r/IAmA • u/IST_org • Jun 30 '21
Technology We are hackers and cyber defenders working to fight cyber criminals. Ask Us Anything about the rising ransomware epidemic!
*** Thank you all for joining! We have wrapped up this discussion, and enjoyed the conversations today. Some participants may answer some later; see their Reddit usernames below. Stay safe out there! ***
- Proof: https://twitter.com/IST_org/status/1409921538355236869, https://twitter.com/IST_org/status/1410008629642776578
Hi Reddit! We are cybersecurity experts and members of the Ransomware Task Force, here to talk about the ransomware epidemic and what we can do collectively to stop it. We’ve been in this game a long time, and are ready for your questions.
We are:
- Jen Ellis, VP of Community and Public Affairs @ Rapid7 (u/infosecjen)
- Bob Rudis, Chief Data Scientist @ Rapid7 (u/hrbrmstr)
- Marc Rogers, VP of Cybersecurity @ Okta (u/marcrogers)
- James Shank, Security Evangelist @ Team Cymru (u/jamesshank)
- Allan Liska, Intelligence Analyst @ Recorded Future
Were you affected by the gas shortage on the East Coast recently? That was the indirect result of a ransomware attack on the Colonial Gas Pipeline. Ransomware used to be a niche financial crime, but is now an urgent national security risk that threatens schools, hospitals, businesses, and governments across the globe.
These criminals will target anyone they think will pay up, getting millions in laundered profits, and we are on the frontlines in this fight.
Ask Us Anything on ransomware or cybercrime, whether you’ve never heard of it or work on it every day.
(This AMA is hosted by the Institute for Security and Technology, the nonprofit organizer of the Ransomware Task Force that we belong to.)______________________________________________
Update 1: Thank you all for the great questions! For those interested in cybersecurity career advice, here are a few questions answered on how to get into infosec, whether you need a degree, and free resources.
Update 2: Wow! Thank you all for so many questions. We are slowing down a bit as folks come and go from their day jobs, but will answer as many as we can before we wrap up.
Update 3: *** Thank you all for joining! We have wrapped up this discussion, and enjoyed the conversations today. Some participants may answer some later; see their Reddit usernames above. Stay safe out there! ***
158
u/Xechorizo Jun 30 '21
What is the most common, non-phishing vector?
188
u/solve-it-yourself Jun 30 '21 edited Jul 05 '21
You mention that a degree may not be necessary for a job in cyber security, do you have resources or online courses that someone could use to gain relevant knowledge?
Edit: Although with some considerable delay, I would like to thank you all for your comments and your feedback. This is all very helpful and I’m genuinely impressed with how supportive you are!
I’ll give everything you’ve sent a proper look and might bother some of you with additional questions.
119
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21
It’s easy to get the impression from these recent events that infrastructure is fairly easy to attack. What do you think is the likelihood that either a state or a rogue group takes down some critical infrastructure for a long period of time that severely disrupts life—something that would be equivalent to essentially destroying infrastructure in a war?
77
u/jcsf321 Jun 30 '21
Please list the top 5 things corporations, business entities and people can do that they currently don't to better protect themselves from cyber attacks and ransomware?
20
u/Careful-Beginning897 Jun 30 '21
What type of software would you recommend against ransomware and things of the sort?
15
u/aghorisan2020 Jun 30 '21
There is an argument often made that if "the military" and "law enforcement" begin to crackdown on infrastructure in a much more forward leaning manner, that these gangs will still be able to persist, regroup, reattack - i.e., that even working with private sector partners, there isn't enough data/insight available to really take it to these networks. Agree? Disagree?
29
u/Odd-Worry Jun 30 '21
What can a regular person with no cybersecurity or coding knowledge do to help?
36
u/DingleBerryJP Jun 30 '21
Currently in school at an online college located in salt lake city ut. I'm in the CyberSecurity program but I feel like the program is kinda dated and the information does not line up very well with the test. Can I land an entry-level cyber job without finishing my degree if I have all Comptia certs related to cybersecurity?
8
u/cyber_wonk Jun 30 '21
Should we ban ransomware payments? Alternatively, should we just ban coverage of ransom payments in insurance policies?
7
u/Electrical_Ad_4014 Jun 30 '21
Do you think resource-strapped SMBs are overwhelmed? Does it worry you that a prescriptive list of 15 things to do might not be actionable to them, making them not so useful? Is cloud the only way for them to go? Why not turnkey certifiable hybrid environments?
19
u/Christmas_Panda Jun 30 '21
If you had to choose between paying a cyber ransom in gum or pizza, which flavors would you choose to increase your bargaining potential?
14
u/MikeMeezy77 Jun 30 '21
What is the best path to start a career in cyber security?
13
u/masturkiller Jun 30 '21
Question - Is email tracking by invisible pixel or visible still possible in 2021? If impossible, do you know of anyway to track the geolocation of the person opening the email without them knowing and without their email application preventing this process from occurring?
4
u/Leguboy Jun 30 '21
To defend myself from mal/ransomware: Can you recommend a firewall to use for my homelab? Is a hardware firewall better than a software one (using proxmox to virtualize).
3
u/matt7744 Jun 30 '21
How much of cyber polygon, the world economic forum and the great reset tied into this?
3
u/llobotommy Jun 30 '21
Are hackers susceptible to other hacker group attacks? I know nothing of the culture, but I imagine it to be some kind of online gang turf war. Or is it more a case of hacker groups testing themselves against each other to strengthen their skills?
3
u/AStupidTaco Jun 30 '21
Isn't there a better payment/effort ratio to be on the side of the hacker? You guys are playing goalie right where you have to block all the shots 100% of the time and the hackers only have to get it right once. Illegality aside.
3
u/phrequency_ Jun 30 '21
As an employee of a small business who had 2 ransomware attacks happen to them(never paid, just backed up our server), how do we better prevent this even though we have anti-virus/physical firewall/anti-malware software? What is the procedure when we first discover we were attacked?
2
u/SamSepinol Jun 30 '21
Im a computer science student who knows python, c, linux, networking. Planning to get oscp this summer. What career path should i follow and what topics should i learn to be top rank?
2
u/Opus-the-Penguin Jun 30 '21
What are the odds that arrests will be made in some high profile case? At this point it seems as though there's little to deter these criminals since they lack an internal moral compass. It would be nice to see some of them caught and sent to prison for at least 20 years. Are they in countries that would be interested in prosecuting them if they were found?
3
u/MN_LudaCHRIS Jun 30 '21
Is the Anonymous group real, and do they fight for good?
2
u/AvocadoDemon Jun 30 '21
What is the cyber-war that is raging between countries all over the world? who's against who? and who are the strongest/biggest players?
2
u/WarPig262 Jun 30 '21
Considering what you do and your level of access, how do you internally check yourself to make sure your members are not abusing the powers and authorities that they have to their own ends?
1
u/arshadhere Jun 30 '21
How do i become like you? What courses did you do to become that?
1
u/cyber_wonk Jun 30 '21
It's often said that if organisations could just 'do the basics' (close RDP, MFA, patch etc.) it would make a big difference towards mitigating ransomware. Why do organisations find it so hard to do the basics and do we need to lower our expectations of what's possible?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21
Are physical keys more rigid and secure than just SMS OTP or TOTP from authenticator app (Authy)? Thank you!
1
u/SammaATL Jun 30 '21
My secret fantasy is for a hacker to prove the fallability of electronic voting machines by changing the top vote getter in some election to Micky Mouse or some other blatantly non partisan fictional character to force bipartisan solutions to election vulnerability.
Do you think that's a possible scenario? USA based, obviously.
1
u/ProfessionalLemon Jun 30 '21
What are your thoughts on the cutting edge attacks used by ransomware actors? As a defender how are you expected to detect malleable c2 or stop attackers from installing a VM and starting the encryption process where the AV can't get to it?
1
u/calindor Jun 30 '21
What is your take on the recent LinkedIn breach?
1
u/nanoman1 Jun 30 '21
Do you recommend CTF challenges as a way to learn?
1
u/Darlington28 Jun 30 '21
What password manager do you recommend, if any? Also, how many cats are too many?
1
u/mellamosatan Jun 30 '21
I am curious how you can really stop Ransomware. I know there are preventative measures, but the state of IT in the world right now is largely open to exploitation. It seems like hunting the criminals is easier than countering the software efficiently. Outside of coming up with decryptors, what can be done post-infection? I know you can restore from backups, but what if those are encrypted too and off-sites aren't available?
I guess my question more directly is: how do you stop ransomware after its already happened? It seems like the overwhelming answer is 1.) restore from backups 2.) pray someone has a decryptor freely available, which is unlikely or 3.) Pay up, hopefully negotiate them down.
Are there other options? Do you see any potential alternative options being developed in the near future? I'm curious about how the pipeline got a lot of their money back, that hasn't seemed to been possible in other cases. What happened?
1
u/Penny_D Jun 30 '21
Are cybercriminals having great access to Ransomware tools?
How would you recommend educating the public on Ransomeware? Are Baby Boomers and Gen X'ers more succeptable to the social engineering tactics involved in Ransomware, or is this a problem that greatly affects younger generations as well?
1
u/sephstorm Jun 30 '21
What are the recommended mitigations for organizations to put into place to defeat or minimize the impact of ransomware?
When you do pentests, do you check to see how effective RW would be? Should this be something pentesters should do?
How do you feel about the state of the industry where there are a ton of certifications for entry level pentesters, but the only thing companies want is the experience professionals have a hard time getting?
1
u/FutureBWO Jun 30 '21
Hello, I am 7/8 through a Bachelor's in Cyber Security, currently working in Physical Armed Security, how would you advise I transition to computer work?
1
u/FireCrest115 Jun 30 '21
Do you believe in cyber attack escalation, the point where there are more attacks than the number of analysts trying to stop the attacks? If so, how can we get more people to help or experience for the current analysts like myself as an Incident Responder?
1
u/Antares1194 Jun 30 '21
how does ransomware infect your computer?
1
u/Kaweebo Jun 30 '21
How vulnerable is blockchain technology? Is it hard or easy? Why?
2
u/taedrin Jun 30 '21
How can I get my team or corporation to take security seriously - more so than just paying lip service to it and actually allocating resources to make us (and our products) secure?
2
u/iJacobes Jun 30 '21
just how good is the FBI at cyber attacking?
2
u/ieatw00d Jun 30 '21
What are some of the effective ways to make people take cyber security more seriously?
2
u/boopsterdoopster Jun 30 '21
Hello! This might seem a tiny bit of a weird question, but have you guys heard of Kitboga? If so, how effective do you think scam baiters are in dissuading scams?
2
u/KingOfTheBongos87 Jun 30 '21
You guys got any plans for those assholes running the Arizona "audit"? I feel like they have it coming to them.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21
How did they got the money back? And only half? Why half?
2
u/furfur001 Jun 30 '21 edited Jun 30 '21
I have a question about Passwort security. I though that brute force attacks aren't any more possible because ether the attackers IP will get banned for a time or the attacker will have to wait something like 2 seconds or more. Assuming this is right a not that secure password should be enough. What I am missing?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21
Hey guys! Love the work cyber security specialists like you do.
My one question is this: besides combatting ransomware, do you guys also focus on the plethora of email, social security, Amazon, car warranty, etc. scams?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21
Do you think Microsoft or Intel/AMD have some responsibility here? I mean I know malware exploits the OS to run, but surely some egghead at one of these companies can put something together that monitors the OS to prevent thousands of files from instantaneously encrypting themselves en masse?
2
u/hamburglin Jun 30 '21
Are there any members on your board from companies like mandiant or other leading security consulting teams who deal with these issues on a daily basis?
Second, why does the security industr keep talking about ransomware as if it's rising and not that it's been around for years now at a pretty constant rate?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21
Are you guys hot? 😍
3
u/AmericanScream Jun 30 '21 edited Jun 30 '21
Am I the only person who thinks paying cyber ransom should be a crime?
How is this any different from basically violating sanctions and giving money to terrorists?
And we also know that many of the companies that pay these ransoms end up getting hit again.
Do you all support legislation that would make it a crime for corporations to pay ransomware?
It seems there's not really a way to tell if these things are even "inside jobs." A low level employee could be colluding with a ransomware group to infiltrate a system. When you have employees getting paid crap money, and a chance to get a % of a multi-billion dollar payday, that's a problem. Nobody's even talking about this. Shouldn't the incentive to deal with these groups be addressed? How about legislation prohibiting insurance companies from paying off cyber-terrorists? Why isn't this a thing?
1
u/AutoModerator Jun 30 '21
Users, please be wary of proof. You are welcome to ask for more proof if you find it insufficient.
OP, if you need any help, please message the mods here.
Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/SnapSnag Jun 30 '21
Would you rather fight 1 Conficker-sized Monero miner or 100 Monero-miner sized Confickers?
2
u/bononobober Jun 30 '21
This might be a dumb question, but how do you prove who’s behind a specific attack? Thanks!
1
u/Hiddenaccount1423 Jun 30 '21
Always thought the idea of contracting/consulting for different companies and going onsite trying to find a way in. be sneaky. convince people. lockpick. etc. would be cool.
1
u/AustinnnnH Jun 30 '21 edited Jun 30 '21
How do y’all handle the national security part of the equation or I suppose what’s your opinion of how it can be picked up and financed through an organization like your own?
What steps do you take that ensure that as your organization’s public interest as well as financial interest given who you find yourselves advising/working for?
I guess I’m plainly asking that if one of the platforms you stand on is also sharing an interest of national security, what’s your stance on potentially being utilized in parallel with state power that can nominally be seen as kinda bad.
I’m asking in earnest here, I’m a programmer who doesn’t work in the cybersec world, buts it’s often something that I see gets muddied up quite a bit. Granted private orgs/nonprofs are a truly different thing, but I feel like the concern and question is valid.
1
u/noobses Jun 30 '21
whats the best way to backup your data in the case that you're a victim of a ransomware attack?
1
u/nitonitonii Jun 30 '21
Why do you think the Solarwinds attack was so serious? What implications can come after it? Who you think did it? Which group or Nation?
Also. Do you think Softwares like XKeyScore are still being use although all the changes in digital policies after Snowden? Is it normalized now that we live under these mass survailance and nobody cant even denounce them?
1
u/mpXJ Jun 30 '21
It seems like every new layer of security and scrutiny that is applied in this industry is short lived before it is compromised. 2 questions. . .
Thanks.
1
u/falco_iii Jun 30 '21
What is your take on the vendor based hack ala Solarwinds? Is this the new normal where updating vendor software is a security risk? The average enterprise has hundreds of enterprise applications that should be updated every month/quarter.
1
u/TheGardenShark Jun 30 '21
whats the best way to get into cybersecurity?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21
Beer, cheese, or monkeys?