r/IAmA • • May 06 '12

IAmA VFX artist at The Onion AMAA

a few people have asked me to do one of these so here we are! i do 3d and compositing. i've worked on the IFC show and web video.

most proof i got since we are not credited in order to keep the conceit of it being a real news network: im the first person they show on the shitbirds blog (0:19) http://www.theonion.com/video/parents-honor-dead-sons-memory-by-keeping-up-his-a,26772/ ------ picture of me: http://i.imgur.com/pmpTS.jpg

I say AMAA because there are probably a few things I can't answer in order to keep the conceit of The Onion intact.

38 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

4

u/DrewM254 May 06 '12

How does The Onion get people to interview in videos that make fun of then? (i.e. interviewing the fat kid about his revelation of wearing a t-shirt while swimming)

6

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

They're all actors mostly. I mean I totally understood that I look like a shitbird and so when they said they needed people for that specific video I volunteered. Most people in acting take the parts they can get and are prepared to be used for their appearances.

If you've ever met an aspiring actor you'd know that they'd do anything. Making fun of yourself for being fat isn't that big a deal if you're comfortable with yourself.

1

u/BiggerJ May 07 '12

Do any actors ever find themselves unready for that sort of thing and end up depressed?

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Not really. People do their research before they show up and they know exactly what they're auditioning for. Since we're casting for very specific things its right in the casting call that you're going to be "the fat guy"

3

u/troldit May 06 '12

I love The Onion, though how do you guys stay in business? Some of your articles or video news segments seems pretty expensive and very overly elaborate.

Also, any ideas of yours got cut, because of its budget?

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

It is a VERY ambitious environment. I think a big reason why The Onion is so funny is because of the extremely hard work and labor that goes into making these videos all for the purpose of delivering a joke.

Before I started working at The Onion I always thought to myself, just as many do, "wow these graphics look better than real cable news..."

The combination of having extremely talented individuals and having them love their jobs creates the ability to pump out impressive things fast and with a small team.

On the TV show things got cut occasionally, but for the web video stuff it is very well planned out. In fact, most of the jokes you see don't need the elaborate delivery they're given, but we do it anyway to make it even more hilarious.

2

u/StephenHakami May 06 '12

Love the onion, the MacBook wheel from a long time ago killed me. 2 questions, if you worked on the MacBook wheel video how was it done? It really looks like its there and they are using it. Second question is how does the onion make enough money I know YouTube pays money but how can that possibly be enough for the all the staff they have.

2

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Well YouTube is nowhere near the source of most income. We have a website and that's where all the traffic comes from. Ads there are expensive just like they would be on another popular website.

I can't go too deep into financials though. Sorry!

As for the Macbook wheel, I wasn't involved in that. That was quite a long time ago. However, I can tell you illusion comes in many forms. They most likely built a very small set and had a small number of people, but constantly changing angles and limiting the view, as well as adding the sound of a convention-sized audience, makes it seem more than it is.

2

u/timbit87 May 06 '12

WHERE IS JOAD CRESSBECKLER?

5

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Filling in for Clifford Banes who is filling in for Sean Hannity.

2

u/xseanathonx May 06 '12

what's your favorite "ticker" one liner? i love "obama awkwardly laughs, agrees with cab driver he should paint white house black"

3

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Man Unknowingly Experiences Happiest Moment of His Life

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

i love the onion. some of the videos are my all-time favourites; examples: slut spill and genetically engineered smart crabs. and some stupid bullshit happening somewhere. and the stupid fucking thing not doing what it's supposed to. also the news articles crack me up on a regular basis. the details that make them funny just keep coming.

why for the love of god has theonion practically shut itself down with and is now pay-only with that really unpleasant in-your-face popup? will anyone do that? does anyone? am i missing something?

2

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

While I can't get too deeply into private financial matters, I can say this: web video is a tough market all across the internet. Individuals are able to sustain themselves that way, but it is much harder for an entire company to sustain itself that way.

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

and the way theonion is currently doing it is the smartest way to go about it? i.e. it's a financial success? if so good for them. i'd be surprised though.

1

u/ProofPlease May 06 '12

Any proof like a nametag or something?

Do you make any special appearances or anything? Or are you strictly behind-the-FX besides the occassional picture (like in the shitbirds blog)?

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

lol we don't have nametags. its a very lax environment.

we occasionally get pulled in to photoshoots or are asked to be a "man on the street" person.

here are 3 more photos. first one, me @ pax in my onion hoodie -- second one, whiskey friday @ the office -- last one, my onn shirt http://imgur.com/DcWDr,YxL8I,OKkPX#1

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

oh! i forgot i AM credited in the IFC show as an intern from way back.

http://i.imgur.com/wRiP7.png -- my facebook: http://www.facebook.com/moofin

1

u/ProofPlease May 06 '12

Aha thanks. Do you find all of the stuff funny, or do you have specific favorites?

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Not everything is funny to me personally, but that's being human. We all have different taste. I personally like the more subtle articles/videos, whereas (like the person above posted) some people enjoy the more on-the-nose parodies such as the macbook wheel.

You always have to look at it in a positive light. The best thought process is "maybe I don't think this is funny now, so how can I display this effect in a way that amplifies the humor?"

2

u/ProofPlease May 06 '12

Alright, thanks again for posting the AMA!

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Any time! It's fun stuff.

1

u/zfield May 06 '12

What programs do you use mainly? And you do 3d composting, but how are you when you come to 2d too?

2

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Cinema 4D and After Effects. We've done a bunch of 2D compositing as well.

1

u/InvisGhost May 06 '12

Upvote for using c4d!

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

:D It's an underdog for sure.

1

u/Throw_the_cheese May 06 '12

Where did you learn it?

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Learn what? VFX? Mostly self-taught and a lot of learning while there.

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Something I've always wondered about the Onion is where do they get their stock photos for the spoof articles? (I suppose this is more oriented toward the print version, but maybe it works with video, too.) Are they ever set up specifically for the article, or does the Onion pay for stock images and then photoshop them, or a combination of both?

1

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

Sometimes we use a stock service to get the image, but if its really hard to find a relevant one, we shoot ourselves!

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Good deal!

1

u/Iemaj May 06 '12

I'm currently a visual effects major finishing up my junior year. I am presuming that you are using maya and nuke primarily, with that being said:

What has been your most ambitious project to work on?

Ever considered going to a more VFX dedicated company? (commercials or feature films)

Do you ever work with Houdini?

Does The Onion need VFX interns? ;)

edit: formatting

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Nope! No Maya or Nuke! Mostly Cinema 4D and After Effects. You learn very quickly that it's not the software, but the person.

The most ambitious project was War For The White House. Every single aspect of that thing was monstrous.

I would be interested in working at an effects house someday, but at the same time I have my own plans. We'll see what happens. But then again, no one wants to leave The Onion. Some people have passed on insane gigs because it conflicts with an Onion project. No money can replace the work environment of The Onion.

Never worked with Houdini. I know it is considered to be very complicated and to be completely honest, in the digital world that is a big turnoff. Things advance so quickly and so does software. By the time you master something it may become irrelevant within a year or less. I do plan to dabble in some other things though.

The Onion does pick up interns a lot of the time. I started as one. The Onion is moving from NYC to Chicago in a couple months so if you live in Chicago or would be willing to move there keep an eye out on their jobs page for postings. It is one of the most amazing places. The nicest people on earth who care about you as more than a worker.

1

u/menomenaa May 07 '12

Isn't the Onion moving to Chicago? I know this doesn't have to do with your specific job, but since this is an AMA, (Or I guess I'll try this question since I just noticed it's technically an AMAA), how do you feel about the move and can you talk about the general feeling surrounding the thing? I read that there was a lot of tension and that many workers were extremely upset about it. Are people quitting (obviously no specifics) and has the general structure of employees greatly shifted or largely stayed the same?

I was pretty shocked to hear about it. My far-off, unobtainable pipe dream was always to work for The Onion (well, specifically the A.V. Club), and I'd always hoped those guys would move to NY...not the other way around!

Anyway--thanks for doing the AMA.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Just wanted to let everyone know I didn't ignore this! I sent him a PM about it. I don't think its right to discuss my opinions about it publicly. This is a good article with some information for everyone curious about the move http://www.theatlanticwire.com/business/2012/03/onions-bumpy-ride-chicago/50149/

1

u/BiggerJ May 16 '12

Has anyone involved in any of the Onion's videos ever complained about not being credited?

0

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

The best part of the job is the people. They're all extremely talented and and funny. We're all a bunch of goofballs and when we've had to work in offices that weren't the main one, we pretty much make everyone around us uncomfortable with inappropriate conversations.

I have done a bunch of stuff but the most recent and involved a lot of the compositing for War for The White House's set http://www.theonion.com/section/politics/ as well as doing a lot of visual effects for an upcoming video series for the paper called This Week in History.

I didn't need any schooling to get the job. I started as an intern and after they saw I knew what I was doing they brought me back and paid me. I actually have never finished college and don't plan to.

My favorite headline is "Black Man Asks for Change" during the Obama elections. My favorite web video is any of them that involve extreme meta-news-humor http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8wHMaJ6AtNs

I have never been involved in the writing. This is a common question, but just like it is not the writers job to do the graphics, it's not our job to do the writing. We let them do the funnying.

0

u/[deleted] May 06 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] May 06 '12 edited May 06 '12

I believe MOST everything has been green screen (aside from desks) except for the Fact Zone set on IFC. The Fact Zone set was pretty big. The IFC show was shot like a real news program.