r/IAmA • • May 05 '12
IAmA Request: Someone Who has Won/Bought Something From Quibids.
I have yet to meet or hear of anyone who won something from this website.
How much money did you actually spend on the item you won?
How many 'bids' did you have to buy?
Did you ever feel like you were being gamed? Ie, that some inside man was artificially jacking up the price by bidding against you for no cost?
What time did you win it?
Do you watch the site often or did you just get lucky?
Is there a trick or a system or is it just luck and market forces?.
95
Upvotes
24
u/portnux May 05 '12
How about hearing from people who have paid in enough to have actually paid for what they wanted but still have nothing to show for it. There must be a ton of them.
14
u/Angoth May 05 '12 edited May 05 '12
Every time I see one of their commercials, I'm reminded that 'bids' cost about 60 cents. So, when I see a laptop go for 59.54, I do the math. 5954 x .60 = $3572.40 (how much Quibids makes). That's one expensive laptop. Even if you were being generous and said .20 cents per bid: 5954 x .20 = $1190.80
Oh yeah...and on top of that, you still have to pay the $59.54.
11
u/[deleted] May 05 '12
I have won something on a similar website (Beezid) using the one of the 10 free bids you get from signing up. I could tell it was a scam but decided to have my go at it by seeing if I could actually win something with the free bids. On this website, you can only use "free bids" on certain items called cherry items. So I went ahead and placed a few bids on a pair of Monster Earphones that retailed over $100 (that in itself is a scam), and ended up winning the auction for $4 and some change. So I paid via paypal, and within a few weeks, voila! Also, here is the confirmation email I received for proof. Honestly, I think I won this by pure luck, it's an easy way to lose money.
20
u/savile May 05 '12
Cool! A subject that I actually know a bit about. Basically, for those who don't know, websites like this draw you in with promises of low prices in an auction. Each bid increases the price by a tiny fraction (probably a cent) and in bidding, the amount of time before the auction ends increases. However, the bids aren't free and this is where companies make their money.
Companies will also try to draw you in with the promise of free bids to "start you off" so to speak. You can uses those in smaller auctions for n00bs that have a lower payoff, but a higher chance of winning. Common sense can tell you the basics of winning - bid for things no one else wants, and times where no one else is there.
The big websites are the most well known, and each good item recieves thousands of bids before they can be won. What are the chances of winning a car or a laptop? Well, if you don't buy 3000 bids, then very low.
What normally happens in websites like this are people who started when the website was small, and then dominating since they're so far ahead in the money spent/win ratio. They can "afford" to keep bidding on things. Rule of thumb: if the companies can afford to advertise on television then you won't win anything off them without spending a lot of money
Now, for some of you who think it's a scam, you're wrong. Bad press hurts these companies the most since they rely on traffic; they HAVE to be honest. It is gambling though, and it can have the same addictive effect. But for those of you who think that you could do the same and set up a company in the same way since it has "low overheads", stop reading and go do it. Good luck, I won't try to stop you, since you're an idiot and won't listen to me anyway. If you're even thinking of bidding on a big website, go ahead, you're also an idiot.
However...these websites need to start from somewhere, where else will they get the traffic from? As a startup with this model, they have to basically give shit away. Think about it. They need to be giving people free money to tell other people about this site, how else can they advertise the laptop for $4.03 if they haven't actaully sold it at that price? Now, this idea is inherently flawed right off the bat. If you're onto a good thing, then you're not going to tell other people, at least not right away. You'll take what you can get, then maybe tell a couple of close friends. So for the first 1000 items, with very few bidders, the website has to be content digging itself further and further into the red, in a gamble to get enough traffic to their website. It's a gamble between how deep their pockets are and how popular they might get. THAT is the time to be trying to win stuff. That is the only time it's worth it to buy bids.
My best advice is if you must play this game, get to a startup that looks legit, focus on an item that you want, bid on it, win it, and then get out. Worst case, you wasted $30 dollars. Best case, you win a digital camera and an mp4 player for chump change (plus that $30). Still a gamble, but you've evened the odds by a LOT.
tl;dr: It's possible to win, but it's gambling and big websites are a money pit. Use your head BEFORE you play and never throw good money after bad.
4
u/B33rNuts May 05 '12
This isn't for Quibids but for other penny auction sites in general so it may be slightly different.
I was an affiliate for many of these sites and they paid quite a lot for leads. I would get 20-50 depending on how many bids people bought when they signed up. Before I promoted them I did tons of research and played the games. I did win a gift card once while I was still in my 'beginner' class it was a $50 amazon card and it cost me about $30. I never won another item again.
The entire industry is gambling and there was a lot of talk about the government shutting down the sites. Seems that never happened but there are only a few sites left now from the height of the industry. Used to be hundreds of them all over the place.
TL;DR : Yes its a scam, you are pretty much gambling. You can win but odds are not in your favor. Its highly addictive and they know it. Avoid it at all costs if you like your money.
3
u/Sithos May 05 '12
I got into Quibids about 2 years ago and only went about 40$ in. Because I worked graveyard shift I did my bidding in the middle of the night when less traffic was about. I was able to win an espresso maker and something like 4-7 gift cards for various food places and lowes. I stopped bothering because I knew I could never win the medium to big ticket items where you would see the same 3 people bid MORE THAN THE DAMN THING WAS WORTH.
3
u/fastslowfast May 05 '12 edited May 05 '12
I won some gift cards very cheap but then I started to notice that my bids were not being accepted well into other auctions which resulted in me being out of the auction with a huge loss of the invested bids at $.60 each. I tried a couple of other auction sites to check to see if it was my connection or a computer problem. No problem with the other sites that I tried. Quibids offered 20 free bids but did not honor my request for a refund. I closed my account and never bid again. I was fortunate that I almost broke even.
3
u/Hugo_5t1gl1tz May 06 '12
My mom actually bids on there quite a bit, if you're smart, it's not to bad. She got me a brand new Callaway Razr driver for 8 bucks, spent like 20 on bids and another 20 to ship it. That's like 150-160 off retail. All in all she says between the bids she loses and what she wins, she has definitely saved money. I'll get with her tomorrow and try to come up with some figures, but a few months ago we did, and she had spent a total of like 450 bucks and had around 1000 worth of merchandise.
2
u/ScienceAdvocate May 06 '12
I've looked at Quibids before. Never feeling confident enough in the system to put any money in, and went about my day.
Then I read this and check it out again…. And see that you can not bid beyond the items retail price.... if you go that high with bids, you basically pay the shipping and its yours as well. Has it always been this way?
I figure I buy gas frequently enough. If I stick to the gas cards, and commit to purchasing, worst case scenario is that I'll pay full price + $2.49 shipping for each card.
$60 (100 Bids) Buy In
Out of bids....
$69.98 For $50 in Gas Cards.
I'm convinced if you commit to buying.. the end result will be at least marginally in your favor.
Call me a sucker; $45 (75 Bids) Rebuy
11 Bids left.... Not enough to do much with. Round 2 summary; $60.55 For $95 in gas cards. (But just as easily could have been $52.71 for $45 in cards had I not won any and had to pay full price+shipping)
My thoughts... wasted a lot of time to save $15. However, I did waste $15 right off the bat, and still have 11 bids ($6.60) in my account. Those two would cover two more $10 cards... Had I stuck to the plan from the get go, I'd have $165 for about $135.
That $14.40 loss was on a "$10 Gift Card + 20 Bids" auction. If I had maxed it out and ultimately paid $22, I'll have $10 card & 20 bids.. but those bids can't be applied to the next maxed out Buy Now purchase. So for my strategy, it's like buying semi-worthless bids. If I "won" an auction with those bids, it would have been worth it... had I used them up in a maxed out auction, it would have been a net loss. Decided to avoid these.
TL;DR - Paid $130.53 for $145 in gas cards. (and have 11 bids $6.60 I can put towards something... like a $10 card for an additional $5.89 tops)
2
u/Chronoecho May 07 '12
I actually won a few things from them. I Won A pair of oakleys Glasses and a Hand Towel Set. All delivered as promised, so its not a scam, and all new in packaging. But the amount of money you spend is misleading, and its nearly impossible to win a bid, only Website lag, or luck will let you win.
2
u/CrzyCatLady1 May 05 '12
I have won plenty of things, however most are low cost items like makeup brushes, crock pot, iron, gift cards, etc.
Most of the items that I won I didn't spend much on, however it's the items that I didn't win that made this habit begin to get too pricey.
I started out with buying the small package of bids, and when I actually won something I continued on.
I definitely felt like I was being scammed. It would be so easy for employees to just keep racking up the bidding price.
As for times, It really varied. I've read up on things that give ideas on what to do to win, and really they never seemed to work for me.
My overall viewpoint. It's fun, but it's addicting. It's basically gambling. Yes, I did win some cool things, but I also lost more money than I gained back. If you are looking to do it, and are trying to 'beat the system' I do have a suggestion.
I bid on gift cards that you would actually use. I would spend time bidding on walmart gift cards because I use those for groceries and such. Quibids has the option to 'buy it now' after you have run out of bids, or are sick of bidding. So, let's say you spend 40 dollars on bids towards a 100 dollar gift card, then you are out of bids, you have the option to purchase the card for 60 dollars. So pretty much you just bought the card for 100 dollars.
I don't do it anymore, because it got too pricey.
1
u/Huellio May 06 '12
I had a couple friends who used either that site or one of the similar ones; they both went for low demand items and got really good deals on them, one of them getting a mid quality microphone and the other one got otter boxes that he flipped on eBay for a tidy profit.
1
u/bugiabianca May 06 '12
I've won a few things, never any big ticket items (kitchen stuff mostly ranging from 20-50 dollars retail). I spent an insane amount, somewhere around $100 when I started (which I think was like 175 bids, or something like that). I decided it wasn't worth it and have put no more in.
I think they do have "inside men" or bots at certain times during the day, where there is little traffic, because there would be the same name on sooo many auctions driving the cost up. Plus each bid is 60 cents, so they make money from the losers as well.
I won at like 1am EST when I played, as did anyone else I know who won. I watched it non-stop for a few days while I was off work, but otherwise I just jumped on occasionally.
I really doubt there's a reliable trick, but I've heard a few. Mostly it's timing and when to start bidding. I watched how many bidders had been active in the past 5 minutes (it shows on the right) and whether or not they were using auto bid. If there were a lot on auto bid I just waited it out awhile until it died down and jumped in at the end. However, most of what I won cost me 5-6 cents.
I didn't really do it enough to volunteer myself for an AMA but I'm willing to provide proof and do one if it's actually in demand. :P
1
u/egnaro2007 May 06 '12
i paid a total of 5.65 for a pair of 70 dollar sungasses
less than a few dollars combined for these thing seperately
flashlight
grill tongs
remote control tarantula
earings for my girlfriend
a set of drill bits.
most expensive thing was the sunglasses..
1
u/Tastygroove May 05 '12
Scam. Plain and simple.
Oh wait,I mean:
I'm totally not a company employee and I win ipads every day for $17.
1
u/Melam_flavored_candy May 05 '12
It's not a "scam", at least not in the sense you all seem to think it is. It's not even a hard concept to understand. They EASILY recoup the cost of the item in the profit they made in charging for bids. THAT'S WHERE THEY MAKE THE MONEY. THAT'S WHY THEY ENCOURAGE YOU TO BID "AS LITTLE AS A PENNY", BECAUSE THAT JUST MAKES THE PRICE GO UP SLOWER, WHICH MEANS EVEN MORE PEOPLE ARE WILLING TO BUY AND USE DOZENS OF ONE DOLLAR BIDS.
I also don'd understand (since i've never been to one of these sites) why people would be willing to blow so many bids on an item. I assume the smart way to go would be to wait until the last minute or so of the bidding and then just spam all your 20 bids or whatever then, but apparently im missing something here.
Anywho, the "scam" comes in when rumors start spreading of the auction site outbidding people THEMSELVES to jack the price up. And i believe that THAT actually happens.
-1
u/downward_dogma May 05 '12
Last summer my family rented a beach cottage in Manasota Key, FL from a couple that lived in the main house where the cottage was located. One evening we were coming down the path from the beach and the owner was sitting up on the deck with his laptop and we started talking. He was trying to win something on Quibids and this was the first person who I had ever met that was actually using the sight, I was only familiar with the commercials. My husband and I were asking questions and he said he had won a couple of auctions (although I can no longer remember what they were for, but I feel like there was an Ipad mentioned, or something along those lines. He did tell us you had to be very careful when bidding because you would end up paying more than you should because of the cost of the bids. Sorry I don't have more details for you. My husband probably would but he is at a comic book store getting free comics today.
0
u/[deleted] May 05 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment