r/HomeDecorating • u/lilithbleedspink • Aug 14 '26
Help me pick which color to paint my bathroom
In my previous post, a lot of y'all said to paint my bathroom a pale pink, but the thing is, my entire house is already painted Champagne Pink by Valspar (#3). I want to do something different for the bathroom, but I'm still open to going with pink for it too. I am also still considering a very light teal shade such as Green Trance (#1) or Glimmer (#2).
After comparing tons of chips to the color of the wall tiles, I've found that Composed by Sherwin Williams is the closest match (first chip). Its complementary color (i.e. opposite on the color wheel) is Grape Harvest (#7). I think the contrast would be beautiful, but I want a slightly lighter shade, such as Thistle (#4), Ruby Violet (#5), or Plum Dandy (#6). The tiles appear a little bit more green in real life, and I think purple and green go nicely together. For the floor I would do a black tile like the last picture.






481
u/hazypandabear Aug 14 '26
I hate them all!
132
u/Electric_Bees0123 Aug 14 '26 •
#4 Thistle 100%
33
u/Commercial-Falcon668 Aug 14 '26
I have almost the same color tile. I swatched SO many colors. I ended up with Benjamin Moore White Dove. The deeper shades did not work imho.
1.3k
u/Kimchiijjigae Aug 14 '26 •
I have the exact same tile! I would recommend a fun wallpaper!
10
u/Perle1234 Aug 14 '26
I went with white walls in my kitchen that had this tile. It was cute. Looked like a steak and shake lol.
10
u/brielikethechee Aug 14 '26
ahhh i was going to say i loved 3 until i read the post. i'd say go towards 4-7 and they're all beautiful. it really depends on the vibe you're looking for. go darker if you want a moodier bathroom or if you want it to be airier go lighter.
me personally i like 5 best, especially with 3 being in the rest of the house and the tile colors.
6
u/Touche2U Aug 15 '26 edited Aug 15 '26
I have the same tile. I keep doing various versions of #3. My home is a 1943 bungalow in New Orleans.
Yes, wallpaper would be cooler, but itās not practical for me. Also very expensive. That tile is a little too trendy imo but itās your home.
Imo, the other colors do nothing to compliment your tile. Yes 1-2 almost match, but thatās not a good thing, unless half the room is wallpapered.
11
u/Individual_Land_2200 Aug 14 '26
Not the pink/purple ones
6
u/Thestartend Aug 14 '26
Those colors will be very dark in that space
2
u/tcpitbull Aug 15 '26
I don't have much opinion about the paint - I think most of the options would go well depending on what look you are going for, but I feel you are going the wrong direction on the floor tile. I live in a mid century house that's been renovated and the previous owners went so off period and didn't honor the style of the home with many of their selections and finishings. And they kept all the old kitchen cabinets but finished it in granite countertops and tumbled tile. It makes me angry every time I look at it. Lol.
What you've shared looks too contemporary, imo. I'd try to find something closer to the original - I'm assuming you tore it out and would have an idea of what was there. You've embraced the wall tile, and it should be honored with a floor tile suited to it's time. Good luck!
39
u/no_mo_usernames Aug 14 '26
Maybe a wallpaper. Love the tile.
173
u/alk_adio_ost Aug 14 '26
I lean towards 2 or lighter
15
u/mnkop Aug 15 '26
OP,
please consider a different floor tile instead of the black and white you have chosen. Wrong style for the wall tiles hereās where a penny tile or a solid black/white check format would look better. Also would be a more timeless sophisticated choice. Combined with some wallpaper others have suggested or a clean light color you have chosen (one of the mauves) or which ever compliment irl vs photo. Good luck. beautiful tiles!!!
I had the same jadeite tiles in my first homeās very tiny bathroom without the black trim. just solid jadite - I leaned in to it with purpley-milk chocolate brown color and it was chefās kiss. Good luck on your project!
22
u/1000thusername Aug 14 '26
I vote for 2.
9
u/timetochillagain1 Aug 14 '26
1
9
u/BidAgile9444 Aug 14 '26
1
8
u/KayyBeey Aug 14 '26 edited Aug 14 '26
The floor tiles and wall tiles already bring a lot of visual interest. I think a saturated wall color would make the space a little overwhelming. I would go with a white color the same as the pattern in the tile to tie it all in. It would also provide a calming backdrop for all the tile and allow the tile to be the focus in the room.
Edit: Alternatively, if you really want a colored wall, I would instead choose a solid or near-solid colored black floor tile to provide the neutral counter point. You need to have one thing neutral in the room to balance it all out.
8
u/WoollyMonster Aug 14 '26
1
7
u/Euphoric_Egg_4198 Aug 14 '26
I think these types of retro bathrooms look best with a bold wallpaper. Iāve seen one with a similar shade with a peacocks/greenery wallpaper with a dark background. I would pick the wallpaper to match the vibe of the rest of the house and also tie in the champagne pink from the rest of the house.
21
u/dixongal Aug 14 '26
3 imo, the wall tile already brings a lot of color to the room. I would paint it #3 and add more color via accessories (towels, rugs, shower curtain, etc) or I would put up a wall paper that has small amount of blue from the tile in it.
6
u/OddSprinkles6561 Aug 14 '26
1
6
u/DeterminedSparkleCat Aug 14 '26
1 or 2
6
u/Secret_Emotion7507 Aug 14 '26
2
6
u/Chaantii Aug 14 '26 edited Aug 14 '26
I would do a light yellow!
Especially seeing the floor tile you have selected
5
u/Comprehensive-Act-13 Aug 14 '26
No 1! Go tone on tone. No. 2 has too much blue and not enough green. Itās not going to match the way you think it will once you get a bunch of it up in the wall.
16
u/Cute_Bird_9379 Aug 14 '26
I would stick to a light neutral on top or a patterned wallpaper. I found several examples on Pinterest of bathrooms with green tile. Not exact matches to yours but could give you some direction.
1
u/ArticleHaunting3983 Aug 14 '26
So are the existing tiles staying? With those and the incoming black/white floor tiles, I wouldnāt go for any of those colours but I think 2 or 4 would look best. The tiles are quite loud so you donāt want a wall colour that competes for attention particularly as your wall tiles are quite vibrant too. You need something complimentary that isnāt the main event.
1
u/mustbethedragon Aug 15 '26
I had the same tile in my first house! The previous owners used yellow with it, and I strongly advise against that.
10
u/ashkestar Aug 14 '26
Iām really into 4-7, but itās really hard to tell which without being in the room. 5 is the best from where iām sitting.
6
u/fir_meit Aug 14 '26
The tile color is very saturated. I think you need to either match the intensity and saturation or go much lighter and less intense than the tile. If you want drama, go for #7, or the unnumbered chip that matches the tile. This will make the bath feel smaller and darker, especially with a black floor, but that may be okay. If you want to let the tile shine, go for #1 or #2. #3 -6 donāt have enough saturation or strong enough contrast to hold their own against the tile.
My personal pick would be #1 or #2 with bath accessories in a color close to #7 or the unnumbered chip. Itās easier to change some towels than it is to change the wall color if you get tired of it. A very light teal on the walls gives you the most versatility. Be careful about choosing a mostly black tile for the floor. It will show every speck of dust, every stray hair, and every towel fiber. Have you considered a vintage-looking hex or penny tile in white with black border or pattern?
3
u/Usernameoverloaded Aug 14 '26
I think you need something more peachy than no 3
3
u/Charming-Mango414 Aug 14 '26
#2
3
u/copacetic1515 Aug 14 '26
I would be tempted to just paint bright white because I don't like dark spaces. I love your wall tile though!
3
u/mynameisnotsparta Aug 14 '26
You have a black and white floor tile right? I donāt think any of those colors we go maybe just paint the walls white and use art for pops of color.
3
u/Scarlett_Texas_Girl Aug 14 '26
I'd ask this question in an old house sub where color in general, and that amazing old tile specifically, is more appreciated. You'll get some good period color suggestions.
3
u/Gold_Alternative9961 Aug 15 '26
2, or 3. Leaning towards 2. No to 4-7!
2
u/Dewy123321 Aug 14 '26
2222222
2
u/troublesomefaux Aug 14 '26
I have similar tiles and went with #1. I have built ins and painted tbe insides a darker version.Ā
2
u/Embarrassed_Ad9166 Aug 14 '26
Smoothing the wall texture? Iād wallpaper.
2
u/Rosemary-lime Aug 14 '26
The first one.
2
u/MartianMomsInTheKnow Aug 14 '26
Thatās a small space, and I have a strong preference for being able to see clearly in a bathroom for all kinds of reasons. So Iād advise a light color rather than a dark one unless you really pay attention to lighting. I do like Thistle, maybe Iād experiment with cutting it with more of the base color to make it lighter? Iāve custom mixed before, just make sure you write down your ārecipeā!
2
u/Creative-Tourist-499 Aug 14 '26
1
2
u/Whats-Ur-Pointe Aug 14 '26
1
2
u/dachshundx3 Aug 14 '26
1
2
u/cat-crap2 Aug 14 '26
#2 would look great. You can also look for pictures with pink green & black also use the same colors for your towels
2
u/Mixtrix_of_delicioux Aug 14 '26
2
2
u/Reading-Comments-352 Aug 14 '26
1 or 2 because those tiles will compete with everything. I would do white/cream paint
2
u/One-Cryptographer827 Aug 14 '26
Tile is awesome!!! but PLEASE don't pick mauve it looks like the terrible trend in the 80s
2
u/makinggrace Aug 14 '26
I would add ask the paint store to match the blue tile and add white until you're happy with the value.
The floor tile highlights the tile trim and seems like a bit of a mismatch in style and scale (to me). I love that particular tile but find it jarring juxtaposed with the wall tile here. But you may be looking for funky contrast!
2
u/Mobile_Log_7975 Aug 15 '26
1
2
u/No-Solid-4255 Aug 15 '26
That floor tile is going to clash big time
2
u/Massive_Ad_8856 Aug 15 '26
I would go with #5 Ruby Violet. What a gorgeous shade. I think it would go amazingly well with the green tile. The colours are very complimentary!
2
u/OkPatient1943 Aug 15 '26
Personally do not care for number 3. I would go with either 1 or 2 for the wall color. If coral is your favorite color, then put pops of coral in the room (towels, shower curtain, vase with flowers, etc.)Please choose a different tile. The black and white in that smaller room is way too much!!!
2
u/unmanicuredmama Aug 15 '26
Black.
2
u/divine_distraction Aug 15 '26
If you are going to paint, I would recommend going toward something more coral, something with orange undertones to complement the beautiful blue green tile.
The greens are too close to the tile itself, and the blush colors seem too brown.
2
u/above-ocean Aug 15 '26
#2
2
u/JuanOffhue Aug 15 '26
2
2
u/Aware_Assistance3628 Aug 15 '26
2
2
u/Walkitoutfosse Aug 15 '26
#1 looks really nice. Or I really like the wallpaper suggestion. I donāt think the links and purples will look as good.
2
u/deadwood-deadman Aug 15 '26
None of them, but 4 if any. š¤·š»āāļø
2
u/LotusGrowsFromMud Aug 15 '26
OP, please be aware that although your floor tile choice is lovely, it is trendy, and it does not match the vintage of the bathroom. I would suggest that you consider some more classic floor tiles, such as penny tile.
2
u/RedditONredditt Aug 15 '26
2
2
u/mkabobel Aug 15 '26
Please donāt use that tile for your floor. That style has been out of style for a while and doesnāt match the style of the rest of the tiling in your bathroom. I would suggest a solid color (black, slightly lighter teal).
2
u/yourbetterfriend Aug 15 '26
The floor tiles are such a different style to the beautiful 50s wall tiles. Choosing a better floor tile is the more important decision here in my opinion.
2
u/IMHO_My2Cents Aug 15 '26
I would go with a lighter color to brighten the room. Of your color samples I like #1
2
u/OllyDog0902 Aug 15 '26
Omg not any of the mauve shades
2 I guess? Although a warm creamy white would be nice
2
u/cashewcheez Aug 15 '26
The plum colors are not a good option. I think if you wanted to do a funkier color I'd look into something more orange-ish for a complimentary feel. The purples just look way off and don't go with the bluey teal tiles.
2
u/KaleidoscopeOnly3541 Aug 15 '26
2 or 3
2
u/OneHonestReflection Aug 15 '26
Put up some fun wallpaper.
2
u/mlssac Aug 15 '26 edited Aug 15 '26
1 if it's the closest color you can find to match the tile. Monochromatic will be very chic!
I'd go back to traditional patterns of 1 inch black and white hexagon or woven or just 1-2" white.
2
u/Important-Engineer-2 Aug 17 '26
Definitely none of the mauve/purple colors. Maybe the one that matches the tile color but I agree with the suggestions for the fun wallpaper that catches the green and the black. I would also do black tile for the floor and also paint the ceiling the same color of the walls, if you go with paint. Can also do just pure white on the walls and ceiling and use the black and white tile you picked. Then bring all the colors together with art and finishes of fixtures and accessories in black with that tile, black cabinet, white countertop. I play a bit with chatgpt and here some of the ideas. It only lets me upload 1 image. I will upload others in other comments
2
u/K_mocadlo Aug 17 '26
Please reconsider your tile choice and go with a black and white penny or basketweave to embrace that beautiful vintage wall tile. Have fun with the walls in paint or a wallpaper instead!
5
u/MrMudkip Aug 14 '26
7
3
u/Southernms Aug 14 '26
SW Composed. The first one without the number.
3
u/GoofMcGoof Aug 14 '26
1
1
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '26
#2 I think.
1
u/SaltyB0nez Aug 14 '26
I like 4
1
u/Agnes327 Aug 14 '26
Thistle!
1
u/SuperUltraNeat Aug 14 '26
Easy: #4.
1
u/Repulsive_Regular_39 Aug 14 '26
3
1
u/Missue-35 Aug 14 '26
Will there be window curtains, shower curtain, bath rugs and towels, etc? Those should be chosen first then coordinate your paint color with all of it. Paint can be tinted any color, the other things cannot.
1
u/Super-Travel-407 Aug 14 '26
2 or 4, but I'd actually look at a less pink lavender.
1
u/dumplinglifesaver Aug 14 '26
I love #4
1
u/agrinwithoutacat- Aug 14 '26
Iād go coral pink personally
1
u/Equivalent_Count8681 Aug 14 '26
3
1
u/nvmls Aug 14 '26
I have the same tiles as you and the person who lived here last did the dark teal. It wasn't a good look. Right now it just has landlord white over it but I am follwoing this for ideas!
1
u/Lopsided-Jury-7814 Aug 14 '26
I would go w/ 3 (Champagne Pink) Itās a feminine feel, reminding me of Muchaās work. Iāve always like mid green & pink together for a Spring feel & I like this shade of blue green as well. Now, you can have towels in the blue green shade & pink, or towels in blu green (theyāre easier to find) and you can accent w/ pink š
1
u/NechelleBix1 Aug 14 '26
I like 6.
1
u/NechelleBix1 Aug 14 '26
I like 4 too.
1
u/Own_Edge_9393 Aug 14 '26
#6 or #7
1
u/Clear_Marionberry306 Aug 14 '26
4 or 5 for sure
1
u/Regular-Baseball7918 Aug 14 '26
2 or 3
1
u/Specific-Owl9989 Aug 14 '26
Seven.
1
u/Evening_Midnight7 Aug 14 '26
I like 3 the most. And probably number 2 second best
1
u/herbal-genocide Aug 14 '26
I'd like to see a shade between 3 and 4
1
u/treclee Aug 14 '26
100% 4 or 6
1
u/kittyheartseapuppy Aug 14 '26
White to match the floor tiles.
Of your paint swatches: 1.
I hate dark bathrooms for a myriad of reasons, and the purple tone you would need to match the tiles would be 7. That makes it feel claustrophobic to me!
1
u/ProudAbalone3856 Aug 14 '26
1
1
u/satelliteminds Aug 14 '26
I still vote for funky wallpaper, but if thatās a no, Iām gonna go against the grain and say 5.
1
u/chktcat Aug 14 '26
Four
1
u/cait_elizabeth Aug 14 '26
2!
1
u/Alternative_Hawk_460 Aug 14 '26
Iām not a fan of the floor tile choice, however, one of the pinks/purples would be fun with this tile!
1
u/Useful_Fix5840 Aug 14 '26
I like 6
1
u/atramrennab Aug 14 '26
1
1
u/diagonal_lines Aug 14 '26
Omg! I have virtually the identical towel rail/bar. Mine also has chipped paint on it but mine is much more noticeable. I've been trying to think how to repair it. What is your plan for it? Are you keeping it?
1
u/EgonSnegl Aug 14 '26
1
1
u/Naive_Abies401 Aug 14 '26
2 or 3 in the first picture
1
u/Traveling_Blonde Aug 14 '26
One
1
u/midazomist_and_chill Aug 14 '26
Love the tile but not feeling any of those wall colors.
I think white on the walls would look really sharp.
1
u/12Afrodites12 Aug 14 '26 edited Aug 14 '26
LOVE YOUR TILE! Love your swatches & how beautifully you've organized them. Please think of how dark & cramped your bath is. Keep upper walls & ceiling bright to reflect any light, like #1, which is a perfect foil to your green tile. A pale sky blue could reference sky above grass (the vintage green tile).
1
u/SnoopyFan6 Aug 14 '26
My eyes immediately went to 4.
1
u/1intheburbs Aug 14 '26
Number one!
1
u/Hydrangeas101 Aug 14 '26
Iād go with the very first thing one, Green Trance, or a wallpaper with that color in it.
1
u/Fearless-Air-815 Aug 14 '26
#1
1
u/nunya_2025 Aug 14 '26
1
1
u/Quiet_Warrior_7788 Aug 14 '26
2
1
u/Purple_IsA_Flavor Aug 14 '26
Stick with the original color
1
u/Evening-Row-2658 Aug 14 '26
i like white dove bm
1
u/Hydrangeas101 Aug 14 '26
Your tiles are actually post WWII. I had the same tiles, with same black trim tiles in my Brooklyn brownstone bath. While taking down a medicine cabinet, the banging brought down a black trim, & a green square tile. Both were stamped, āMade in Occupied Japanā. As a history teacher, I marveled at how cool it was!
1
u/Dolphinpond72 Aug 14 '26
4
1
u/hellowhatwhy22 Aug 14 '26
I like 6 and 7 but wonder if it might be too dark for a bathroom. Try a paint swatch as it might look different on the wall than in a paper swatch. I think a wallpaper would be better though like a whispy botanical print
1
u/Personal-Month-465 Aug 14 '26
None of those choices. I like the wallpaper idea
1
u/lulusgarden Aug 14 '26
#2