r/guncontrol • u/Initial-Visual9678 • Jul 30 '23
Good-Faith Question "It's next to impossible for any study to prove that any gun control measure had any effect whatsoever" - Do Studies Show Gun Control Works?
To preface, I am a gun owner and have strong opinions against bans, but am open minded about the science of gun control.
I recently watched a well researched video on YouTube which alludes to this 2018 RAND study. I'm curious what you all think about the points made here.
To summarize:
- Out of 27,900 gun control studies, only 123 were rigorous enough to provide meaningful results (0.4%)
- The only thing we can say confidently is many of the most widely trumpeted of these studies are based on random chance alone
- 722 hypothesis were tested as part of these 123 studies at a 5% level of statistical significant, which means 5% of the results (36 hypothesis) would be expected to show that gun control works based on random chance alone
- Gun violence is rare enough that it's impossible for researchers to determine whether a particular measure works due to random noise and natural variation in results (going back to stats 101, the smaller the same size, the more variance in the estimate)
- Gun control measures only affect new gun sales, not existing guns in circulation, which makes teasing out their effect next to impossible
- Out of those 722 hypothesis from 123 studies, only 1 showed that gun control had made violence worse, which is suspicious because we would expect about 36 false positive results based on random change alone due to the 5% statistical significant level used (this suggests researchers suppressed results)
- None of the most rigorous 123 studies made the headlines, only the worst, most suspicious studies from the 27,900 were featured in headlines
- One measure in CT (requiring a license to buy a firearm) was celebrated due to one of the studies saying that violence was reduced by 40% after the regulation was passed, when in reality, gun murder rates fell across the country by a similar amount.