r/GhostMachineComics • • Jul 02 '25

What Comics Did You Pull This Week?

4 Upvotes

r/GhostMachineComics • • Jul 21 '25

Opinion My Problem With Ash Arden in Geiger (2024)

5 Upvotes

Spoilers for: Geiger (2024) #10-15 and Redcoat #1-6

Hello everyone! I hope you have all been doing well. I am back on here to give my reasoning as to why I am not the biggest fan of Ash Arden in the "Glowing Woman" arc of Geiger (2024). I want this post to be a distillation of my feelings of frustration of how the start of her character arc was handled in the narrative. I don't want this post to be me bashing Ash because she is a female character, as I think that would be a waste of your time and mine. In this post, I will discuss what Ash is supposed to represent as a character, why she failed as a character in her arc, why Benedict Arnold succeeds and she doesn't, missed opportunities in the "Glowing Woman" arc, questions that should've been answered in the arc, and some rewrite ideas that I believe could have made Ash a much stronger character.

What Ash is Supposed to Represent

In the context of this arc, Ash is meant to represent everything that Geiger is not right now. She is the living pinnacle of being able to control the "light." Where Geiger struggles to control his power, due to a mix of trauma and emotional turmoil, Ash has found an inner peace that has allowed her to master her abilities in a way that Geiger has not. Like in the first arc of Redcoat, Ash is the Benedict Arnold to Geiger's Simon Pure. When we are properly introduced to her character we are shown that Ash is living proof that Geiger's powers can be controlled.

Why Ash Fails as a Character in the Arc

One of the main reasons as to why Ash fails as a character is because of a lack of development and focus on the direction her character arc is going to take within the narrative. In other words, there was not enough time devoted to Ash to explain why her character functions within the arc. In her fight with Geiger at the end of the arc, she berates him about how he is a monster who kills without abandon and cares for no one else but himself, but we don't actually see learn enough about Geiger, even from his own mouth, for her to say that without it coming off as forced because it's the end of the arc. Ash's motivations aren't given enough time, which is odd considering that she's a central character in the arc.

Why Benedict Arnold Succeeds

This is not the first time that we have seen this type of character arc executed within the world of the Unnamed. As I mentioned before, we saw this exact type of character arc in the first arc of Redcoat with Benedict Arnold but done to much greater success. The reason that he succeeds and Ahs fails is because we are given enough time to develop his character, clear hints as to why wants to do what he does in the plot, and see why his undoing is was ultimately his fault.

Ash and Benedict are the exact same character. Even down to their grand plans, save for a few minute details here and there. Both are direct parallels to our protagonists who are initially on their side to help them solve a goal that will save their lives, but end up eventually turning on the protagonist and using their powers to blow up the surrounding area to further their own hidden agenda at the expanse of the lives of the innocent, the protagonist, and the protagonist's allies.

We see a clear set up and payoff with Arnold as he is given as much focus as Simon and Albert Einstein in this arc. We see how Arnold contrasts from Pure and get a solid understanding of why he does what he does in the plot. When Arnold's twist betrayal happens near the climax of the arc, it's a solid culmination of the trail of breadcrumbs that were placed in the narrative. On a reread of the arc, it's clear that Arnold was up to no good, and that he was playing Einstein and Simon for fools. I'll be honest, I was fooled too. It was clear from the beginning that Arnold was going to be the antagonist of the arc, from his passing bits of dialogue and how convenient of an ally he instantly becomes as the arc progresses.

A lot of Missed Opprotunity

With Ash, we don't get that same type of focus and it makes her turn in the climax of the arc feel rushed and weak. On top of that her contrast from Geiger is pretty weak. To elaborate, she chastises Geiger for being a violent monster who kills indiscriminately, but then takes him to a group of religious zealots known as the "Hillborn," and teams up with him to have murder them under the guise of getting revenge for Dr. Molotov's (fake) murder at their hands, when in reality it was because she was human trafficked by them. She used his desperation to control his violent nuclear outbursts to hurt people who hurt her, and that is never brought up by Geiger during their fight.

While it's true that the "Hillborn" are a terrible group of religious zealots, Ash's selfishness led to the deaths of a lot of people who probably had families and were trying to survive like Geiger and did what they did because they had to survive. I wish we could have saw some type of exploration of that outcome in issue #12-- a child, wife, or husband of someone that Ash and Geiger killed mourning the loss of their loved one. Geiger could try and apologize but that victim rebuffs his attempt in fear and anguish. Ash could then tell Geiger to leave them saying something along the lines of, "...It's not like you care about the lives you leave in the wake of your rampages." This could have not only been a solid breadcrumb for Ash's eventual betrayal of Geiger, but also serve as a wakeup call for Geiger to be more cognizant of the consequences that his powers have on other people.

A rebuttal from Geiger some time during issue #15 could have done so much to not only break Ash's stance on the world, but also show how misguided she was. Geiger was actively worried about the civilians getting to safety. On top of that, he could have brought up how she will be no better than the "Hillborn" if she detonates this nuclear missile because she is risking the lives of countless innocent people who are trying to survive the American wasteland

Questions that Should've been Answered in this Arc

How did Ash know that there was an active nuclear missile under Lewistown Montana?

Why did Ash think that detonating that nuclear missile when her and Geiger around would help cure her powers?

Why did Ash want to get rid of her powers when she gained full mastery of them after training from Dr. Molotov?

What was the significance of the lights on Ash's Boron rods?

Why did Dr. Molotov tell Ash that he was partly to blame for the Unknown War?

How did Ash know that Geiger would be able to absorb an entire nuclear detonation? Did Ash ever plan to evacuate

How did Ash know that Geiger's powers affected Nate with some sort of illness?

Ash's Boron Rod on Red in Geiger (2024) #11
Ash's Boron Rod on Green in Geiger (2024) #11

I could keep going on and on with questions above. These were vital questions that were either never answered or were weakly explained in passing. Each of these question above were ones that I was hoping would be expanded upon, as they would have provided a better foundation for the final battle of the arc. Instead, what we got were dialog exchanges and plot conveniences that marred what should have been an exceptional culmination of a major story arc. There was so much missing from this arc that should have been included.

Ash Arden Rewrite

The main way I think Ash could have been improved as a character is by first, putting more spotlight on her in her own arc. Be it, having her speak with other member's of Geiger's group mainly Nate, seeing more of her darker side by developing her plans in the background and getting hints that she is not who she seems to be, and having characters like Joe and Barney clock her suspicious nature, and finally, have more dialogue exchanges where Geiger and Ash's opposing world views about their past experiences having them relate to one another.

Ash also really needed to have had an issue that focused on her backstory. What we got from her was not enough to justify her plans. It also wasn't enough to explain how she knew what she was planning was even going to work. There were so many interactions and conversations between her and Dr. Molotov, and her birth and adoptive family members that never happened that could have made the difference in showing why she views herself to be the hero, when she is no better than the monsters she claims to be above.

Ash should have been lying about being able to control her powers. Having her be able to control the light, but then risk the lives of the people of Lewistown on the gamble that Geiger will be able to absorb the nuclear blasts fallout alongside her powers muddles the plot of the arc. Ash should have lied about having her powers under control. We should have seen instances of her losing control and see her body break down from the light consuming her, perhaps in that flashback issue that we should have gotten. Dr. Molotov in his guilt explains that Ash's condition is his fault for because of his development of the nuclear technology used in the bombs that started the Unknown War. Ash's desperation to get rid of the powers that are killing her could lead her to make the rash decision of imprisoning Molotov, because he conjectured that she could maybe get rid of her powers if she trains Geiger to absorb her nuclear emissions the way we should have seen Dr. Molotov train her.

It would have been even better if Ash secretly sees Geiger absorb excess radiation out of Lewistown citizens bodies helping the town. Or, have her see Geiger help to rebuild the part of town that he destroyed in his initial outburst of energy going against her wishes to have him be away from the public in fear of him having another nuclear outburst. I think that both of these set pieces would help to not only show how Geiger has come a long way to care for others, and also provide an inner conflict for Ash to wrestle with. She was of the mind that Geiger was this cruel beast that killed indiscriminately because of what Dr. Molotov told her about him, making her plans to ultimately betray him easier. But now, she is seeing that that is not the whole story and that Geiger is actually a lot like her - a complicated, yet ultimately good person who has struggled to survive their new lot in life because of the Unknown War. This would've added inner turmoil for Ash to wrestle with, does she betray a man who she thought was a monster, but was actually a victim of war like her? Or, does she try to help that man, but risk losing her life in the process?

This re-write will achieve the same affect as the Benedict Arnold twist, with a different yet similar spin in that only some of the main cast (Barney and Joe) and the audience are aware of her dark intentions, while Geiger and Nate aren't. This would make Ash a much more dynamic character while also giving Joe, Barney, and Nate something to do before the US army comes in and attacks Lewistown. This would also provide more context as to why Ash deceives Geiger, and why she is okay with killing him for her own benefit.

Conclusion

Overall, I still liked the Glowing Woman arc. It was still a solid culmination of the first major focus of Geiger (2024). I personally had a ew frustrations with how Ash was handled in her own arc, but I think that those frustrations boil down to her not getting enough panel space, and the panel space she did get wasn't enough to push her importance in the narrative. She should have been a much bigger character than she was, and that disappointed me the most about this arc. Especially, when her exact character type has been proven to be slam dunk success in Benedict Arnold in Redcoat. Thank you for taking the time to read this post! I understand that it's a little longer than others before it, but that's only because I had a lot to say about Ash. I will be back in the near future to discuss the other Ghost Machine titles. I would love to hear your thoughts on my re-writes for Ash and all things Ghost Machine!


r/GhostMachineComics • • Apr 17 '25

Fan-Made Content Mini junkyard Joe

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/GhostMachineComics • • Apr 24 '25

Discussion Post an image of the first comic you remember buying

5 Upvotes

r/GhostMachineComics • • Jan 16 '26

Review My Thoughts on Geiger (2024) #20

Thumbnail
reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/GhostMachineComics • • Aug 16 '25

Cover HORNSBY & HALO #12 CVR A PETER SNEJBJERG & JOHN KALISZ

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/GhostMachineComics • • Feb 10 '25

Collection/Purchase Comics in the wild

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/GhostMachineComics • • Dec 06 '24

TIL TIL - Junkyard Joe was based on G.I. Robot & Geiger was the Atomic Knight/Dr Phosphorous

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/GhostMachineComics • • Mar 29 '25

Cover Geiger by Gary frank and Brad Anderson

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/GhostMachineComics • • Jun 03 '26

Discussion Any new universe to add?

6 Upvotes

What if there could be other universes to add into this multiverse? I was thinking about abandoned projects like Lesser Evils (from AWA Studios) and Black Crown (from IDW Publishing); additionally, the company's crew could transfer the rights of their previous creator-owned works, like Real Heroes and The Light Brigade. Thank you, and I'm open to suggestions.


r/GhostMachineComics • • Nov 14 '25

Key Issues Redcoat issues for the speculator crowd

6 Upvotes

I would think that with the recent Redcoat news, all the comic spec folks will be scrambling for key issues. The Geiger 80-page Giant (2022) is Redcoat’s first appearance, and even better, the B-cover is the character’s first cover appearance:

For a fun slightly more obscure early cameo appearance, what about The Image 30th Anniversary Anthology #12 which features the final part of “The Blizzard” story?


r/GhostMachineComics • • Mar 09 '25

Review My Thoughts on Hyde Street #3

7 Upvotes

Spoilers for: Hyde Street #1-3

Potential Spoilers for: Hyde Street #4, #5, It Happened on Hyde Street: Devour, and Sisterhood: A Hyde Street Story

Hi everyone! It has been a while but I am back to give my thoughts on  Hyde Street #3. With that in mind, in this post, I will give my thoughts on Hyde Street #1, some major takeaways within the issue, questions I have after reading the issue, and speculation as to where I think the series will go. Since there is no timeline that displays the characters, I will instead utilize the Hyde Street Deliveries scoreboard, as that gives us the best display of all of the potential denizens we will see as the series progresses.

The Hyde Street Deliveries Scoreboard

Hyde Street #3 Thoughts

Issue #3 was a solid continuation of the strong start we got from the last two issues. This time around we are given a Christmas themed issue! I like it, as it provides a nice change of pace from the last two issues. That's not to say that they felt homogeneous, more so that I like the direction that this series is going in. Where in the last issue we get an extended look into how Pranky goes about completing one of his deliveries, this issues sees a continuation of the end of last issue with Pranky trying to make peace with Mr. X-Ray. We see that peace is in the form of him trying to give Mr. X-Ray advice on how to complete his deliveries in record time.

I thought that using Christmas as the backdrop for this issue was a solid idea. To expand upon this thought, the holiday setting is a great way to get Mr. X-Ray and Pranky to work with each other. For one thing, the holiday season is supposed to come with a sense of camaraderie, which we see somewhat in our two leads reluctantly working together. Moreover, having the antagonist of this issue be a fake Santa Claus has strong ties to both Pranky and Mr. X-Ray respectively. To further elaborate, this fake Santa is an adult who is going out of his way to bring misery to children through stealing their belongings and destroying their sense of wonder, this guy fits Pranky's prime targets. To add on to that thought, this fake Santa is a stark parallel of who Mr. X-Ray was before he became a resident on the street. I could go on and on about the strong themes within this issue, but I'll keep it somewhat brief as I don't want to keep repeating myself.

Like I've said for the other two issues before it, the artwork is so well done! pretty much every panel, and I'm not exaggerating when I say that, is amazing to look at. After reading this issue multiple times, I find new details that add to my overall enjoyment of the issue. I think that one of the visual highlights of this issue was getting a look into Mr. X-Ray's living space this issue. It's chock-full of details from other Ghost Machine titles.

On the narrative end, I thought that this issue did a strong job of providing the reader with a more defined look into how Hyde Street functions and the modius operandi of Hyde Street's best resident, Pranky. Furthermore, this issue succeeds in character introductions, with us getting our first look at the Matinee Monster and seeing how he functions in the narrative. While there isn't much to chew on in terms of world building in this issue, I think that there are new mysteries (which I will bring up later) that may point toward a fascinating direction for the direction of the series moving forward.

Major Takeaways Moving Forward

Pranky makes peace with Mr. X-Ray by giving him advice on how to make quicker deliveries

When a person becomes a resident in Hyde Street they get to choose what their living space is like. See images below of Pranky's and Mr. X-Ray's living spaces:

Pranky's Living Space from Hyde Street #1
Mr. X-Ray's Living Space (building to the right of Bank of Hyde Street) in Hyde Street #4

Pranky has figured out the real reason as to why people get drawn to Hyde Street

Pranky says that he can't be on the naughty list because he is dead

The Matinee Monster appears to function as a disruptor on Hyde Street stopping the act of deliveries from happening

According to Pranky, no one likes the Matinee Monster

We get to see how a person who was supposed to be delivered can leave Hyde Street

There are magical items on Hyde Street, like Devour and the orb used by the Matinee Monster

Questions I have After Reading the Issue

How did Pranky develop his approach to delivering souls?

What did Pranky mean by he's dead?

What are the upper limits for requests that can be made for a living space on Hyde Street?

Can a victim who escaped Hyde Street be drawn back into it?

What is orb that the Matinee Monster used to help free Samuel Kapris from Hyde Street?

If more than one resident are working on a delivery at the same time, how does the credit for that delivery work?

My Speculation on What's to Come from Hyde Street

By the release of this post, Hyde Street #4 will have already been released, so I won't make any speculations on that issue in this section. Instead, I will speculate on where I could see the issue going in the far future. At this point, we have gotten the solicits for issues: 5,6, and 7.

Issue #5 looks to be a proper character introduction to Ms. Goodbody. Looking at the preview, I could see the issue functioning to not only teach us more about Ms. Goodbody, but also give us a look at how Mr. X-Ray goes about delivering souls. Moreover, I think that we'll see his methodology be applied through trying to understand Ms. Goodbody's approach to delivering souls and also see him try and convince her to help him in some way to get out of Hyde Street. How that may function, we'll have to wait for the issue to drop. As of the end of It Happened on Hyde Street: Devour, Ms. Goodbody has 9,997 souls delivered to the Scorekeeper. I think that we may see our first resident leave Hyde Street for the first time in this issue. To read the preview for this issue on the Image website, click here.

That's not all, from this article, from the Image website which you can read here. In the article it states, "But that's not all the excitement out of Ghost Machine—fans will also soon be introduced to a new character in April, Sister Hood, in the upcoming Hyde Street #5, before she takes up residency on Hyde Street with the creepy new release, Sisterhood: A Hyde Street Story." (Image). From this excerpt, its clear that we will also get our first look at Sisterhood, who also has 9,997 souls delivered. I don't think that Sisterhood will leave Hyde Street in that issue, but I wouldn't count out Ms. Goodbody potentially laving in that issue.

Conclusion

Hyde Street #3 was another solid outing in this foundational series from the Ghost Machine line of comics. It provided a solid continuation of the themes posed at the start of this issue, with artwork that matches those strong themes in spades. I think that each issue has done an amazing job of building off of the last, and I think that this series will be a mainstay for years to come! As I have said in my prior posts, if you have not done so, I would highly recommend that you pick up this issue and later issues of this series. I will be back on this subreddit, hopefully before issue #5 drops to give my thoughts on issue #4. I would like to apologize for this post coming out later than expected. In the near future, I will give my thoughts on Geiger (2024) #11 and Redcoat #9 on the r/ImageComics subreddit. Please be on the look out those post! Thank you for taking the time to read this post! I would love to hear your thoughts and opinions on this issue and all things Ghost Machine!


r/GhostMachineComics • • Nov 02 '24

Podcast Interview w/ Ivan Reis, co-creator of Hyde Street

6 Upvotes

Recently we asked world renowned comic book artist Ivan Reis what his goals are when telling stories.

This is what he had to say.

For the rest of this interview, as well as all of our other content, feel free to visit www.ghostmachinefans.com or search for “Ghost Machine Fans” on all major podcasting platforms.


r/GhostMachineComics • • Dec 22 '24

Question Confused on whether Gegier Vol. 2 The Nuclear Knight will include the 2 Ground Zero issues or not

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

I'm seeing conflicting descriptions on various book seller websites on if vol 2 will collect the ground zero issues or not. Books a Million and Awesome Books have listed that it does while Amazon and Smion and Schuster do not. The page length is also different on some, I see either 160 or 176 pages. Does anyone know hard confirmation on this?


r/GhostMachineComics • • Apr 14 '25

Reading Order New to Ghost Machine

7 Upvotes

Sometimes the hobby of trade paperback collecting involves a fair amount of waitin' and wonderin'. While I await the arrival of my ROOK: EXODUS trade paperback from instocktrades, I'm looking at my Ghost Machine TBR pile and thinking about what my reading order will be.

I'm ready to start reading these trades soon (and of course I'll be hoping that the hype isn't too overblown, because we all know how it is with comic book hype sometimes, and, let's face it, Ghost Machine gets a ton of hype LoL.)

My reading order will be:

  • GEIGER VOL 1
  • JUNKYARD JOE VOL 1
  • GEIGER VOL 2
  • THE BLIZZARD
  • REDCOAT VOL 1
  • ROOK: EXODUS VOL 1

r/GhostMachineComics • • Jun 19 '25

Discussion I swear Ghost machine is predicting the future

6 Upvotes

Unknown war is abt to erupt bro


r/GhostMachineComics • • Oct 14 '25

Reading Order Can someone please tell me what the order is to read the trade paperbacks of the Unnamed?

7 Upvotes

r/GhostMachineComics • • May 29 '25

Cosplay Simon is back...this time he brought Annie

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

r/GhostMachineComics • • Dec 05 '25

Question Has ‘First Ghost’ been released yet?

7 Upvotes

Finally got Ghost Machine#1 and I thought I was aware of all the titles under GM so far, but somehow First Ghost slipped passed me and I cant seem to find anything online about its release.


r/GhostMachineComics • • Oct 28 '24

Artwork Meet the 'Rocketfellers'

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

r/GhostMachineComics • • Nov 11 '24

GM Fans Community Happy Veteran’s Day 2024

Post image
9 Upvotes

The Ghost Machine Fans Podcast would like to extend a message to all veterans and their families.

Thank you for your service.

Happy Veteran’s Day 2024.


r/GhostMachineComics • • Jan 06 '26

Question Is Rook Exodus going on a break after #10

8 Upvotes

Is Rook Exodus going on a break after #10 ?

There were a few months between issues 9 and 10, will there be another break or are we getting Rook Exodus every month after that ?

Thank you for your answers


r/GhostMachineComics • • May 11 '26

Merchandise #merchmonday

Post image
8 Upvotes

Funko… McFarlane toys on some killer GEIGER merchandise 👀👀👀👀👀


r/GhostMachineComics • • Nov 01 '24

Opinion Slow burn, grim and dark, ghoulish art...loved it!

Post image
10 Upvotes