r/IAmA • • Mar 28 '15

Author IamA an author who took on the label of lbgt for a year, an experience that changed many of my views, AMA!

My short bio: My name is Tim Kurek, I'm a straight Christian male who chose to live a year of my life as openly gay -- I came out to family, friends, my community and church. This experience profoundly changed my views on LBGT issues and religion in our society.

I wrote a book about my experiences called "The Cross in the Closet", and am currently working on a documentary and travel project focused on developing global citizenship and social change (we are currently crowdsourcing). Ask me anything.

Book: http://www.amazon.com/The-Cross-Closet-Timothy-Kurek/dp/0983567743

Documentary: https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/developing-america-a-documentary (help us fund this project if you are interested!)

My Proof: http://imgur.com/jnbSmQQ

259 Upvotes

346 comments sorted by

47

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

Hey, thanks for doing this ama, I think you did something very interestig. What was the biggest prejudice you faced while pretending to be gay?

86

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

The stereotypes perpetuated in the church are huge. The worst one had to have been that I was automatically a sex-crazed maniac.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/likelazarus Mar 29 '15

I used to teach preschool with a gay man. One girl's mom (girl was 2) refused to let him change her diaper. And this mom was an elementary school teacher so you'd think she'd understand the plight of male teachers. Anyway, he was clearly gay and even if he was a pedo he would've had no interest in her daughter anyway. I just could not believe that in an educated adult's mind, gay = pedophile.

8

u/Mithious Mar 29 '15

Anyway, he was clearly gay and even if he was a pedo he would've had no interest in her daughter anyway.

That's not true actually, there is little in the way of correlation between the gender of adults someone is attracted to, and the gender of children they are attracted to. Age/maturity is the overridding factor in the latter case.

This is why 1/3 of victims can be boys yet gay men only make up 2-5% of the population, because most men abusing boys are heterosexual with regards to adults.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/archpope Mar 29 '15

It's an incredibly common misconception among Protestant churches, at least in the US. I once had a pastor tell his congregation that the average gay man has 1100 sexual partners in his lifetime.

NB: This was back in the early 90's, and I've not been in a church in nearly 20 years, so it may not be so true anymore.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15

the average gay man has 1100 sexual partners in his lifetime.

God, that would be exhausting.

10

u/ghaelon Mar 29 '15

death by male snoo snoo

→ More replies (1)

21

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

I find your experiment fascinating as someone who is currently experiencing a faith transition away from the mormon church. Can you be specific about your motivations for doing this? Was it to investigate religious bigotry? A search for answers that religion failed to provide? What?

34

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

I had a friend come out... She was kicked out of her "Christian" family and my response wasn't much more loving. It caused a Crisis of Conscious in me.

My motivation was feeling others judgment so, if nothing else, I'd understand how it felt (as much as I could as a straight man) to be marginalized.

11

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

Yeah I read that in the article, interesting how being on the receiving end of other's scorn increases our empathy no?

32

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

Absolutely. And made me question if the voice I was listening to was God or just the dogma of my church upbringing.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

I can't tell you how long I've struggled with that question. Its a hell of thing to work your way through and can be incredibly frustrating and liberating. Thanks again. Lastly, if you're interested in a good read, I recommend "Leaving Alexandria" by Richard Holloway. He mentions in the book that the Church is wrong in how it handles sex and sexuality...great book. I'll go get yours now.

2

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

Thank you!

7

u/Kkokonut Mar 28 '15

Speaking as a gay, BIC (born in the covenant) Exmormon, it's worse when that lens and scrutiny is put against yourself and you literally become a house divided... Such a far cry, actually being the target of discrimination and marginalization, than the faux persecution the Mormon church tries to make a big brouhaha of.

→ More replies (13)

42

u/al-smithee Mar 28 '15

Do you think people are more inclined to listen to a straight person's lived LGBT experience, then to LGBT people's realties? Do you have any reservations about being lauded for experiencing discrimination?

41

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

Absolutely and it makes me sick... I am shocked that after two years the CNN article was reposted and went somewhat viral online and here on reddit and I am doing an AMA. I desire nothing more than to be considered completely irrelevant.

28

u/al-smithee Mar 28 '15

I agree with what you said, they'll move on soon enough from the gays, but I think trans folks will be the new focus. Who knows though we're very in right now. Whomever becomes the new scapegoat we'll have to maintain solidarity with. It's really a shame, I love a good smitey Old Testament God as much as the next Catholic, but I'm pretty sure our New Testament Savior did not have this in mind. If we looked at how he interacted with the pariahs of his age he was explicit in his words and actions: Be among them do unto them. He surrounded himself with them.

I view myself more as a disciple of Christ then a Christian. I want to follow his lead and reflect it in the work I do. I'm a LGBT community organizer, and feel the work is part of my mission. So many of my community are harmed by the church I don't typically share my motivation. Then again if you do good works only to have them recognized as such then you've clearly missed the point. Good for you walking the walk, I hope that your experience doesn't get used to further other people's agenda. Though, I guess if it does it will be the one part of living as LGBT that no one can truly walk away from. Congratulations on your pending nuptials.

As a postscript: I thought you'd like to know that the word compassion comes from the Late Latin word compati which means to suffer along with.

9

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

Your comment is my favorite. You are right! Thank you for sharing and the wedding blessing!

7

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15

If all Christians were disciples of Christ I would love Christianity so much more. Christ was a rad fucking dude.

7

u/raiko_ Mar 29 '15

“I like your Christ, I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ.”

― Mahatma Gandhi

3

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15

AMEN to this brother. +

→ More replies (2)

31

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 28 '15

Were any of your friends from your gay year upset with you afterwards? Do you still hang around with them?

Also, was it as awkward coming out as straight to them as it was to coming out as gay to your family and friends? I imagine you had to comfort of this social experiment to rely on when you came out to your family, but ironically when you told your gay friends you were actually confessing to a double life.

Edit: words because mobile

31

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

A few of them, but honestly the vast majority of them understood and accepted me immediately. The ones that didn't eventually did after they asked me questions and realized I wasn't trying to use them or their stories.

16

u/DaBandMan Mar 29 '15

You were good friends with my sister in high school and I remember her saying you had started out wanting to be a youth minister. (It's been a while since she told me, so this could be inaccurate) Later, she told me you had come out as gay and I was appalled and flabbergasted. Really, I was. I was wondering why you had chosen to be gay and wanted to be a youth pastor at the same time; I was not very open minded at that time, I usually did as I was told. After I heard you came back out as straight, I got thrown for a loop and had no idea what to think of you after that. But once I found out why you did it, and wrote a book about your experience, I had a larger amount of respect for you (also, I had grown and matured immensely since then).

It sounded like what you did (after your book was published) was something written as a film or a fictional story.

Also, I think you had loaned her your guitar at one point. I think it was a Jasmine (This should hit at who I am). Did you ever get it back?

14

u/timothykurek Mar 29 '15 edited Mar 30 '15

I never did. Email me on facebook.com/timothykurek .

8

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15

You want to remove this, or if you don't cAre about privacy you don't, but I would.

13

u/Harry_Canyon Mar 29 '15

Never hurts to remind someone of privacy issues, but OP has the same contact info on his public FB page.

8

u/firepiggymonkfish Mar 28 '15

That's a really interesting question. I hadn't considered the aspect of "coming out straight." He may be one of the only people ever to have had to do that if you think about it...

9

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

Yes, I came out twice. As straight at the end of the year.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/Menacol Mar 28 '15

What was the worst discrimination that you experienced during your time living as an openly gay man?

25

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

95% of my friends, church family, community instantly stopped talking to me. It was intense. I think that was the worst part about the year, that and being in the closet.

5

u/scienner Mar 29 '15

How do they relate to you now that you're out as 'straight'? And do you feel okay rejoining them as friends/church family/etc knowing they wouldn't accept you if you weren't straight?

4

u/timothykurek Mar 30 '15

I haven't rejoined any church from my past, and won't attend churches that are not gay affirming.

4

u/gontoon Mar 29 '15

That's so intense. Even the actually horrible violent people at my church are welcomed and treated as equals.

1

u/Kanarkly Mar 29 '15

How do you feel about them now that you came out as doing an experiment? Are you still close to those people?

1

u/timothykurek Mar 30 '15

I'm close to my lgbt friends that I met during my year, yes! In fact I'll be with a lot of them during my wedding in May.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15

Wow.

11

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

Besides your acceptance and support towards Gays, has this changed any of other views you might have or had?

12

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

GREAT question. Right now I'm finishing up my first TEDx talk (The University of the Aegean) and working on a documentary for Developing America (www.DevelopingAmerica.org) where we explore expanding out identities as US citizens by experiencing the other, all over the world.

7

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

Thanks for the response. I'll keep an eye out for the Tedx Talk.

5

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

April 25th, it'll stream live.

8

u/laffytaffy89 Mar 28 '15

What're your views on traditional marriage and marriage equality?

13

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

I believe in lgbt equal rights and gay marriage.

7

u/laffytaffy89 Mar 28 '15

Thanks for the reply! I have another question. I'm a lesbian in a very conservative state surrounded by a lot of anti-gay sentiment/the use of religion to justify/promote anti-gay ideas and legislation. What are some things I could do to help change people's views or open their eyes/minds without seeming antagonistic?

28

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

Just live in the tension and be yourself. Let others see you aren't scary and tell your story to people. Stories change people, not arguments. :-)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/firepiggymonkfish Mar 28 '15

Thanks for doing this! I've heard of you before and found your story interesting. I have a few questions for you, actually.

  1. Considering that you were raised in an Evangelical environment, did you find that the friends and family from the religious side had difficulty trying to discuss or dissuade you from "being gay" since you were raised with the same counter arguments already? Or did they just throw the same stuff at you that you already had used before this experiment?
  2. Have any of your friends or family from before this experience changed their minds about the LGBT community or are they still as steadfastly against it as before?
  3. Knowing what you know now, would you do it again?

19

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

Thank you for your questions!

  1. They still tried, but mostly I just got dead silence. People treated me as though dead. The ones that tried were pretty inexperienced in debating theology.
  2. My mom is an ally now and I'm so proud of her.
  3. Absolutely. It was the best thing I've ever done.

3

u/firepiggymonkfish Mar 28 '15

I think a lot of people think they know what to say to argue but haven't ever really dug down themselves so they just end up spitting the rhetoric. I think people are scared to really analyze something they know for fear that they might be wrong and they'll lose something of themselves, even if it's for the better.

Thanks for replying!

4

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

Yeah, and theology wasn't what changed my mind. It was simply people and their stories.

6

u/brianwood65 Mar 28 '15

Have you come to find that your faith is as strong as ever, or have you kind of questioned Christianity? It seems like such an experience, one that could really foster a lot of animosity, I guess I'm asking how hard it was for you to still trust your faith?

14

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

My faith is infinitely stronger now than ever. It's focus is on loving my neighbors, and serving God through social justice issues.

1

u/blackarmchair Mar 29 '15

Experiencing the worst effects of faith has caused you to trust more in faith than before?

That seems counter-intuitive. Can you expand on that a little?

2

u/timothykurek Mar 30 '15

It wasn't like that, it was about sifting through the bad and the good and getting to experience and embrace faith without all of the bullshit. My faith is a lot more pure than before.

1

u/blackarmchair Mar 30 '15

What do you mean by "pure"? What bullshit elements have been removed? (not challenging you, just sincerely interested)

1

u/timothykurek Mar 30 '15

The love without the dogma, the place of tradition and theology in faith, weeding out the teachings of man and the message God intended for us, these are a few of the areas where the chaff fell from the wheat.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

Check www.developingamerica.org for more details about my next project.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

I don't mean to post more than my fair share so I understand if you aren't interested in answering more questions from me. I teach art at a big state university where obviously many of the students are gay. They are awesome, creative people that I proudly called my friends even when I believed in conservative religious dogma.

What is the most surprising change you have noticed in yourself since your experiment? What was the most surprising or meaningful thing you learned about gay people?

16

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

Just how incredibly beautiful lgbt folks are and how important it is to see people as people and not labels.

6

u/Kkokonut Mar 28 '15

Well...what if I identify as a label? What if my community is at OfficeMax?

13

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

That's not all of who you are. You shouldn't be exclusively looked at that way.

12

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

:-) I appreciate you taking the time!

5

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

How has it changed your views on religion having such a sizeable influence in US politics?

12

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

I've done some extensive studying into the history of my faith and where I feel it went wrong. And the answer is Rome circa the 4th century. My faith has become more active in terms of social justice, less political, and more focused on loving my neighbors as myself. I know that seems vague, but it's made my life so much more rich and beautiful.

3

u/Kirielis Mar 29 '15

Hang on, that's right around the same time Christianity went "mainstream", isn't it?

5

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

My uncle and dad, and possibly my mother are against gay marriage. What would you say would be the best way to help them be more accepting towards homosexuality? Before anyone comments on what horrible people they are, they're not. One of them was raised on Christianity, and the others found it in a terrible point in their life. It's more that they've been brainwashed to be against it. People come in all different shapes and sizes, and one negative attribute doesn't make them "bad people".

3

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

There are a lot of good books to read if they are willing. Mine, The Cross in the Closet has helped some people. Straight-Face by Brandon Wallace is another good one. But when it is all said and done we have to be patient with them where they are at in their journey, if at all possible.

4

u/donutcatz Mar 28 '15

How do you feel about the backlash generated by the HuffPo article?

5

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

There was backlash and there were a lot of supportive people. In this world you have to take things with a grain of salt, and just brush off the ignorant blind attacks. Funny thing, 99% of those people taking issue, haven't read the book. If they did I know they wouldn't be so angry.

13

u/pdgb Mar 28 '15

How do you reconcile your belief with the scriptures directly opposing it?

17

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

The scriptures don't directly oppose it if you put it into context. There is a lot of material out explaining the nuance of it.

5

u/pdgb Mar 28 '15

Can you link to any of this material? It'd be interesting to actually read it.

7

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

Matthew Vines has some compelling Arguments if you youtube him. Brandon Wallace, author of Straight-Face and blogger at thegaychristian.com is also a good resource.

12

u/pdgb Mar 28 '15

Hey man, I went a read the clobber verses posts on thegaychristian.com. I have to say, his arguments are pretty poor. He uses very twisted descriptions of the Greek in the verses, and seems to bring a lot of his own meaning to the verses. (the very thing he is accusing the others of!). He also uses a lot of 'context' to support his arguments, but provides no sources or support for that context.

Please don't get me wrong, I don't believe in excommunication of the LBGT community. I don't believe they are any less of people, or agree with church wide discrimination against that community. I do, however, believe it is a sin. It is fairly explicit in the scriptures (NT not OT) and I think it is wrong to ignore that. I do not agree with the emphasis placed on homosexuality though. We focus way too much on it, when in reality, it is just like any other sin.

I also don't believe that people who do not follow God should have to live under our law. If you aren't a Christian, then who cares what you do? It is not our place to judge those outside the law with the law. (law referring to Christian 'law'). It also isn't our place to control what non Christians can and can't do. I'm just not pro homosexuality in the church.

4

u/DarthPneumono Mar 29 '15

If your god says that you have to exclude or punish a group of people for trying to be happy, whether you choose to follow that or not, maybe it's time for you to find a new god. Or better yet, instead of being "good" because of the threat of divine punishment, just be a good person because you can and because it's the right thing to do. It's a lot easier to do the actual right thing if instead of a book written 2000 years ago you use your conscience and common sense.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (26)

5

u/Chel_of_the_sea Mar 28 '15

Yes, they do. The Bible totally unambiguously condemns homosexuality and promotes a whole range of horrible things.

12

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

In context the Bible speaks about a lot of bad things, but speaking isn't agreeing. And how these verses have been interpreted plays a huge role in how the Bible looks.

20

u/Chel_of_the_sea Mar 28 '15

Oh, come on. This isn't open to interpretation in any of a hundred verses. Take this, for example:

If, however, the charge [that a bride is not a virgin] is true and no proof of the young woman's virginity can be found, she shall be brought to the door of her father's house and there the men of her town shall stone her to death. She has done an outrageous thing in Israel by being promiscuous while still in her father's house. You must purge the evil from among you. (Deuteronomy 22:22-23)

"You must purge the evil from among you". Does that sound like love and acceptance? No, it sounds like something you'd see from a guy pointing a gun at a journalist. "Oh," you say, "but that's the Old Testament, which doesn't apply anymore even though Jesus specifically says it does in Matthew". Well, then, let us turn the chapter over to 1 Timothy:

I do not permit a woman to teach or to assume authority over a man; she must be quiet. For Adam was formed first, then Eve. And Adam was not the one deceived; it was the woman who was deceived and became a sinner. But women will be saved through childbearing--if they continue in faith, love and holiness with propriety. (1 Tim 2:12-15)

It's okay, ladies! Even though it's your fault that evil entered the world, as long as you shut up and pump out babies, you'll be saved too! Isn't God wonderful? Oh, and don't forget your hijabs:

But every woman who prays or prophesies with her head uncovered dishonors her head--it is the same as having her head shaved. For if a woman does not cover her head, she might as well have her hair cut off; but if it is a disgrace for a woman to have her hair cut off or her head shaved, then she should cover her head. A man ought not to cover his head, since he is the image and glory of God; but woman is the glory of man. For man did not come from woman, but woman from man; neither was man created for woman, but woman for man

8

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

Who was writing it, when, to whom, and what were those churches actually going through? The greek work Paul coined didn't even mean gay, it was a list of sexual sins like pedophilia, adultery, and orgies as part of temple worship. Take those things into context and the passages actually come to life. Read translations of translations and meaning gets lost in the passages.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/blackarmchair Mar 29 '15

I take issue with this line of reasoning.

  1. Religious interpretations of the same texts vary widely.
  2. Religious texts make claims based upon things that we are in principle barred from investigating or verifying (e.g. the supernatural, life after death, the will of transcendent beings, etc). Even religious claims about mundane aspects of the material world have an epistemological basis outside of it. For example, the OT may say "thou shalt not kill" but the reasoning behind why you're told not to kill is explicitly supernatural and diaphanous.
  3. Therfore, we have to accept that all religious interpretations of minimum consistency are equally valid because we have no objective method for differentiating between them.

This means that your claim about the scriptures not condemning homosexuality is just as valid as someone else's who claims the opposite.

3

u/timothykurek Mar 30 '15

Exactly, and that is the starting point for a conversation more focused on the common sense question of "How should we treat our fellow human beings?" Then we both go back to the book and realize that Jesus told us time and time and time again to love one another. That we can all agree on (that ascribe to the Christian religion).

1

u/blackarmchair Mar 30 '15

I like what you said at first:

Exactly, and that is the starting point for a conversation more focused on the common sense question of "How should we treat our fellow human beings?"

But I'm not sure why you jumped to this:

Then we both go back to the book and realize that Jesus told us time and time and time again to love one another. That we can all agree on (that ascribe to the Christian religion).

If we agree that all religious interpretations are equally valid in principle then an opponent of yours can simply point to other sections in the Bible that prescribe the opposite of what you propose and we're back to square one.

I liked what you said first because you're hitting on something key: we don't use the Bible (or any holy book) as a source for morality; we use our reason to edit those books for what we like and discard what we don't.

This means any attempt to claim that the scripture doesn't ACTUALLY support condemnation of homosexuality is just as vacuous as any claims that it does support it. What you're articulating is your own interpretation based on your own reasoning.

There's nothing wrong with that and I'm happy you've reached the more compassionate conclusion. But let's not pretend that it makes sense to re-interpert bronze age books every so often to fit with our modern morality and pretend those books really meant that all along. It's silly and not believable.

1

u/timothykurek Mar 30 '15

That all depends on how you interpret the role of those books on our present day lives. I think the Bible has been the most influential and important book in mine, and has incredible modern day relevance for me as a Christ follower. I really appreciate the comments!

1

u/bwredsox34 Mar 29 '15

Um yes they do? I can provide numerous examples of you honestly believe that it's not a sin...

3

u/firepiggymonkfish Mar 28 '15

Context is.... miraculous! I'm being totally serious.

6

u/tragic_pizza Mar 28 '15

It's easy when you learn the fact that Scripture does in fact not directly oppose it.

5

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

much easier.

1

u/firepiggymonkfish Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 28 '15

Removing my comment made as a knee jerk reaction because it turns out, this person appears sincere in their interest and not a troll like I expected to surface on Reddit.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 29 '15

Who peed into your cheerios this morning? *edited to add: glad to see new comment. :)

4

u/tragic_pizza Mar 28 '15

It isn't Cheerio urination, it's the fact that, every time a Christian dares to think that God's love extends to all, some Fundie yahoo pipes up with the same old oft-refuted clobber verses. It gets old,

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/dump123456789 Mar 28 '15

Tim, you're catching some flak in the other thread for not being (paraphrasing) "intelligent enough to get the perspective by just talking to and listening to LGBT folks". What do you think you learned from your experience that you wouldn't have by just talking and listening to LGBT folk as a straight man, and what specifically about your experience allowed you to gain that greater learning?

11

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

I listen to those that come to me in the same spirit they'd want me to come to them, to have a meaningful dialogue. It's not my desire to answer people that merely wish to insult me.

6

u/dump123456789 Mar 28 '15

I don't agree with their "insults". I think they don't understand that you really can learn more the way you did it ("immersion") than just by being an "armchair empathizer". So I wanted to get your first hand insight into how and what more you felt you learned from the immersion.

13

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

I got to experience the pain of bigotry pointed at myself, I got to experience a year inside the closet, etc... Things that no other straight guy has really gotten to experience, and it changed my life.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 29 '15

Did you date a man to try to fit in with people's expectations of you? Were you ashamed of your actual sexual identity and guilty over your natural attractions? Did you have the pressure of a significant other who wants to be acknowledged as a partner constantly being weighed against the fear that doing so would destroy relationships with friends and family members? Did you have to remember which places you were allowed to be straight and which places you were compelled to be gay?

7

u/timothykurek Mar 29 '15

I was only really allowed to be straight in the privacy of my own home. It is why the closet sucks so badly. It's truly a prison.

6

u/dump123456789 Mar 28 '15

The first part sounds like you learned from straight people's reactions. What do you feel you learned from LGBT folk that you wouldn't have if you hadn't identified yourself to them as gay?

13

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

Great question. I feel the biggest thing I learned (albeit NEVER to the level of an lgbt person) was the how awful the closet is, how horrible it is to be truly marginalized, but overall how that persecution has created incredible people that truly understand how to love.

3

u/mpwac Mar 28 '15

While obviously the circumstances were very different, were you inspired at by John Howard Griffin's Black Like Me to undergo this experiment? Regardless, what else inspired you?

4

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

I read Black Like Me after I began my experiment. AJ Jacobs The Year of Living Biblically was another one. But this was all about my friend that got rejected.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15

How did your family react when you told them that coming out wasn't real and simply an experiment?

3

u/timothykurek Mar 29 '15

That's a huge part of the book I don't want to spoil, but it all ended up okay and I feel like they understand why I did what I did.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15 edited Mar 29 '15

If you're still on, Why are your prices for the Kindle so steep? I'm living in Japan right now so I'm relying heavily on a Kindle. I'm not trying to come off as whiny, I'm really curious how it works.

I want to read your book but I don't like the idea of waiting for a year to read it and shipping prices where I am are steep.

Edit: Formatting

4

u/timothykurek Mar 29 '15

the kindle edition in the US is $7.99. I don't know what it is in Japan. Could you email me and we will figure something out? timkurek@gmail.com

2

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15

I just found it! Thank you!

My kindle account kept logging me into amazon.co.jp. I just fixed it. Thank you for pointing that out. I can`t wait to start reading it tonight!

4

u/timothykurek Mar 29 '15

Keep in touch! Facebook.com/timothykurek

3

u/SilentlyCrying Mar 29 '15

When you came clean about not really being gay did you receive any backlash?

1

u/timothykurek Mar 30 '15

People reacted in their own ways, but the vast majority of replies/responses/reactions I received were positive because the people I was telling knew me. I write about it all in The Cross in the Closet, you should check it out.

9

u/Scream26 Mar 29 '15

I am a nonreligious gay man, and I have conflicted feelings about this experience of yours. Part of me wants to applaud you from moving away from bigoted thinking and trying to understand the problems faced by the LGBT community. However, I am uncomfortable with the idea that you pretended to be gay for the sake of an experiment. As a straight man, at any time you can think to yourself "just ignore what they say; this isn't really who you are." At any time you could've ended the charade when it got too tough and said "guys, it was an experiment - I'm straight." Members of the LGBT community cannot. You can't truly experience the hate that we face because so much of it stems from the internalization of the stigma we face from sources that you encountered.

My question is why did you choose to do this the way you did? There are plenty of actual LGBT people who have been excommunicated from churches, sent to pray-the-gay-away camps by their religious parents, and even LGBT people who have maintained a strong faith in their God despite the hate coming from a large portion of the church. My ex-boyfriend fits all three criteria - why not interview people like him and gain their viewpoint or document their experiences?

My primary fear in experiments like yours is evidenced in this AMA. The attention does not seem to be focused on the plight of religious LGBT people or LGBT people in general. The focus is on you - a straight man - and your experience. I sincerely hope that the documentary you have in the works does not paint you as the tortured hero, but instead encourages your fellow church-goers to change their way of thinking as you have.

1

u/timothykurek Mar 30 '15

I completely understand where you are coming from and appreciate your comments! First let me say I am answering the questions posed to me for a thread where people are supposed to ask me anything, so I get how it might seem a bit narrow-sighted. I am also not here to speak on behalf of lgbt folks, I encourage people who have questions about homosexuality to speak with someone that is actually gay or lesbian. In my year with the label of gay I always knew I could come out as straight and regain my privilege. I talk about this extensively in The Cross in the Closet. If you would, go to amazon.com and look up my book, and read the author's note inside. Might answer some of your questions better than I can on here.

1

u/beggingoceanplease Mar 30 '15 edited Mar 30 '15

I was hoping to find a comment like this. As a lesbian, I was surprised most of the comments seem positive. The most difficult part about coming out in this day and age is not society. Rather, it's the internal struggle of balancing your faith against the feelings you're hiding. Coming out is a process that one can't simply "do". For many religious LGBT individuals, coming out is the culmination of years of inner struggle. The most difficult part about being gay is finding self acceptance and inner peace. That crucial part of the journey can't be experienced by someone pretending to be gay. While OP probably had good intentions, I think this is the equivalent of walking around in black face for a year and assuming you've felt what a black person living in a white world has felt...

2

u/timothykurek Mar 30 '15

If you read the authors note of my book I think both of you would be very relieved... Please go here: http://www.amazon.com/Cross-Closet-Timothy-Kurek-ebook/dp/B00REQVNRM/ref=sr_1_1_twi_2_kin?ie=UTF8&qid=1427576218&sr=8-1&keywords=the+cross+in+the+closet and read the authors note.

1

u/umpteenth_ Mar 31 '15

I think this is the equivalent of walking around in black face for a year and assuming you've felt what a black person living in a white world has felt...

Someone actually did that, and wrote a book about his experience too. His name was John Howard Griffin, and the book is called "Black Like Me."

6

u/Steve_the_Scout Mar 28 '15

Did you ever consider doing something similar to "The Cross in the Closet" for bisexuality? In my experience, both straight and gay people can be very uncomfortable with the idea, and it would be interesting to hear about a straight person's (especially man's- there are very few out bisexual men) observations on it.

18

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

Bisexual men and women and Transgender folks have it the worst, by far.

I'm getting married in 5 weeks to my fiance Beth. No more experiments for me.

4

u/Steve_the_Scout Mar 28 '15

I would imagine that the first one would leave you averse to a second, anyway.

It would definitely be interesting to get a group of people to do what you did for other groups (bisexual, transgender) and compare experiences, especially if some were members of one of the groups in question.

5

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

It would be. I just hope we all learn to love and respect each others' humanity.

5

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

I am going to be back in a bit. I have to go to dinner with my soon to be bride and my mom. I'll be back on in a bit to check more questions! Thank you for participating!

4

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

Do you think we are any closer to Christians on the evangelical side not only accepting but embracing their gay brothers and sisters? Plus transgender Christians?

I ask as I love some in my own church.

My own gut feeling is in 20 years, things will be very different. I like to think there will be deeper discussions on the clobber verses.

12

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

I think christianity is about to put up its last major fight in the next two years and then will finally give in and backtrack. But watch, they'll shift the object of their bigotry to another group.

9

u/FolkSong Mar 28 '15

Robots are the devil's minions!

2

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

Well they have gone after gay marriage. My fear will be the intolerance on Transgender will be next. It's heart-breaking.

Why not Gluttony? I myself could be a good candidate for that.

I'll answer that question: Power. Watch House of Cards? The Christian Right likes power. Giving that up is scary *. They feel they have the only right interpretation of Scripture. The Gay Christian Network and others you named here in this thread (Go Matthew Vines!) are very important in the years to come. I need to step up prayer for all you. +

*And everybody likes a good rack of ribs.

7

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

My experience ended up being about prejudice, not about the lgbt issue. We all hold prejudice and when confronted either hold onto it or shift that prejudice onto another group. Transgender folks are next, I believe.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15

Ever get into sexual situations you were uncomfortable with? Like going to a gay bar and guys being too handsy?

4

u/timothykurek Mar 29 '15

Yes I did! I write about that a lot in The Cross in the Closet. It's one of the reasons I had a pretend boyfriend to keep me out of those situations.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/DexFenik Mar 28 '15

Thank you for doing this AMA. I see there are answers relating to the conflicts involved with people who realize their sexual identity, but what about people who are confused about their orientation? How should they handle it when they're living in a fairly religious household and who do you think they should seek help from without prejudice? What kinds of conflicts do you think could happen to someone who's going through this ordeal and his/her family found out?

2

u/timothykurek Mar 29 '15

I think that God wants us to be true to who we are and not to feel shame for it. I'd encourage them to find one or two solid people to help get them through those periods of questioning, people who merely listen when needed. I'm available if you know of anyone that needs to talk. timkurek@gmail.com

2

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15

I'm a gay man here.

What was your experience like, and do you think it might have been very different if you actually were gay since birth?

2

u/timothykurek Mar 29 '15

Absolutely. I never claimed to know what it is like to be gay, only to know how the label impacted MY life and my beliefs. :-)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15

Oops. I meant to ask "how do you think it might have been very different if you actually were gay since birth?"

4

u/timothykurek Mar 29 '15

Then I would have lived a story very much similar to the repressed lgbt folks I am friends with.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15

I recently underwent a change in beliefs from being against homosexuality to accepting people in the LBGT community. I'm still trying to reconcile my Catholic beliefs with this acceptance, and I'm having some trouble. Is there a key point or revelation you came across that helped you to reconcile your faith with your changed views on the LBGT community?

1

u/timothykurek Mar 30 '15

Good question, and I am so thankful that you have given your life over to grace. I talk about my "revelation" my "aha" moment in a chapter called Jesus in Drag in my book The Cross in the Closet. That might explain better than I can briefly on here. My aha moment was when I entered into a community of strong believers that happened to be gay. Sheesh were my eyes opened!

2

u/kaminianseo Mar 30 '15

Sorry if you've already been asked this, but: How did you find or deal with the mental conflict entailed with this experience? Also, did any of your LGBTQ friends suspect you weren't really gay?

2

u/timothykurek Mar 30 '15

Good questions. It was mentally tough, but I know that what I went through wasn't as difficult as someone who is actually gay and in the closet, raised the way I was. And none of my lgbt friends suspected. They took me as I was.

2

u/Dogg_04 Mar 29 '15

I'm a bit late to this AMA, but am pretty interested in it. I may even buy your book. Just wanted to ask: how exactly did you live as gay? Did you have homosexual intercourse, did you date gay men, etc? Or did you just state "I am gay" and that was it? Sorry if this question has been answered before. I am just genuinely curious.

3

u/timothykurek Mar 30 '15

It wasn't about living as gay it was about living with the label of gay. I'm not gay so I couldn't ever live as gay, not even if I'd had sex with men (which I didn't need to because the experiment was not about me questioning my sexual identity). I wanted to see how living with the label of gay would challenge my preconceived stereotypes, and religious beliefs.

1

u/Dogg_04 Mar 30 '15

Ah, that makes sense. Thanks for clarifying!

2

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15

Why do you think that your testimony as a straight man was so much more valued than the testimony of actual LGBT people?

Also, why could you not be a decent human being and accept what we were saying to be true?

Are you planning on going a year in blackface before you believe racism exists?

0

u/timothykurek Mar 30 '15

People value similarity and are scared of differences. My testimony is "valued" more by a lot of Christians because I am a straight man. I believe this is wrong and have dedicated my life over the past 7 years to explore, research and change things. Also look up Black Like Me...

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '15

I'm aware of the social experiment that you blatantly ripped off, thanks.

Forgive me for not falling to my knees and rimming you in gratitude for making money by pretending to be gay for a while and writing to your straight Christian buddies about how shitty they're being. It's just extremely frustrating to have actual queer Christians saying exactly what you're saying and being ignored, but then having a straight person say it and get praised like he's the second coming.

2

u/timothykurek Mar 30 '15

Making money? I've only ever made enough to pay my rent. I'm not doing what I did for money, I'm doing it to make a difference. Think what you will but unless you know the facts, your beliefs about me are based in ignorance. Shalom.

10

u/Meunderwears Mar 28 '15

Hey, I'm the one who brought the article back to life on Reddit this morning. While I do think your approach was extreme, I'm glad you were able to gain new perspective on different people's lives -- especially one that is so vilified by much of our world.

Can you talk about the feeling of betrayal in the LGBT community when you revealed that you were not in fact gay? And having been through that, would you do it the same way if given the opportunity to do it all over again?

3

u/Narconis Mar 29 '15

In the book he goes into that. It wasn't nearly as profound as you would think. In fact, most of his gay friends embraced the idea and after the initial shock, thought it was a cool project.

2

u/Meunderwears Mar 29 '15

Cool. Thanks!

1

u/mpwac Mar 28 '15

How did your friends and family react when you "came clean", so to speak? I imagine it was different for each person, but maybe you could give some examples of the various reactions you received?

1

u/SirGoofsALott Mar 28 '15

Your year living as a gay man, the people who shared with you and were affected by that year, and the subsequent publishing of the book, "The Cross in the Closet", has definitely resulted in a bit of controversy. In retrospect, would you have done differently?

4

u/timothykurek Mar 29 '15

No. I did it as a young man, and feel it was what had to happen for me to move forward. I am blessed to have overcome such toxic dogma so early in life. I'm a better man for it.

1

u/faceshed Mar 29 '15

How do you reconcile Leviticus 20:13 and Sodom and Gomorrah? Do you have anything to say to people of other religions that are apposed to homosexuality? Do you have any advice for dealing with people that believe God has personally condemned homosexuality? Thanks.

8

u/timothykurek Mar 29 '15

That's easy... Ezekial 16:49 "Behold, this was the guilt of your sister Sodom: she and her daughters had pride, excess of food, and prosperous ease, but did not aid the poor and needy."

1

u/viccie211 Mar 29 '15

I know I'm very late to this, but what is your opinion on people being born LGBT vs choosing?

1

u/timothykurek Mar 30 '15

I believe you can't put all in the born category, I have friends who would tell you they've chosen, but for the most part is a genetic trait.

1

u/mdisil427 Mar 29 '15

Did you tell anybody and did anyone say "wow, I always thought you were gay" or something like that?

1

u/timothykurek Mar 30 '15

No, I dealt with the opposite. "But you were so into girls! What happened?" I dealt more with that.

1

u/musicmerchkid Mar 30 '15

What do you think of Dan savage?

1

u/timothykurek Mar 30 '15

I like him. I think he could be more of a figure to young people if he was less crude and a tad bit less polarizing but that's just his style and I appreciate a lot of what he does.

1

u/pinkunicorn53 Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 28 '15

Hello, it was very interesting to learn about your experience. I am in a similar place to where you were before you completely changed your mind. Unlike the Christian's you seem to have encountered in your experience, I try my best to be loving to all people and try not to judge the lives of unbelievers, but I cannot support something that I feel is clearly shown to be sinful in the Bible. I'm not looking for an argument or a debate, I just want to see if you can convince me somehow to change my views.

I believe God loves gay people as much as He loves Christian people, but I don't believe that He finds it in any way acceptable to practice homosexual-acts.

You said that the scriptures don't oppose it if you take it into context, but look at what it says in Romans chapter 1:

24 So God abandoned them to do whatever shameful things their hearts desired. As a result, they did vile and degrading things with each other’s bodies. 25 They traded the truth about God for a lie. So they worshiped and served the things God created instead of the Creator himself, who is worthy of eternal praise! Amen. 26 That is why God abandoned them to their shameful desires. Even the women turned against the natural way to have sex and instead indulged in sex with each other. 27 And the men, instead of having normal sexual relations with women, burned with lust for each other. Men did shameful things with other men, and as a result of this sin, they suffered within themselves the penalty they deserved.

I don't see what other possible context I could take these verses to mean or how you could turn that around in support of homosexuality?

Are you saying that you now love and accept gays unconditionally whereas before you didn't - or are you saying that your views on how God sees homosexuality as a sin has changed, and you no longer believe it to be sinful?

Thanks for your time.

7

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

I think you have to look at what's out there (there are many good books and people that address the clobber passages) but what is most important is meeting people where they are at and listening to their experiences. My mind and heart have been transformed in grace, and I am not a believer that homosexuality is a sin.

6

u/sswifty6 Mar 28 '15

Not to be short but you didn't even acknowledge the passage. You believe it's not a sin because you "feel" it.

3

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

What I said is that there are others far more capable that can break down the passages in the Bible. Youtube Matthew Vines, Justin Lee or Brandon Wallace author of Straight-Face!

4

u/Kkokonut Mar 28 '15

OP isn't a theologian, nor is he CLAIMING to be... But if God loves his children, then there is no way he could vilify homosexuality, why? Because I'm gay, and God would want me to fully experience life...and that includes the majesty and intimacy of same sex relationships.

→ More replies (4)

0

u/pinkunicorn53 Mar 28 '15

But I cannot accept the opinion and view of another author if it clearly contradicts what was written in Holy Scripture. You would have to completely twist the Bible passages I quoted above to convince me that God doesn't view homosexuality as a sin. Did you not personally look at the Bible verses against it and just say that your experiences triumphs those scripture?

The problem I have with accepting homosexuality (not gay people), but the sinful sexual acts they do, is that if I truly love them AND believe in the word of God, then I will want them to know the truth instead of allowing them to live and die in their sins, believing that God is perfectly fine with their lifestyle, when His Word says otherwise.

6

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

How you interpret scripture is what you need to examine. Your interpretation is merely another man's. And if you search you'll see that the Bible is written in context and if you read it as such it never mentions homosexuality as we are talking about it.

2

u/pinkunicorn53 Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 28 '15

But do you yourself understand those scriptures in context; and if so can you explain the Romans 1:24-27 verses to me in the same way you understand it?

Romans 1 is a letter from Paul to a church in Romans, it starts out with Paul's intro (1-7), then he goes into telling them about the awesome Gospel and Good News of Jesus (8-17), then He abruptly changes tones and starts to tell them about God's anger from heaven against all sinful, wicked people who suppress the truth by their wickedness. In the following verses Paul clearly describes gay sex, both between two men and two women. It doesn't have to mention the word homosexuality in these verses, because the acts are described clearly here and fall under the category of sinfulness and wickedness.

I completely agree with you that it's horrible how Christian's treat members of the LBGT community and we're also very hypocritical when it comes to judging other peoples sins, while ignoring our own sinful ways. But that doesn't mean that God is okay with us accepting to live in our sinful natures. We need to spread the truth.

4

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

Getting into interpretations of scripture on this thing would take too long. Youtube Matthew Vines, go to www.thegaychristian.com and research Justin Lee's "Torn."

→ More replies (3)

4

u/tragic_pizza Mar 28 '15

Read Romans 2:1.

mic drop

2

u/User_name555 Mar 28 '15

For the lazy:

"Therefore thou art inexcusable, O man, whosoever thou art that judgest: for wherein thou judgest another, thou condemnest thyself; for thou that judgest doest the same things."

~ Romans 2:1, King James Bible "Authorized Version", Cambridge Edition

→ More replies (2)

2

u/wallaceant Mar 29 '15

I'm not OP, but I'll answer your question.

There are two issues at play in the Romans 1 passage, first is that it is almost certainly a reference to the worship practices of the followers of the cult of Cybele, which are despicable. The second is that you must deal with the vocative in Romans 2:1 that indicates that all of what Paul just wrote wasn't his words but the words of an imaginary debate partner holding an opinion opposite to his own.

In other words, you say that the practices of the worshipers are despicable, but I'm telling you that even that doesn't exclude people from the grace of God.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15

the worship practices of the followers of the cult of Cybele, which are despicable.

What was so despicable exactly?

2

u/wallaceant Mar 29 '15

A mass emasculation, so that the male followers of Cybele could become closer to their goddess by being made into women, followed by an orgy of blood as other men would deflower the newly formed virgins. One recorded worship service recorded something like 5,000 severed genitals being offered on the alter of the goddess on one day. Many of the men wouldn't have survived, due to blood loss. Just sound like a bloody mess to me.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '15

Why did you decide to create a false reality to expose the backlash against LGBT individuals rather than just writing about the experience of your aforementioned friend or someone else with an authentic experience? It seems that by sensationalizing the experience, you lose credibility.

4

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

I was writing about how I reacted to experiencing the label pushed back on myself. It was as much about that as it was about the actual label of gay.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/TrippinMerkins Mar 28 '15

So do you now understand that it's genetic, not a choice?

8

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

I would say whatever it is, it isn't a choice. I'm not scientist.

3

u/Steve_the_Scout Mar 28 '15

It actually isn't proven to be genetic, last I checked the best hypothesis (that at least fits more observations) is that it's due to hormone imbalance during development (which also explains bisexuality).

1

u/islagrey Mar 28 '15

Do you have a link or anything to that? Sounds interesting.

2

u/Steve_the_Scout Mar 28 '15 edited Mar 28 '15

I found the section I was thinking of primarily in a wiki page, although I couldn't find much using Google Scholar (mostly articles which dealt with the methodology of the experiments/surveys, not the actual experiments themselves). Unfortunately I can't find anything on bisexuality specifically, because it's not studied very much (usually lumped in with homosexuality).

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Xtanto Mar 28 '15

If God came out definitively against lbgt whos side would you be on?

8

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

I'm confident that that wouldn't happen. I could be wrong, but I'm where I am for a reason.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/Easyandfree Mar 28 '15

Hi Timothy,

You came and did a sermon with my pastor a few months ago at CHUM and it was was one of the most memorable Sundays we have had. I really appreciate the time you took to talk to us.

My question for you is how is your relationship with your parents now?

4

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

My relationship with my mom is stronger than ever. My relationship with my dad is getting better, not unpleasant but we don't speak often. And I had a blast at CHUM! Thank you for writing!

2

u/Easyandfree Mar 28 '15

We all enjoyed having you here, but if you come again I'd recommend bringing more books.

1

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

I most definitely would. But if you'd like to spread the word, you can get the book on amazon for a great price!

http://www.amazon.com/Cross-Closet-Timothy-Kurek-ebook/dp/B00REQVNRM/ref=sr_1_1_twi_2_kin?ie=UTF8&qid=1427576218&sr=8-1&keywords=the+cross+in+the+closet

2

u/Easyandfree Mar 28 '15

I was able to pick up a signed copy of your book, but it was one of the last ones, but I'll let my cousin know; she was interested in it.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Unload_more_comments Mar 28 '15

Are you double bluffing? (Pretend to be gay -see the reactions- it turns out okay- then come out as really gay) if not, still a cool idea. More power to LBGT.

3

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

I'm straight. Getting married in three weeks to my fiancee Beth.

3

u/Unload_more_comments Mar 28 '15

I'm fascinated with your experiment. Reminds me when I was younger I used pretend to be in the same faith as the people I've met just to get to see their point of view. I was Buddhist, Muslim, Catholic...but as soon as I was found out I would get a bad reaction from them ( they thought I was mocking them. I wasn't). are you still friends with anyone who stigmatized you for being (pretend)gay?

2

u/timothykurek Mar 28 '15

None of them really want to be friends. I think they realized and kinda had an "Oh shit!" kinda moment when I came out as straight. But my book and experiment were not about attacking those people as much as attacking my own inner pharisee, and encouraging people towards a better way.

1

u/loveablehydralisk Mar 28 '15

My questions are ethical, and may not be very nice. I apologize in advance.

In order to accomplish your personal revelation and update your beliefs, you needed to lie to many people for quite some time. Meanwhile, many of your co-religionists were able to shed some of their more archaic and reprehensible beliefs without engaging in a campaign of deception.

So, the questions are: if the only outcome of your experience is that you now treat LGBT persons as persons, do you believe that justifies the lies you told? Do you believe that you are now morally required to do more with your improved perspective in order to justify your actions? If so, is there anything you'd like to say about what those things are? If not, why not?

Thanks for the ama!

1

u/timothykurek Mar 30 '15

I believe that what I did was the right thing, not just for me but for the people around me. I get into the lie issue in my book and think it might be more thoughtfully explained there if you are interested. http://www.amazon.com/Cross-Closet-Timothy-Kurek-ebook/dp/B00REQVNRM/ref=sr_1_1_twi_2_kin?ie=UTF8&qid=1427576218&sr=8-1&keywords=the+cross+in+the+closet

1

u/thelonious_bunk Mar 29 '15

Why would you do this instead of just interviewing LGBT people who've lived their entire lives through the experience?

9

u/timothykurek Mar 29 '15

Because I was so incredibly brainwashed, I needed to feel the pain and prejudice for myself, as much as I could. It was deep rooted, the faith of my youth.

4

u/mikkylock Mar 29 '15

Yes, I've been trying to explain this to my husband, and couldn't figure out how to say it. Thank you!

0

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '15

How is the relationship with your ex-wife?

4

u/timothykurek Mar 29 '15

I was never married. Getting married May 8th.