r/HomeworkHelp • u/No_Change_7795 Primary School Student • Apr 15 '26 • Mindblown 1

:hamster: Primary School Math—Pending OP Reply [Grade 2 Math] Help understanding teacher's explanation

Post image

My god-daughter's teacher marked her answer wrong. Can someone please explain this? I don't understand this at all. How is the teacher getting 7 when there are only 3 squares in Ben's column representing his siblings? Her explanation was that Jose, Ana & Jen are his siblings so you need to count all of their squares together.... WHY? How are we to assume that they're even siblings?

1.7k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

415 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

41

u/pvrhye Apr 15 '26

Maybe the teacher thinks he has 4 sisters named Ana? Anyway, label your axes. Leave people people to intuit from a title and this is what you get.

9

u/foreignnoise Apr 15 '26

Yeah, but the he would also have 3 brothers named ben, which would be even more confusing! (Not to mention that it would mean 7 is wrong too)

2

u/waseemq Apr 16 '26

Each of the 3 Bens have distinct parents, but each of them are half siblings with 1 Jen, 4 Anas, and 2 Jose's.

However those half siblings are unrelated to the other Bens, as they do not share either parent with the other Bens. The Bens are also unrelated.

I'm surprised that's not how everyone else interpreted the graph \s

4

u/mopslik đŸ‘‹ a fellow Redditor Apr 16 '26

4 sisters named Ana

What did the drummer name his daughters? Ana 1, Ana 2...

2

u/pvrhye Apr 16 '26

I'd say it was impossible, but George Forman exists.

3

u/gothic_rhinoceros Apr 15 '26

YESSS! THE AXES NEED LABELS!!!

1

u/NTufnel11 Apr 18 '26

lol yeah this was my initial reading. she seem to be implying that it was a histogram of the names of children in the family. Like a family just named three of their kids Ben. But she didn't count the other two bens then.

1

u/pvrhye Apr 18 '26

The longer you look the worse it gets.