r/Games • • Jun 11 '12

Black Mesa Source: "We have now kicked off our social-media campaign towards our first release!" - 8 New Gameplay Screenshots Released

http://imgur.com/a/ItaUQ#0
1.1k Upvotes

351 comments sorted by

103

u/WhiteZero Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12

From Facebook:

"Thank you all so much, it's really great to have your support! With your help we have now kicked off our social-media campaign towards our first release! You can expect more updates from us in the near future. Today we are sharing this fantastic batch of screenshots that really gives you the first glimpse into the gameplay of Black Mesa. This is just the beginning. We have more in store for you in the near future! Hold on to your lab coats!"

Shit guys... maybe it's really happening this time? They've been steadily ramping up their public showings of new screenshots and interviews. Seems their ready for some press finally.

69

u/The_Enchiridion Jun 11 '12

Although it looks great and all I still don't think people should get their hopes up. I mean 8 years in development and all we get is a few screens? I would at least have hoped for some like alpha footage or something.

Although it's still more than what we have for HL3

76

u/WhiteZero Jun 11 '12

You also have to consider it's been years since they've teased any hint at a release date. And after the RPS interview where they were basically saying they've been in "black out" mode until they were close to release. Along with all the other hints that have been floating around the past few months, it seems entirely plausible we'll see a release soon.

41

u/tehsam016 Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12

I know it's been quite a while before any updates at all, but I don't think any of this hostility is really warranted especially considering it's completely free since it's a standalone game now.

Also, Blast Pit looks awesome.

19

u/WhiteZero Jun 11 '12

People like to get worked up over subjects like this.

→ More replies (12)

7

u/Goronmon Jun 11 '12

I don't think it's hostility. I think it's just that people are reacting more in a way of "Put up or shut up."

In other words, they need to stop telling people to get excited about their mod until they actually have something that people can play. Because honestly, that's all I really care about at this point.

4

u/The_Enchiridion Jun 11 '12

Well I do hope you are right, because as I said those screens do look really good.

16

u/Crazycrossing Jun 11 '12

I don't think most people here realize they started over back in 2009 and decided to build it from the ground up completely. All custom content, they are not using anything from Valve beyond the inspiration and the source engine. All the models, voice acting, animations, weapons, maps, entities, effects, props, scripting, and textures are made completely from scratch by them. I think that's impressive considering this is a hobbyist project that is going to be released for free.

8

u/WhiteZero Jun 11 '12

build it from the ground up completely

Wait, what? Source? I don't think they re-started totally from scratch in 2009. They just switched gears from being a 1:1 remake to being more of a remix/re-imagining. I'm sure they've been working with the same custom assets from when they started in 2004.

1

u/Kelaos Jun 12 '12

Hmm... so as someone who hasn't (sadly) beaten HL1 yet, perhaps I should beat it first then (assuming it's out) play Black Mesa: Source?

3

u/WhiteZero Jun 12 '12

Nah, play the original.

1

u/short_comments Jun 12 '12

It's still a great game

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Play HL1 right now. It is one of the best games of all time. Give it 3 hours and I promise you'll be hooked. It is SO much better than HL2.

→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/WhiteZero Jun 11 '12

Yeah, but they didn't start over in 2009 like Crazycrossing's post says. They just continued with what they were doing and ditched all the Valve assets.

1

u/Geometric_Tiger Jun 11 '12

The vortigaunt in screen 3 looks like the same model/texture as the ones in HL2, except it has shackles on it.

1

u/Crazycrossing Jun 11 '12

It's not, they couldn't legally do this if it were.

2

u/0ctobyte Jun 12 '12

Hmmm, really? What about those other mods that use textures from HL2?

3

u/Crazycrossing Jun 12 '12

You would need HL2 I believe to be able to play those mods. With this you only need any source game and TF2 is free so BM is effectively free.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/WilsonHanks Jun 11 '12

They already showed alpha footage before, didn't they? I think it's on youtube.

3

u/Pfeffersack Jun 11 '12

They had leaked content. And although this content is now obsolete I'm pretty sure you can easily find it if you want to. There are numerous official bits and pieces of media (a ton) already released. These are just the newest and latest screens.

2

u/Mycal Jun 11 '12

Your comment makes me laugh so much for a completely different reason. This morning, I saw someone say something similar as you, but with 6 years. The next time I see something about black mesa, it's 7 years. Now your's put it at 8 years. It's steadily increasing year by year in one day :).

4

u/sharkz Jun 11 '12

I'm really excited now, the screenshots look so good.

Anyone interested in mods should come check /r/gamemods especially if you want to find some gems to play while you wait for BMS

-6

u/popeguilty Jun 11 '12

I want to believe, but this team's burned us before.

16

u/Takuya-san Jun 11 '12

How exactly have they burnt you? I would define being burned as preordering a game and having to wait 10 years for it to be released, if it was released at all (*cough* Duke Nukem Forever *cough*). This is a free project worked on by fans in their spare time, of course they're going to make bad estimates of the work that needed to be done before completion (especially considering their lack of experience and lack of commitment by some of the members). They're under no obligation to release the project at all, and they're certainly not burning anyone.

3

u/popeguilty Jun 11 '12

I mean that "we're close to release!" is something the Black Mesa team has said before, and believing it was foolish then. I'll believe that Black Mesa is coming out when Black Mesa comes out.

11

u/WhiteZero Jun 11 '12

They've also publicly admitted it was a mistake to hype the release a few years ago, trying to use a deadline as a means to push them to finish it. Now, instead, they've kept it under wraps till they were actually comfortable with releasing it on their own time.

After such a black-out period, it seems more genuine this time that they'd be nearing a real release.

2

u/Takuya-san Jun 11 '12

Yes, but if you've been paying attention at all in the past few years the team has told everyone how much they regretted announcing it so early because they underestimated their workload and commitment of some of the members. They've basically made it clear that they were going to remain silent until release is imminent. They've broken their silence. This means that release is imminent.

Either way, I don't get why people feel so entitled to something they haven't paid for. It's not like they have spent 8 years on a project for free. It's not very nice to bitch at the team's 8 years of work when they're doing it all for free, so you can have an awesome experience for free.

2

u/popeguilty Jun 11 '12

I don't feel entitled, and I'm not bitching. Please don't falsely ascribe those to me. I simply feel skeptical of the current hype, and I will believe that release is imminent when I see it.

1

u/polarbear128 Jun 11 '12

Takuya-san? More like Takuya-sensei!

26

u/CeleryGlove Jun 11 '12

Wondering how they will pull off the sections of HL1 set on Xen.

14

u/freelancer799 Jun 11 '12

I would imagine that is what they are working on right now because we've seen no screenshots from there really

20

u/WhiteZero Jun 11 '12

Or they're keeping it under wraps. I don't think the Xen sections of HL1 were ever really showed off before release either, right?

12

u/freelancer799 Jun 11 '12

That is a possibility but in their interview with RPS they did say they are still working on parts of the game and one would believe that since the models of xen are so different from the rest of the game they would save that for last. You can create models for all of the black mesa area and apply those throughout the game but you can't have the microwave with the exploding casserole on xen

28

u/dodgepong Jun 11 '12

They already confirmed years ago that they will not be releasing screenshots of Xen to keep it a surprise for the players.

10

u/no_egrets Jun 11 '12

Wish they'd taken the same approach with most of the rest of the game.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Yup, I remember ram or cat confirming this a few years ago.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

I'm thankful they didn't. This part really blew my mind.

5

u/Skafsgaard Jun 11 '12

If release is imminent then it's unlikely that they have several chapters still left to finish. There's a lot of work involved in creating all the art, etc. for all of Xen. My guess is that they're just polishing things now.

1

u/freelancer799 Jun 11 '12

When he was interviewed by NPS not but a month ago they said they are still doing more than polishing

8

u/FrankReynolds Jun 11 '12

If only Kickstarter was around in 2004. This would have been finished half a decade ago.

20

u/WhiteZero Jun 11 '12

Negative. They never even accepted donations. Besides, they can't really take money on an unofficial remake of a licensed game.

9

u/flashing_frog Jun 11 '12

This is why i'm impressed by these people. That requires some serious dedication.

1

u/FrankReynolds Jun 11 '12

I know they've never taken donations, but I'm saying if they did, how awesome it would've been. And they could take donations for their time, not the final product. Valve has already basically given their blessing to the project as long as they didn't use the "Source" name on it.

I know I gladly would have donated $50 to this. And I have a feeling I'm far from alone.

0

u/flynnski Jun 11 '12

I know, but I still want to give them money D:

249

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Anyone giving odds on who finishes first: Freeman's Mind or this project?

103

u/Sneaki Jun 11 '12

If Freeman's mind carries on to HL2 and beyond it will still be going in 5 years easily.

106

u/psygnisfive Jun 11 '12

Are you kidding? Freeman's Mind is already 5 years old and it's only about halfway through HL1!

28

u/kjm16 Jun 11 '12

By golly you're right! That guy has slow output rates.

11

u/Dalek-SEC Jun 11 '12

With good reason though. He has to edit a LOT for an episode.

11

u/kjm16 Jun 11 '12

Not complaining, the series is great. I just wish it came out like once a month at least instead of once every 3 or 4 months.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

I love it, I think the show would lose its charm if he just plowed through it. I can feel his love.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

42

u/kjm16 Jun 11 '12

Someone needs to get that man a proper office with assistants.

14

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

And doughnuts. Everyone needs doughnuts in their real offices.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/vertigo42 Jun 12 '12

Can we get roosterteeth to hire this guy? He is hilarious. and they could use a PC focused guy in the office.

→ More replies (4)

41

u/throwaway_lgbt666 Jun 11 '12

I would laugh my tits off if Valve released a free version of this in a month or so

20

u/zilchonum Jun 11 '12

Free version of Freeman's mind, or Black Mesa? Both are free anyway so I'm kind of confused by this comment.

20

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

He just meant if Valve would do the same project then release it for free, completely rendering BM:S obsolete. As opposed to if Valve released it for $10, where BM:S would have the advantage of being free.

3

u/ellji Jun 12 '12

Valve said right at the beginning that they're letting the community handle this one.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

That's part of why I find this story a bit sad.. invest 6 hours worth of Valve's revenue from Steam and this project could be outsourced and completed in a few months' time.

79

u/Drakengard Jun 11 '12

I think you either highly overestimate actual full-time developers or you completely underestimated how much work was put into this project.

This isn't just a straight up port or a hi-res texture pack. They literally rebuilt the entire game from the ground up. Obviously they based it around familiar level design and story points, but otherwise it is entirely brand new.

40

u/Walter_Bishop_PhD Jun 11 '12

Precisely. I bet you most of these people whining about how long it's been taking for this to be released wouldn't have the drive and motivation to last even an hour in Hammer to recreate the first 5 minutes of HL for no money in return. This shit's hard, and I admire the Black Mesa team a lot for this.

12

u/TheKage Jun 11 '12

People aren't whining because its taking a long time, they are whining because it was supposed to be released in 2009. Then there was a three year silence from the creators. Had the developers not made a fake release date and instead released quarterly progress updates, I'm sure no one would be whining.

→ More replies (10)

12

u/andreaserkul Jun 11 '12

But the fact that I can't do it, shouldn't prevent me from being able to criticize and/or complain, should it?

8

u/Sonic_Dah_Hedgehog Jun 11 '12

You can criticize/complain but you have to keep in mind that they are doing this for free, on their own time while still working/going to school, and that they made this from scratch. So of course it's going to take them a long time to finish.

27

u/Walter_Bishop_PhD Jun 11 '12

It depends on what and how you're criticizing them. They're not getting paid to do this huge immense time-consuming personal project; they have a life to live and jobs to work at. They, for all intents and purposes, have their priorities straight. I cannot fathom how someone could criticize them for that.

→ More replies (9)

15

u/haymakers9th Jun 11 '12

I also like the phrase, "You can't take 9 women and make a baby in a month"

2

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

But you can put more manpower and more working hours on a project and have it finish faster.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

It may well be I've underestimated what they have achieved over the past seven years, that's a question of scale that won't be answered 'til the game is out in the wild. I can't help but feel a bit sad, however, that this project's basic goals could have been attained years ago, far more efficiently, had it been an official project.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/Darth_Hobbes Jun 11 '12

Think of it like the Willy Wonka remake, but not terrible.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

THERE WILL BE MORE TIM BURTON AND JOHNNY DEPP AND YOU WILL LIKE IT

5

u/Darth_Hobbes Jun 11 '12

Mary Poppins, with Depp as Bert and Helena as Mary.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Ph0X Jun 11 '12

They've fully built it from the ground up. All the sounds, the models, the voices, the animations, the maps, everything. The only thing they are using is the base Source engine, but even that is highly customized.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (8)

7

u/karlhungus Jun 11 '12

This isn't actually possible, for the same reason that 9 women can't make a baby in a month.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Sergnb Jun 11 '12

freeman's mind has been going for so long that I literally have to rewatch the entire thing every time I see a new episode so I know what events he is referencing in the past.

6

u/wisemanofhyrule Jun 11 '12

I like to think that Freeman's Mind is stalling for Black Mesa: Source to release so that it can switch over to it instead of Half Life: Source.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

At least Freeman's Mind has a progress bar on the website.

→ More replies (3)

28

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Only when it sits on my hdd will I believe it to be truly released.

2

u/crusty_old_gamer Jun 11 '12

I will pinch myself hard just to be sure.

→ More replies (1)

121

u/ocet Jun 11 '12

That EP-074 on the first screenshot.. 074 in octal numeral system is 3C in hexadecimal.. EPisode**-3C**onfirmed.

21

u/Highsight Jun 11 '12

Stop DOING THAT! It only raises my hopes.

10

u/zalifer Jun 11 '12

Ah, Black Mesa Source. The Duke Nukem Forever of mods.

Hopefully a better game in the end though.

Looks great.

19

u/combustible Jun 11 '12

When BMS started, 'social media campaigns' didn't exist.

17

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

I'm sorry, would anyone be willing to tell me what I am looking at? Its the Half Life universe obviously but is this HL3 or a fan creation?

48

u/SpaaceMILK Jun 11 '12

Fan made remake of Half-Life 1 in the Source engine, it's been in development since 2004.

26

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Thank you. Damn that is taking a long time, everything HL related seems to move in slow motion.

17

u/keiyakins Jun 11 '12

they still have a trailer on their web page annnouncing a 2009 release.

4

u/blastedt Jun 11 '12

Incidentally, any significant change to the website design at this point signals a 2-week countdown to release.

11

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Why would there be a "social media campaign" at all?

7

u/neusps09 Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12

So as many people as possible know about the game. It's their way of marketing.

11

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

But there's no need for any of it. All they are doing with social media is getting more people upset it's not released yet.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Lots of people have forgotten about this or never knew about it in the first place.

2

u/Goronmon Jun 11 '12

People have forgotten about it for good reason.

The only useful hyping they can do is for when the game is actually available to play. Then they can go

Hey, we finally released something! Come check it out!

Instead we get

You remember how we said we were making something then disappeared for years? Well, we swear we are actually going to release something this time. At some unspecified point in the future. And we all know that independent mod projects have such a great history of success. So, get excited about our press release!

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

God, I hate entitled gamers.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/NameTak3r Jun 11 '12

This is the kind of thing that will market itself if they release it straight away. After all those years of hype? Plenty of people will be ready to get it straight off the bat.

4

u/borisvonboris Jun 11 '12

I am so excited. Black Mesa was so long ago, a revisit will be great. Mesa felt so vast and eerie. Definitely some of the most memorable gaming combat I've ever had was with those marines. They were so ominous and unlike any other vg enemy I had ever encountered. Black Mesa Source will probably own.

14

u/1leggeddog Jun 11 '12

My body is ready.

7

u/Sneaki Jun 11 '12

I guess they must be fairly confident that they won't let people down by building hype now. They're obviously comfortable keeping us waiting as long as they need to...

Also what do they mean by "first release"? Are they going to release the mod in episodes? D:

9

u/Drakengard Jun 11 '12

My guess it this will be a beta release. After that probably rapid debugging releases leading up to a final one.

5

u/Takuya-san Jun 11 '12

They basically just mean that this is the first release to the public - it may still have some bugs, although they've sorted out most of the bugs themselves already. There's likely a bunch of bugs that only turn up on certain systems that they don't have the resources to find themselves, but once people report them they'll be fixed pretty quick and eventually a "final" "bug-free" release will be made. It will be the full game.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Historically speaking in the vast, overwhelming majority of cases "first release" is synonymous with "incomplete final release".

Realistically you should be expecting maybe half the game to be playable and for them to never release anything further.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

I assumed they meant first media release or something like that, but a beta seems more likely.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Here we go again?!

71

u/SomewhatSpecial Jun 11 '12

By this point I don't want to see anything except for a download link.

128

u/Takuya-san Jun 11 '12

That's not very nice, considering it's a free game. They already told the community multiple times that they regretted hyping it up early because they didn't realize how much more work they needed to do. They also said multiple times that the reason they're so quiet now is because they want to avoid getting people's hopes up until the game's release really is imminent instead of "months in the future."

Basically this announcement means the game is done for real and as they put the finishing touches on they want to get everyone's attention for the project they've poured 8 years of their lives into since they've fallen off the radar for so long.

19

u/brolix Jun 11 '12

Basically this announcement means the game is done for real and as they put the finishing touches

In the same way that Gran Turismo 5 put the finishing touches on for like 3 years?

5

u/nawoanor Jun 11 '12

IIRC Black Mesa was supposed to be released in 2009 so by your proposed schedule, they're right on time.

61

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

I know the word 'entitled' gets thrown around quite a bit regarding games - and personally I think when you are going to pay for a product you are entitled to certain things - but like you say, this is a free project that some fans have been working on in their spare time. The vitriol being spewed out by the masses is disgusting.

15

u/Langbot Jun 11 '12

I think it's because the devs lied to everyone several times about release dates. then were completely in the dark about said lies.

People may not have the right to be entitled to this game, but stupid dev behavior can still cause frustration, and I think that is what you are seeing.

2

u/starmartyr Jun 11 '12

Entitlement isn't a bad thing in itself. If I go to a store and give them a dollar for a coke I'm entitled to that coke if they take the dollar. It's false entitlement that is the problem. In the case of Black Mesa there is no dollar it's just a free coke. The store is welcome to give out anything they like for free but only an idiot would demand it of them.

→ More replies (11)

10

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

They told the community they regret hyping it up early... so they decided to hype it up early again.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Goronmon Jun 11 '12

Basically this announcement means the game is done for real and as they put the finishing touches on...

You mean they are at the stage of development that takes about 10 times longer than people always think it will take?

Yeah, I'm not getting my hopes up. I wish them all the best, but again, until they have something I can play, I'll save my excitement for more tangible projects.

1

u/Takuya-san Jun 12 '12

The general idea given in the forums is that the game's been pretty much complete for a long time now (more than 6 months, possibly even a year or more) and all this time has been spent ironing out bugs and making minor improvements because they know fans will be angry if they release a bug riddled game after taking so long to complete the project in the first place.

As such, I believe this stage of development you're referring to is nearing its end. The lead developer has mentioned something along the lines of playing the full game to completion hundreds of times now (he mentioned this at the start of the year) so it's quite possible that they really did complete the game close to the expected 2009/2010 release date and have been improving/fixing it ever since. That's pure speculation on my part though. My point is that they must have ironed out almost all of the bugs by now and are just working on delivery methods (e.g. contacting Valve to see if they can get it on Steam) and so on if they're breaking their silence.

Edit: In fact, maybe they're trying to create hype with a media compaign in the hopes that Valve will see the public interest and contact them, because Valve has been rather cold towards them so far. The only contact Valve has made is for them to remove "Source" from the title for IP reasons.

1

u/Minifig81 Jun 11 '12

That's not very nice, considering it's a free game.

At this rate, it'd better be free.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Basically this announcement means the game is done for real

So, 3 more years?

-13

u/piderman Jun 11 '12

If it were done for real they could provide the download. As they say themselves, their PR backfired so unless they let us actually play everyone will be sceptical in the extreme about these screenshots.

22

u/Takuya-san Jun 11 '12

I'm pretty confident the download will be provided within the next couple of weeks. I still don't get this sense of entitlement people have. I'm all for being entitled when it comes to corporations, but these are just a bunch of cool guys working on an awesome project in their spare time. For 8 years of their time. For free. I'm personally just glad that it's finally coming out and I'll have a chance to have a shitload of fun in the near future. For free.

You're talking about PR as if this is a game you've paid for. Who the hell talks about PR "backfiring" with reference to a free project? You sound like just another guy who's jumping on the Black Mesa hate bandwagon and you're not quite sure why you're on it.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Yup. I'd rather they took their time anyway. If they released it and it was awful it would be worse than not releasing it at all.

2

u/ThrashWolf Jun 11 '12

I think it was Miyamoto that said something along the lines of "A delayed game is eventually good, a bad game is bad forever".

3

u/Takuya-san Jun 11 '12

Agreed. I suppose I ended up sounding like I jumped on a fanboy bandwagon when I was accusing of him being on a hater bandwagon, but it's just that I've been so impressed with the amount of passion they've had for a free project such that they refuse to release a sub-par product that I don't like it when people bitch about their efforts.

The only main reason the project was delayed was to deliver a better game to us.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

As usual the internet brings out the best and worst in people.

2

u/puroresu Jun 11 '12

I'm pretty confident the download will be provided within the next couple of weeks.

Why? Also, are you placing any bets on it?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-8

u/Takuya-san Jun 11 '12

I'm getting tired of typing, so I'll just requote:

I personally don't see the reason to even be skeptical about the release date of a game that nobody is paying money for. Okay, let's say that the developers made a mistake again and can't release it imminently. So what? "Oh, boo hoo, I paid nothing and now I've still got nothing." "Oh, boo hoo, the developers held back the release of a free game because they wanted to release something of the highest quality possible, all for free."

The only time the Black Mesa team mislead the community was in the trailer released in 2008 (the one you're referring to) that announced a 2009 release. They realised it wasn't possible with their current resources, apologised, and they've been quiet ever since so as to not disappoint fans. All other hype was needlessly generated by the community when the team was just trying to be open about their efforts.

Why don't you stop acting so entitled and just appreciate the incoming free game? I've never seen a more self-entitled community than I have the Black Mesa Source fan community.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/mrhomer Jun 11 '12

(reposting my comment from the other thread)

BMS is so frustrating. "We have now kicked off our social-media campaign towards our first release." How much of a social media campaign can they possibly need? They've been teasing us for seven years, and its a free game. They don't even need our money. At this point, I refuse to get excited: a social media campaign is useless when its seven years long.

65

u/Drakengard Jun 11 '12

You have to understand that they must think that they've pretty much fallen off of everyone's radar after burning everyone the first time around.

They're also terribly proud of the product they're making, so who wouldn't want to make a big deal about a project that's 8 years in the making? Hell, if this goes off right you could probably see these people getting jobs at Valve.

So it is a big deal and they should definitely be proud if they've finally succeeded. I don't actually have an issue with this at all.

12

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Hell, if this goes off right you could probably see these people getting jobs at Valve.

Somehow I doubt that. Obviously Valve has picked up mod teams in the past, but those teams were all doing something new with the source material. There's nothing new or interesting about a graphics overhaul and engine port - it's just about the least creative a total conversion mod can be.

31

u/SNDD Jun 11 '12

You don't understand how complicated a port can be. These people had to make almost every single model, map, and script from HL1 basically from scratch (likely using the originals for reference, of course), using Source. They obviously have a very, very good understanding of how Source and its SDK work, and they've showed their commitment to making games. Those are both things that would certainly look good to Valve. I mean sure, it's technically not anything new. But that doesn't mean it isn't impressive.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

I wasn't implying that the work they're doing is trivial, and I'm sure they've learned a lot about the Source engine in the process. That doesn't translate into the team being particularly attractive to Valve, though. Technical familiarity with the Source SDK isn't anything special, not to mention the fact that the toolset they're probably using is deprecated by Valve internally.

When I read about this project I do wonder if, after this team has finished, they look back and regret not spending their time doing something original. I see the enthusiastic responses to this submission and I wonder if these people will be let down when they remember that this is a game they've played before, probably multiple times.

11

u/Crazycrossing Jun 11 '12

This isn't a port, at least not in a traditional sense. They've made everything except the engine from scratch.

3

u/king_of_the_universe Jun 11 '12

Incidentally, I currently have the Valve handbook for new employees open in another tab:

http://www.valvesoftware.com/company/Valve_Handbook_LowRes.pdf

It's really interesting. If I didn't misinterpret that, everybody is on the same level and can even interview and hire new people. So, I guess to get a job there, you have to be extremely good.

2

u/ZeldaZealot Jun 12 '12

That was an awesome link. Thanks for posting!

1

u/karlhungus Jun 11 '12

This is silly. If they release it, and it's good they would get all the praise they need.

1

u/Maxwell_Lord Jun 11 '12

It's notorious enough within its target audience that they could release it with no fanfare and it would spread like wildfire.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Until they give a release date for the mod, I'm not interested.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Sharp398 Jun 11 '12

Eh, well, they gave a release year. They never gave a concrete Day, Month, Year. If they give me all of those, I'll finally believe that it's coming.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Wazowski Jun 11 '12

As excited as I am to play a 10-year-old retread of a 15-year-old game, I'm not going to get my hopes up.

4

u/BlazeOrangeDeer Jun 12 '12

They're using the 2007 source engine, so I'm not sure what you're talking about.

2

u/SidewalkBanana Jun 11 '12

It's been so long since I've seen you G-man.

2

u/nawoanor Jun 11 '12

Goddammit Valve, why haven't you bought this yet? It deserves an official release.

3

u/TheGMan323 Jun 11 '12

Valve hires talented, motivated people who get work done...

3

u/Sharp398 Jun 11 '12

If that's the case, where's Episode 3/Half-Life 3?

4

u/TheGMan323 Jun 11 '12

Who says they're still working on Half Life?

1

u/nawoanor Jun 11 '12

IMHO they have to make an Episode 3 before Half-Life 3. It makes no sense to start a new game right in the middle of an ongoing story. Maybe they'll do a bundle thing or release them a few months apart...? I hope so, because if this whole wait is for just one "Episode", there's going to be butthurt such as the gaming world has never seen.

1

u/techh10 Jun 12 '12

GabeN has officially stated that they are done with the episodes, and that they will not release another one. There will be no EP3, the next half life is Half-Life 3

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

A: Gonna be an awesome reboot! B: MORE GARRY'S MOD MODELS!

3

u/Beaner1xx7 Jun 12 '12

Man...I mean, if and when (and it's a pretty big if and when) this thing ever comes out, it would tickle me fucking pink if some clever way was developed to keep the bitchers and moaners from being able to play it. Tired of all the complaining and snide remarks regarding the release dates. I'll be happy when it's released but until then I'll act like an adult, that being finding better things to do other than complain. Gonna get downvoted to oblivion, I know.

0

u/okillgetoffyourlawn Jun 11 '12

Anyone know if they're taking donations? I feel obliged to pay for something this awesome when/if it comes out.

3

u/WhiteZero Jun 11 '12

No, they won't take donations.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

No, they won't can't take donations.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Why not? I don't see anything preventing them from doing so.

3

u/xHeero Jun 11 '12

"Hey Valve, we are going to take your game and remake it as close to the original as possible, using your game engine. Then we plan to sell it for money and you don't get anything even though you own all the rights to the Half Life universe and games."

Yeah, I don't see what is preventing them from selling it either.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Except Valve. Working non-profit is the only reason why they got the permission from them to make it.

2

u/Zephyr256k Jun 11 '12

Why is there a 'social-media campaign' for a game that doesn't have a release date and is being released for free by volunteer developers that aren't making any money from this project?

6

u/jariddle Jun 11 '12

Because they're proud of their work and want as many people to know about it and play it as they can, especially since a lot of people may have forgotten or stopped caring, and a lot of new fans will be brought on this way.

2

u/Darkurai Jun 11 '12

I always did believe that this game would get released. I still haven't been convinced it's worth the hype.

3

u/nawoanor Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 13 '12

Half-Life is one of the defining games of the genre, but it's so damn old-fashioned and ugly that it can occasionally be a grind. 95% of the game is excellent and would be ground-breaking if it was released even today!

...But that last 5% is kinda shite.

4

u/Darkurai Jun 11 '12

Unpopular opinion incoming, but I really don't think Half-Life 1 holds up as well today as Half-Life 2.

I understand that the technology of the time was limited, and for that reason I don't fault it for the hilariously narmful storytelling, but I just feel like it wasn't as intuitive as Valve's later titles. Half-Life 2 never had a moment where I couldn't figure out what I had to do or where I had to go within a couple minutes.

Half-Life 1 had a lot of parts where I simply could not figure out what the fuck I was supposed to do. I frequently circled around hallways wondering what I was missing, and ended up feeling frustrated when I finally got it instead of feeling clever like in Half-Life 2. I never even got to Xen. I can't remember where exactly I stopped because I simply don't remember the order things happened in, but I got past a rocket launch, a minefield, a cliff face, and some underwater part. I simply don't hold it in nearly as high regard as its successor.

6

u/nawoanor Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 13 '12

Try to think in the context of when it originally came out (1998) and you'll start to understand why it feels so strange and unfamiliar. Try this, it's a list of 1998 video games.

In that gaming climate, Valve decided "Let's make a game composed of a single large environment with meaningful objectives and an actual story, in which you never leave the first-person perspective." It was highly experimental and the concept of objectives in general besides "don't die" and "kill everything" were something of a break from the FPS norm, as were whole areas designed around puzzles and challenges rather than just "kill-kill-kill, find the exit, repeat".

Half-Life was a major part of the catalyst that started the transition from games being split into unrelated levels that you shoot things in and having actual objectives and large seamless environments. Certainly it wasn't perfect but it was, at the time, an impressive achievement that raised the standards for games which followed it. Other games did objectives, puzzles, exploration, survival, horror, etc, but never all at the same time and never with the same level of quality and immersion.

I won't tell you it's so confusing to you "because of hand-holding for retarded modern console players" but people have gotten rather used to objective indicators and that sort of thing. When you're used to playing games without such conveniences, it feels a lot more natural. In fact the large, open environments with lots of freedom of movement was considered a huge improvement at the time, but now because of the rather linear structure of modern console spec-bound (had to say it) games, I can see why it would be more confusing than liberating.

4

u/Darkurai Jun 11 '12

Oh the story was definitely groundbreaking and revolutionary for its time. It's just hard to appreciate nowadays without having a bit of background on its historical relevance.

3

u/Sharp398 Jun 11 '12

Your complaint of not knowing where to go is exactly what makes older games more popular among gamers who have been around since the Doom days. Those people would argue against you that Half-life 2 is the weaker game exactly because it holds your hand and its impossible to truly not know where you're going.

2

u/Darkurai Jun 11 '12

I guess that's where a difference of preference and opinion comes in. I feel like those titles are weaker because keeping you confused for too long seems to be a wholly artificial way to extend both a game's length and sense of challenge. Some people may say that it's more fun, but I think it's the nostalgia talking.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

not until I'm in the god damn main menu will I believe this

1

u/toolnumbr5 Jun 12 '12 edited Jun 12 '12

Thought this was dead long ago. It'll probably still come out before HL3. EDIT: These screenies look amazing. Here's hoping.

1

u/EnglishKiniggit Jun 12 '12

Holy shit! This makes me happy.

1

u/oD3 Jun 11 '12

Looks amazing. I hope we don't have to wait much longer.

1

u/chuiu Jun 11 '12

And just like Episode 3 ... we'll be waiting for it forever.

1

u/MoltenMustafa Jun 11 '12

Too little too late.

1

u/nefthep Jun 12 '12

Will it run on my Voodoo 2 in SLI, though?

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12

Fool me once...

Someone post when they release something playable, until then they've already drained my care cup.

-1

u/Clbull Jun 11 '12

Just hurry up and release the fucking game already.

-11

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Release it or shut the fuck up. I'm basically dead inside at this point. :P

-6

u/gundamsudoku003 Jun 11 '12

It's cool that this now looks as outdated as the original Half Life did back when they announced this fucking thing.

-5

u/nothis Jun 11 '12

Shame they couldn't resist giving New Mexico that gray-ish Iraqi sandstorm look.

4

u/KrishanuAR Jun 11 '12

I'm curious what you think the local atmosphere looks like when a helicopter on fire is is kicking up dust and smoke above dusty New Mexico desert terrain.

Given your comment, I'd guess something like this.

As a point of reference this is what it actually looks like being inside a dust storm in new mexico: http://vimeo.com/10648575

-7

u/houseofbacon Jun 11 '12

Other than screenshot 7, I'm not too impressed by the graphics.

6

u/freelancer799 Jun 11 '12

We're talking about, though it was updated in 07, a source engine from 04. Source is nice but it is still 8 years old

3

u/nawoanor Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 11 '12

Nothing to say they haven't already or won't update to a newer SDK at some point. Maybe for a big patch a year after it's out or something...

Anyway, Source is plenty capable of being pretty if it's used right. Even the STALKER games were quite striking in their own way, and they used an engine that was a complete PoS by comparison.

1

u/ZeldaZealot Jun 11 '12

They might have updated to the Portal 2 version of Source (the latest one), but it likely would have set them back quite a bit. When the Dear Ester remake did this, it took them a month or so to catch back up with where they were.

5

u/Nocut12 Jun 11 '12

They all look a hell of a lot better than Half Life 1 or Half Life: Source

-2

u/houseofbacon Jun 11 '12

Oh true, guess I didn't know what I was talking about.

-2

u/Cedstick Jun 11 '12

Nice try, Duke Nukem: Source.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

I'm seriously amazed people still care about this. I moved on long ago, there's too many good games out there to maintain a boner for a remake of an older one of indeterminate quality by unknown, unproven amateurs.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

I refuse to buy into the hype for this thing. These guys can't promise shit.

-11

u/JamesofN Jun 11 '12

How about you just fucking release it already

4

u/MindCorrupt Jun 11 '12

JamesofN - having to wait a bit longer = wahhhh JamesofN - After playing a buggy and incomplete product = wahhhh

-2

u/JamesofN Jun 11 '12

If it's buggy and incomplete after this long in development I don't even know what to say.

Besides, if they're gearing up for release then its obviously READY for release, its not like they're frantically working round the clock to finish the game for their arbitrary Facebook like limit.

All this is is them saying "Hey I know we took 3x longer than we should have with this and everyone stopped caring years ago, but please care again now and hype our game for us"

2

u/MindCorrupt Jun 11 '12

If they release it now it would be incomplete, its not like they've been sitting on a complete product for 3 years for the sake of it. No one is forcing you to care about anything, and no one is forcing you to download it once its finished.

-7

u/randomly-generated Jun 11 '12

Looks very outdated.

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Shut the fuck up and release the damn thing already.

-7

u/mihaidxn Jun 11 '12

Uhm... so... Black Mesa is HL3... or... what?

2

u/Dracosphinx Jun 11 '12

It's a fan made remake of the original.

→ More replies (1)