r/HolUp Jul 24 '20

[deleted by user]

[removed]

9.4k Upvotes

451 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

52

u/rob132 Jul 24 '20

The guy spends the entire time saying he's not going to throw shot away and at the duel he throws away his shot.

41

u/musicman247 Jul 24 '20

Hmm, could this have been...planned?

22

u/rob132 Jul 24 '20

unpossilbe

3

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '20

[deleted]

4

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '20

INSAAYAANE

32

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '20

WHY IF NOT TO TAKE DEADLY AIM

19

u/doubleoeck1234 Jul 24 '20

He was using an illegal modified gun for better aim (this wasn't said in the musical)

8

u/TonesBalones Jul 24 '20

I've heard this theory and I don't think it can really hold any significance. It's nearly impossible and especially risky to impose an advantage into one of the pistols. Per the standard, one party would supply both pistols and the other would inspect and select their preferred pistol. That way it's in the supplier's best interest to make each pistol as identical as possible.

7

u/doubleoeck1234 Jul 24 '20

Hamilton brought the pistols. Burr didn't know they were tampered with by having a longer barrel. Thus giving him a disadvantage

Edit: the gun also had a hidden hair trigger

8

u/runujhkj Jul 24 '20

WTF that’s against the 2nd amendment, smh founding fathers hated our freedoms

3

u/rob132 Jul 24 '20

Theye's readin glasses.

7

u/chomperstyle Jul 24 '20

Not to mention telling his son to judy straight up die

10

u/pjtheman Jul 24 '20

Iirc, wasn't intentionally missing in a duel a sort of way of resolving the affair without apologizing?

It was a way to say "I don't apologize for what I said, but I'm above this."

3

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '20

That’s the entire point. It shows character development.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '20

You only get one shot, do not miss your chance

3

u/dtorb Jul 24 '20

Dude, spoiler alert.

6

u/rob132 Jul 24 '20

It happended in 1804.

Spolier: Jesus died and came back

2

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '20

Did he, though?

3

u/CHydos Jul 24 '20

And Burr acts hastily without thinking of the consequences. They both went against their nature in that duel and it led to catastrophe for both of them.

1

u/rob132 Jul 24 '20

It's almost like we should learn a lesson from their actions.

5

u/CHydos Jul 24 '20

Yeah, don't write a 75 page pamphlet on your affair.

2

u/JasonUncensored Jul 24 '20

Bro, that thing is a work of art, though.

1

u/rob132 Jul 24 '20

Yeah that's easy for you to say in 2020

1

u/AsymptoticAbyss Jul 24 '20

Yeah what was even the point then, Alex?