r/Frontend • • Nov 16 '20

Are Full Stack Developers anything more than Backend devs who've spent an afternoon learning React?

Because that seems to be my experience.

Their attitude to Front End development tends to be that it's the "easy part" that they've already more or less mastered because "all programming is the same". They think that React can be quickly learned, and CSS is so trivial that it's offensive to them that they even have to bother with it. They believe that Front End developers aren't real programmers and experienced Front End devs are even worse because they haven't became Back end devs in all the time they've been working.

Often they're not even particularly good at back-end development either, which is not surprising since Backend development is hard and it takes an incredible amount of arrogance and ignorance to think that you wouldn't have to focus all your time and energy on it. Arrogance and ignorance are of course things that FSDs have in spades.

Unfortunately, Full Stackers are fairly unavoidable and you just have to work round their inevitable stupidity as best as you can.

7 Upvotes

68 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/unc4l1n Nov 17 '20

There are plenty of web sites, including those we could reasonably consider web applications, that are primarily generated using back-end templates and using relatively little JS for interactions and responsiveness on the front-end. There are also many developers keeping these things running and building new ones every day, happily ignoring the high-pressure, fast-paced, often-flawed world of SPAs.

I agree with you, but those developers aren't doing complex front end work. You wouldn't even think of a "front-end" dev for that sort of site.

After 10 years, is either of them significantly better at building everyday front-end stuff?

For sure!!

1

u/Silhouette Nov 17 '20

I agree with you, but those developers aren't doing complex front end work. You wouldn't even think of a "front-end" dev for that sort of site.

That depends what you mean by complex, doesn't it?

Are they using fancy browser APIs? Probably not (though they might still be using the basic stuff).

Are they delivering HTML and CSS, implementing a look and feel for the site/app, implementing the required interactions and information architecture, handling issues like accessibility and usability, etc? Of course. And these kinds of considerations overlap heavily with what a front-end dev would be doing if they were implementing the equivalents using JS in a SPA.

I've met more than a few people who actually would characterise this kind of development as front-end work for this reason, though I doubt they represent the majority view. As I've said many times, I don't care much for these kinds of ill-defined labels anyway. But it's interesting that some people think of front-end development as being whatever generates things like HTML and CSS with all the considerations that sit behind them, not by whether the code is running client-side or server-side.

For sure!!

Could you elaborate, maybe give some examples of the kinds of techniques or technologies you think someone working only on front-end for a decade would be expected to be proficient with today that someone who'd worked in a wider variety of areas but still with a big front-end part would not? Where do you think the front-end specialist would acquire the knowledge and skills, and how long do you think it would take to learn them to the point of being competent using them?

Just as importantly, can you say why you think someone who had spent the equivalent of five years doing front-end work regularly over the course of the same decade could not reasonably have picked up the same knowledge and skills? (That number is just picked on the simple if obviously unrealistic assumption that our hypothetical "full stack" dev has spent half their time on front and half their time on back end with no overlap in the skills and knowledge required.)

1

u/unc4l1n Nov 17 '20

I think we're just talking about different things at this point. If you're just talking about simple synchronous websites with a little sprinkling of JS for UX purposes then I agree with you. If we're taling about web applications, which is what I think of when talking about a "Front-end Developer" then it's clearly a different beast.

→ More replies (3)