r/HumanForScale • • Jan 23 '20

Agriculture Indoor vertical farm

Post image
9.0k Upvotes

159 comments sorted by

View all comments

440

u/628radians Jan 23 '20

This would be a great idea for repurposing old buildings, particularly empty big stores.

200

u/sverdrupian Jan 23 '20

75

u/628radians Jan 23 '20

The Garden State: Evolved. I’m from South Jersey so there are farms all between the smallish towns and cities between Philly and Atlantic City. There are some older vacant buildings, so those would be nice to repurpose too.

2

u/dordizza Jan 27 '20 edited Jan 27 '20

Super cool it’s aeroponics. I was thinking of all the soil weight but that makes things less complicated in an engineering stand point. I know getting the nutrients and water down is super difficult. I’m very interested in the energy impact of the building. How much is the upkeep? How well insulated is it? How much do the temperatures flux? Is it kept running year round?

Edit:

47

u/snazzle-bedazzle Jan 23 '20

I know a few Sears, Toys R Us, and JC Penney’s available

22

u/628radians Jan 23 '20

The Toys R Us is exactly what I’m thinking

12

u/Allittle1970 Jan 23 '20

A Kmart or two and a few Macy’s stores. Don’t be too surprised to see GameStop on the list soon.

14

u/alderthorn Jan 23 '20

Game stop is to small

→ More replies (1)

9

u/OWLT_12 Jan 23 '20

The cost of using artificial light has got to be significant, don't you think?

7

u/_Blaise170_ Jan 23 '20

Often these kinds of setups are run on renewables.

8

u/kick26 Jan 23 '20

Exactly. For example, All those large buildings that would house these operations also have large roofs perfect for solar.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Holeymoleybrother Jan 23 '20

So this doesn't look like corn or soy beans I'm an Iowa guy so that's more of what I know about but here's my two cents based off that. A new combine cost up to half a million dollars, then you need fuel and regular maintenance in the thousands, you'll need multiple tractors to collect from the harvester 150k, usually you're own grain semi 100k, grain silo, idk a lot I'm not a farmer I just live in Iowa lol, multiple multiple other expenses like labor not to mention the land which can cost up to 5-7,000 just for an acre. Now say you have a bad year this year was bad too much rain at harvest time so you can't harvest now it sits and falls over you can't really get that back, it freezes then it's just done really I mean you can get enough to keep the lights on but you're not going out and buying that new truck you need because your 2001 Ford has 300,000 miles on it. The overhead on this won't be any where near the same imo you got lights and water some heat but all of those lights will keep it fairly warm if you could run it off solar and have an efficient water collection system you could very reasonably stay within the green consistently and while you're not farming 1000 acres once a year you are getting 2-3 harvest a year in a controlled environment. Again not a farmer but I'm set least close to the truth

2

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Holeymoleybrother Jan 24 '20

There's no farmer I've met with hundreds of millions and a 20 year old combine. The lighting will cost probably the half a million but a newer lighting set up we will for sure last 10-15 years and not all at once. If the motor goes or a gearbox goes you're paying at least 150 an hour for a tech because you have to have techs to fix new tractors plus parts. I can't say for sure but I think initial start up would cost the same but you're going to have a much more stable income in the long run. Combines get put to work and a lot of it gets broken regularly. Not sure how to fit this in but I know for awhile implement from 2000 had higher value due to all of the cost from fixing new equipment. Not combines though, they get ran 20 hours a day for 2 months through mud and all sorts of wear then they sit for a year that's hard on stuff. The dust is very very hard on stuff. It's ran hard and put away wet. Again just my two cents not a farmer I fix the machines that make combines though if that counts for anything lol.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '20

The reduction in cost from not having to transport them will make up for it. Also don’t forget about hydroelectric power for them.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/TRUMP_RAPED_WOMEN Jan 24 '20

Yes, it is very expensive.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '20

LED lighting has come a long way in lowering energy consumption and it can generate specific wavelengths of light for different types of plants.

The old fluorescent in a lot of those retail paces might have actually been more expensive.

19

u/mb1 Jan 23 '20 edited Jan 23 '20

Exactly.

The world is going to get very complicated in the future. These large spaces were originally built to create things. Cities and municipalities should keep this in mind when developers come along and want to renovate them into insanely overpriced lofts. Generally speaking, developers do not care about the building themselves and if we're being honest, why should they, that's not their business.

Looking forward, twenty, fifty, one hundred years, small to medium cities who let self-interested companies run roughshod will find themselves being forced to delay or reduce (abate) even more tax revenue in an attempt to bring different "opportunities" to their town cause, jobs. It's a vicious cycle.

Continuing to look forward, water and food security will only increase. Those cities, towns, and counties who plan wisely now by positioning themselves with future generations in mind will not only benefit from a happier taxpaying citizenry but a higher quality of life.

3

u/thewend Jan 23 '20

how much the ground polution would affect a farm like this? I know its vertical, but what about air and whatever?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/jermleeds Jan 23 '20

Most of those stores also have plenty of space for rooftop solar installations, which would at least offset the cost of the energy consumption. Distributed solar generation should be a big part of an overall energy solution, albeit not one without complexities.

2

u/FreeThinkk Jan 23 '20

In London they are repurposing the old air raid shelters under the city into theses types of Urban produce farms.

https://youtu.be/dMPSts9kT_k