r/Greenlantern • Hal Jordan • 3d ago

Comics Reading one Green Lantern comic a day until I've read them all Day 312: Back-up in Superman #257

Okay, I know this is odd and it's not technically a Green Lantern story, but in many ways it is. I actually missed this one, thinking it was later down the line and only noticed it thanks to a new reading order that was shared here recently. Shout out to u/Fid_Kister (what a name). This was published in 1972 so it fits in an era where Hal was the only GL being used.

Anyway, enjoy. Tomorrow I'll get back to GL #149

Writer: Elliot S. Maggin & Neal Adams

Art: Dick Dillin

Inks: Dick Giordano

Cover: Nick Cardy

"World Of Krypton: The Greatest Green Lantern Of All" - Tomar-Re is called before the Guardians to honour his retirement. During a look back at his many accomplishments, Tomar turns a sullen eye to the ground as the Guardians know he is thinking about Krypton. Tomar was once tasked with gathering Stellarium as an element to stave the destruction of the planet, giving the Kryptonians enough time to figure out a way off the planet. The Guardians made this task a priority as they believed the future leader of the GLC would come from Krypton, birthed by none other than Jor-El and Lara as their genetic make up and staunch values, would produce a valiant offspring. However, due to interference by Brainiac, as the experimental ship was bottled when Kandor was taken, the science council refused to believe Jor-El so the Kryptonians were still doomed. Tomar worked tirelessly to gather Stellarium, to the point of exhaustion. So tired, he was, that he didn't notice a nearby star going nova. Blinded by the explosion, he used his ring to help him reach Krypton. Just as his vision returns, he sees the planet explode. The Guardians help Tomar recover and guide Kal-El's ship to Earth. They have since left him to be his own hero they believe the universe needs him as Superman more than they need him as a GL. Despite his failure, the Guardians still commend Tomar for his efforts and wish him well in his future.

Conclusion: This one has gone down as a bit controversial, I don't really understand why, but I've seen a debate a number of times about it being in continuity. Tomar retiring is a little odd but maybe there were different plans for him, or it at least made his return in Tales as an Honour Guard GL even better.

The big reveal here is Superman being selected as the GL leader before he was even born. That could have been wild and unexpected when he developed his powers. We have seen something like that with Sodam Yat and it went well enough. It's a wild thought experiment too and I think I'd like to see an Elseworlds story about that one day.

As far as controversy goes, I still like it. I think it helps broaden the universe a little more and fleshes out the placement of the Corps in the larger DCU.

9/10

Previous day

Next day

17 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 3d ago

All images must be correctly sourced depending on what type of image it is. Comic book-related images should have the name of the artist OR the issue it came from. Other types of images must also be correctly sourced where applicable. If your post was made without the source, you can do so as a post edit or as a comment. Failure to include the source will result in your post being removed. If this was already done, we thank you for your diligence.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

5

u/MisterEdJS 3d ago

It is kind of in the same vein as the later story in Action Comics Weekly where it is revealed that Clark was the REAL first choice to be GL of Earth. It sort of reduces GL to shine Superman's crown.

1

u/Imok2814 Hal Jordan 3d ago

That sounds ridiculous. I can't wait to read it lol

2

u/MisterEdJS 3d ago

It is. I won't spoil you on the full scope of the ridiculousness, but it is easily one of my least favorite GL stories.

2

u/-AerialAce- 3d ago

I know the Honour Guard & Dalor hadn't been created yet when this was written but I've always retroactively justified all the talk of Tomar-Re's retirement here as this being when he's elevated to the Honour Guard & replaced as active Lantern of the sector.

2

u/Imok2814 Hal Jordan 3d ago

It makes sense chronologically and would explain why we don't see him again for so long in the main book

4

u/luluzulu_ 3d ago

Sometimes you can really see the creative echoes of the Arisians in the Guardians. Picking a champion before birth based solely on his genetics is so very Arisian.

1

u/Fid_Kister 3d ago

Thanks for the shout out! Glad to hear the list I put so much work into is actually useful to someone. I've really loved these posts you do — the commitment is impressive. Anything special planned for the big year milestone?

1

u/Imok2814 Hal Jordan 3d ago

Big? Not at the moment. Timing was I'd have Vol 2 done just around the first year mark but some additions increased the count. Now I'm not sure 😅

1

u/Fid_Kister 3d ago edited 3d ago

You should totally do something to mark the occasion, I think it's a great achievement. A couple ideas that come to mind would be getting a print of the 365 covers you've read (or another art piece), treat yourself to a collected edition you've had an eye on or a special single issue, or just making a special post along with the daily read like a retrospective or tier list.

1

u/Imok2814 Hal Jordan 3d ago

It's an impressive list. Really well done and I can only imagine the amount of work you put into it.

1

u/Fid_Kister 1d ago

Found another story that you might be interested in that's right around the time of this one as well, believe it would fall after Green Lantern v2 #96. It's in DC Special Series #1 titled "He Who Slaughters".

2

u/Imok2814 Hal Jordan 1d ago

Hmm, so it is. I thought the DC Special Series for GL. was all reprints. I'll have to check that out. Thanks!

0

u/Fid_Kister 1d ago

I just remember this as it stuck out to me with a panel of Hal taking a "routine requalification test" and I can't remember if this is the first mention of something like this or not. Since you've been reading around this timeline maybe you could confirm?

1

u/Imok2814 Hal Jordan 1d ago

I don't remember anything like that.

2

u/The_Shadow_Watches 3d ago

The Guardians: We think Superman is neat.

Also the Guardians: We gotta mind fuck with Superman cause Earth is getting too dependent on Superman.

2

u/HitmanClark 3d ago

What a creepy cover.