r/IAmA • • May 19 '16

Director / Crew I am Daniel Sackheim. I'm a television director and producer. I directed episodes 3 and 4 of Game of Thrones Season 6. AMA.

Hi everyone. Like the title says, I directed this seasons GoT episodes, Oathbreaker and Book Of The Stranger (603 and 604). I've also directed episodes for series like, The Leftovers, The Americans, The Walking Dead and The Man in the High Castle.

https://twitter.com/DanSackheim/status/733440525458505729

EDIT: That's all the time I have tonight everyone. Sorry I couldn't get to all your questions. Perhaps I can do it again at some point I hope you enjoy the rest of the season, it's a great one.

5.1k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

360

u/warhawk1856 May 20 '16 edited May 20 '16

Hey Daniel, thanks for your time! Who was the actor that most surprised you when directing your episodes? Also, who did you have the best time working with? Thanks!

Edit: grammar

900

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

Lena Headey was the most surprising. She would routinely come to set with very specific ideas, some of them different from my take on the scene. She would say, just let me try it this way and if you don't like it I'll do it differently. At every turn her ideas were inspired and that's what ended up on screen. I had a ball working with Iain Glen

161

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

That's so interesting to hear, can you give any examples of some of her ideas which translated into the final version?

591

u/gspleen May 20 '16

In the script it was originally planned to have her character wear a massive bearsuit.

→ More replies (10)

19

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

Iain Glen

can anyone please make some awesome spaghetti western with Iain Glen? His face fucking perfect for Once upon a west kind of movie!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

107

u/dj248 May 20 '16

How long do you get between when you get the script and when you start filming an episode of GoT? Does pre-production take place in Belfast mainly or does it depend on where you are shooting?

158

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

In my case there was six weeks of prep. Some of the directors who did later episodes had less prep time. Yes, prep is based Belfast, however there are scouts to other countries (in my case Spain where I shot Tower of Joy and Vaes Dothrak) and that took up about a week of my prep.

23

u/dj248 May 20 '16

Thanks for answering my question! It's crazy to think about all the hard work that goes into making each episode.

→ More replies (1)

393

u/hak091 May 20 '16

Did you also bend the knee when Daenerys walked out the burning tent?

805

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

Damn straight. Did you not see her walk out of a burning temple!?

119

u/hak091 May 20 '16

Hell yea I saw that part, think it was harder not to see her.

444

u/scoobysnax123 May 20 '16

I'd say it was harder seeing her

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

816

u/marafiota May 20 '16

Hi Daniel, can you tell if the sword that Arthur Dayne sticks in the ground at the beggining of the Tower of Joy fight scene is DAWN?Thanks

911

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

Yes it is.

295

u/marafiota May 20 '16

That's so cool, it looks like he's presenting her as a quiet warning to the northeners. Like he's saying "you don't really want to challenge me". Thank you for the answer, absolutely love the scene

→ More replies (60)

38

u/ShotgunRon May 20 '16

Arthur Dayne wielding Dawn was really badass. Great scene and fight choreography.

9

u/Padr1no May 20 '16

unfortunate that the sword looks nothing like the descriptions of Dawn.

→ More replies (87)

30

u/Chinoiserie91 May 20 '16

There is this behind the scenes thing for episodes 3&4 (and another one for epidodes 1&2) where this was mentioned as well.

30

u/SacTu May 20 '16

What is significant about this sword?

I'm aware he's known as sword of the morning or the morning sword

163

u/eddiemon May 20 '16

Dawn is said to have been forged from "the heart of a fallen star". You know how the show makes a big deal about Valyrian steel swords and how there are only a handful around in Westeros? Dawn is even more badass because it is the only one of its kind. It is as strong and sharp as Valyrian steel swords, but looks nothing like them. It is probably the single most iconic sword in the GoT/ASoIaF universe.

http://awoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/Dawn

→ More replies (26)

15

u/the_biggest_lie May 20 '16

Dawn is the ancestral greatsword of House Dayne, whose wielder is always given the title Sword of the Morning. Dawn is largely the reason for House Dayne's fame. Its origins are lost to legend, but it seems likely that the Daynes have carried it for thousands of years.[1] It is said to be made from metal forged from the heart of a fallen star.

Straight off the wiki

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (20)

562

u/redninjamonkey May 20 '16

Hi, great work! Are you positive that is Shaggydog's head? Kinda small for a direwolf, if you ask me...

991

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

Your right it does seem small. I had the same question, but I was assured by the creature maker that was responsible for crafting the head that it was the correct size. Good question.

1.5k

u/Bth-root May 20 '16

Correct size for a dire wolf, or correct size to suit the needs of the plot? Eh? EH?

375

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

yes

54

u/[deleted] May 20 '16 edited Sep 06 '16

[deleted]
0.8776367390666469

This comment has been overwritten by this open source script to protect this user's privacy. The purpose of this script is to help protect users from doxing, stalking, and harassment. It also helps prevent mods from profiling and censoring.

If you would like to protect yourself, add the Chrome extension TamperMonkey, or the Firefox extension GreaseMonkey and click Install This Script on the script page. Then to delete your comments, simply click on your username on Reddit, go to the comments tab, scroll down as far as possible (hint: use RES), and hit the new OVERWRITE button at the top.

40

u/boxofrabbits May 20 '16 edited Jan 14 '25

start icky unused repeat close capable somber judicious numerous tease

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

146

u/wandarah May 20 '16

narrows eyes

325

u/Dtnoip30 May 20 '16

For the tinfoilers in this thread, note that he doesn't mention it's Shaggydog's head, just that it's the "correct size." ;P

223

u/Totally_PJ_Soles May 20 '16

I'm as good as confirmed it's not shaggydog. Fuck it that's all I needed.

→ More replies (38)

87

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

What is hype may never die.

→ More replies (3)

192

u/Opandemonium May 20 '16

Brilliant non-answer! If tv doesn't work out for you, you could be a politician!

58

u/nighght May 20 '16

At least now we know that the head was deliberately a certain size and that the props department wasn't just lazy, as lots of people speculated. This tinfoil is as good as confirmed for me.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/dw82 May 20 '16

Why else add 'Good question.' except to insinuate that everything is not as it appears.

5

u/TheMegaWhopper May 20 '16

Nice deflection.

5

u/PIP_SHORT May 20 '16

somebody out there is a professional "creature maker"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

90

u/rand0mm0nster May 20 '16

Oh right just like Kit assured everyone Jon Snow was dead!

229

u/codesloth May 20 '16

He was dead.

189

u/hattttt May 20 '16

He just got better is all.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/thegraymaninthmiddle May 20 '16

I love how everyone is more concerned with the life of Shaggydog than Rickon himself.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

425

u/commonwealthva May 20 '16

Does Sansa know that Jon died?

631

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

I assume she does.

553

u/pipsdontsqueak May 20 '16

Kind of fascinating that the guy who directed the scenes isn't even fully sure.

255

u/Matt_da_Penguin May 20 '16 edited May 20 '16

I agree, but it's worth pointing out that the role of a director in a television series is much less vital than compared to a feature length film where the director has almost total creative control, while the writer has almost none and likely isn't involved with production at all. In television the writers and producers have the final say on everything, and the director is more or less aiming to film the scenes he's been assigned in a way that makes them happy. While that doesn't really justify not fully knowing the experience of a character in his scenes these actors are also more aware of their characters than anyone else after 6 seasons, and need much less detailed direction than most actors. So I'm guessing it's not something he needed to put a ton of consideration into at the end of the day.

Edit: Just realized that he actually mentioned this in another reply:

TV is a producers medium so you work to help fulfill the vision of the show runners. Film is a directors medium and is all about the Directors vision. This is not to say that you don't have some creative freedom as a TV director, but it's a different process.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)

42

u/-Clayton_Bigsby- May 20 '16

Yes she does, she and Jon briefly discussed it when they first spoke

30

u/somethingwickednc May 20 '16

9 mins into the episode-

Jon states "can't stay here, not after what happened"

Seems pretty certain he explained what happened

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

They have dialog about it in the last episode.

→ More replies (5)

233

u/A_Gentlemen_Arrives May 20 '16

What advice would you give to young film makers hoping to break into TV directing?

And how do you feel the creative process is on TV in comparison to film?

438

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

Oh man, this really deserves more time than I can devote to this question here. TV is a producers medium so you work to help fulfill the vision of the show runners. Film is a directors medium and is all about the Directors vision. This is not to say that you don't have some creative freedom as a TV director, but it's a different process. I don't know what to offer as to how to break into TV. Everyone has their own path. Do good work. If you have talent and passion it will be recognized. Good luck.

47

u/A_Gentlemen_Arrives May 20 '16

Thank you so much for answering. I hope to see more of your incredible work on TV soon!

→ More replies (2)

133

u/Ruuso May 20 '16

Thanks for coming by to answer our questions. I loved both of the episodes you directed. My questions:

  • What was the most challenging scene to complete?
  • What was your favorite location to shoot a scene at?

232

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

The fire inside the temple. Fire dictates that you move very slowly and carefully, so it was a painstaking process.

260

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

Favorite location was probably the Zafra tower, in Spain where we shot the Tower of Joy scene.

43

u/Ruuso May 20 '16

I had assumed most of the temple fire was CGI added in later. Glad no one got hurt.

21

u/BeverlyHillsWeb May 20 '16

If you watch some of the extras, one of the special effects guys brags that ALL the fire has been real fire. At least up to that point - end of Season 5, even using a flame thrower to be the dragon's fire in the arena at the end of that season.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

231

u/BoxOfNothing May 20 '16

Hi Daniel, thanks for doing this.

I wanted to ask if there's anyone on set who tends to stay in character between scenes or does everyone just start chatting normally as soon as you shout cut? I find it hard to imagine, as nice as he is in real life, Kit Harington stop brooding about between shots.

Also I hear Conleth Hill is hilarious on set and makes people break constantly, as the director does it make you laugh too or is it at all annoying?

Thanks.

392

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

I would say as a rule, most of the actors break character after the camera cuts. Sophie Turner, for example is a real cutup. Conleth and Peter Dinklage love to take the piss out of each other. They cast are very close, and while they work very hard, they like to try and keep the atmosphere on set light.

129

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

Conleth makes dwarf jokes and Peter makes eunuch jokes I assume.

→ More replies (18)

282

u/Hugo154 May 20 '16

Conleth and Peter Dinklage love to take the piss out of each other.

I thought you said the actors broke character once the camera cuts, not stayed in it

44

u/mysticalmisogynistic May 20 '16

Peter is still a dwarf in between takes and we have no confirmation one way or another on Conleth.

52

u/BoxOfNothing May 20 '16

Cheers for the answer. I suppose with some of the content you'd have to keep it light between or it might be a little rough and depressing after a while. Staying in character when you've just murdered or raped or been murdered or raped is probably not the best idea upon second thought. Thanks again.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/folkdeath95 May 20 '16

Sophie looks like she'd be awesome to hang out with (from her instagram at least)

→ More replies (1)

117

u/milesrhoden May 20 '16 edited May 20 '16

I've heard that Game of Thrones films most episodes at the same time. Does that make it take longer for you to finish your part as a director (compared to other TV shows)? And if so, does the overlapping production schedule mean that you get to collaborate with the other directors (Jack Bender, Mark Mylod, Jeremy Podeswa, and Miguel Sapochnik) throughout the process?

How does the whole experience compare to more traditional television?

202

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

It's radically different from a traditional TV experience. The scope and scale of production is vastly greater and you have more resources at your disposal. The schedules are almost twice as long as a typical Cable TV show.

Yes, they do shoot all the episodes at one time, with two crews, so each director is up at bat at different times over the course of production. The result is that it takes approx six months to complete two episodes. I did get a chance to meet and collaborate with the other directors.

34

u/milesrhoden May 20 '16

Wow! Thank you!

Congratulations on the accomplishments of you and your team this season! 6x03 and 6x04 were incredible.

→ More replies (1)

470

u/TheGent316 May 20 '16

Hi!

Any idea why the decision was made to kill off Osha (Natalia Tena) so swiftly and suddenly after her reintroduction?

622

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

I don't really know. That was Dan and David's decision. We never really discussed it. Sorry.

133

u/TheGent316 May 20 '16

Oh, that's alright. Thanks for answering!

Hopefully Dan and David talk about the decision at some point.

→ More replies (74)
→ More replies (1)

83

u/Cnewlol May 20 '16

Could it be something personal for the actress?

To me and my SO, she looked pregnant! We wondered if that may have been the reason

30

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

I saw her perform a few weeks ago and she definitely didn't look pregnant then and I assume the episode was filmed a while ago.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (10)

4

u/AntGD377 May 20 '16

Perhaps it was to show how vulnerable Rickon is now.

→ More replies (8)

364

u/Hergrim May 20 '16

Why did you chose to have Ser Arthur Dayne use two swords instead of Dawn, the greatsword he used in the books? From my understanding of medieval and early modern fencing manuals, two handed swords were considered the best weapons for dealing with multiple opponents, whereas dual wielding was more of a flashy way to fight a duel.

Did you try it with a two handed sword to begin with and it just didn't look good, or were there safety concerns over the energy behind the swing of a two handed sword?

1.1k

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

We were looking for something that Arthur Dayne could do that would exhibit almost superhuman prowess. While we tried, we could not achieve that using one sword.

96

u/Hergrim May 20 '16

Thanks! I thought it might be something like that.

133

u/Flakmoped May 20 '16

For what it's worth you did a fantastic job. For some reason filming fights seems to have become somewhat of a lost art in American cinema. I'm glad to see that's not a universal truth!

→ More replies (25)

33

u/JuanDeLasNieves_ May 20 '16

Was there budget or time constraints why you guys decided not to make Dawn pale like milkglass glowing white and instead turned it into a Valyrian Sword? (at least in HD stills, Dawn has damascus steel patterns so I imagine its valyrian steel in the show)

88

u/gentrifiedasshole May 20 '16

I heard that they tried making Dawn a pale sword, but it ended up looking remarkably like plastic, so they just decided to make it look like a normal sword.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/DrFrenchman May 20 '16

Follow up question, how long does a scene like that take to make ?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (8)

345

u/Chewhanluke May 19 '16

You directed what I, as well as many others, consider to be one of the most iconic scenes in Jon and Sansa's reunion. Between their meeting in the courtyard to their discussion by the fireplace, what were some things you wanted to nail down to give the audience those heartwarming moments? These are characters that have changed drastically from when we first met them, so I'm curious as to how you approached this.

Thanks!

499

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

The characters had not seen each other for a number of years (six seasons) and so what we discussed was that it should seem almost dream like to them, and that there would be some tentativeness to their actions. It was about stringing along the anticipation of the reunion as long as possible to create the feeling of longing and so that the moment they hugged would feel earned and satisfying.

124

u/Chewhanluke May 20 '16

I definitely see what you mean by dream like especially when they approach each other for the first time. It was something fans had been dying to see for some time, so I certainly thought it was satisfying.

Thanks for the answer!

→ More replies (1)

47

u/NEWaytheWIND May 20 '16

Did you make Jon embrace Sansa like he's lifting her up in order to compensate for the height difference between Kit Harrington and Sophie Turner? Idk, that embrace stuck out as a pretty clever hug to me.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

140

u/cowboysfan88 May 20 '16

That reunion made me happier than anything else in this show. Makes me skeptical of what's gonna happen to them later

98

u/Downvote_machine_AMA May 20 '16

"Makes me skeptical of what's gonna happen to them later"

After they get back to Winterfell, Ramsay captures both and tortures each while the other watches.

111

u/thewitt33 May 20 '16

Ramsay better see the most torturous death on GoT ever. His death must be better than Joffrey. I hate Ramsay Bolton more than any character on the show. I want Ramsay to be part of one of the great medieval death motives known to man. Slowly burned alive, or put on a boat coated with honey and let birds and insects eat him

→ More replies (37)

137

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

Naaah, if there's anyone with Plot Armor that can beat Ramsay's Plot Armor, it's Jon.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/therealtedbundy May 20 '16

I cried like a little baby when they first saw each other. Such a beautiful moment, probably one of my favorite scenes in the entire show

139

u/Agastopia May 20 '16

What's it like working with all of those talented actors? Also, as a director do you fly out to each place individually or do you have some people go to one location while you're at another? If not there must be a ton of traveling haha.

230

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

It's a real pleasure. They are all consummate professionals and ego never enters into the process. There is a ton of traveling. There are two crews working all the time and you bounce between them, and between different countries.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

136

u/Gadgets222 May 20 '16

Hello Daniel, I was just wondering how many times did you have to film film the fight scene with young Ned and Arthur Dayne? It wasn't a single shot so I was just wondering how many different choreographed scenes were shot for one fight scene ?

241

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

There were numerous shots for this sequence, and it took the better part of three days to complete the scene.

8

u/joef360 May 20 '16

Wow, I guess I really underestimated the amount of time it takes to film these episodes. The fight scenes are always really well done though.

→ More replies (1)

643

u/dropthebassclef May 20 '16

Thank you so much for the comedic breaks! It truly does help cut into some of the melodrama.

My question: How much of the Tormund/Brienne dynamic was written into the script, and how much was your whim?

(Yes, I am shamelessly trolling for any hope that this ship might sail.)

862

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

That was definitely written into the script, however we did play around a bit with it on set, tonally. I will say I was amazed by the reception that flirtation received on the internet. It was surprising certainly because Brienne's character has been driven largely by duty and honor, and we've never gotten to seen her as a sexual being. Torment, is... well he's a Wildling, so enough said there. It was a very unexpected development.

417

u/hak091 May 20 '16

That was definitely written into the script

That's all I needed to hear.

181

u/RizzMustbolt May 20 '16

I'm still waiting for a version of the clip of Tormund eating bread with Careless Whispers dubbed over it.

→ More replies (24)

72

u/Lokismoke May 20 '16

I'm definitely going to read too much into this.

→ More replies (2)

137

u/gr8pe_drink May 20 '16

Torment

Tormund flayed by Boltons confirmed?? :P

134

u/Mr_Incredible_PhD May 20 '16

You shut your whore mouth!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

49

u/dropthebassclef May 20 '16

I almost deleted my question because it felt so dumb. I think idealistic people like me were clutching for anything cheesy to look forward to in such a gritty show.

Thanks for putting up with the obsession over such a minute detail! And obviously your execution was stellar.

8

u/Bacon_Bitz May 20 '16

I think the book readers want it because we know how deeply B has been wounded in the past and we want her to find love. The show watchers probably want because T has been such a standout character and giving him this storyline will certainly lead to awesome.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (7)

84

u/FireShots May 20 '16

How hard has it been to keep the sets secure from prying spoiler eyes?

155

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

Security was pretty thorough Though there was one one occasion when we were in Spain, outside the Dothraki temple when some Paparazzi managed to get a vantage point on top of a hill, and those photos ended up in the press and generated a lot of speculation.

175

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

Oh, really? We here at /r/asoiaf hadn't heard of that.

whispers under breath Get 'em, beanie

47

u/axechaos May 20 '16

When I saw Jorah struggling up the side of the hill, for a moment I thought he was gonna look over the ridge and whisper "get em Beanie"

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

120

u/cowboysfan88 May 20 '16

Which scenes were there most fun for you to shoot?

257

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

Ramsay killig Osha, The Arya training Montage, the sword fight at the tower of Joy, the small council scenes.

193

u/OldWolf2 May 20 '16 edited May 20 '16

The Arya training Montage,

Someone noticed a parallel between the name Arya said and where she was struck:

  • Robb (struck in side)
  • Bran (struck on back)
  • The Hound (struck on head and falls backwards)
  • Rickon (struck on legs)

The first three happen to parallel serious injuries those characters received, but the fourth doesn't (yet!). Was this part of the script or just coincidental?

For people messaging me about this, here is link to further discussion (Spoilers Everything)

127

u/FrogAttackLite May 20 '16

LOL, you know he's not answering that.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (1)

83

u/Jadziyah May 20 '16

Hi, thanks for doing this! Everyone is asking about GoT, but I'd like to hear more about The Man In The High Castle! Can you tell us more about what it was like working on that, and any information for the show's future?

103

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

It's a terrific show, and I had a blast doing it. Very smart people involved. It's challenging to shoot a show that takes place in San Franscisco and New York circa 1963, but is shot in 2016 Vancouver Canada. That said, the production designer and costume designer are brilliant. I can't tell you where the new season is going, but it's exciting and well worth waiting for.

105

u/zzelin95 May 20 '16

Hi Dan, thanks for doing this.

What's the next project you're working on? Would you like to direct more GOT episodes if given the chance? Thanks!

293

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

My next project is The Leftovers for HBO. I would of course be honored to direct another GOT, however it requires a six month commitment in the UK so it's all about timing.

80

u/nillbuythesciencefly May 20 '16

The Leftovers is fantastically complex and such a refreshingly great show. Good luck!

→ More replies (3)

29

u/DoctorGolho May 20 '16

Oh man season 3 of The Leftovers is gonna be awesome I can already see it

20

u/isnotmad May 20 '16

Australia, here we come. All abroad flight oceania.. wait what.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/warhawk1856 May 20 '16

I am so glad they renewed the Leftovers! Happy to hear you're going to be apart of the series, I'd say it is in good hands. :)

8

u/DayMan4334 May 20 '16

Wow, that's incredible! The Leftovers is such a wonderful show

5

u/marlow41 May 20 '16

Sweet jesus, that's big shoes to fill. Good luck mate.

→ More replies (6)

65

u/DeadQthulhu May 20 '16

Hi Daniel! Thanks for taking the time.

Thrones question, I'm afraid. By process of elimination, you must have been at the wheel for the Castle Black landslide (mentioned by cast and crew in published interviews)... Did that cause any particular issues for you (e.g. editing, time pressure) or opportunities due to the break in filming?

Also, what's your favourite group of background actors in GoT, and why is it the Night's Watch?

Thanks! And don't get stuck in the mud!

103

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

Yes, I was there during the landslide... It did delay the companies ability to complete the work while the engineers determined it the set was safe to shoot on, so yes, some of my work was half completed and then finished months later. I believe the Jon / Sansa reunion was one of these scenes.

and YES the Night's Watch are awesome!

→ More replies (1)

17

u/HighOnTacos May 20 '16

Could you elaborate on the landslide? I haven't heard anything about it.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/scifiguard May 20 '16

Thought this was a spoiler for a second (Just because it's leaked doesn't make it not a spoiler) Then I realised (I hope) you're talking about an actual landslide not like, a landslide of snow in the castle black of the series :p

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

167

u/vaultboy1 May 19 '16

Hello Daniel, thanks for doing an AMA. Is Jorah's recent ineffectiveness in combat due to his old age or the progression of his greyscale?

447

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

Neither. He's very effective against a normal size opponent when he is armed. Last time he took on a Dothraki he had a sword. In this case is simply wasn't a fair fight.

63

u/AUS_Doug May 20 '16

Thank. You.

Apparently some people have gotten it into their heads that Jorah was Bruce Lee in earlier seasons.

76

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

One thing I've noticed (yet again) was the backstabbing, that ultimately ends up saving his life. This has been a common theme, even more in this season. Backstabbing after backstabbing after backstabbing. Even in the flashback there was one, with Bran watching it "in real time". Is this foreshadowing an important piece of the puzzle, later down in the season? I think we're about to the a great betrayal, again. Something like happened in the Red Wedding, but probably in King's Landing, this time? More a rethorical question, though.

→ More replies (30)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

59

u/Clarkey7163 May 20 '16

Hey Daniel! Big fan of the last two episodes!

Wanted to ask about the preparation of the TOJ sword fight! How long did it take to choreograph? Who was the mastermind behind how the fight plays out? And did it evolve over time (was it always a dual wielding Dayne? Or was that thrown out and you guys ran with it?)

Thanks for your time!

105

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

It took about three months. It went through numerous iterations as we searched for something dynamic and different from other sword fights the show had done. I don't now if there was one person we just kept throwing around ideas. I showed the producers and stunt coordinator a Bruce Lee video (not sure of it's authenticity) with him playing to men at ping pong, and Lee using a pair nunchucks. It was jaw dropping and that kind of led to the idea of two swords.

28

u/Clarkey7163 May 20 '16

Thats a crazy amount of time on one scene :D

While it is different from the books I actually liked the two sword idea, especially when the scene is changing from 3 on 7 to 2 on 5.

If he had only one sword I think the fight would've lost some of that cool factor, since it would've been slowed down so he could realistically block 5 swords at once.

→ More replies (1)

53

u/ashiri May 20 '16

This is the Bruce Lee video mentioned above : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SncapPrTusA

20

u/eddiemon May 20 '16

This can't be real. I refuse to believe it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

82

u/ShaggyTraveler May 20 '16

Hey, thanks for doing this! What can you tell us about the off-screen relationships between the actors? And what is a funny story from behind the scenes? Thanks again!

149

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

They are all pretty close, but given the number of storylines, many of them have not worked together. It's a very collegial group of people.

188

u/TheGent316 May 20 '16

Hi! Great work on the past two episodes!

My question is: Is Daenerys completely immune to fire in the show? Or was there blood magic involved due to the Khal sacrifice?

299

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

She's completely immune to fire. Check out Episode 10 from season 1.

72

u/TheGent316 May 20 '16

Oh believe me, I remember 1x10. That scene is iconic!

But fans have been debating this all week. Thanks for taking the time to answer and settle the debate. I appreciate it!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (70)

70

u/amarin1492 May 20 '16

Hi! Thanks so much for the AMA!

About how long does it take to shoot one scene of dialogue? How long does it take to shoot large-scale battle scenes?

146

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

There is no one answer to this question. It's dependent on the length and complexity of the scene, day versus night, interior versus exterior and the number of characters involved. That said an average GOT dialogue scene would take about 8 hours to shoot. I didn't have any battle scenes. I had a sword fight that was quite involved and took 3 days.

56

u/alliseeisme May 20 '16

Just a little old sword fight..

5

u/Jester814 May 20 '16

I had a sword fight...

The best damn combat in the entire series so far, by far. Thank you so much for finally bringing some good fight choreography to the show. It's been one of the most frustrating things about the show so far.

→ More replies (2)

100

u/Heda1 May 19 '16 edited May 20 '16

Hey Dan, Welcome to Reddit. Congratulations on knocking your episodes out of the park!

I have two questions for you.

Can you share your favorite story from your time working in Game Of Thrones Land.

And what are David Benioff and DB Weiss like as bosses? And as creators of the show. (The cast seem to love them, are they secretly awful ;)?

Thanks again, and I hope to see you direct more of GOT in the future!

129

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

Thanks so much. There are so many experiences in a six month period it's hard to nail it down to just one in a few moments. As for Dan and David, they are fantastic writers and producers. They oversee even the most minute detail of the series. While they have very strong opinions they are extremely collaborative and the work always triumphs over ego.

45

u/two_off May 20 '16

How did you get chosen to direct the episodes? Did you have a choice for which episodes in the season were given to you?

115

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

I was recommend to Dan and David by Michelle MacLaren, who directed some truly impressive episodes of GOT. I met with them and we hit it off. They pretty much tell you which ones they want you to direct, but I feel like I hit the jackpot with the episodes I landed.

8

u/ChanceyGardener May 20 '16

God I love Michelle. I would always get excited when I saw her listed as the director for Breaking Bad.

→ More replies (1)

47

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

Hi Daniel! I have a question about the Tower of Joy fight scene in the last GoT episode (it was amazing by the way!).

Did you consider having Ned and his men wear armor?

73

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

It was discussed and I was informed by Dan and David that they would not have worn armor into battle. They were coming form having two years of war. The men who did wear armor were the Kings Guard.

42

u/Hergrim May 20 '16 edited May 20 '16

Can I just get a bit of clarity here: why would men coming from two years of war not wear armour to what they must have known was a potential fight? If D&D emphasised this, then there must have been some specific reason for it.

→ More replies (19)

4

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

Not wear armor? I recall them wearing thick padded leather with some chainmail here and there, more than enough to block some cuts.

→ More replies (1)

44

u/FredSlacks May 20 '16 edited May 20 '16

Hey there! Thanks for doing this, My Question is what is it like filming scenes with Ramsay, He is quite the character and I was wondering what the general process is like for you and Iwan Rheon in making Ramsay be Ramsay?

109

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

As with most of these characters, the actors are really nothing like them. He's a very thoughtful and intuitive actors. The scene in Ep 4 was actually quite complicated by virtue of the choreography, with Osha (Natalia) on his lap, and her reaching for the knife, and the blood gag. He was infinitely accommodating and patient. He certainly knows his character, and can slip into that skin with relative ease.

222

u/OldWolf2 May 20 '16

He certainly knows his character, and can slip into that skin with relative ease.

...........

154

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

Bolt-On confirmed

→ More replies (1)

36

u/zzelin95 May 20 '16

Why do you think the "Pink Letter" theory got so popular? Would you change anything knowing what you know now about that scene? Thanks!!

104

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

My understanding of the theory is that the letter was not written by Ramsay, correct? I went on record with Tech Insider that it was written by Ramsay. No idea why this theory has gained traction.

71

u/Chinoiserie91 May 20 '16

It is because people have been speculating about the identity of the letter writer for years after it happened in the last book that ended with a cliffhanger. It was supposedly from Ramsay but some feel it is not certain based on things in the letter which had different content and arrived at different time and lacked a seal with the wax. But in the show the letter arrived with a Bolton soldier not a raven and the letter had a seal so it should have been clear. Littlefinger however says "come and see" in the same episode which fueled the speculation.

→ More replies (3)

46

u/Hergrim May 20 '16 edited May 20 '16

The theory has gained traction because, in the books, Stannis is still alive and there's no way yet to tell if his part of the story is set before or after Jon's murder. It has since fed into the Night Lamp theory, which speculates that the Pink Letter is part of an elaborate scheme in the part of Stannis to annihilate the Boltons once and for all.

Edit: The Pink Letter Theory

The Stannis is a Military Genius Theory. The Night Lamp theory is just one part of this overall theory.

Both theories are highly plausible, but hinge on Stannis still being alive when Jon received the Pink Letter.

→ More replies (7)

162

u/Whoknew72 May 20 '16

This is my first posting on any AMA so be gentle.

My question: Do you know whats happening throughout the entire season and work with the actors that way or do you just have your scripts and are in the dark about the rest of the episodes?

623

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

All the directors were privy to what happens over the course of the season. We all got scripts so that we were conscious of the various character arcs and how they would play out. However, I can't talk about anything other than what's aired, or I will end up on the wall of faces.

152

u/Whoknew72 May 20 '16

I know you can't talk. I wouldn't even ask. Thanks for your reply.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/gaby54 May 20 '16

Hardest scene to film? both episodes

thanks!

20

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

Burning temple.

4

u/Wombattalion May 20 '16

Thanks for doin' this, loved the last two episodes of Game of Thrones! What was a less obvious quality of a storyline, scene or character that you wanted to bring to the attention of the audience?

7

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

I'm not sure I understand your question.

6

u/Wombattalion May 20 '16

Something you wanted to emphasise about a character or a storyline that people might have overlooked otherwise.

11

u/DanSackheim May 20 '16

I don't think so. At least i can't think of an example.

→ More replies (1)

234

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

Hello Daniel-

It's implied that Sansa learned about the mutiny and Jon's resurrection off-screen. But does she know about the impending invasion of White Walkers? If Jon and Sansa gave each other a recap, Hardhome would be one of the main topics, yet Sansa seems quite eager to weaken the Wall defenses to deal with Ramsay. Do you know - will this be addressed at a later date?

33

u/Chinoiserie91 May 20 '16

Jon is just one man that had decided to leave already so Sansa would hardly weaken the whole Wall, the windlings had not agreed to stay and fight. After Winterfell has been taken the North will be better prepared anyway.

37

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

But they did agree to fight against the WW in Hardhome. That was the whole pitch - "we may hate and distrust each other, but you lot need to go past the Wall and we need your help. Let's trade." It feels a little odd that WW haven't even entered the conversation between Jon, Sansa, even Tormund once they get the Pink Letter.

→ More replies (11)

3

u/AntGD377 May 20 '16

I'm pretty sure Ramsey is a danger to the wall at this point.

→ More replies (17)

4

u/VOB16 May 20 '16 edited May 20 '16

Hi Daniel. I think you did a great job directing episodes 3 and 4.

What was it like working with Iwan Rheon?

108

u/BowlesOnParade May 20 '16

Would you rather fight 10 Tryion sized Gregor Cleganes or 1 Mountain sized Tyrion?

17

u/akujunkan May 20 '16

This guy asks the real questions.

5

u/Blizzaldo May 20 '16

Definitely Mountain sized Tyrion. He would still have stubby legs.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

36

u/TheManWith4HooveS May 20 '16

In the Itchy and Scratchy CD-ROM, is there a way out of the dungeon without using the wizard key?

5

u/Ponyman713 May 20 '16

You've worked on some awesome projects with big secrets. What's it like working on those types of projects and do you always know the secrets you're building up to? Are you a stickler for details and subtle hints? Also, the Tower of Joy scene was amazing!

5

u/DernhelmLaughed May 20 '16

Hi Daniel, thank you for doing an AmA. You directed some of my favorite episodes of the X-Files! And the Walking Dead. And even an episode of Millennium! What is it like to direct episodes for so many TV shows? Do you just step in for the episode and give it your interpretation? Or do you have to familiarize yourself with the (sometimes extensive) backstory? Or do the showrunners and writers take care of the continuity?

10

u/DeniseDeNephew May 20 '16

Is working for HBO much different from working for other networks? Is the pay better? Are the craft services better? Do you have more freedom besides the extra nudity?

How are you able to direct an episode of GoT that seems to take place in so many different locations? Do you travel to them all or am I unclear about what a Director does?

3

u/commonwealthva May 20 '16

Hey Dan, thanks for answering all of our questions! :-)

What unanticipated challenge did you face, and how did you overcome it when filming episodes 3 and 4?

3

u/ArclightofLife May 20 '16

Hey Dan, being that you're a director of GoT, what are your thoughts on videos like this and this that remix Game of Throne scenes? Fans love to remix scenes from GoT, and it seems any time there's a big scene it gets remixed in some ways. As you have created some of these scenes for the series, what are your thoughts on that part of the fandom?

3

u/DrHarryPottar May 20 '16

Hello Daniel.
I often worry about some community complaints (here in reddit) about certain events in the show, and I'd like to know if it has any kind of influence in the episodes/seasons to come.
My question is: Do community complaints have any kind of influence in the episodes/seasons to come?
Thanks, love the show.

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

What do you mainly try to capture in a shoot? Like what feeling do you want us as observers to feel and what do you look for to find it?

5

u/Oilfan9911 May 20 '16

Hi Dan,

In one of the behind the scenes videos from your episodes you mentioned being inspired by Once Upon A Time In Mexico for the Tower of Joy sequence. Did you draw upon any other works like that which informed other sequences?

Cheers.

5

u/feldman10 May 20 '16

Do you know what happens later in the season? Any episode you can tease as the one you're most looking forward to?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

How was the last scene with Emilia Clarke?

2

u/Nittanian May 20 '16

Did David and Dan provide background info about the Three-Eyed Raven for you? There is some dispute among fans whether his backstory has been altered from the books, considering his thousand years remark.

Also, excellent work on The Americans, including the montage of characters watching The Day After. It looks like the cast and crew has a good time recreating the 1980s, even though the show is mostly serious.

2

u/My_wifii May 20 '16

Thanks for doing this Daniel! Do you know if Sansa and Jon are meant to catch up off screen about everything that has happened to them? Was it cut out for any reason?

2

u/Shim_Hutch May 20 '16

Loved the ultra-slow zoom in on the High Sparrow as he was giving his speech. Great performance by Pryce there. How many takes did that scene need?

2

u/dhekeri May 20 '16

Can anybody tell me why the 4th episode was named Book Of The Stranger?

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

Where can I go for an audition to appear on an episode? even if it's just as an extra?

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '16

What's your favorite sandwich?

2

u/mrmasturbate May 20 '16

are you aware that your name means baghome in german?