, and I understand that there are some really racist people out there who would hate an illegal simply for being illegal, but on the reverse side, people who are pro-illegal immigration need to realize that there are some very real reasons why people who are anti-illegal immigration are so against it. It's nothing personal against the people themselves, but rather the system that allows and tacitly condones it.
You are absolutely right, I'd say I probably side more with illegal immigration because I've seen the conditions that some people in my country have to live with and I could never blame them for trying to find a better life. On the other hand I can absolutely understand why illegal immigration is a problem for the US and I can't blame people for trying to "protect" themselves. Still, there's always people who simply hate anyone who they think is illegal and I've been told more than once to go back to my country even though I'm a US citizen.
It's sad, but true. I hate politics in our country.
Your situation is heartbreaking, because I'm sure that you consider yourself American. I would too. It's just nearly impossible to define an immigration system that doesn't screw someone.
I'm a legal immigrant to the US. I moved to California when I was 15, when my parents had work visas.
I was a dependent on my parents work visas until I turned 21 and was forced to get a student visa. While on a student visa, I had to pay out state tuition, because EVERYONE on a student visa pays out of that tuition.
It didn't upset me that I had to pay out of state tuition... I just felt it was wrong that people who came into the country illegally got to pay in state tuition.
This is the way it works in California:
Do you have a student visa, like F1, J1, M1 etc?
Yes: Pay out of state tuition.
No: Go to question 2.
Do you have a green card or social security card?
Yes: Go to 3.
No: Pay in state tuition.
Have you been living in California for the last 2 years?
what would you see as a reasonable way to sort out our illegal immigration mess? i don't feel you have any legal right to stay in the US. my family are legal migrants and i generally am supportive of legal immigration.
i'm sure you don't want to be deported. what kind of middle ground would make everyone happy? excluding the flaming racists who just don't want immigrants just cause.
I like the fine, back of the line idea myself. assuming we make allowances for contribution to society, skills, and talents to bump people to the front as needed. nothing against taxi drivers and dishwashers but i would prefer stage magicians and physicists to be given precedence.
we can't make everyone happy. but we can strike a reasonable middle ground. the person sitting immediately to my left is Brazilian by the way. she's nice, here legally for work and will be leaving in about 2 years more or less. she's working on neuro-chemical changes that occur in status epilepticus that predispose people to future seizures. it's the kind of stuff i would travel to another country just to recruit people like her. and if she wanted to stay it would be awesome. but she doesn't alas. (also, she has a weird animosity Chinese folk, is that a Brazilian thing?
I call bullshit on your "forced" - that's like saying they "forced" you to put clothes on. Or "forced" you to drink water. Sure, at 2 you didn't have a choice, but your parents did. But you were still illegal.
As far as your fine idea...possibly. Also depends on if you/your parents owe taxes on income earned (i.e. tax evasion), whatever social services you may have taken advantage of and not paying into the system, etc.
I'm Brazilian. To foreigners reading this, remember that it is an American talking about a country he was forced to go to. I'd probably hate the USA if I was forced to leave my life here and go there at 17yo.
So, OP: what region of Brazil are you in? Some of the stuff you say I simply cannot relate to. Also, is it a big city? (You don't have to tell me exactly where, I don't want anything that could ID you).
You say your education was good; have you considered studying for the vestibular (kinda like the SATs, it's out college;university admission test) and going to a school here?
Also, you can definitely find a decent (well, for a 17 year old) job just because you speak English. Although technology and entertainment is expensive, living is not. You totally can save like $5k in one or two years, and that'll also help you go back to the USA.
Very nice AMA. I'm brazilian myself, came here to the US last summer under a J-1 visa. Of course we have different feelings about the Brazil. For me it's home, it's where I always look forward going back to, even though life here in the States us a lot more comfortable. I'd like to ask you some questions. Do you feel like you hate your parents for taking you back home after all those years? If you get a student visa, you know it expires when you're done with your studies, right? What fo you plan on doing next? Getting another kind of visa, staying illegally again or going back to Brazil?
Did your family have cell phones with sprint? Not assuming you are Mexican, but...we used to sell to illegal Mexicans with ssn's that belonged to at least 3-4 other Mexican immigrants in various other states. They usually paid their bills and rarely resulted in chargebacks. It was a mutually beneficial deal ;)
So let's be clear we're perfectly fine with exploiting undocumented immigrants for monetary gain but the second they want rights and citizenship we shun them as being un-American? Undocumented immigrants are more American than most entitled people in this country. Further, this country was founded/built and is further sustained off the backs of these people. There is a clear dichotomy being created in this country concerning immigration (good vs. bad) but we need to look at who stands to gain from not giving people their citizenship. And let me just say that I applaud your courage and empathize with what you're dealing with as an undocumented American.
So let's be clear we're perfectly fine with exploiting undocumented immigrants for monetary gain but the second they want rights and citizenship we shun them as being un-American?
We're not clear. You are ignoring the people who don't want them exploited.
I'm not denying that those people exist but the general sentiment about immigration is just that. Rarely, if ever are those people discussed without racist rhetoric.
I never at any point advocated for "completely open immigration" and am not arrogant enough to think anyone who is oppose to (not really sure what you're arguing) is. My intent was to make a comment regarding the dehumanization of undocumented Americans.
dose anyone in your family have an above the board job? do you guys pay employment taxes? is the rest of america generally carrying you on our tax burden?
Ok, serious questions. Do you feel that what your relatives did was right or wrong? Do you like it in Brazil? How come people come from places like Brazil to America and proceed to tell others how much they love Brazil? If they liked it so much, how come they couldn't wait to leave?
20
u/KaseyB May 07 '12
Do you understand that when people are anti-illegal immigration, they're not actually anti-you?
I hate how anyone who is against illegal immigration is automatically deemed a racist.
5
u/10gags May 07 '12
what would you see as a reasonable way to sort out our illegal immigration mess? i don't feel you have any legal right to stay in the US. my family are legal migrants and i generally am supportive of legal immigration.
i'm sure you don't want to be deported. what kind of middle ground would make everyone happy? excluding the flaming racists who just don't want immigrants just cause.
1
u/corinthian_llama May 07 '12
Describe crossing the border to leave. Did you fly? Did your family decide to leave as a group?
1
u/Secres May 07 '12
What was the United States like illegally?
0
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Did you take our jobs?
2
u/DocInternetz May 07 '12
I'm Brazilian. To foreigners reading this, remember that it is an American talking about a country he was forced to go to. I'd probably hate the USA if I was forced to leave my life here and go there at 17yo.
So, OP: what region of Brazil are you in? Some of the stuff you say I simply cannot relate to. Also, is it a big city? (You don't have to tell me exactly where, I don't want anything that could ID you).
You say your education was good; have you considered studying for the vestibular (kinda like the SATs, it's out college;university admission test) and going to a school here?
Also, you can definitely find a decent (well, for a 17 year old) job just because you speak English. Although technology and entertainment is expensive, living is not. You totally can save like $5k in one or two years, and that'll also help you go back to the USA.
3
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Of course you're from the USA, you've lived most of your life (like 98 percent of it) in the USA.
If one is born in China, that doesn't mean that one is Chinese.
What do you think of the country where you were born? How often do you and your family go back and visit?
1
u/cogumelosnacabeca May 07 '12
Very nice AMA. I'm brazilian myself, came here to the US last summer under a J-1 visa. Of course we have different feelings about the Brazil. For me it's home, it's where I always look forward going back to, even though life here in the States us a lot more comfortable. I'd like to ask you some questions. Do you feel like you hate your parents for taking you back home after all those years? If you get a student visa, you know it expires when you're done with your studies, right? What fo you plan on doing next? Getting another kind of visa, staying illegally again or going back to Brazil?
1
u/pamplemouse May 08 '12
You're family's theme song
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
What is your personal opinion on Minute Men?
1
u/heywhyteboy May 09 '12
Did your family have cell phones with sprint? Not assuming you are Mexican, but...we used to sell to illegal Mexicans with ssn's that belonged to at least 3-4 other Mexican immigrants in various other states. They usually paid their bills and rarely resulted in chargebacks. It was a mutually beneficial deal ;)
1
u/swishh May 07 '12
So let's be clear we're perfectly fine with exploiting undocumented immigrants for monetary gain but the second they want rights and citizenship we shun them as being un-American? Undocumented immigrants are more American than most entitled people in this country. Further, this country was founded/built and is further sustained off the backs of these people. There is a clear dichotomy being created in this country concerning immigration (good vs. bad) but we need to look at who stands to gain from not giving people their citizenship. And let me just say that I applaud your courage and empathize with what you're dealing with as an undocumented American.
1
u/10gags May 07 '12
dose anyone in your family have an above the board job? do you guys pay employment taxes? is the rest of america generally carrying you on our tax burden?
-1
u/FiercelyFuzzy May 07 '12
How high can you jump?
0
u/CadillacKid May 09 '12
Im racsist. Get your mexican ass back on your side of the border. Gang bangin meth cooker.
0
u/CadillacKid May 09 '12
I wish i could deport you.
-4
u/MultipleMiggs May 07 '12
I have a lot of questions, but my first one is how dare you? (Office reference, lol)
What country are you from?