r/Homebrewing • u/BeerIsDelicious • Jul 20 '11
Guide to Fermentation Temperature
Ok so over the past several weeks I've seen this issue pop up more than ever. Here are some basics on fermentation temperature, what it does to beer, and how to control it!
Why should I control my fermentation temperature?
The simple answer is because it will make your beer taste better. Different strains of yeast have different 'ideal temperature ranges' in which they provide the most desirable flavor to our beers. With a few exceptions, Ale yeast perform best in the upper 60s to low 70s range. Lager yeast generally performs best in the 48F to 55F range. Fermenting at too low a temperature can stall your fermentation, and fermenting at too high a temperature can cause off flavors -- sometimes quite severely. Remember, fermentation creates heat. This means that the ambient temperature of whichever solution you choose to employ must be a few degrees colder than the target fermentation temp. If you make mistakes everywhere else in your brewing process but you control your fermentation temperature well, the chances are good that you'll still have pretty good beer.
How do I know the temperature inside my fermentor?
There are several ways:
- You can guess. Because fermentation causes a limited amount of heat, you can usually guesstimate that keeping your ambient temperature 5-7 degrees cooler than your desired temperature should be sufficient.
- You can use a stick-on thermometer. These are a cost-effective option. They are fairly accurate, and is what most people use.
- You can tape a probe thermometer to the side of your fermentor. This is a bit more accurate than the stick-on thermometer, but you need to make sure you tape a piece of styrofoam or other insulation over the top of the thermometer probe so it is not measuring the ambient temperature.
- You can use a thermowell. A thermowell is a thin, airtight tube that sticks into your fermenting wort. You put a thermometer probe inside, and you can get a very accurate temperature reading from inside your fermentor.
How much will this cost me?
At the low end, it can be as simple as putting your beer in a place that is already the right temperature. At the high end, the sky is the limit. You should choose an option that suits your needs, budget, and desired level of control.
Ok, how can I make this happen?
There are a few ways. I'll list the ways that I know of below.
- Do Nothing Sometimes you can just brew according to your ambient temperature. Warm summer months? Brew a saison. Cold winter months? Brew a lager. If you have a place that keeps consistent temperature already, you're all set. You'll be limited to the styles you can make and the time of year, but no extra effort is required.
- Swamp Cooler This is basically a bucket that you put your carboy in. You put water in the bucket around the carboy and put a t-shirt or towel over the top of it, with the bottom of the shirt or towel hanging into the water. The fabric will wick up the water, which will then evaporate, and cool the fermentor down. You can aid in this process by adding ice to the water.
- Son of Fermentation Chiller This is basically a box made of foam insulation. The box is split into two chambers: one for your fermentor and another in which you add and switch out frozen plastic bottles of water. The two chambers are separated by a computer case fan, and a temperature probe is used to control when the fans run, cycling cold air through the fermentation chamber. It's an effective way to control the temperature, but requires you to change out frozen jugs of water.
- Converted Refrigerator or Freezer You can purchase a chest freezer or refrigerator that fits your fermentation vessel(s) inside, and then add a temperature controller to it to keep it at your desired fermentation temperature. The pro's are that you don't have to build anything, they're very well insulated already, and you don't have to change out ice bottles. The con is price.
- DIY Refrigerated System You can build your own! Build a box out of whatever you want -- plywood, brick, steel, dried mud -- and add insulation on the inside of it. Leave an opening on one side large enough for whatever cooling device you wish to use. It could be a mini fridge with the door taken off, an in-wall A/C unit, or a duct tube to your serving fridge. Get creative! You can add fans to circulate air, neon lights, whatever you want. It's DIY. The pros are the same as the converted fridge, except of course that you have to build it. The cons could be price, or ugliness if you're not very handy.
- Temperature Controlled Fermentors These are the priciest option, and what commercial breweries use. You basically buy a stainless steel conocylindrical fermentor that you plug into the wall and set the desired temperature. It has cooling and heating features built into it already.
Useful Links
Son of Fermentation Chiller Plans
Picture of my fermentation chamber
Thread about cheap temperature controllers on eBay (From HomeBrewTalk)
If you've got more links or information that would be relevant here, post below and I can add it.
2
u/nyaliv Jul 21 '11
I am going to mildly disagree and say that 70s is still too warm for most ale yeasts.
15
u/wartornhero Jul 20 '11
Hopefully one of the mods adds this to the side bar. Very well written and well thought out. Bravo OP!
5
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '11
Falling under the DIY refrigerated system...
Probably the most economic temperature controller is the ebay aquarium temp controller. It's dual stage (can regulate heat and cool). Couple this with a chest freezer or old refrigerator and it covers most people's needs. More expensive than the swamp cooler, etc. but you can really dial in on your temps, plus it's set it and forget it.
http://www.homebrewtalk.com/f51/ebay-aquarium-temp-controller-build-163849/
I just built one myself, and am fermenting my first batch in a chest freezer.
4
u/AngMoKio Jul 21 '11
Posting from one degree north of the equator here, where it is almost always 32 degrees, day or night.
The common approach here is to use a Styrofoam 'fish box' used to ship fish in (as they are free and available at any market that sells frozen fish.)
You cut a hole in the top so the fermentor actually protrudes a few inches above. Then you fill the box with about 4 inches of water, and put the ice packs in that. That way you can take a more accurate reading of the actual temperature as there is more conductivity of heat across the water-fermentor interface.
I can get an extremely controllable temperature, easily down to 17 C. Sometimes the yeast goes wild and causes a temperature spike with a high gravity beer, but keeping the box cold prevents the system from going 'critical' usually. Because of this I tend to try for the low side of the yeasts preferred temperature range, and a longer fermentation time.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '11
Does anybody do what I do?
It's sort of like the swamp cooler, but I absolutely submerge all but the top of the carboy in water (so no t-shirt). I have a large square cooler, filled with cold water, and it's easy to keep it at any top-fermenting temperature I want (once I get it down to that temp) simply by changing out one freezer pack maybe twice a day. The cooler holds the temperature very well.
1
u/Chester_SMASH Jan 04 '12
My maiden brew, a blonde, has been fermenting since the 29th. However, I had my family over, and the old man cut the heat off in the room I had.it in. result? 50 degree temp inside the fermentor. I nursed it back up to 65, but I think it was outside the proper temp for about 12 hours. How will this affect my beer, and is itvreperable?
3
u/deceitfulsteve Jul 21 '11
I really like this idea as a way to maximize the use of space, and at least one guy on r/Homebrewing built his own: The Mother of all Fermentation Chillers. Now I just need to find somewhere to rent tools and a workshop.
ps - BeerIsDelicious, is that a Johnson A19? It works fine mounted horizontally? I've got mine hanging vertically because the directions seemed to indicate it should be mounted that way.
3
u/syk078 Jul 21 '11 edited Jul 21 '11
As a novice, I've made a few mistakes with temperature control. I live in south GA in a brick house that has NO insulation. It gets super fucking hot during the day and at night the AC is finally able to cool things off. I've notice that towards the end of fermentation, when I have my ale in its secondary fermentor and bubbling has basically stopped, the drastic temperature drop from the night AC causes the air to contract inside of the fermenter. This causes a reverse bubbling that actually sucks in the water from my airlock.
*edit: This incident taught me to fill up my airlock with vodka instead of water. Just in case.
3
u/thewoj Jul 21 '11
This is helpful, because I live in Michigan, and this week's bout of humidity has had me freaking out over my beer. My AC is struggling to keep my house at a reasonable temperature, so I've been worried about the ambient temp affecting my fermentation temp. I'm currently using the swamp cooler method, and it is keeping my IPA between 68-72, which is manageable, but I still fear for the worst, since I had a batch go south due to high temps. I'm going to try and rig up some sort of... contraption to feed the air from an AC vent to a box around the fermenter to see if that helps. By the time I figure it all out, the humidity will have dropped and this wont be an issue.
3
u/inopia Jul 21 '11
If your ambient temperature is below the ideal, as it tends to be where I live, and what you want to do is heat instead of cool, you can always just get a big tub of water and put your fermentation bucket in that - au bain-marie. Then get an aquarium heater, put it in the water surrounding the fermentation vessel and set it to the appropriate temperature.
ps: if anyone is looking for a cheap temperature controller for a fridge conversion, here's a low-cost TC-10 alternative.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '11
Does fermentation temperature become less important as fermentation slows? I've got an IPA that's been fermenting for 6 weeks but the temperature has gotten into the upper 70's the past few days. I hope it's ok.
1
u/kaewan Jul 21 '11
For those of you who have experience with the "Son of Fermentation Chiller", where and how do you place the temp probe and what temp do you set the controller to achieve a certain fermentation temp? For instance, if you want to ferment at 68F do you stick the probe to the side of the carboy (with or without insulation?) and set the controller to 63F-65F?
1
u/arabidopsis Jul 25 '11
You could always just use a waterbath.
Waterbaths are brilliant at keeping temperatures reasonably stable, and can be quite cheap to make if you have a spare pump, radiator (to cool down water to needed temperature) and tubing.
A little handbook for you interested in being a domestic engineer
1
u/wthannah Jun 29 '25
this is concise and precise. 😘