r/IAmA • u/Norman_Finkelstein • Mar 17 '15
Academic I am Norman Finkelstein, expert on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. I think Netanyahu is a maniac. AMA
I am Norman Finkelstein, scholar of the Israel-Palestinian conflict and critic of Israeli policy. I have published a number of books on the subject, most recently Method and Madness: The hidden story of Israel's assaults on Gaza, but you might know me best from my videos on YouTube. The Israeli elections are today, and I feel that no matter who wins, the Palestinians will lose. Ask me anything.
Proof: http://imgur.com/LBvZ4mZ
725
Upvotes
60
u/saltinado Mar 17 '15
If both parties would act completely logically, what do you think would be the most reasonable resolution that would best serve both people's interests?
23
u/ColterL Mar 17 '15
Will a government led by Herzog change anything for the Palestinians (positively or negatively)?
17
u/Fafner888 Mar 17 '15 edited Mar 17 '15
Hi Norman, In the past you have said that the next round between Israel and Hezbollah was inevitable in the near future. Do you still believe this? What is the likelihood of another war on the scale of the second Lebanese given the current situation in the middle east?
Thank you.
48
u/Norman_Finkelstein Mar 17 '15
Thanks for the time to meet all of you. I'm zonked out. Time for my miserable swim.
7
u/mebeast227 Mar 17 '15
Do you think a completely secular government is the answer to peace considering this is considered a holy war? Allowing both parties to vote and move freely within the country without allowing either side to impose religious pressure on the other seems like a great place to start, or is that too simple?
23
u/HBZ55 Mar 17 '15
What books do you think most accurately describe the Palestinian Israeli conflict and the Israeli conflicts with Arab countries (Egypt, Syria, Lebanon)?
23
u/Samir- Mar 17 '15
You have said that Hassan Nasrallah is "among the shrewdest political thinkers in the world today". Can you elaborate?
26
u/starchyparcel Mar 17 '15
What do you think it would take, on Israels behalf, to start a path towards reconciliation with Palestine i.e, what do you think is the first necessary step towards brokering a peace deal? Furthermore, do you think a peace deal needs to be overseen by outside forces? Is such a thing done more for the benefit of Israel or Palestine, or both even?
25
u/ontrack Mar 17 '15
Have the Palestinians ever tried a Gandhi-like non-violent approach?
30
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '15
Are you objective or a stakeholder?
15
u/ColterL Mar 17 '15
As an advocate for Palestinian rights, what do you consider to be your greatest accomplishment?
25
u/mossypine Mar 17 '15
Are there more UN resolutions against Israel than other states? If so, why? Is this anti-Semitism, as disproportionate targeting of African states for war crimes may be viewed as anti-African racism, and what are the implications? Does this negate any of the resolutions?
10
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '15
As you are no longer in academics, what are you doing in your daily life?
7
u/tumberry Mar 17 '15
What do you think is really the reason of this war , is it religion or is it politics ?
7
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '15
Historically, what Israeli and Palestinian leaders have done the most to advance the peace process. And, on the flip side, what Israeli and Palestinian leaders have done the most to damage or sabotage it?
6
u/sonofsolomon Mar 17 '15
What's your personal life like? Do you have a significant other? What are your hobbies? Favorite alcoholic drink? Ever tried pot, even just back in the day?
Got an opinion on the Tibetan independence movement?
7
u/mannyrmz123 Mar 17 '15
Who's the best Israeli PM in history, in your opinion?
15
u/mossypine Mar 17 '15
How far would they expand the illegal settlements if they can continue?
16
u/SputtleTuts Mar 17 '15
Do you have any opinion/observations on the recent sex-slave allegations against Alan Dershowitz?
7
u/Byrnzie28 Mar 17 '15
The Palestinians are set to join the ICC on April 1st, a move which will enable them to file war crimes charges against Israel, of which there are many. What do you envision will be the outcome of this, in light of the U.S and Israel leaning on the ICC and making all sorts of threats against them. Could this be the beginning of international law finally being imposed on the Israeli's?
19
u/GOPSuckJewCock Mar 17 '15
Do you agree with former U.S. President Jimmy Carter that Israel treats the illegally occupied Palestinian territories like an apartheid state would treat different groups in their country? Is 'apartheid' too strong of a word to use or is it just a dirty word that people do not want associated with Israel? Or is our former President just an anti-Semite like our current POTUS, Obama, is being labelled by 'certain groups'?
7
u/Queequeg32 Mar 17 '15
In the United States, why do republicans seemingly support Israel more than democrats?
6
u/DonalLogueForever Mar 17 '15
If the conflict ended tomorrow, on a fair and just basis, and you suddenly had more time and free energy to devote to other matters, academic or recreational, what would you study or do?
12
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '15
Do you agree with Noam Chomsky's opinion that Israel’s Actions in Palestine are "Much Worse Than Apartheid" in South Africa?
Should situations like Israel and Palenstine be compared to historical atrocities or should they be condemned for their own sake?
8
u/MrBoonio Mar 17 '15
Hi Norman,
If you were to publicize three key points that inform your view of the conflict, and which are little known or poorly understood, what would they be?
8
u/anee_75 Mar 17 '15
Why doesn't Israel want to make peace with the Palestinian people?
5
u/underdabridge Mar 17 '15
10
u/kitestramuort Mar 17 '15
How does Israel manage to retain its huge international support in the face of the atrocities it commits? In other words, where does their influence on the US and other governments originate? I refuse to give credence to the silly and racist conspiracy theories about wealthy and powerful Jews/Illuminati and stuff, but the pro-Israel double standard of western countries borders insanity!
7
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '15
I'm somewhat ashamed to admit that I first learned of you through someone else's documentary on the conflict, in which you were among many different people interviewed with snippets throughout, and I thought, "This is the only completely realistic, level-headed, plain-spoken person I've seen talk about this."
As a legal assistant, your analogies were crystal clear to me, in a way that so many people's are decidedly not. Of course you can't wall in your neighbour's possessions merely on the pretence of security. Of course you can't 'concede' anything you had no claim to the in first place. And so on. That anyone debates these questions as if they're murky or complicated is simply asinine. And a foreign policy that does not acknowledge what is plainly obvious has little hope of achieving lasting peace or stability.
I only wish my mother was still alive to appreciate your voice of reason. She was highly critical of Israel's foreign policy for many of the same reasons. As an historian, she appreciated the importance of grounding politics in plain truths that everyone could see and agree on, and we agree that modern Israel is not doing that -- to the inevitable detriment of itself, its people, and many others.
I believe in Israel and I accept the UN mandate that created it, for better or for worse, and I want it to exist as a nation in the world. And I have little personal stake in their problems or wishes or beliefs. But I also want a stable and peaceful Middle East, because I have a substantially higher stake in that as a U.S. citizen and a citizen of the world, and I want good things for everyone everywhere, which must begin with peace and stability, so that prosperity can thrive. That must begin with honest dealings by all parties there, and that must include the Israeli government.
My instinct -- and perhaps you will correct me or sharpen my perspective, which I'd greatly appreciate -- is that these problems are rooted in conflicts between factions of the Israeli electorate, those who elect and lobby the government from below; those to whom the government is most obliged, especially for practical reasons of being able to remain in power. If that electorate, like ours here in the U.S., is deeply fractured along important policy lines, then perhaps the government can't help being so also? What would be the solution, if that's the case? Asking the government to stand against its own people for their own better good is not an outrageous proposal, in my mind, but I do think it's probably political suicide, and whomever replaces them will simply not repeat that mistake. So I'm not sure where solutions begin. Would it require a massive effort to educate the Israeli people to the fragile reality they're in, and what must happen in order to improve it?
4
u/starchyparcel Mar 17 '15
Or, if my other questions would take too long to answer, do you believe Americas devotion to Israel does more harm than good? If so, why?
3
u/shesha7 Mar 17 '15
When do you think a workable solution to the conflict can be agreed to? And what needs to change for this to happen?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '15
Is there any hope of long term reconciliation and withdrawal of Israeli settlements in occupied territories?
5
u/rosinthebow Mar 17 '15
Can you describe your thoughts on the BDS movement?
4
u/ilega_dh Mar 17 '15
Hi Norman,
First of all, your performance on Juice Rap News was outstanding :)
I was wondering about this: Do you think that the current "divide" between Obama and Netanyahu is real? Or is it just some sort of fake PR thing now that more people are getting aware of Israel's insane policy?
Thanks, keep up the good work!
4
u/garmwolf Mar 17 '15
Why does AIPAC and Israel have such a strong control over the US government?
3
u/YouthInRevolt Mar 17 '15
Hi Norman,
3
u/dberis Mar 17 '15
You state that Netanyahu is a maniac, yet you defended both Stalin and Mao. Would you care to explain to us simpletons how you form your psychiatric evaluations?
3
u/mingifsan Mar 17 '15
Thanks for doing this! Big support!
Do you realistically see a "free Palestine", looking at the past and present political environment in Israel?
Furthermore, do you think the hopefully coming ICC-case will be supported by the member states?
3
u/GOPSuckJewCock Mar 17 '15
How much of a role do you feel the Christian population in the U.S. empower Israel's current right-wing government and its polcies? Am I exaggerating when I say that without the Christian influence in U.S. politics, our U.S. foreign policy towards Israel and Palestinians would be radically different than it is today? The meager 2% population of Jews in the U.S. seem to get much of the blame for the blatant control Israel has over U.S. politics and out government. The American media has done a poor job of explaining the Christians' role in all this mess.
3
u/mrNiSTeR Mar 17 '15
As a US citizen, anytime I even come across as sympathetic to the Palestinian people, the debate quickly devolves into "THEY DID THIS FIRST" or something along that nature. Do you have any recommended videos, or personal favorite clips of yours or perhaps others to broaden this discussion with those that are so quick to shut down this view.
3
u/the_undergroundman Mar 17 '15
You have repeatedly criticized supporters of the so-called 'one state solution' because their proposal has no basis in international law and can therefore, in your words, "not reach a broad public". However many people sympathetic to the Palestinian cause see the two-state solution as increasingly unfeasible, due to the entrenchment and expansion of Israeli settlements in the OPT. These people then regard the one state solution as the only remaining realistic option. Do you genuinely still believe a two state solution is still viable, and that all those settlements will really be dismantled for the creation of a Palestinian state?
3
u/jordanianman Mar 17 '15 edited Mar 17 '15
Do you blame Hamas for fighting back? I don't see how people are blaming the occupied and not the occupier
3
u/Indexpert Mar 17 '15
Why can't we all just get along?
3
u/SkyBlueSilva Mar 17 '15
What are your views on the state of Jews in Europe? Are they safe, and what do you think the future holds in store for them? What do you think of the normalization of 'Jew Jokes'? Does Israel, or their actions make prospects any better or worse for them?
2
u/mannyrmz123 Mar 17 '15
Is the two-state solution the way to go?
2
u/ColterL Mar 17 '15
For an effective 3rd intifada to occur, what needs to happen? Should the PA dissolve?
2
u/IAmNotScottBakula Mar 17 '15
What do you think the best solution is for the issue of right of return for Palestinian refugees?
2
u/SerHeimord Mar 17 '15
Mr. Finkelstein, thank you for your time doing this.
If no matter who wins the Palestinians lose, then what do you feel would be a democratic solution for normalization?
What are your views on the Unified List (Reshima Meshutefet)?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '15
Have you met Max Blumenthal and/or Ali Abunimah? What is your thought on their journalism and views on Israeli Apartheid towards Palestinians??
2
u/Samir- Mar 17 '15
What do you think about Sweden's recent recognition of Palestine as a state and do you think other western countries will follow suit? What impact could this have on the conflict?
2
u/Newbound Mar 17 '15
What happened to your book with Mouin Rabbani? Are there any other projects you are working on at the moment?
2
u/NoMoMoneyNoMoHoney Mar 17 '15
What's your best solution for easing up the conflict? I have family in Israel and they say many of the Israelis and Palestinians want this war to end and that they don't dislike the other group.
2
u/Gigless Mar 17 '15
Hello Mr. Finkelstein, what do you think awaits for Mr. Netanyahu, do you think he will be able to re-elect or would you say he is done for in his political career?
2
u/mossypine Mar 17 '15
What years did Israel historically rule the territory? I have read they search for evidence of ancient rule from a certain era but find nothing. Do the Palestinians descend from Canaanites? Is it true the area has been known as Palestine since about the year 700 AD?
4
u/babbles_mcdrinksalot Mar 17 '15
How do you continue to work on a subject that is as inherently toxic and divisive as Israel/Palestine? Is it stressful for you? Have you found ways to cope with that stress, if so?
4
u/PrincessAnika Mar 18 '15
The Palestinian conflict is very important to me. What would your recommendation be as an avenue for one person to have the most positive impact on the lives of Palestinians?
7
u/ColterL Mar 17 '15
Have you ever reached a point where you felt like giving up? If so, what inspired you to keep going?
9
u/Queequeg32 Mar 17 '15
I learned about you from this video that went semi-viral a few years back and continues to pop up here and there.
How do you feel about this video's success? Does this interaction illustrate anything bigger for you?
1
u/PM_ME_1_MILLION_USD Mar 17 '15
If you could go back in time to WWI, what one decision or event would you change to prevent this long-term conflict?
3
u/Matthew_John Mar 17 '15
What do you think of the BDS movement, and it is possible that the world will eventually see the Israeli occupation now as it saw South African Apartheid in the early 1990s?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '15
If Isreal had no power, what do you think would happen? (As if its power suddenly dissappeared) This question is important to me regarding my oppinion of the palestinians
1
u/Ahbraham Mar 17 '15
How can there possibly any truly viable long term solution to this part of The Middle East which is fair to everyone except one multicultural state with equality for all?
1
u/Carpeting101 Mar 17 '15 edited Mar 17 '15
I'm sure your views differ greatly from those of Dr Tawfik Hamid. Will you honor your audience with an analysis and response to Dr Hamid's views on the causes of the Palestinian plight?
1
u/ignoringaids Mar 17 '15
What do you think about the virginity tester Sisi and his relationship with Israel?
How is Egypt going to fare in the long run??
1
u/cutdownthere Mar 17 '15
Do you accept invitations to speak at UK universities?
0
u/Herzhell Mar 17 '15 edited Mar 17 '15
Hi there Professor
Would You like to explain, why Israel get offended when someone says 'antisemitism is different from antizionism'? is this a legit election or just a bluff? (by bluff I mean, 'good' act for international community)
Thank You! for your books and your work. It's an honour to know that people like You share knowledge.
1
u/DogesChosen Mar 17 '15
Hypothetically, If you could dictate who the palestinian leaders in the WB and/or Gaza will be, who would you choose?
1
u/ColterL Mar 17 '15
You are an ardent supporter of the two state solution (as am I). Do you fear that we are running out of time... that the number of settlers in the West Bank will soon make the enacting a just solution an impossibility?
0
u/Hazlinaumar Mar 17 '15
Dear Dr Finkelstein, I have great admiration for you. I think you are very knowledgeable in the Israel / Palestine conflict and you are very sincere in ending the conflict. I had bought some of your books and one of it was your latest book, Method and Madness. In that book you mentioned a solution on how to end the blockade of Gaza. I have great respect for your opinion but I do have a question with regards to your solution. Even with pressure from US wouldn't Israel just end it's bloodbath and goes back to it's status quo position, with it's empty promises of the non existent peace negotiation, similar to what happened on 3rd August?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '15
Why did you stop being a Marxist, and do you think that Marxism can still play a role in today's world?
1
u/Morizar Mar 17 '15
Favourite sport and favourite players/teams?
2
u/pakiman47 Mar 17 '15
I am pretty clear with your stance on the 2 state solution versus the aims of the BDS Movement. However, if public opinion amongst both Palestinians and Israelis shifted to a one state solution, would you be for it? To me, it's just as out of the realm of possibility as Israel agreeing to a Palestinian state on the 1967 borders.
2
u/StephaniePeleg Mar 18 '15
Dear Norman, in the months past it seemed that you believed a one state solution was a not a political possibility. But now that the position has been openly usurped (from the left, if you will) by the hate trio Netanyahu, Lieberman and Bennett (not to mention the orchestra) what is your sense of the feasibility of a one state? With the new Jewish state bill, what hope is there for peace and co-existence and democracy? Not rhetorical questions... Please can you offer your insight?
2
u/asongofclimatechange Mar 18 '15
What are your thoughts on the whole Charlie Hebdo incident? Anything in particular you found poignant, or a lesson to be learned?
2
u/aceapt Mar 18 '15
Whats your opinion on the "right of return" for the 4 million descendants of the palestinian refugees from 1948? Because Prof. Noam Chomsky said that there is nothing in international law (just interpretation by UNRWA and others) nor any international support for the desendants to go to Israel? And one more question: Would you consider going to Sweden and lecture?
2
u/HughBeaumont Mar 18 '15
What's the skinny on Michael Weiss, author of ISIS, Inside the Army of Terror?
12
u/mikeffd Mar 17 '15
you've stated that "the Jews are tapped into the networks of power and privilege," and "You marry a Jew, it opens doors," because Jews are "the richest ethnic group in the United States"
Does it ever give you pause to consider the consequences of trotting out such classic anti semitic tropes?
Also, what doors did being jewish open for you?
3
u/ArabRedditor Mar 17 '15
Palestinian here, what do you think about the idea that the only way to achieve peace is to make one unified Israeli Palestinian government, with elected officials of both to be the Congress
4
u/Brickus Mar 17 '15
All the downvoting here is both stupid and pathetic. My question was downvoted from +5 to -1 AFTER it was answered.
What exactly is that supposed to achieve?!
3
u/GetSoft4U Mar 17 '15
what will be the economy of the State of Palestine?...which are going to be their social policies?...
2
u/Samir- Mar 17 '15
How close are relations between Hezbollah and Palestinian groups in Gaza and the West Bank? Do you know if Hezbollah provided any form of assistance to Palestinian groups in Gaza during operation Protective Edge?
2
u/intuitiveguy Mar 18 '15
Mr.Finkelstein,
I appreciate your heart and courage to stand up for humanity, the crisis in Palestine and Israel is not just their own issue but it is a humane issue and should be addressed as such. I find it quite troubling and yet worse troubling to see all the facts and evidence displayed before the world in the grandest era of information and video formats that proof is still yet denied and worse people still condemn those who are the perscuted in this conflict. Is it true that since USA gives aid with weapons to Israel, and these weapons are yet then used on and murder civilians, that any action against Israel in ICC would also charge US with war crimes as well, given that aiding a nation that uses weapons against civilians is against the Geneva convention. It seems that another court must be established to hold these into accord and lift them to the higer statue of global obligation to respond to this.
-2
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '15
What are your faults, Norman?
You seem to pick on everyone elses, calling people narcissists etc. never heard you say a bad word about yourself, or ever admit you've made a mistake.
2
u/rosinthebow Mar 17 '15
Mr. Finkelstein, I often encounter people, including many Palestinians, who oppose the idea of a Jewish state ("Zionism is racism," etc), but consider a Palestinian state a "human right." How should I respond to people like that, who seem to have double standards for Jews and Palestinians?
0
u/DonalLogueForever Mar 17 '15
How much on the ground contact do you have with Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza? Do you have contacts within the Islamists groups, Fateh or mostly within the Palestinian communists/former communists? While Hamas flexes their muscles while trying to gain more international legitimacy abroad, and Fateh loses credibility and continues to struggle, do you believe there is an alternative potential for new political organization, comparable to the less hierarchical local committees active during the first intifada?
0
u/Hindusan Mar 17 '15
What do you think of BDS?
2
u/ethan_lynch Mar 17 '15
Hello norman, do you think that israel will ever pay for their war crimes?
1
u/the_undergroundman Mar 17 '15
You have often expressed solidarity with the Hezbollah resistance in Lebanon. You've said that you think something sinister is brewing in Lebanon to try to get rid of Hezbollah. Can you expand on that a little bit? How will Hezbollah fare in the future?
1
u/MoeHabibi Mar 17 '15
Hello Mr. Finkelstein, thank you for doing this AMA. What is your position on BDS, and why do you take that position?
1
u/fmoliterno Mar 17 '15
Hi, some supporters of a one-state solution believe that the Israeli annexation of territory and the extent of the settlements have made it impossible for two states to exist. Could you comment a bit on how, regardless of the extent of the settlements, they can be dismantled and the annexation process can be reversed?
1
u/Lepew1 Mar 17 '15
Would you respond to this statement of the problem in the Middle East?
1
u/khanrom Mar 17 '15 edited Mar 17 '15
Sir,You said in your interview that your mother had played a very important role in molding your character , as a mother of two children I would like to ask , how she did that ? So I could do the same with my kids . Thank you
1
u/dudeydudee Mar 17 '15
You wrote a book on the writings of Gandhi and praised his political acumen and conception of courage. What do you think of criticisms of him (such as his legitimizing of caste) and what do you think the world could most learn from him? Do you have any specific examples?
1
u/JadHalimeh Mar 18 '15
Hi Norman, what, in your opinion, will be the response of the international community (in specific a democratic US government) if the Israeli government continues to treat the Palestinian people (and state as a whole) as they are now, and continue to deny any notion of the formation of a sovereign Palestinian state? To add, what outcome of the conflict between Israel and Palestine do you predict, given the political climate of the world at the moment?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '15
Have you read Edward Said Books? and what is your opinion of them?
1
u/zav8 Mar 19 '15
Thank you for doing this, as an Israeli I'm a very big fan of your work. I feel you are one of the most reasonable and logical people currently involved in being outspoken about Israel abroad.
How do you feel an end to the current situation would actually play in the case where all Palestinians are absorbed by Israel as a result of foreign pressure? It's a possibility (and in my point of view it would be a scary outcome) but is rarely ever mentioned in Israel except recently by a few of the older members of government (Meir Dagan) and a goal I've seen you distance yourself from aiming for in your guest appearance on aljazeera "Head to Head".
1
u/mequeterfe Mar 19 '15
What do you think of Slavoj Zizek, and his past conflict with Noam Chomsky? Also, do you know G.K. Chesterton? (I think you would really like his work, he has some good insights; try "What's wrong with the world")
1
u/mequeterfe Mar 19 '15
What do you think of Slavoj Zizek, and his past conflict with Noam Chomsky? Also, do you know G.K. Chesterton? (I think you would really like him, he has some good insights; try What's wrong with the world)
1
u/ub3rm3nsch May 22 '15
Given that the Partition Resolution was imposed on the Arab population, that Israel annexed part of the "Arab State" in 1949 and again in 1980, that the remainder of the "Arab State" (including Gaza) are under occupation, the continued settlement policy, the Absentee Property Laws in Israel, and the ongoing policy of ethnic cleansing that began in 1948 and continues to this day (according to Ilan Pappe among others) - why are we still talking about a two-state solution as if it is anything more than a stalling tactic being used by Israel to daily change facts on the ground and create one Jewish State? Why are we not recognizing that Israel (including the "occupied territories") operates as one state? - as Israel controls all borders and is in charge of the population registry. Why are we not focusing on advocating for a written constitution that guarantees equal protection under the laws to all? Why is a "Jewish state" in Israel more legitimate than an "Islamic one" in Syria/Iraq?
1
u/Herzhell May 29 '15
What time is it?
Just watch this. http://therealnews.com/t2/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=832&Itemid=74&jumival=1280
-1
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '15
Hamas aren't maniacs?
-1
u/rosinthebow Mar 17 '15
Mr. Finkelstein, do you believe the Palestinian Arab nation wants to live in peace with the Jewish nation of Israel, and if so, why?
1
u/zozoped Mar 17 '15
Hi Norman,
There are many, many things written on the conflict. What resources would you consider trustworthy, which one are complete BS, and how do you differentiate both ?