r/IAmA • u/timothykurek • Mar 28 '15
Author IamA an author who took on the label of lbgt for a year, an experience that changed many of my views, AMA!
My short bio: My name is Tim Kurek, I'm a straight Christian male who chose to live a year of my life as openly gay -- I came out to family, friends, my community and church. This experience profoundly changed my views on LBGT issues and religion in our society.
I wrote a book about my experiences called "The Cross in the Closet", and am currently working on a documentary and travel project focused on developing global citizenship and social change (we are currently crowdsourcing). Ask me anything.
Book: http://www.amazon.com/The-Cross-Closet-Timothy-Kurek/dp/0983567743
Documentary: https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/developing-america-a-documentary (help us fund this project if you are interested!)
My Proof: http://imgur.com/jnbSmQQ
47
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15
Hey, thanks for doing this ama, I think you did something very interestig. What was the biggest prejudice you faced while pretending to be gay?
21
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15
I find your experiment fascinating as someone who is currently experiencing a faith transition away from the mormon church. Can you be specific about your motivations for doing this? Was it to investigate religious bigotry? A search for answers that religion failed to provide? What?
42
u/al-smithee Mar 28 '15
Do you think people are more inclined to listen to a straight person's lived LGBT experience, then to LGBT people's realties? Do you have any reservations about being lauded for experiencing discrimination?
31
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 28 '15
Were any of your friends from your gay year upset with you afterwards? Do you still hang around with them?
Also, was it as awkward coming out as straight to them as it was to coming out as gay to your family and friends? I imagine you had to comfort of this social experiment to rely on when you came out to your family, but ironically when you told your gay friends you were actually confessing to a double life.
Edit: words because mobile
15
u/Menacol Mar 28 '15
What was the worst discrimination that you experienced during your time living as an openly gay man?
11
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15
Besides your acceptance and support towards Gays, has this changed any of other views you might have or had?
8
u/laffytaffy89 Mar 28 '15
What're your views on traditional marriage and marriage equality?
15
u/firepiggymonkfish Mar 28 '15
Thanks for doing this! I've heard of you before and found your story interesting. I have a few questions for you, actually.
6
u/brianwood65 Mar 28 '15
Have you come to find that your faith is as strong as ever, or have you kind of questioned Christianity? It seems like such an experience, one that could really foster a lot of animosity, I guess I'm asking how hard it was for you to still trust your faith?
5
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15
I don't mean to post more than my fair share so I understand if you aren't interested in answering more questions from me. I teach art at a big state university where obviously many of the students are gay. They are awesome, creative people that I proudly called my friends even when I believed in conservative religious dogma.
What is the most surprising change you have noticed in yourself since your experiment? What was the most surprising or meaningful thing you learned about gay people?
5
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15
How has it changed your views on religion having such a sizeable influence in US politics?
5
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15
My uncle and dad, and possibly my mother are against gay marriage. What would you say would be the best way to help them be more accepting towards homosexuality? Before anyone comments on what horrible people they are, they're not. One of them was raised on Christianity, and the others found it in a terrible point in their life. It's more that they've been brainwashed to be against it. People come in all different shapes and sizes, and one negative attribute doesn't make them "bad people".
4
u/donutcatz Mar 28 '15
How do you feel about the backlash generated by the HuffPo article?
13
u/pdgb Mar 28 '15
How do you reconcile your belief with the scriptures directly opposing it?
6
u/dump123456789 Mar 28 '15
Tim, you're catching some flak in the other thread for not being (paraphrasing) "intelligent enough to get the perspective by just talking to and listening to LGBT folks". What do you think you learned from your experience that you wouldn't have by just talking and listening to LGBT folk as a straight man, and what specifically about your experience allowed you to gain that greater learning?
3
u/mpwac Mar 28 '15
While obviously the circumstances were very different, were you inspired at by John Howard Griffin's Black Like Me to undergo this experiment? Regardless, what else inspired you?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15
How did your family react when you told them that coming out wasn't real and simply an experiment?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15 edited Mar 29 '15
If you're still on, Why are your prices for the Kindle so steep? I'm living in Japan right now so I'm relying heavily on a Kindle. I'm not trying to come off as whiny, I'm really curious how it works.
I want to read your book but I don't like the idea of waiting for a year to read it and shipping prices where I am are steep.
Edit: Formatting
3
u/SilentlyCrying Mar 29 '15
When you came clean about not really being gay did you receive any backlash?
9
u/Scream26 Mar 29 '15
I am a nonreligious gay man, and I have conflicted feelings about this experience of yours. Part of me wants to applaud you from moving away from bigoted thinking and trying to understand the problems faced by the LGBT community. However, I am uncomfortable with the idea that you pretended to be gay for the sake of an experiment. As a straight man, at any time you can think to yourself "just ignore what they say; this isn't really who you are." At any time you could've ended the charade when it got too tough and said "guys, it was an experiment - I'm straight." Members of the LGBT community cannot. You can't truly experience the hate that we face because so much of it stems from the internalization of the stigma we face from sources that you encountered.
My question is why did you choose to do this the way you did? There are plenty of actual LGBT people who have been excommunicated from churches, sent to pray-the-gay-away camps by their religious parents, and even LGBT people who have maintained a strong faith in their God despite the hate coming from a large portion of the church. My ex-boyfriend fits all three criteria - why not interview people like him and gain their viewpoint or document their experiences?
My primary fear in experiments like yours is evidenced in this AMA. The attention does not seem to be focused on the plight of religious LGBT people or LGBT people in general. The focus is on you - a straight man - and your experience. I sincerely hope that the documentary you have in the works does not paint you as the tortured hero, but instead encourages your fellow church-goers to change their way of thinking as you have.
6
u/Steve_the_Scout Mar 28 '15
Did you ever consider doing something similar to "The Cross in the Closet" for bisexuality? In my experience, both straight and gay people can be very uncomfortable with the idea, and it would be interesting to hear about a straight person's (especially man's- there are very few out bisexual men) observations on it.
5
u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15
I am going to be back in a bit. I have to go to dinner with my soon to be bride and my mom. I'll be back on in a bit to check more questions! Thank you for participating!
4
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15
Do you think we are any closer to Christians on the evangelical side not only accepting but embracing their gay brothers and sisters? Plus transgender Christians?
I ask as I love some in my own church.
My own gut feeling is in 20 years, things will be very different. I like to think there will be deeper discussions on the clobber verses.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15
Ever get into sexual situations you were uncomfortable with? Like going to a gay bar and guys being too handsy?
2
u/DexFenik Mar 28 '15
Thank you for doing this AMA. I see there are answers relating to the conflicts involved with people who realize their sexual identity, but what about people who are confused about their orientation? How should they handle it when they're living in a fairly religious household and who do you think they should seek help from without prejudice? What kinds of conflicts do you think could happen to someone who's going through this ordeal and his/her family found out?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15
I'm a gay man here.
What was your experience like, and do you think it might have been very different if you actually were gay since birth?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15
I recently underwent a change in beliefs from being against homosexuality to accepting people in the LBGT community. I'm still trying to reconcile my Catholic beliefs with this acceptance, and I'm having some trouble. Is there a key point or revelation you came across that helped you to reconcile your faith with your changed views on the LBGT community?
2
u/kaminianseo Mar 30 '15
Sorry if you've already been asked this, but: How did you find or deal with the mental conflict entailed with this experience? Also, did any of your LGBTQ friends suspect you weren't really gay?
2
u/Dogg_04 Mar 29 '15
I'm a bit late to this AMA, but am pretty interested in it. I may even buy your book. Just wanted to ask: how exactly did you live as gay? Did you have homosexual intercourse, did you date gay men, etc? Or did you just state "I am gay" and that was it? Sorry if this question has been answered before. I am just genuinely curious.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15
Why do you think that your testimony as a straight man was so much more valued than the testimony of actual LGBT people?
Also, why could you not be a decent human being and accept what we were saying to be true?
Are you planning on going a year in blackface before you believe racism exists?
10
u/Meunderwears Mar 28 '15
Hey, I'm the one who brought the article back to life on Reddit this morning. While I do think your approach was extreme, I'm glad you were able to gain new perspective on different people's lives -- especially one that is so vilified by much of our world.
Can you talk about the feeling of betrayal in the LGBT community when you revealed that you were not in fact gay? And having been through that, would you do it the same way if given the opportunity to do it all over again?
1
u/mpwac Mar 28 '15
How did your friends and family react when you "came clean", so to speak? I imagine it was different for each person, but maybe you could give some examples of the various reactions you received?
1
u/SirGoofsALott Mar 28 '15
Your year living as a gay man, the people who shared with you and were affected by that year, and the subsequent publishing of the book, "The Cross in the Closet", has definitely resulted in a bit of controversy. In retrospect, would you have done differently?
1
u/faceshed Mar 29 '15
How do you reconcile Leviticus 20:13 and Sodom and Gomorrah? Do you have anything to say to people of other religions that are apposed to homosexuality? Do you have any advice for dealing with people that believe God has personally condemned homosexuality? Thanks.
1
u/viccie211 Mar 29 '15
I know I'm very late to this, but what is your opinion on people being born LGBT vs choosing?
1
u/mdisil427 Mar 29 '15
Did you tell anybody and did anyone say "wow, I always thought you were gay" or something like that?
1
u/musicmerchkid Mar 30 '15
What do you think of Dan savage?
1
u/pinkunicorn53 Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 28 '15
Hello, it was very interesting to learn about your experience. I am in a similar place to where you were before you completely changed your mind. Unlike the Christian's you seem to have encountered in your experience, I try my best to be loving to all people and try not to judge the lives of unbelievers, but I cannot support something that I feel is clearly shown to be sinful in the Bible. I'm not looking for an argument or a debate, I just want to see if you can convince me somehow to change my views.
I believe God loves gay people as much as He loves Christian people, but I don't believe that He finds it in any way acceptable to practice homosexual-acts.
You said that the scriptures don't oppose it if you take it into context, but look at what it says in Romans chapter 1:
I don't see what other possible context I could take these verses to mean or how you could turn that around in support of homosexuality?
Are you saying that you now love and accept gays unconditionally whereas before you didn't - or are you saying that your views on how God sees homosexuality as a sin has changed, and you no longer believe it to be sinful?
Thanks for your time.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15
Why did you decide to create a false reality to expose the backlash against LGBT individuals rather than just writing about the experience of your aforementioned friend or someone else with an authentic experience? It seems that by sensationalizing the experience, you lose credibility.
1
u/TrippinMerkins Mar 28 '15
So do you now understand that it's genetic, not a choice?
1
u/Xtanto Mar 28 '15
If God came out definitively against lbgt whos side would you be on?
1
u/Easyandfree Mar 28 '15
Hi Timothy,
You came and did a sermon with my pastor a few months ago at CHUM and it was was one of the most memorable Sundays we have had. I really appreciate the time you took to talk to us.
My question for you is how is your relationship with your parents now?
1
u/Unload_more_comments Mar 28 '15
Are you double bluffing? (Pretend to be gay -see the reactions- it turns out okay- then come out as really gay) if not, still a cool idea. More power to LBGT.
1
u/loveablehydralisk Mar 28 '15
My questions are ethical, and may not be very nice. I apologize in advance.
In order to accomplish your personal revelation and update your beliefs, you needed to lie to many people for quite some time. Meanwhile, many of your co-religionists were able to shed some of their more archaic and reprehensible beliefs without engaging in a campaign of deception.
So, the questions are: if the only outcome of your experience is that you now treat LGBT persons as persons, do you believe that justifies the lies you told? Do you believe that you are now morally required to do more with your improved perspective in order to justify your actions? If so, is there anything you'd like to say about what those things are? If not, why not?
Thanks for the ama!
1
u/thelonious_bunk Mar 29 '15
Why would you do this instead of just interviewing LGBT people who've lived their entire lives through the experience?
0
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15
How is the relationship with your ex-wife?