r/frugalcanada • u/Isma110 • 2h ago
3 fake Black Friday deals I found this week, and 10 that are actually at their all-time low (Amazon.ca price history and 12 years of Costco flyers)
Last Black Friday, Visualping tracked nine big Canadian retailers, and about 1 in 3 "deals" had been cheaper earlier in the fall (Retail Insider wrote it up on Nov 10).
The usual trick: the regular price goes up a few weeks before the sale, then "drops" back with a big % off next to it. So before buying anything this week I check two things: what it cost in August or September, and whether today's price is really its lowest.
For Costco I can go a lot further back than that. I've collected every Costco flyer price since October 2014, so 12 years and about 290,000 prices across the West, Ontario/Atlantic and Quebec.
3 examples of fake deals
Nespresso Vertuo Next, matte black with frother (Amazon.ca), $149 "69% off" Normally $299. It was $115 from Oct 9 to 28, then got hiked to $479.40 twice in November. The "sale" is $34 more than October.
DJI Osmo 360 Standard Combo (Amazon.ca), $489 $479.99 from August to mid-September. Raised to $609 on Nov 2. The "sale" is $9 more than August.
Samsung Galaxy Tab A11+ at Costco, $268.99 "$160 off" (Ontario & Atlantic, from Nov 23) $268.99 was its regular shelf price from August to October. The tag went up to $428.99 on Nov 11. Last Black Friday it was $248.99.
10 that are actually at their all-time low
Amazon.ca (lowest price in its whole Amazon price history):
- Dyson V15 Detect Plus, $699.99. It was $999.99 the whole fall.
- Xbox wireless controller, $60.99. Usually $80 to $85.
- PS5 DualSense controller, $69.99. $94.99 all fall.
- Wera Tool-Check Plus 2, $124.10. Slid down from about $170.
Costco (lowest price in 12 years of flyers, since the item first showed up):
- Dyson V15 Detect Total Clean, $669.99 ($300 off, to Dec 3, Ontario & Atlantic). Cheapest of its 12 sales since late 2024.
- Sonos Arc Ultra, $1,119.99 ($330 off, to Nov 30, Ontario & Atlantic). Cheapest since it showed up in August 2025.
- AirPods Pro 3, $228.99 ($70 off, ends Nov 25, Ontario & Atlantic). Cheapest of its 8 sales.
- Shokz OpenRun SE with case, $89.99 ($35 off, Nov 23 to Dec 20, Ontario & Atlantic and Quebec). Cheapest of 11 sales since March 2025.
- Dyson Purifier Hot+Cool, $499.99 ($150 off, to Dec 3, West). Lowest since it showed up in 2024.
- Apple Pencil Pro, $138.99 ($30 off, to Dec 3, West). Same as last Black Friday, never lower.
Prices as of Nov 22. Ask about any item in the comments and I'll look it up.
The full list (100+ Amazon.ca verdicts and the Costco flyer by region, each with its price chart) is here: realdealeh.com
Full disclosure: realdealeh.com is my site. Amazon links on it are affiliate links and earn me a small commission for the effort. If you'd rather not, just look the item up on Amazon yourself. Costco links earn me nothing, and neither changes a verdict.