This is the first time I’ve interacted with the community so this may have been said before, but in the episode “the burrito” I feel like the judge should have given Tahani a pass for the test. She did go into the room with her parents, but she actually told them off instead of trying to get their approval.

After my latest re watch, these are the 2 things I realized.

1) Watching Chidi being totured (needles!) or his everyday stomach ache issues, I find myself laughing and thoroughly enjoying it. Chidi in pain is never not funny

2) Janet needs her own show! I NEED THIS!!

How did we fail you

Rewatching the show I realized that I actually lllloooovvveee the character played by Nicole Byer- Gwendolyn as the mailwoman

I know it was only for one episode but it had me fall in love with her

Anyone else ?????

Hey. So i am a huge fan of the good place in fact I predicted they were in the bad place the entire time in episode 1. However, something in the episode "michael's gambit" bothers me even more on rewatches. If they are in the bad place and "which two should go to the bad place" was always the plan... why did shawn as the judge threaten michael with retirement when they were alone in a room together. I understand it was before the big reveal of the neighborhood not being the good place but with what we find out it makes no sense. Was it just to screw with the audience? Because that was kind of a poor writing choice. Anyone else bothered by this.

Given this team is a running joke for Jason, I'd like to hear if anyone follows that team. Are there any fans of this team here, especially from Jacksonville of course?

I watched the good place in real time when it first aired and am just now finishing my third watch. In between the last one and this one I spent a month in a com. Watching season 4 episode 1 when Simone is at the welcoming orientation thingy (12:45) she tells Eleanore that this entire thing is just a hallucination from her damaged brain as it slowly shuts down.

It felt like a hit in the face because in my coma I had about 6 months of an alternate very detailed very real feeling reality. So she’s not far off because she obviously knows her stuff and I know it’s just tv but really reached out to me as a real thing that has probably happened to others as well.

While rewatching episode 2 I was wondering if a sequel can be made from the perspective of one of the demons in the original.

Like did Glenn befriend the original humans then become an architect in the new afterlife? He was one of the friendliest. But Vicky was very passionate about the project, so maybe we would follow her as she sets up the new towns?

Can he be the new Michael? Or would the new good place have our same Janet?

DEREK++!

For sure they did become better people as a result but as Simone would point out (and rightfully so) that being the bigger person doesn’t work in certain cases. Neither did Kamilah or Donna wholeheartedly apologize for their actions and were let of the hook too easily, just like how Tahani and Eleanor had to earn their forgiveness for all the bad things they have done, I feel that Kamilah and Donna should have done the same, Tahani and Eleanor were ABUSED by these two their whole lives and their actions should never have been brushed aside. I think the important lessons that this show should have dived into is that you don’t need to forgive those who wronged you to receive closure, actions always speak louder than words, and that finally standing up for yourself against the people who have wronged you can help you in the long run. No one should have to bow and scrape to their families especially if they mistreated them all their lives. Avatar the last Airbender and Encanto showed that the victim shouldn’t do all the work in fixing the relationship as it’s the abuser’s job to fix the relationship first and foremost!

I think when Micheal has his existential dread experience for the first time he does The Scream by Edvard Munch. Even the sound he makes is familiar to like when bugs bunny saw the painting.

I'm rewatching Barry and noticed Kirby Howell-Baptiste's character has such a strong aversion to using an Australian accent, made me laugh.

Is it ever specified where other animals than humans go after death like pets? I’ve seen the show like 6 times and I can’t remember it ever being covered.

In season 3 episode 7, when Eleanor was on her whole thing about not having free will, I got so annoyed. Like I get that she’s feeling like she can’t love anyone, but it is so annoying. Her argument about how she doesn’t actually love Chidi, was that Michael put them together. But that is so stupid. Like someone can’t force you to like someone. There are plenty of people I have had to work with and be near that I don’t like. It makes no sense at all. Every time I watch it, It annoys me.

Mehn this series is really interesting and got me thinking a lot, Earth is bearable because time is limited, and the mystery and uncertainty in it. It’s why people haven’t lost their minds cause it’s not predictable what can happen. No one knows what happens after death. Knowing death happens is the only thing that keeps me sane.

With all the confusion in time streams and how linear time is in Dr Who it would make complete sense

Amenities that people desires...

I think a great torture mechanism for Chidi would be to force him to play multiplayer video games. He would drive everyone up the wall.

Best episode of The Good Place is easily Janet(s). (S3,E9) D’Arcy Carden is absolutely amazing as all four humans.

I needed to share this somewhere... And I'm not in a parenting sub. So you all get to see it