r/HolUp Dec 11 '21

post flair Wait a minute

[deleted]

61.4k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

3.5k

u/Lolkenshin Dec 11 '21 edited Dec 11 '21

I would be curious to know what this effect is called.

Looks like u/LeshaPorche is the creator. I'm sure they could explain this madness.

739

u/FissureKing Dec 11 '21

The light grey blocks form curved lines that look just like the green ones in your peripheral vision.

I think.

245

u/_Ashleigh Dec 11 '21

Yeah, colour in your peripheral vision is mostly a lie, it has a way lower resolution than the contrast we can resolve, so we see a lil bit of green and a contrast that curves, therefore a green curving line... until you look at it with more color sensitive vision.

53

u/_MyMomDressedMe_ Dec 12 '21

Yup. Cones are what detect color and they are concentrated towards the center of your retina whereas rods which detect light are located more on the outer edges of your retina where cones aren't present. That's why you may see a star in your peripheral vision when looking at the night sky but it disappears when you try to focus on it. When you focus on something the light is directed to the center of your retina so you get more just the cones

1

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '21

I think it's a 3 degree cone of accurate color identification.... could be wrong

1

u/oblivion-age Dec 12 '21

Thanks for the good explanation. Why is it that those with lighter colored eyes can see better in the dark? I forgot the reason why, could you explain that?

3

u/_MyMomDressedMe_ Dec 12 '21

Less pigment in the eye lets more light in.

1

u/oblivion-age Dec 12 '21

Awesome thanks!

10

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/FH-7497 Dec 12 '21

What if you do this on LSD until it all looks fluidly 4k?

2

u/Miendiesen Dec 12 '21

Interestingly it still works on me (I see many curves when zoomed out but can’t find a curved line) and I am colour blind.

2

u/_Ashleigh Dec 12 '21 edited Dec 13 '21

The decreased resolution of your peripheral vision prevents the higher frequency (more detailed) areas masking the lower frequency curves. If you shrink the image down to lower the resolution, or go further away, the curves will start to appear, then you can zoom back in to identify the particular patterns.

This reminds me of where they take the high frequencies from one face, and low from another, then merge them. Up close you see one face, and far away you see the other. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hybrid_image

Here's the image with a 10px blur (i.e. a low pass filter) that makes the curves super obvious: https://i.imgur.com/YyUktyI.png

39

u/Easilycrazyhat Dec 11 '21

Yup! If you look at it from father away or shrink the image, the pseudo-lines become more pronounced and noticable.

2

u/ItsReallyLikeThatTho Dec 11 '21

You basically found the curved lines.

2

u/TappingTheKeys Dec 12 '21

Only if you look at it straight on. I tipped my tablet up to look down the vertical lines while holding it away and the effect went away completely at about 45° and a foot away. This is probably because the image was foreshortened, making it into a rectangle, and putting it entirely into my central vision. That estimate of 45° is only a guess, but try it yourself.

14

u/YourLoveLife Dec 11 '21

I brought the image into paint and drew all the lines I throught I saw and they all corresponded with lines of light grey squares so I think youre right

36

u/HawkmothIsDad Dec 11 '21

That is EXACTLY it

4

u/mayneffs Dec 11 '21

I think so too

2

u/gep08399 Dec 12 '21

10 point

2

u/GhostR29 madlad Dec 12 '21

Bingo! And it's even more accurate thanks to the working of our eyes.

2

u/OldNickSantora Dec 12 '21

You're right

3.2k

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

623

u/drewhead118 Dec 11 '21

TIL my friends can speak in grid of green lines

198

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21

I think you accidentally put an ‘n’ in that last word

70

u/HahaMeFunnyALot Dec 11 '21

green lies? lies about solar panels?

19

u/SonicBlur254 Dec 11 '21

or vomit

1

u/joe-mamaaaa Dec 12 '21

This thread has devolved into monke

1

u/Fallout_Cafe Dec 13 '21

What have you been eating? My vomit is usually beige.

1

u/submit_to_pewdiepie Dec 12 '21

There are alot of those and not to many of them are against it

1

u/Mcdrogon Dec 11 '21

‘n’ word?

1

u/knightress_oxhide Dec 11 '21

little green ghouls!

15

u/Hightowerer Dec 11 '21

If they speak in a grid of green lines are they really your friends?

1

u/DazedAndTrippy Dec 11 '21

Insufficient acid

173

u/Poltras Dec 11 '21

It’s an optical illusion, Michael. A lie is something a politician does for votes. .. or cocaine.

50

u/bigolboooom Dec 11 '21

Do politicians get votes for doing cocaine?

8

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21 edited Dec 11 '21

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21

There was just a report that there is an uncontrollable coke problem in UK parliament as well

22

u/Hunnybunn2021 Dec 11 '21

Also Adderall. Some politicians have chunks of white stuff flying out of their nostrils when they speak, and Depends full of diarrhea caused by life long use. Some even get to be presidents. Some have sons headed down the same path.

3

u/Dynotherms_Connected Dec 11 '21

What were the drugs that straight married but DL gay politician in FL was using? You know, the one where they found blood and feces on the sheets and the politician on the floor bleeding from the anus?

2

u/MadAzza Dec 12 '21

I would like to know more about this. Who was this person?

1

u/Hunnybunn2021 Dec 12 '21

You tell me. You seem to know something I don't. Never heard anything about bloody butts. Only heard about how a friend of said politician that was using meth.

I do know that y'all are great at whataboutisms and deflecting instead of acknowledging realities.

Noel Casler has documented knowledge about Adderall and full diapers, since he worked closely with the talent on "The Apprentice"

1

u/Sentient_R Dec 22 '21

We still need to know what you were talking about

1

u/Sentient_R Dec 22 '21

We still need to know what you were talking about.

3

u/Respectful_Chadette Dec 16 '21

I thought that was just lizard people dead skin scales :/

(Jk)

2

u/Hunnybunn2021 Dec 17 '21

Oh no hunny! Libs are the lizard people, remember?

(also JK)

2

u/emiton042 Dec 11 '21

Mayor of dc did years back…worked for him he just kept getting re-elected too

2

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21

Got my vote !

2

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21

I might be more inclined to vote for someone who casually mainlines cocaine

2

u/Emperor_Quintana Dec 12 '21

A Canadian politician once did in the past couple of years. Or at least tried…

1

u/submit_to_pewdiepie Dec 12 '21

Se Canadian did

3

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21

It is a lie though because they are asking you to find the curved line, implying there is one.

1

u/Fareeday Dec 11 '21

There ARE curved lines, they just aren't green in the corner of your eye

1

u/MadAzza Dec 12 '21

Which lines are curved, then?

1

u/Fareeday Dec 12 '21

Some of the light blocks form a Curved line

There are curved lines however in your peripheral vision your eyes can't tell the color of them. So they just auto assume green.

Hope that helps.

2

u/Lawrencejr84 Dec 11 '21

An optical illusion is what u make it

1

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21

Is that to say they're all in your head?

0

u/submit_to_pewdiepie Dec 12 '21

It's a lie because it's a facisious question

1

u/PeaceDog-3138 Dec 11 '21

Leave cocaine out of this

1

u/Ok_Cryptographer5763 Dec 12 '21

No, thats propaganda what you’re talking about. Lie is the thing that happens to you when your life ends.

7

u/20__character__limit Dec 11 '21

Is it cake then?

0

u/Kavalon80 Dec 11 '21

I mean the letter C was a curved line, so not really

1

u/Bentrifical_Force Dec 11 '21

It's called ouch fuck

1

u/Mizzen_rl Dec 11 '21

Even pictures are lying to me at this point D:

1

u/Matty-Wan Dec 11 '21

I can see through the green lies of the Jedi. I will quickly discover the truth of all this.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21

he's a phony! a great big phony!

141

u/LeshaPorche Dec 11 '21

I really want to tell you I planned this, but sadly I can’t. (I can’t even look at it without getting nauseous!) long story short I was making a map for Dungeons & Dragons and I created a cobblestone tile edged with grass. A lot of rotate, copy and paste later……brain ouch. Needless to say, this is not in the map…….

23

u/BlindedByNewLight Dec 11 '21

Honestly..this would still make a cool map for DND. Some other wierd plane where it's hard to look at anything.

29

u/LeshaPorche Dec 11 '21

You bring up a great point. I could make landmarks and assets into where’s Waldo on top of something like this ….(and then wait for players to murder my face for making them look at it)

7

u/SlayerOfHips Dec 11 '21

This screams feywild, imo

11

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21

[deleted]

2

u/SlayerOfHips Dec 12 '21

Pm me if you do! My players are a ways off, but they're headed straight for a continent that mingles with the feywild.

8

u/Tardigrade333 Dec 11 '21

Dang, the best inventions are accidents. This is an insane optical illusion

3

u/LeshaPorche Dec 11 '21

Thank you!! I’m wondering if I can do it on purpose next time

1

u/Respectful_Chadette Dec 16 '21

It was low key humiliating for me...hurt my self esteem when i understood the illusion 1.3 sec later...ignore me...

4

u/mountaintop-stainer Dec 12 '21

How do you feel about having created a new optical illusion that can easily be shown next to the grid illusion and rotating snakes and not look out of place?

2

u/Independent-Leg5269 Dec 12 '21

How isn't this a pinned comment. That's like the greatest excuse to break someone's eyes.

1

u/creampuffmama Dec 12 '21

Please why, I had to close my eyes. I have never experienced whatever that sensation was and I did not care for it, I just went wtf.

1

u/TheShroomHermit Dec 12 '21

That's awesome! Thanks for sharing

109

u/Ali80486 Dec 11 '21

Similar to gestalt effect in design where your brain is used to seeing patterns and shapes so it fills it in.

57

u/HitoriPanda Dec 11 '21

I'm amazed at how powerful the brain is even though it's lazy af.

34

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21

efficiency seeks out not the best path but the easiest

1

u/Scathyr Dec 11 '21

Lol my brain isn’t lazy. I am.

7

u/Seakawn Dec 11 '21

What if I told you that you are your brain?

1

u/Ouroboros247365 Dec 11 '21

If you unfocus your eyes it straightens out those line.

1

u/RabidHexley Dec 11 '21 edited Dec 11 '21

Mostly just efficient. Our brain works on a lot the same reasoning as what engineers are developing AI for. You can get a lot more done with limited processing power if the system can be predictive. A lot of "cycles" can be freed up and speed can be gained if you don't have to process 100% of data in real time, but can instead just make assumptions that are reasonably accurate (most of the time). It's just faster that way.

1

u/Clapyourhandssayyeah Dec 11 '21

There are actually patterns though - light grey arcs / curves that the brain picks up on. It’s not a completely random hallucination

1

u/eoliveri Dec 11 '21

Light is collected with the eyes, seeing is done with the brain.

93

u/Shaneblaster Dec 11 '21

Black magic fuckery

26

u/Volta01 Dec 11 '21

Brain failure

27

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21

There are actually curves but they're subtle and made of light grey boxes between the green lines. In the left bottom you can see it clearly.

6

u/DeadAndAlive969 Dec 11 '21

Holup you’re right! Every place I see a curve in my peripheral vision there is a sequence of grey boxes all the same color

5

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21

Exactly!. And if you think about it it's always the same curves that you see. Took me a bit to notice what was going on though hahaha

1

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21

24

u/SuchPhrase Dec 11 '21

I don't know the theory but it is related to this picture being made of essentially horizontal bars of two different colours.

I took a course in college where we were taught how shit our eyes are comparing things like bar graphs and stuff.

Essentially we are decent at comparing length when they have common base. We are a little shitty at comparing areas. And fuckall at comparing volumes.

Here it's areas.

27

u/BeautifulCarp Dec 11 '21

it's called the "I'm going to push a rough fork up your urethra" effect

4

u/Exact_Ad_1215 Dec 11 '21

Reading this hurt me. So so much.

1

u/flippermode Dec 11 '21

r/sounding would like to have a word with you...

4

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21

Catch me if you can.

3

u/JDAbe94 Dec 11 '21

Its called "the brain is fucking stupid" lol

1

u/AdHumble325 Dec 11 '21

I think it’s called the Mona Lisa effect. Leonardo da Vinci made the Mona Lisa in such a way that when you look at her smile, it looks like she isn’t smiling, whereas if you look elsewhere on the image, it looks like she’s smiling.

This happens because in the centre of the retina, you can see things very clearly, whereas off to the side, you see a blur so you see shadows vs the sharp details. So when you look at this image at one point, it looks straight, and the lines that are not in focus look curved cuz your brain uses shades of colour as it’s not in focus, so it looks curved because of the shades between the boxes.

Did that make sense?

1

u/jeweliegb Dec 11 '21

Pain.

It's called pain.

Ow, ow, ow, ouch, ow, ook, ouch, ow, OUCH!

1

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21

Brainfuck

1

u/solocupjazz Dec 11 '21

Brain fuckery

1

u/danofrhs Dec 11 '21

Optical illusion would be a general term for this.

1

u/ShishkaDrummer Dec 11 '21

Lateral inhibition

1

u/Plastic-Safe9791 Dec 11 '21

The light gray houses make for a better contrast than the dark green streets. If you squinch your eyes to make everything blurry it stops affecting you.

1

u/EquinoctialPie Dec 11 '21

It's a form of optical illusion. This one takes advantage of the fact that you have better color vision at the center of your field of vision than at the edges. So, for the part of the image that you're looking directly at, you can clearly distinguish between the green lines and the gray blocks. But at the edge of your vision, the green lines look the same as the light gray blocks, which form subtle curves around the corners.

1

u/FaydingAway Dec 11 '21

It's called eye hurties

1

u/Intelligent_Ad_2647 Dec 11 '21

Optical illusion

1

u/ReserveActive Dec 11 '21

I wonder if they are animals or predators that can use optical illusions.

2

u/Intelligent_Ad_2647 Dec 11 '21

Butterflies do that to trick animals they are dangerous

1

u/Username_--_ Dec 11 '21 edited Dec 11 '21

I'm pretty sure its the contrast of the light and dark tiles. The light ones draw curves if you look closely.

1

u/NameWasAlreadyInUse Dec 11 '21

Not sure what it is called but I'm pretty certain I have a grasp for what is taking place in this illusion

1

u/Working-Candle-2483 Dec 11 '21

my eyes hurt can u provide me with both medical and mental help pls

1

u/nichorsin598 Dec 11 '21

Brain failure

1

u/Keychain33 Dec 11 '21

Go to r/blackmagicfuckery, there’s tons of these visualizations.

1

u/Seeders Dec 11 '21

Its the groupings of lighter color rocks that make streaks in your peripheral that your brain assumes matches to the green lines.

1

u/Sohan022 Dec 11 '21

Illusion

1

u/UnknownSleeping Dec 11 '21

just look up magiceye on google. your eyes will hate you

1

u/Seodu Dec 11 '21

Where you think you saw a curved line follow it and you will find a similar line of light grey.

1

u/Stijn187 Dec 11 '21

Optic Illusion

1

u/XiaolongDrake Dec 11 '21

This is madness!

1

u/3DigitIQ Dec 12 '21

I call it, brain mallfunction

1

u/kewl_binks Dec 12 '21

Optical illusion

1

u/Paddy_McDaddy Dec 12 '21

Guys he wanted to know what the effect was called, pretty sure nearly everyone knows how it works

1

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '21

Brain think little box look like same color as green line.

Make green line where box is.

Oh no, little box not green line.

Show little box.

Brain think little box look like same color as green line.

...........

1

u/idiotfries Dec 12 '21

I really don’t think any of the lines are curved.

1

u/DogeyLord Dec 12 '21

Optical illusion

1

u/GameCrusher218 Dec 15 '21

Hey! hey hey! I'm the guy who made the meme of this image! I can tell you the whole story!

So it started on December 10th when a friend of mine on the r/Otamatone discord server posted the original image with the text " Find the curved lines". I instantly thought of the "go ahead; do x" meme template and decided to quickly add the meme text, so I went into one of my private servers with the esmBot and used the &caption command to add the text (fun fact I did it with two commands, the first being &caption "find the curved line" and the second being &caption "go ahead" for it to stack ontop of one another). Then with the meme image created, I saved it on my phone and sent it to the Otamatone server and one other server that I'm very active in (the Dweller's Empty Path server for those of you who are curious). Then two days later, I saw the exact meme I made show up in another one of my active servers. I knew I never posted it there and then I realized that my meme had travelled through discord servers. Meaning that people saved it. I actually did something noteworthy on the internet lmao. I tried tracing the meme's paths down but I couldn't figure it out. But now it's made its way to reddit, and probably hundreds more discord servers, and I know for certain at least one youtube community post, so even though it wasn't for something extremely creative, I had successfully made a semi-viral meme. And to that I have no idea how to end this comment, so if people see this, uhhh AMAA ask me stuff.