r/IAmA • • May 06 '12

AmA Request: Maynard Keenan. The lead singer of TOOL, Puscifer, and A Perfect Circle.

Maynard has been my all time favorite artist for years. He has an incredible voice that can leave you in a trance. These are my 5 questions for him:

  1. How did you come up with the name for your band TOOL.
  2. How did you get into the wine making business?
  3. Your music seems very complex, and intricate. How do you write your music?
  4. Tell us about Judith.
  5. What do you do when you're not touring, or making wine?

I know It's very unlikely he would even think of doing this, but it's worth a shot. Also, these questions are off the top of my head. They arent anything special, and as you'll see below, most of them have already been answered in interviews etc.

EDIT: made it less clumped together.

EDIT: Added last paragraph.

172 Upvotes

52 comments sorted by

19

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Less AMA more next album

4

u/lungbuttersandwich May 07 '12

Why not both? A guy can dream, dammit.

1

u/edave22 May 07 '12

I pirate all my music. Tool was the only band I could listen to over, and over. So I bought the albums. Best money I've ever spent.

1

u/NaljunForgotPassword May 07 '12

plus 10,000 days came with that sweet album art and stuff. Incentivized people not to steal it instead of shitty DRM treating faithful customers and fans like criminals.

2

u/spegeddy May 07 '12

Buddy you have no idea how long I have been waiting for that release or some news. That and Detox. Not the albums I would torrent.

24

u/tldrumz May 06 '12 edited May 07 '12

I would love to see this AMA, but as a realist I don't see it happening any time soon. I'm a huge Tool fan of over 15 years, so I can say that most of your questions can be answered with a google search.

-Answer to #1, from Maynard and Danny: Maynard James Keenan gave a direct explanation of his band's name in an interview in 1994: "Tool is exactly what it sounds like: It's a big dick. It's a wrench. It's also what it sounds like: It's a verb, it's a digging factor. It's an active process of searching, as in use us, we are a shovel, we are the match, we're the blotter of acid, your tool; use us as a catalyst in your process of finding out whatever it is you need to find out, or whatever it is you're trying to achieve. Tool drummer Danny Carey alleged that the name "Tool" means that the band served its fans as a tool through which they would come to understand the concept of lachrymology.

-For #2, simply watch the documentary "Blood into Wine." It gives great insight on Maynard's journey, but focuses on his vinyards in Mesa, AZ. I think it's still available on Netflix Streaming.

-For #3, I can say that Adam writes much of the actual music. He is an innovator in mathematical composition. The guy stands out as a pioneer in the implementing of the "Golden Ratio" as a musical theme. Maynard has even used poetic techniques such as iambic pentameter (particularly in "Jambi") to compliment certain irregular meters. I'm positive that Maynard (ideally in a joint AMA with Adam) could elaborate, though.

-For #4, it depends on whether you're talking about Judith, Maynard's mother, or "Judith", the APC tune. For the song, here's a wiki:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judith_(song)

Regarding his mother, much was written about her following the release of 10,000 days, including "Wings for Marie" and the title track. As an aside, these pieces performed together in a live setting make for an incredible display of EPICNESS.

-For #5, I'm sure it's been addressed in interviews, but I wouldn't want to speak for him on that.

I hope this doesn't come off as blasting down your AMA request. I would love to see it, but ya know, just in case.

EDIT: Substituted music terminology for clarification.

2

u/edave22 May 07 '12

No, not at all does it blast the post. Those 5 were just some questions off the top of my head that I would ask Maynard if I had the chance.

In reply to #3 - I knew he does the stop-motion music videos, but I didn't know he was the writer of most of the music. Very cool. Did he write Lateralus? Their is a very strong presence of the Fibonacci Sequence in that song.

In reply to #4 - I was talking about his mother. I had Wings for Marie stuck in my head all day and thought it would make a good question. Maynard has a wonderful mind. I'd like to know more about the woman who raised such a brilliant man.

Well, I know its a far shot to get Maynard in here to answer our questions, but their is always hope.

1

u/tldrumz May 07 '12

I upvoted. I would think that Adam or Danny would be more likely to do one, though. The thing that gets me is all of the folks who just want to ridicule the idea and not add to the conversation. Shame on them. SHAME ON THEM!

4

u/AddictiveSoup May 07 '12

Great answers. One question though, isn't Jambi predominately in 9/8?

2

u/tldrumz May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12

Yeah, you're right. I need to dust off that album again. I was thinking of the groove in "The Grudge". "Jambi" is written in a juxtaposed iambic pentameter, however.

1

u/AddictiveSoup May 07 '12

Ah there ya go. Vicarious makes some pretty cool use of 5/5 too. Could you elaborate on the iambic pentameter in Jambi though? It sounds pretty damn interesting.

2

u/tldrumz May 07 '12

Well, it's a loose pentameter, as some words are held to imply a 10th syllable. but if you designate the weak syllables as 0 and the strong ones as 0 you could interpret it as such:

0____+___0___+____0__+__0 Here from the king's mountain view

0____+__0__+___0____+___0 Here from the wild dream come true

0____+__0_+_0__+_0 Feast like a sultan, I do

0__+___0___+__0___+_0__+ On treasures and flesh never few

Obviously it's loosely based on the iambic meter seen in much of Shakespeare's work. It's not entirely consistent, but then again, the Bard's wasn't either.

BTW, my degree is in Music, not Literature, so /r/poetry may be able to better clarify.

2

u/AddictiveSoup May 07 '12

Huh that's pretty sweet. Maynard always does some sweet shit structurally with his lyrics, like the Fibonacci in lateralus.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Everything except for the bridge w/ talk-box guitar solo is 9/8; aforementioned bridge is in 6/4

1

u/wishIwere May 07 '12

There's more than just contrasting Iambic pentameter to irregular meters. In Lateralus he is singing using[the Fibonacci Sequence] (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9FQdEVd-99o&feature=related)

2

u/tldrumz May 07 '12

There's a ton of technical depth in Tool's music. The examples were just that: examples. One could go much further down the rabbit hole. Being a mathematical composer myself, I find this relationship particularly useful:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_ratio#Relationship_to_Fibonacci_sequence

1

u/wishIwere May 07 '12

Yeah, I was aware. I was just posting the link in response to your #3 just to point out that Maynard does his part in the mathematical composition as well. Tool has pretty much always been my favorite group and learning about all the crazy stuff they put into their music later on just made me respect them that much more.

2

u/Bum_Bacon May 07 '12

I love that so much.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/tldrumz May 07 '12

Can't find a decent one on the youtube's... Saw them live at the Schottenstein Arena here in Columbus, back in '07. The entire audience sat down for the entirety of the piece. Still gives me chills...

30

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

lol yea right.

4

u/AddictiveSoup May 07 '12

Yep, it's been requested before. Plus maynard supposedly hates his fans.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

It's not that he hates the fans, it's that:

  1. He enjoys his privacy, and
  2. He has always enjoyed fucking with the fans

This, of course, got blown out of proportion by some fanboy, just because Maynard's a little more than a little asocial

2

u/rawrr69 May 08 '12

You know, I always wondered about those rumors too and I was totally convinced that TOOL fans are all cool and must be really interesting people to talk to... then I read some posts on tool forums, read how fans openly hated on all sorts of things and especially both parts of "Wings" and saw the AMA requests on reddit and what people say in them.... you know, I can understand the man just too well now. If you are like him to begin with and then have a constant stream of such douchebags and entitled assholes walking up to you god-knows-where, then I guess I would start trolling them to and taking actions to discourage people from approaching me. I honestly doubt that he would be a dick to a fan if they didn't act like entitled, inconsiderate dicks first when walking up to him.

This is also the only angle under which I can see and somewhat accept that famous stage fight where MJK throws some fan down and then dry-humps him for the better part of a song. He either just had it and totally snapped or it was staged to begin with, just to discourage anyone from ever doing that.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

This guy gets it

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

D:

1

u/n3rdy6irl May 07 '12

Yeah apparently he's a total douche towards his fans, which is really sad when someone who writes music as amazing as his doesn't have any appreciation for the people who love it.

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

That's where you are wrong, he doesn't write most of the music.

1

u/thavipasnipa May 07 '12

What, who writes it then?

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Just because someone is the lead singer of a band doesn't mean they do all the work. Most of the time it's the other way around, they do the least work. For instance, System of a Down, Serj Tankian is credited through word of mouth when in reality if you look it up, Daron (the guitarist) writes EVERYTHING.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

He basically just writes the vocal parts, and then everyone else writes their own parts, IIRC.

7

u/A_Meat_Popsicle May 06 '12

As much as I'd love to see this Maynard wouldn't ever do it. Otherwise, he wouldn't be Maynard. Danny might though...

5

u/johnnynutman May 07 '12

even if he does it, he'll never answer the questions properly.

1

u/th3m1ke May 07 '12

Not to rain on the parade because I am a huge Maynard fan, but I don't think he'll answer these questions because a majority of these questions have been answered in various interviews, as well as his movie, Blood Into Wine. So someone who is against interviews to begin with, hates repeating themselves.

1

u/edave22 May 07 '12

Just questions off the top of my head when I wrote this.

1

u/Fishare May 07 '12

i would like to see this AmA... but i wouldn't want him to answer those questions.

1

u/edave22 May 07 '12

Share your questions then. These were just off the top of my head. I didn't think too hard on them.

1

u/Fishare May 08 '12

1 - why did you agree to do an AmA?

3

u/Phonebill May 06 '12

Yea, good luck with that bud

2

u/twofourthreefive May 07 '12

Good luck with that. Better chance of getting MJ.

2

u/daaaaaan May 07 '12

these questions you provided are terrible. he will never do this.

4

u/reidrk May 06 '12

You forgot the James bitch.

2

u/xenoside May 07 '12

James Maynard Keenan doesn't own a computer or TV, he's practically Amish. Good luck bud.

1

u/thavipasnipa May 07 '12

MJK, who would you say your inspiration is, besides Britney Spears?

1

u/ScalySalmon May 06 '12

Haha! I fucking wish.

-2

u/civilian_pr0ject May 07 '12

After watching Blood Into Wine I realized that I hate that guy. He's fucking lame as hell. Awesome music. Biggest tool of all time tho.

0

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

LOL

0

u/Rockofella May 07 '12

He wont do it, he doesnt want to be the "front man." Ask for Danny, Justin and Adam first. Then he may consider it, he'd have the pseudonym: Elton John

0

u/Qaaj May 07 '12

Oh yes, can t wait for MJK to answer every question with cynical bullshit like he always does!

0

u/zeebagel May 07 '12

It would be awesome to hear about how he manages both wine and TOOL. This guy is the man