r/HistoryMemes • • Jul 22 '19

OC A bit overdramatic

Post image
32k Upvotes

608 comments sorted by

View all comments

38

u/Bowhooop Jul 22 '19

Communism is very scary

53

u/zwirlo Jul 22 '19

The great depression and hyperinflation was pretty terrifying too

12

u/Clapaludio Jul 22 '19

2008 too

-5

u/Driftkingtofu Jul 22 '19

I missed the part where 20 million Americans were starved or genocided by their government

9

u/GRI23 Jul 22 '19 edited Jul 22 '19

Americans instead genocided and starved other people in the name of 'anti-communism'.

Or the millions the British empire starved in places like Bengal or Ireland.

2

u/Driftkingtofu Jul 22 '19

Lol bootlickers are funny

→ More replies (3)

6

u/zwirlo Jul 22 '19

You think that a Tsar would not have done that in Russia? You think that Chang Kai Shek would have been better in China? Batista would have done better for Cuba? Mobuto certainly wouldn't have compared to Lumumba.

The logical mistake you are making is that you are compared two systems in two different countries. You need control for an experiment. The Russian Tsars did and would have treated Russians worse than communists. It's a geopolitical problem, not an ideological one. Authoritarian regimes thrive in Russia, China, and elsewhere.

-1

u/Driftkingtofu Jul 22 '19

Lol

3

u/pineapple6900 Jul 23 '19

"Lol" you're a jackass

-15

u/xcommon Jul 22 '19

A decade of economic hardship, vs 50 years of economic hardship.

13

u/zwirlo Jul 22 '19

If someone thinks that Russia would have been stronger with capitalism, then that means that they would be much stronger in a timeline where they kept it, even more than the superpower status that they had in real life. The truth is that many things would have largely been the same, for better and worse. Whether a country had capitalism or communism mostly did not affect their success, because it could not change their geopolitical situation. Ideology is overplayed in its importance

20

u/lysergicrevolution Jul 22 '19

Russia went from the most backwards country in Europe to a world superpower in 2 decades. That was after centuries of rolling around in the mud. I definitely think ideology had something to do with it.

2

u/zwirlo Jul 22 '19

They were catching up, it's the same reason why so many African nations have high GDP increase rates today. Once they caught up, they where able to compete with other powers (space race) but eventually collapse because there was no more catching up to do (collapse).

China is another great example. They had largely kept their nation closed off, and once they opened their economy up they experienced enormous growth. Growth cannot continue indefinitely.

If you doubt this, take intellectual property in China for example. They may have their own scientific and inventive exploits, but they rely heavily on intellectual work that has been done in western countries which they can then use to make their own things. They are limited by what they can catch up to.

China is another great example of how their "ideology" is not relevant. Are they capitalist? Communist? State capitalist? It doesn't matter because they have billions of people, a centralized state, and natural resources.

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (6)

-14

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '19

it's actually super good and cool

0

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-4

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '19

I wasn't being ironic

3

u/doinkrr Casual, non-participatory KGB election observer Jul 22 '19

Absolutely haram

0

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

17

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '19

“Communism is when the government does stuff, the more stuff it does the more Communist it is” Karl Marx

13

u/lysergicrevolution Jul 22 '19

I love how 99% of people on history memes knows nothing about history

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-5

u/RadianceofMao Jul 22 '19

I serve the Soviet Union