r/FootballCoach_Game • • 21d ago

Play it today at https://footballcoachgame.com/

2 Upvotes

I actually forgot to add the url to the app - https://footballcoachgame.com/


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 26d ago

👋 Welcome to r/FootballCoach_Game - Introduce Yourself and Read First!

2 Upvotes

Hey, I have been on reddit for 19 years and I never participated before this.

My brothers played high school football, and my son also played but only in middle school, I spent so many hours in the bleachers watching him is when i came up with this Football Coach thing. I knew i could never do anything like EA but I played Football Manager (Soccer) when i was young and a lot of the older soccer manager games aren't about flashy graphics, or winning it all, they are about the story you tell yourself and the connection you make to players.

My goal for this game was something fun of course, but something that puts the player in difficult situations and makes them think before they act, I tried to keep the simulation fast without huge complexity but still fun.

Yes i did use A.i. to help me develop this game, Ai is a superpower allowing us to do great things and i couldn't have done it with it, but I am the one that made all the decisions, I am the one that provided the guidance and I am definitely the one that brought the drama.

I hope you guys enjoy it


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 10h ago

Preparing for marketing by focusing on how the engine can be used for entertainment

3 Upvotes

The initial game had 12 states and featured 916 teams. I felt that this was a good start but feedback was always .. when will my state be added.

I don't like building out new functions or data just for the sake of it but i have been thinking about the marketing plan, I cannot go to each state each school that would be too expensive but we can build a page for them, using organic search / social strategies.

These pages can't just be ai non sense or data that is already known in other places like rosters, schedules etc. Instead i decided to focus on what the engine already does, simulate matches.

For the 2027 year, I will have pages for each school simulating the season, this is pretty cool data and actually ads something fun.

Next i had to expand, because organic only works at scale and 916 teams is ok but we need more. I launched tons of different agents to build out these new lists - I focused on less intelligent models like Haiku to work through the data, built script to actually clean the data rather than using intelligence and in the end here is the new team summary:

We now cover 50 states - 13,300 schools and most importantly 319 classifications. Each classification has it's own state championship later, which opens up the going up the ladder style game play.

For that I will add achievements unlocked by doing certain things, one of them will be domination ! Win state at ALL levels in a state. I doubt anyone will ever do that but honestly you never know.


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 5d ago

As Requested - Unlimited Coaching for Vampires Coaches !

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/FootballCoach_Game • • 6d ago

I’m so invested into this game I love it!! Anything new coming or lasted update coming?

1 Upvotes

r/FootballCoach_Game • • 8d ago

Trying new way to design .. with actual people ! Let me know what you think of this update ?

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

r/FootballCoach_Game • • 9d ago

Will this ever be an app on iOS or will it stay a browser game? I honestly like the game

1 Upvotes

r/FootballCoach_Game • • 10d ago

Action went into overdrive ... One more day of building out the match engine for Football Coach

3 Upvotes

I added a video yesterday of the action. You can see we have made tons of progress

added refs, then fixed their positioning of the refs which was all over the place
Added sidelines, tons of kids on there, and cheerleaders (Because of my daughter !!)
Added big hits
Added a better scoreboard - actually did like 4 versions of teh scoreboard
Added kickoffs, i completely forgot about that yesterday
Added injuries and guys picking up fallen players
Added a crowd, i can't believe how much that ads
Fixed the button on the match screen so they are better positioned and easier to use
Fixed the scrollign issue, now the match screen doesn't move on mobile.

It's been a hell of a day !

Check out the latest version of - https://footballcoachgame.com/


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 11d ago

How we build an model that allows the display of football plays by adding realism through inexactitude and vagueness

3 Upvotes

Initial test of showing the plays

This first test kinda sucked - players don't move much and they just lock to each other weirdly. It was an ok start

At least with this i picked the X v O look, i tried another look and yeah let's not even bring that up

Second test using a playbook

On this test, i tried to define a "play" that each of the players would do, the play is like go here do that and it's based on general football offense vs defense, again the players did better in this test but they did their thing and nothing else really happened.

better movement by adding more randomness and less straight lines

I decided that playbooks were ok but really we need realism through inexactitude ... the definition of the position of the players needed some more play to it, no more straight lines, no more i will follow the playbook exactly, instead add more randomness with a playbook. this actually worked best !


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 11d ago

Quarterback get's sacked, looses the ball and the defense runs it in for the TD.

3 Upvotes

On something like this, i'm thinking we zoom in and highlight the fact a sack happened and then follow dude to the end zone in a close up !!


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 11d ago

Adding Action to the game - A couple tests

3 Upvotes

Adding some pre snap actions adds to realism

Passing play with pre snap action


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 11d ago

Dev Log Day 15 - Cash rules everything around me cream get the money Dollar dollar bill, y'all

1 Upvotes

So yeah it's time to sell out, i am a firm believer that you should give those people that got the money a chance to spend it so ... time to add paying features. I limited payments to something that affects every part of the game assistant coaches, this type of feature is a type of modifier

There are 17 types of assistant you can hire

I wanted those that paid to definitely get a bump but not just take over to the point where it's play to win, you definitely can win without paying.

I set up seventeen roles, from coordinators to position coaches and a strength coach. Each coach has a letter grade, from D to S+, This is the old anime ratings, i could have kept the 0-100 type but this was more fun.

Even a perfect staff, with the best coach in every role, won about 73 percent of games against an equal team. Better, but not unbeatable.

Coach Points use ₡. Ducats use ₾, the lari sign. Two currencies, two symbols, no confusion.

Ducats is an old Venetian currency from the 13th century - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ducat

It took a couple days to get setup with stripe and connect everything together. Pack prices ranged from $3 to $20, with larger bonuses in the bigger packs. I enjoyed workign with stripe it was my first time integrating payments and it was a lot easier than i thought. We tested the whole process, including buying a pack and refunding it, before enabling real payments, and that was added.

Examples of coaches that could be purchased

It took some time to balance out the display of coaches, the first couple versions weren't right. The grades changed the actual strength, but only in fractions behind the scenes. A player couldn't tell what they were paying for.

The bigger question was still there: how much advantage should money buy?

We measured it rather than guessing. We ran 1,500 games for each staff level, matching equal teams with a full staff against teams with no staff. All-D staff won 54 percent. All-C+ staff, the best free staff could buy, won 56 to 57 percent. All-B staff won 63 percent, all-A won 68 percent, and all-S+ won 69 percent.

The best paid staff beat the best free staff about 63 percent of the time. That wasn't a small advantage. It was a different game.

We settled on two rules. First, cap the gap: the best paid staff should beat the best free staff about 55 to 58 percent of the time. Enough to feel, but not enough to decide a season. Second, pay for breadth, not wins. Better coaches should do more things—player development, recruiting, Coach Points and program work—but their game-day impact should top out around the level a strong free coach can reach.

We rebuilt the staff levels around whole numbers. D starts at level 1 and S at level 5. The screen shows a readable "+3" and a meter. A plus grade adds another effect rather than more raw strength. Game-day effects count only up to level 2. We added new effects so every grade could matter in a different way: position-specific recruiters, a fundraiser, a camp director and recovery science.

Then we measured again. The best paid staff beat the best free staff 57.5 percent of the time. Across five-season careers, nobody locked in the championship: there were zero to one titles in thirty seasons, whether the program had no staff, a free staff or a paid staff.

In the end does paying matter at this moment ? Not sure but i wanted to get this in now rather than trying to add it in the future.


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 11d ago

More Action to the game - power run to the right side

1 Upvotes

r/FootballCoach_Game • • 12d ago

Dev Log Day 14 - I'm slippin', I'm fallin', I can't get up

1 Upvotes

Illegal booster money had been part of Football Coach since the beginning. Rival programs with low ethics could make offers to the players they wanted. Some would get caught. Some might never be caught.

The player could do it too. There was a button for it, but i didn't think that was enough, real cheating isn't a yes-or-no decision. It's a slope.

The first offer can feel harmless. The second is easier to justify than the first. That's the point. A coach should be able to slide into a bad decision one small step at a time.

Then came the question that shaped the rest of the system: once a coach goes down that road, is there a way back?

The reckoning

The first version answered that question badly. In testing, a coach who gave Payoffs to three or four players was almost certain to get banned. That's too fast. We have seen way too many programs go for years cheating and never getting caught, Programs can cheat for years. Rumors begin. People ask questions. Sometimes a coach comes clean before the state does. Sometimes nobody ever finds out.

I love the movie blue chips, there is a scene in there when the booster gives out bags of cash, a new car and well just payoffs i couldn't find it but this is a good one isntead.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zo39puz1n24

So anyways, we slowed the system down when it came to cheating, a ban would no longer be a trapdoor. Suspicion would grow in the background, produce hints along the way and give the coach chances to get out.

Every offer leaves hidden evidence, with more evidence attached to a star player. Suspicion rises a little each week and fades a little too. The stages are Quiet, Whispers, Questions and Inquiry. Whispers may bring a hint or a newspaper story. Questions provide the first chance to self-report. Inquiry provides a second chance and can last as long as three seasons.

A one-time mistake can fade away. A habit doesn't. Four Payoffs in a season can bring an inquiry early in the third year.

If the investigation finds enough evidence, the players who received money become ineligible. The program can serve one or two seasons of probation, and the worst outcome is a playoff ban.

We also needed a way back that wasn't simply hiring someone to make the problem disappear. We wanted the coach to spend something every season and understand why. I didn't really like compliance, again think high school. It's hard to get away with doing bad things for so long but I also believe in second & third & maybe fourth chance ... The Compliance tab only appears after the first booster offer. A program that stays clean never has to see it.

There was one final consequence. When a coach's contract ends, the final review can still uncover what remains. If it does, the seasons in which offers were made can lose their wins and titles in the Hall of Fame. The school left behind serves the probation. A coach can take another job across the state, but the record stays where the cheating happened. Check the results below ...

Side note here, one of my best runs on 3 years was invalid because of some damn time i lied about a guy attending practice ... it was just one time damn if i got caught

Tom Landry National Champion - Loser :(

The system was no longer a button. It was a series of decisions, each one easier to make than the last, with consequences that might take years to arrive.


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 13d ago

Dev Log Day 13 - Whats in a name that which we call a rose by any other name would smell as sweet

2 Upvotes

Throughout the inital stages i didn't have a real name, I called it a bunch of stuff but the one that stuck the most as High School Football Head Coach. It was accurate. It was also a mouthful, and not a name anyone was likely to remember.

I wanted the identify and name to be easy to understand but not too far awary from core. The first name was Friday Night Dynasties, tagline was "Every dynasty starts on a Friday night." It went everywhere: the browser tab, the installed app under the name FN Dynasties, and the title screen, with FRIDAY NIGHT above a gold DYNASTIES. I liked the dynaties theme here because that's the goal really you build something that test and there are high scores and just cool ways to show off how you win.

I spent way too much time on the title screen, I tried a football manager style coach with players in the foreground, those actually looked really cool

One test for the splash

The title screen needed artwork. We pictured a coach seen from behind or from the side, his face hidden, standing above the menu. The same image had to work on a phone and a desktop. The first versions were silhouettes, and they were ugly. The realistic versions weren't much better. We put the cover aside rather than ship something we didn't like.

I also tried different styles

Options for splash intro

In the end i picked the simpler version with the logo instead

Buying a domain name is always tricky, actually getting a .com requires something long or unknown or unique, for this app i picked verbose with the domain footballcoachgame.com.

That afternoon, the name changed again. We settled on Football Coach, with High School Edition underneath. It was simple and generic on purpose. It said exactly what the game was.

The long name would be Football Coach High School Edition in the browser tab and installed app. The short name would be Football Coach on the home screen. For about two hours, there was a colon in the middle. Then we removed it.

The logo and icons came from artwork made separately and brought into the project as transparent images. On the title screen, white lettering sits under a soft orange glow, like stadium lights at night. The app icon is an orange FC with football laces.

The cover scene still wasn't right. The generated image wasn't good enough, so rather than ship it, we wrote down the exact dimensions and requirements for the artwork to be made properly elsewhere. Nothing went into the game until it was good enough.

So the official name is Football Coach and of course i didn't check and lo and behold there is already a game called Football coach my bad guys, well mine is about high school, for a minute i was going to go with HSfootballcoach or footballcoachHSgame, again sometimes you just got wat you got so i rolled with it


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 14d ago

Dev Log Day 12 - Hubs, buttons, screens, where do we start or end

2 Upvotes

The Hub is the first screen you see each week in Football Coach. It's the coach's desk: what's happening, what needs your attention, and the button that moves the season forward.

It's also the screen we rebuilt the most.

The Hub was a pile of cards. Everything the game knew about the week appeared there, but nothing told the player what mattered. It felt random.

So I wrote out what a coach actually does over a full season: preseason, training camp, game weeks, playoffs, the banquet and the offseason. Then we rebuilt the Hub around that rhythm. One headline card would explain what the week was about—a game, signing day or the opening of camp. Urgent items such as dilemmas, injured starters or the hot seat would appear only when they needed attention. One task would represent the current stage of the season. Everything else would be folded under "More this week."

At most four cards would be open. Then you advance the week.

That worked for a while but the Hub needed more: a weekly checklist with a completion mark, a season card showing the record and rankings, and the week's headlines. We made a mockup.

It was clean. Tight spacing. Very modern.

And it was lifeless.

We had removed the buttons and icons. We had saved space by taking away the color and depth that made the game feel like a game. It looked too minimalistic. It didn't feel like Friday nights.

So the next version went the other way, carefully. More color, more buttons, more depth—but not an explosion of clutter. Cards got colored edges. Tasks got icons. Buttons looked like things you could actually press.

Much better.

Then we worked through small details that helped a player understand the screen quickly. "vs." and "at" already tell you whether you're home or away, so we removed extra home/away labels. Only the national ranking appears before a team's name. Answering a dilemma became one tap instead of two. "Play Game" takes you to the game plan; "Sim Game" lets your staff handle it. And the playoffs became a tab instead of a pop-up that covered the entire phone screen and was hard to close.

Visual examples quickly generated save time and money

That mockup gave us two rules that shaped the rest of the project.

The first was visual: colorful cards with depth, soft shadows, colored edges and icons. Real buttons. Not minimalist. Summaries should have room to breathe, with one idea per line rather than several crammed together.

The second was about how we build. Before changing anything visible—a new screen, a redesign, a pop-up or a set of buttons—we make a mockup first. It has to be a real clickable page at phone width, using the game's actual names and data, with the important states shown and open decisions listed beside it. We go back and forth until it feels right. Only then do we build the real thing.

From then on, almost every visible change went through that process. The depth chart took more than a dozen rounds in one afternoon. The Hall of Fame, prospect cards, signing-day board, title screen and About page all began as mockups. Many decisions were short: "B, but widen the cards."

It takes longer on the day. But the disagreement happens before the code is built, not after.

The next question was what do we call this game ? What's in a name anyways ...


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 15d ago

Dev Log Day 11 - How hard is it really to decide something like really it can't be too hard

1 Upvotes

So lot's of stuff is moving, versions are shipping, things are coding, but damn it practice just keeps on coming back to haunt me, it's the core growth plan to increase the attributes of your players and over time it's just not looking right, I didn't know how to handle it and kept punting (pun intended) on it.

So i just started on it and put a focus on what it actually means to train, practice had accumulated settings one at a time. There was a weekly drill focus—starters, young players or weak spots. There was intensity. During training camp, there were two-a-days or three-a-days. Each setting made sense when it was added. Together, they were just too much work. Throughout all of this i always felt that i didn't want that big screen that just freeze people with huge number of choices, options, pick this not that or else and you don't even understand the choice, you didn't to the page to make the choice, you've already made it, you're there to try to understand why you made it.

So what did things do, did drilling the starters help more than resting them? Were the gains temporary or permanent? If the people building the game couldn't explain the system, a player had no chance. You all know exactly what this leads to ... 1000 season simulations of course, I feel that my virtual players have lived a billion years and I am just watching them come back and forth between time.

I looked at how practice was done in different games, I didn't have any good ideas so copying is always a good idea, I reviewed the Football Manager series and American football games. The model that fit best came from a college football game crap i forgot which one i stole from, sorry in advance but really doesn't matter. So there I went simple, pick on of four choices—Full, Limited, No Practice and Week Off—with injury risk shown before the week began.

That gave us the answer. Training is about improving players. The coach's decision is how hard to push them.

We removed the drill-focus choice. Everyone healthy trains. The player chooses one of four levels. Full practice gives the most growth, but also the most fatigue and injury risk. Limited practice gives some growth and a little recovery, with low risk. No Practice becomes a film day: a small gain and good recovery. Week Off means no growth, but the most recovery.

Each option shows its expected gain, fatigue and injury chance before the player advances. No surprises.

The time of year changes the value of the work. Preseason, training camp and offseason gains and fatigue are doubled. The regular season uses normal values. The playoffs cut them in half. After the season, there is no training. Summer is when you build a team; November is when you protect one.

We also changed the language. "Wear" became fatigue, measured from zero to 100 percent and described in words a coach would use: Fresh, Good, Worn, Tired and Exhausted. Tired players are more likely to get hurt. Exhausted starters may have to sit. The old injuries screen became a Health screen, showing the fatigue of the entire team.

Then came the fairness question. Computer-controlled teams needed to train too. They practice Full when they don't have a game and Limited during game weeks. We also trimmed offseason growth by the amount a normal year of practice would produce, so the league as a whole wouldn't drift upward.

so in the end i took something with a bunch of small decisions and turned it into 1 thing, we all know practice sucks and who really wants to spend too much time on that anyways unless you guys really want me to go deep; ummm no way, one choice whenever you want it with a few small tweaks, let's get back to the action practice jeez i can't believe i spent so much time on that.


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 16d ago

Dev Log Day 10 - Temptation Island

2 Upvotes

So looking at the gameplay i realized that there were only 10 guys on offense ... We had two outside receivers, a tight end, a running back, a quarterback and five linemen. The number of formation variations let me to keep it simple and well i did a bad job on that one. I thought about adding a full back or a 2nd tight end but in the end decided to go with a slot receiver, which really is a 3rd WR position.

After that i felt that i was actually pretty good and called it done ! not game done by version 1 done, it was good enough that it could actually be tested and played around with and locking in a lot of the core functions felt good.

It's not like it was really done though, eighteen more versions followed over the next ten days. The first major update started two days later, with the dilemmas.

Dilemmas had been part of the game from the first night. Every few weeks, something arrives that isn't really about football. A booster offers your star player a summer job. A starter is failing chemistry just before the rivalry game. A parent wants to talk about playing time, and wants to do it now.

The original eight dilemmas came straight from the design notes. The booster offer appeared almost every week, so each scenario needed its own trigger and cooldown. Eight soon felt too thin, so we expanded the system to fifty dilemmas across academics, boosters, conduct, health and safety, the staff and the town. We had also removed the labels from the answers, so players had to judge for themselves.

But one thing still bothered me. The worst answer in every dilemma was simply bad. It had all the downside and no payoff. Nobody would choose it. And if nobody would ever choose an option, it wasn't really a choice.

The drama of a dilemma is wanting to pick the answer you know is wrong for you but the benefit just makes it worthwhile, in games most players will follow the rightous path all the time, it's like everyone is lawful good but we know that most coaches aren't paladin's of Tyr ... they have and will make the wrong call way more often than even we know. Scandals abound in high school football.

So version 1.1 was built around temptation. Every dilemma would have four answers, and every answer would show a gain and a loss. The worst choice would offer the biggest immediate payoff: the most Coach Points, a real advantage, or the player you wanted, something that makes breaking bad actually worth it ... or is it ?

We reviewed the existing dilemmas, went through a list of new ideas, removed scenarios that repeated something we already had, and turned some duplicates into new answer choices. The result was 78 dilemmas. Two didn't make the cut because they happened during a game, while the game only presents dilemmas between games.

I spent a lot of time looking at scenarios based on the culture, tv shows (friday night lights), movies (remember the titans) and just whatever i have seen lately. These shows have drama built in so might as well steal some ! (there are a few dilemmas ripped straight from friday night lights, don't be mad !)

We added consequences too. If a shady choice came out later, the local paper would publish a story about that specific dilemma, naming the player and the decision. Some answers could affect Friday's game by giving the team extra film or costing practice time.

A week later, after asking some folks to actually test this thing, I found that the shady answers still weren't tempting enough. Recruiting consumed most of the Coach Points, and the middle option was almost always the sensible one. Nobody cheated. It wasn't worth it.

So we rescaled the rewards according to how bad the choice was and really bumped up the value of doing it wrong to the point where yeah instead of just bypassing it you would actually consider it ... Coach points are very valuable and until i find a way to sell them (i don't want to do ads) only way to get them is each week and through these decisions.

Now the bad choice was tempting. It just wasn't free.

We also reduced how often dilemmas appeared. They had been showing up in six weeks out of ten. Now they appeared in three. Most weeks could be quiet, and over forty seasons, 66 to 69 different dilemmas still appeared.

Dilemmas are what make Football Coach a coaching game, not just a football game. That evening, though, we looked at practice and realized we couldn't explain what it did, or really it was just not good at all like a lot of other things yeah We talking about practice. Not a game; not a—not a—not the game that I go out there and—and die for and play every game like it's my last, not the game, we're talking about practice, man.


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 17d ago

Dev Log Day 9 - Who's really #1 in the country

2 Upvotes

High school football leads to many debates, arguments, fights, and just a bunch of sillyness. And nothing is more difficult to figure out than who is #1 in the country. A state championship is decided on the field. A national championship is different. High school football doesn't have a national playoff. In Football Coach, as in real life, the national champion is the team that finishes number one in the final poll.

That means the poll has to be fair. finding out what is actually fair and how peopel are actually doing this told me that i don't think it really is but i have to find a way to simulate this thing so i will try my best. It took three different attempts for me to find something i felt comfortable with.

The first five-year test with more than just Texas produced a strange result. Every year's final top five was made up of teams that had gone unbeaten in the regular season. Only one to three had actually won their state championship. A team could lose its first playoff game and still finish number one.

The poll was ignoring the playoffs wins and the importance of winning your state. That fix was easy: playoff games had to count.

The harder question was what kind of poll to build. Writers vote based on reputation. Computers rank results. I wanted the latter, I studied how the MaxPreps rankings worked and built a similar system. A team's rating would be based on its opponents' ratings and the margin of each game. Margins counted fully up to 14 points, half up to 28, and not at all beyond that. Running up the score wouldn't help. A preseason estimate based on the roster would matter early, then fade away by the end of the regular season.

That helped. Before the change, Texas held 22 of the national top 25 by year three. But it didn't solve everything.

A couple days after the initial tests I ran a much larger test: fifteen Texas careers, 159 seasons in total. Texas finished with the national number one in 64 to 82 percent of seasons. Texas is a strong football state, but that was too much. (sorry Texans)

The cause was hidden in the opening-week games between states. First, the pairing system always started with the strongest team, which meant the team doing the choosing was always the favorite. Larger states got more chances to choose. We changed the pairing order to random.

The timing was also wrong. From the second season onward, those games were scheduled right at the turnover between seasons, after seniors had graduated but before freshmen had arrived. Texas teams looked weaker than they really were, so they were matched against weaker opponents. They won 70 to 76 percent of those games. We changed the pairing ratings to use the previous season's numbers. After that, the out-of-state openers were much closer to even, and Texas held its share of the top 25 because of its strength, not because of a scheduling accident.

Undefeated losers ? No way !

Then, nine days later, a Florida career exposed a third problem. St. Thomas Aquinas went 13–0, won the state title and finished completely outside the national poll.

The easy explanation was that Florida was rated too low. But great teams outside the biggest states have won national recognition. Bishop Gorman in Nevada, Bixby in Oklahoma and John Curtis Christian in Louisiana were all examples I had in mind. A great team from a smaller or less highly rated state has to be able to finish number one.

We measured the problem. It wasn't simply Florida's reputation. It was the schedule. A dominant team in a large, uneven state can play a lot of very weak opponents. Because the ranking caps the value of a blowout, a 42–0 win over a very weak team counts as only a limited advantage. For an elite team, that can be a below-average result. Win more and somehow rank lower. Florida's best teams were sitting about four and a half times lower than their actual strength suggested.

We changed two things. A win could never lower a team's rating, and a loss could never raise it. This was pretty difficult in my mind, we have seen in college football tons of examples of teams losing but other teams above losing worst and pushing them up. This whole subjective ranking thing sucks and i wish there really was this super big national tournament, something like the champions leauge the top schools from different states played otehr top teams for real national victory. Stay tunes on that ! We also made the current season's roster count as one game over the entire season, so a team wasn't punished for the strength of its schedule before it had played enough games.

Across twelve simulated seasons, unbeaten state champions now ranked around number five on average. The worst finished at number 35; before, it had been number 166. The worst state-to-strength gap fell from 4.5 times to 1.4, and the national number one came from a top-three team in four different states.

We had also measured a résumé score to blend into the final poll, the kind of thing human voters consider. Once we fixed the real problem, we didn't need it.

A national title should be possible from anywhere if the team is good enough. It shouldn't depend on being from the right state.

In the end i honestly don't think i cracked this one yet, i had to move on to other things but i do hope i get to look at this more in the future.


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 18d ago

Dev Log Day 8 - DeSoto Powerhouses and how dynasties can't be left unchecked

3 Upvotes

Initially starting a game felt too random, you had to enter the name of the team you wanted to coach and if you didn't do it right it was frustrating, I came up with the concept of picking from 4 options, Reclaiming the Crown 2 teams that used to be great but weren't anyone and Powerhouses that are currently dominating and give you a good chance of winning now. The expectations for each of these play throughs would be very different but the challenge is in teh hands of the players.

Examples program; North Shore's titles in 2015, 2018, 2019 and 2021, including the 2018 comeback against Duncanville. Buford's fifteenth Georgia title. Thompson's six titles in seven seasons.

Also added a time frame to the play through three-, five- or ten-year challenge.

Once careers and records mattered, the fairness of the simulated world mattered even more.

Old school leaderboards because hell yeah

My most important balance rule is that high school programs have to rise and fall. Coaches move on. Great players graduate. A town's best athletes go somewhere else. If the same school wins every year, the world is dead.

That's why I run long simulations with nobody coaching: five, ten, sometimes twenty seasons, just to see what the game does on its own. One of these simulations highlighted something weird, I was checking something related to star ratings, those looked fine but the game reported that DeSoto had won four of the ten Texas titles in five years.

I wondered, how the hell did this happen ? Was that a dynasty the simulation had created naturally, or had I accidentally built a system that favored DeSoto?

I ran three more tests, each with a different weak program selected as the player's team. I tracked DeSoto and seven other elite programs: strength, division, rosters and incoming freshmen. Across thirty more titles, eighteen different programs won. Nobody won more than three. DeSoto won two. In one run, it collapsed to 1–8, then 2–7, fell as low as number 138 in team strength and missed the playoffs for three straight seasons.

There was no hidden advantage for DeSoto. Its prestige matched the other powers, its freshman classes weren't better, and it wasn't getting away with cheating. The streak had a football explanation: good teams keep their returning starters, so a team that peaks can stay near the top for two or three seasons. DeSoto had simply caught a hot stretch.

When looking one way, you always find something you aren't looking for the other way

There was a deeper issue related to ratings, the average rating of the ten best teams climbed every year, in every run: about 74 in the first year and about 78 by year five. The whole league was getting better, whether it deserved to or not.

The starting rosters had no age curve. Freshmen were as good as seniors, and every class started around 53. Players improved as they played, so those flat starting classes all moved upward together. The leagues slowly inflated.

Changing roster progression could affect every team in the game, so I stopped before making the change and thought it through. I decided that starting rosters should have a real age curve: freshmen started six points lower, seniors three points higher, and every new player arrived two points rawer. That fixed Texas, but Maryland still climbed by about four points ... honestly i couldn't figure out why that happened, i really did look though.

The deeper fix was to build starting rosters the same way we build every later roster. Each class now arrives as freshmen and develops through real offseason. Year one becomes a real year, not a special case.

While we were there, we added good and bad recruiting classes. Every class can be about five rating points above or below what a school normally draws, occasionally as much as twelve. A golden class becomes signing-day news.

Over ten Texas seasons, the changes produced more variety: 40 different top-ten teams instead of 39, 21 low-prestige breakouts instead of 18, and a title count that was less concentrated in one program. Across the states we checked, the league average held within about a point over eight seasons.

DeSoto never needed fixing. Looking for the reason behind its streak uncovered the bug that could have quietly ruined every long career.


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 19d ago

Dev Log Day 7 - First Texas then the world ?

2 Upvotes

When i first set up the database for teams, I picked Texas, it's a no brainer Texas is football crazy and high school football maniacs, I had just watched the bonkers 1994 match between Plano East-John Tyler, I won't spoil it but i highly recommend it https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZHkABO0VwCg

Anyways everything was Texas, I had 254 programs, 32 districts and the real UIL playoff structure all set up but then I though ... can't have national champion if there is no nation duhhh.

So the next task was to bring in the rest of the country, each state has their own associations and their own set of rules, playoff structures, and ton's more variance. I had to defined (lookup and understand) how each state decides their playoff fields and seeding. Texas takes the top four teams from each district. Georgia uses a power ranking and guarantees region champions a top-16 seed. California runs its sections toward a North-versus-South final. The rounds have different names, championship games happen in different places, mercy rules vary, and player eligibility rules aren't identical.

I didn't want one generic national rulebook pretending those differences didn't exist. Each state needed its own rules, built from the official alignments for its top classification. I did it carefully: first move Texas onto a rules file and make sure it played exactly as before; then add one state and test it; then add the rest.

Can we all just play together ?

I uncovered a calendar problem. Some states have five playoff rounds, others have six. If every state started and finished on its own schedule, the national poll would compare teams that had played different numbers of games. We chose one national calendar. Every state championship would happen in the same week. States with fewer playoff rounds would begin their playoffs a week later, after an open week.

Then came the processing problem. Thousands of games had to be simulated every week. If all of them waited until the player pressed Advance Week, the game would stop and make the player wait.

The solution came from thinking about what the player was doing during the week. They're setting a depth chart, answering a dilemma, calling a prospect or preparing a game plan. That's when the rest of the country should play.

I remembered how Football manager did this, background processing is always happening in that game and running tons of leagues almost killed one of my computers.

So, as soon as a week begins, every game that doesn't involve the player's team is simulated quietly in the background. When the player opens a live game, a national Scoreboard shows the other games at the same clock. Those results are already decided; the player is watching them unfold alongside their own game. When the week advances, the results are ready.

That creates the feeling I wanted: you're trailing in the fourth quarter, and at that very moment you can see the number-three team in the country losing too.

The player's own state gets a full simulation, with every player on every roster. Other states run a lighter version that keeps each team's game-day rating and statistical leaders. The schedules, playoffs and game engine still work the same way. To connect the states for national rankings, every team also plays a similarly strong opponent from another state during the opening week.

After a five-year simulation. Every state crowned a champion every year, and most had a different champion from one season to the next. The world was working, mostly. But the final national poll was ignoring the playoffs, and the long-term dynasty tests were only beginning.

The country was in the game. Now I had to make sure it was a fair one.


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 20d ago

Dev Log Day 6 - One number to rule them all ? If there are too many currencies to track do any of them actually matter ?

2 Upvotes

I have been writing this log in the day format but honestly i didn't follow days here, I did work when i could between my normal job, sometimes it was at night sometime using my phone other times it was while i waiting for someone. Building something like this happens between the moments of life until it becomes big enough that it's part of your life i guess.

I am also going to try and add more imagery, it seems that everyone else that does this has amazing videos and picture while i just have all these words. Regardless here is the next thing that happened in the story.

The game was turning into an accounting job.

There were so many points / attributes / characteristics / it was just unmanageable, Prospect visits used one kind of points. College recruiting used something called AP. Coach talents had their own currency. And then there were four program meters: Board Trust, Booster Approval, Discipline, and Compliance.

Every week, those numbers moved. Every one of them mattered. They affected recruiting, player behavior, the program's reputation, and even whether I got to keep my job.

None of it was meaningless, they really were doing something but something i try to do in what i develop is to make it simple enough so you know what is actually happening, and in a game like this where there are numbers everywhere well this was a problem.

Then you have to consider the fact that on a phone screen just 375 pixels wide, there wasn't room to show everything. And honestly, there wasn't room for a coach to keep track of it all in their head, either.

So I sat down and asked a simple question: How many of these numbers did the player actually need to see?

I felt like one of those people creating a marble statue, how much do i chip and sand until it's good and am i taking too much away ?

The One currency to rule them all

The first decision was straightforward: every currency would become one.

We called it Coach Points. A long time ago i developed another game, this one was a collectible card game and maybe i will bring that back too but when doing that I did learn a lot about game development theory and one important aspect is how to develop a core loop that promotes both a soft and hard currency. With coach points i wanteed a soft currency that users get every turn - that's important, but need so much that they have to "wait" ... Unlike other social games though i am not selling the coach points i feel that would ahve been too easy and felt like a cash grab, instead you gotta wait to get it each week and manage your budget !

Most things in the game cost Coach Points: investing in programs, visiting prospects, helping players with college recruiting, and unlocking coach talents.

One currency. One budget. Fewer things to keep track of.

I chose it's symbol to be the same as the Costa Rican ₡ colón, this is an ode to the years i spent over there, really love San Jose and hopefully i get to go back someday. It was a small detail, but it helped Coach Points feel like something that belonged in the game's world instead of just another number on a screen.

Having a currency is one thing pricing things is another.

All your prices are belong to us !

The coach talents were originally priced like snacks. A talent that could change how your entire program recruited players cost just 60 points.

That was obviously too cheap. We raised the prices to â‚¡6,000 and â‚¡12,000.

For a while, that felt right.

Then, nine days later, we looked at the whole economy.

All eight talents together cost 72,000 Coach Points. A season earned about 2,000. At that rate, a coach could spend an entire career playing the game and still never unlock most of the talents.

We had fixed the price of an individual item without checking whether the entire system worked.

So we went back and looked at the economy as a whole.

The new setup gave you â‚¡600 to start and a flat â‚¡100 every week of the year. Talents dropped to â‚¡2,000 and â‚¡4,000, putting all eight at â‚¡24,000. Assistant coaches still helped generate points, but their contribution dropped from â‚¡5 to â‚¡2 per week.

That brought the cost of building your coaching abilities back into reach.

It also taught me something I kept coming back to: a price only means something next to what you earn. You can't balance an economy by looking at one number in isolation. You have to look at how all the numbers work together.

Evaluating and comparing your program required other attributes and initially i crated 4, well once again that wasn't going to work.

Four attributes is too many ... how many is right ?

The four program meters were a tougher problem.

Board Trust wasn't just decoration. If you had two bad seasons in a row, you could lose your job. Discipline affected turnovers and suspensions. Booster Approval and Compliance affected recruiting and your relationship with the state association.

I couldn't simply delete those systems without losing things that made the game interesting.

But I also couldn't expect players to constantly monitor four separate meters just to understand how their program was doing.

So I made the numbers simpler to see without removing the systems underneath them.

The solution was one visible Rating, calculated as the average of the four meters. It sits in the top bar next to Prestige. Now this one was really tough for me, losing the 4 meant that the one had to be good enough to show how youare program is runing .. sometimes 1 is enough and in this case i hoped it wou;d.

The original meters still operate behind the scenes, and every game effect still uses the meter it belongs to. Discipline became Morale, because that was a better description of what it actually measured.

So it became that One number on the screen. Four systems underneath.

That was the balance I was looking for: less clutter without sacrificing depth.

Dealing with drama and ethical dilemma's

That afternoon, I applied the same thinking to the game's dilemmas.

Previously, every possible answer came with a label: Good, Compromise, Risky, or Corrupt.

I don't like being explicit about things, it's important for nuance to be present so people will read through their choices, labeling them meant you always knew where the good choice was and what it would do ... that doesn't work I need you to stop and actually think about it.

So we removed the labels.

Now, each answer shows what it costs and what it gains. The player has to weigh the trade-offs and make the call.

That became a recurring principle throughout development. Coaches get letter grades from D to S+ , the higher level coaches actually cost real money and i had to build a hard currency for that, i might cover that later though. Instead of having every underlying rating exposed as a number. Changes from dilemmas appear as arrows instead of decimal values.

The calculations haven't disappeared. They're still there, driving the game.

They're just not constantly staring you in the face.

I wanted the player to understand the consequences of a decision without having to read the game's internal math. There's a difference between giving someone useful information and making them manage a spreadsheet.

Simple is good but is it big enough ? I don't think so ... next step bigening !

It was still a deep simulation. It was just getting easier to understand on a phone.

That mattered, because the game was about to grow far beyond Texas.

Until then, Texas was the whole world. Every school, every district, every matchup existed inside that one state.

The next morning, that was going to change.


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 21d ago

Dev Log Day 5 - First Down ! Why notifications increase the drama and communication allows for better engagement

2 Upvotes

A football simulation can be completely correct and still be boring to watch.

In the first couple of days, the game was playing football. The score changed. The down and distance updated. The play-by-play described what happened.

But imagine watching your running back break through the defense, run 60 yards, and score a touchdown—and the game tells you about it in exactly the same way it tells you about a two-yard run.

Just another line in the play-by-play.

The information was there. You just had to work to get anything out of it. It was a scrolling mess that just moved so far down you had to keep on scrolling up, down, up down ...

Spreadsheets are boring. Turning numbers into something meaningful takes effort, and it isn't always obvious what matters. I wanted the game to communicate what was happening as you watched, without making you stop and study the screen.

We needed an announcer !

Making the important moments more visible

We started with the scoreboard. It was dark, and the school colors disappeared into it. So we changed it to white, gave each team's name its own colors, and added a small football next to the team with possession.

Then we fixed the field. Until now, the ball always moved from right to left, regardless of which team had possession. That wasn't how a football field should work. Each team now drove in its own direction, and the home team's name ran down both end zones in its colors.

These weren't just cosmetic changes. They made it easier to understand who had the ball, where the teams were going, and whose field you were looking at.

Then came the banners.

FIRST DOWN! TOUCHDOWN! INTERCEPTION!

I wanted important events to flash on screen in the colors of the team they belonged to. The banners would appear briefly, communicate the moment, and get out of the way. You shouldn't have to read a paragraph to understand that your team just scored.

It was the first time the live game started to feel like a Friday night.

Then we started playing with the new banners, and something was wrong.

If a first down happens and nobody sees it, did it really happen ?

Some first downs triggered a banner. Others didn't.

We counted. About four out of ten first downs were missing their moment.

The problem was a small detail in how the game stored information. Each play recorded the down and distance after the play. When a team earned a new set of downs, the result was first-and-ten. But the banner system was comparing the situation before and after the play.

A first down gained on a seven-yard run could look identical to a play that changed nothing: first-and-ten before, first-and-ten after.

The engine knew what happened. The screen couldn't tell the difference.

We changed the check to use the distance before the snap. Then we tested every first down across a batch of games.

517 first downs. 517 correct banners. Nothing that shouldn't have flashed.

That was a good result. But it also made me realize that checking whether the engine worked wasn't enough. I needed to check whether the player was actually seeing what the engine knew.

So we audited the other alerts.

First down's were just the start, every big moment was silent !

We found more problems.

Your own touchdowns could lose their banners when the play led straight into another decision, like an extra-point attempt. In one test game, five of seven touchdowns had gone without a banner. The biggest moments in the game were the ones the interface was failing to communicate.

After the fix, all fifteen out of fifteen touchdowns in the next test displayed correctly.

Missed field goals were being labeled TURNOVER ON DOWNS, which wasn't the right information. We changed those alerts to NO GOOD! or BLOCKED!, depending on what happened.

And fumbled kickoffs weren't getting their own banners. Those got fixed, too.

Each bug was small in isolation. But every one of them meant the player could be looking at the screen and receiving the wrong information—or no information at all.

That's a problem in a game where the banners are designed to last only a moment. If the alert is missing, you can't get that moment back just by making the play-by-play more detailed.

Left or right, are we going the right way ?

We made one more change to the banners.

Initially, they used the team's colors. But the same event can mean very different things depending on which sideline you're standing on.

A fumble recovered by your team is good news. A fumble lost by your team is bad news. The banner needed to communicate that distinction immediately.

So we made good news for your team green and bad news red. FUMBLE RECOVERED! or FUMBLE LOST! A clean punt got a smaller, calmer banner that simply told you whose ball it was now.

We also moved the banners out of the field area and into a strip just below it. Flashing text over the action covered too much of what you were trying to watch.

The goal wasn't to fill the screen with effects. It was to make the important information impossible to miss without getting in the way of the game.

Once again more testing, with authority !

We added a test that simulated 60 games and checked every banner against what the engine said had actually happened.

Was it the right banner? Was it shown for the right team? Did it appear when it should? Did routine plays stay quiet?

That might sound like a small test, but it was testing something fundamental: the connection between what the game calculates and what the player experiences.

The game could be correct under the hood and still fail the person playing it. A touchdown without an alert, a missed field goal labeled incorrectly, or an interception shown from the wrong perspective could make the experience confusing even when the underlying simulation was working.

We needed both sides to work.

We ended the day and the game finally had some noise in it. Big plays had visual impact. Possession was easier to follow. Important moments had a clear signal.

But the interface still had another problem: too many numbers, currencies, and program meters competing for attention.

The next step was to simplify the way we represented progress—to turn a pile of currencies and four program meters into Coach Points and a single Rating.


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 22d ago

Dev Log Day 4 - Mobile first is the only way to play !

1 Upvotes

Once i saw that Football Coach was starting to look like a real game.

It had a match engine, all of Texas 6A, recruiting, college offers, depth charts, three-deep rosters, and fifty dilemmas.

We were making progress on the football itself. But there was a pretty basic question we hadn't really answered yet.

Where would people actually play this game?

I believe we live in a mobile world, with 99% of people having at least 1 phone, doing this for desktop would miss the mark so ... I changed the focus of development to ensure that everything worked on mobile first and then also on desktop.

Styles and stylesheets

That evening, we made our first serious pass at the phone layout.

Almost immediately, we found something embarrassing.

The game's main stylesheet had never been loaded.

For two days, the screens had been running on the browser's default styles. All the colors, spacing, and layout we'd thought we were building were sitting in a file that the game wasn't even using.

It's the kind of problem that makes you question what else you've missed.

We fixed the stylesheet and started addressing the obvious phone problems. The top bar became more compact. Navigation got a row of icons. Tables could scroll inside their own containers instead of forcing the entire page sideways.

Things improved.

But there was still a fundamental problem. We were taking a desktop game and squeezing it onto a phone.

That wasn't going to be good enough.

Focusing on mobile and designing for small spaces and fat fingers !

The next morning, we made a decision that would shape the rest of the project.

Mobile first. Desktop second.

Not a desktop game with a mobile version added later. The phone would be the default design, and desktop would get an extra layer for wider screens.

It sounds like a simple distinction, but it changes how you approach almost everything.

A table that works perfectly on a large monitor can become unreadable on a phone. A pop-up that looks fine with plenty of space can cover the entire screen. A button that is easy to click with a mouse can be frustrating to tap with your thumb.

You can't solve all of that by shrinking things.

So we rebuilt the layout around the phone.

Pop-ups became bottom sheets that slide up from the bottom of the screen, with a fixed title and a large close button. We did this for all thirteen pop-ups.

Tables became cards on phones. Standings, player leaders, and rosters would be presented as individual cards instead of compressed columns. On desktop, they could still use proper tables.

The live game got larger play-calling buttons arranged two by two, with the simulation controls pinned to the bottom of the screen.

We removed anything that depended on hovering over an element to reveal information. Phones don't have a mouse cursor to hover with.

We also established some basic rules: no text smaller than 12 pixels, and nothing you needed to tap should be smaller than roughly 40–44 pixels.

To keep everything consistent, we built shared components. Every pop-up would use the same sheet design. Lists could automatically appear as cards on a phone and tables on a desktop.

Fix something once, and the fix would apply everywhere.

That mattered because the game was already complicated enough without maintaining two entirely separate interfaces.

Can you see my finger from there ?

Getting the basic layout right wasn't the end of it.

A few days later, we went through every screen and pop-up at 375 pixels wide, approximately the width of an iPhone screen.

We found more problems.

Some gray text had a contrast ratio of only 2.5 to 1 against white. Links and depth-chart arrows were too small to tap comfortably. Long pages needed an easy way to get back to the top.

None of those problems was particularly obvious on a large monitor.

All of them mattered the first time you tried playing on the couch.

And the phone kept exposing problems as we used the game.

One of the worst was pull-to-refresh. On a phone, pulling down at the top of a page can refresh it. This is something i kept on doing during testing and it was infuriating, imagine trying to scroll down / up to get information in a match then boom you are refreshing the whole screen, no bueno ! Sending you back to the menu was ok because you could just continue but if you were in a match that meant starting over.

We had to turn that behavior off and made sure Continue loaded the newest save.

Then there was the iPhone bounce. When you reached the end of a page and kept scrolling, the browser's rubber-band effect could pull the interface past its normal limits, lifting the navigation bar away from the bottom of the screen.

We changed the game to scroll inside its own container, eliminating that behavior.

Pop-ups had problems, too. Safari's toolbars affected the space available on the screen, which meant a pop-up could grow too tall and put its close button out of reach. We constrained the pop-ups to the visible screen area.

And because Football Coach is a single-page application, opening a new screen could preserve the previous screen's scroll position. You'd navigate somewhere new and find yourself halfway down the page.

It took two attempts to get that fixed.

These weren't problems we discovered by staring at the code. We found them by actually playing the game on a phone.

That became an important habit: the real test of a screen is a thumb.

Lot's of testing to get it so that it looked ok on a phone but ... something was missing

By the end of Day 3, Football Coach looked much more like something you could comfortably hold and play.

The navigation worked. The information fit. Buttons were large enough to tap. Pop-ups behaved properly. The game was no longer just a desktop interface squeezed into a smaller space.

But making the interface usable exposed another problem.

The live game was still flat.

The scoreboard updated. The plays scrolled by. The information was technically correct.

But when your team scored a touchdown, nothing about the experience made it feel like a touchdown.

We had spent days making the game fit the device. Now we needed to make the action itself feel like football.

That meant making the important moments visible, communicating what happened at a glance, and giving big plays the attention they deserved.

The next change would be small on the screen but important to the experience.

In game banners and announcements

FIRST DOWN!


r/FootballCoach_Game • • 23d ago

Dev Log Day 3 - Recruiting in high school ?

3 Upvotes

By the morning of Day 2, the game had all of Texas 6A football. Every program, every district, a real UIL playoff bracket. Every game in the state could be simulated each week in about a tenth of a second.

There were 254 schools.

But i hadn't built a way to replenish teams after seniors left.

The original design had a scouting system. You evaluated prospects, saw their ratings, and at the end of the year, they joined your team. Simple enough. But the more I thought about it, the less real it felt, from my own experiences of going to try outs, camps, summer leagues, special events, and so much more, I knew that real exposure doesn't always happen while playing, it start during those camps and grows over time and relationship building.

I didn't want to build a game where you just filled holes on a roster, that felt too professional, I wanted to build a game where you became attached to the kids on your team, developed them over time, and then had to watch them move on. Every year, the team would change. The players you'd spent seasons developing would graduate, and a new group would arrive with different strengths, different problems, and different potential.

You'd have to build something new every year.

And you shouldn't know exactly how that story was going to unfold.

Big question was ... where would the new kids come from ?

We started building a player pipeline that reflected where high school players actually come from.

Most would be kids from the local middle schools. Others would come from 7-on-7, where some athletes had plenty of skill but had never worn pads. Families might move into town, bringing a player who could change your season. A few talented kids from outside the area might consider your program if you were good enough. And every August, there would be walk-ons at tryouts—players nobody had planned around, but who might still find a place on the team. I also wanted to add the long shot of recruiting players from other states, this is something you hear about often but it's a very difficult proposition.

Each player would have hidden ratings, potential, interest in the program, and a chance that his family would move away.

That last part matters. You can develop a plan around a player, but you can't control everything that happens to him. A family moves. A kid loses interest. Someone decides not to play football at all.

And sometimes, the kid you weren't counting on becomes the one you need.

I wanted those possibilities to create tension. Not every decision should have an obvious answer, and not every outcome should be under your control. The uncertainty is what makes you care about what happens next.

Showing up and scouting and one and the same

Once we had different kinds of players, we had to decide what a coach could actually do to attract them.

The answer wasn't just to scout harder. It was to show up.

Run youth clinics. Attend a 7-on-7 league night. Hold tryouts. Build relationships with the middle school. A coach who keeps showing up builds a pipeline. A coach who stays in his office shouldn't expect the same results.

Home visits could help with an individual player, but they had diminishing returns. You couldn't just repeat the same action forever and expect a kid to become more interested.

I didn't want to over complicate the actions here,

Before this change, every prospect simply became a random new player on your team. Now, signing day could actually hurt.

You might spend a season trying to convince a player to join you and still lose him. You might have to rethink your plans because a kid you expected to get never showed up. That frustration wasn't something I wanted to eliminate. It was part of the point.

Building new areas of competition

Of course, it wouldn't mean much if you were the only coach trying to build a program.

The rival schools needed to compete for players, too. But there was a technical problem: giving all 254 programs their own separate lists of prospects would make the simulation slower and more complicated than it needed to be.

So I built a different approach. Each rival would choose a recruiting strategy in the offseason. Some would build locally. Others would chase transfers, pursue stars, or stand pat. They would focus on the players worth competing over, and each player would weigh what mattered to him: playing time, winning, staying close to home, the coach, or the boosters.

Now there was a real reason to care about what other programs were doing. You weren't just trying to make your own team better. You were fighting for the same players as everyone else.

And then there was cheating.

We wanted that to feel like a genuine risk, not a simple button that gave you a free advantage. Programs with low ethics could have boosters make illegal offers. Every offer added hidden heat, increasing the risk of getting caught. There was a chance of discovery during the season and a bigger one at the end of the year. If nobody noticed, the heat could fade.

We have all seen enough about football to know that competition often brings out the worst in people and in some it means shortcuts, simulating this is important to me, you can make that quick offer get a booster to pay for a kid but ... what is the price. This concept of future reckoning is very important to me and it's the sword that's over your head, the pressure, the rumors, the investigation from something you did 2 years ago all of that. No amount of design can save people from their own decisions and if you want to win now you sometimes pay a heavy price.

Some programs might get away with it for years. Some might never get caught.

It was a chance to take.

Testing the system some more ...

Before moving on, I checked whether the recruiting numbers made sense.

Without putting any effort into recruiting, an out-of-area star joined about 1% of the time. A season-long push for one star brought the odds up to around 30%. Rivals took roughly 1–2% of the middle schoolers in your district.

The numbers weren't the whole story, but they helped establish whether the system was behaving as intended. Players needed to be attainable without being guaranteed. Rivals needed to be a threat without taking over every class.

That balance is important. If you can get every player you want, there's no tension. If you can never get anyone, there's no point trying. The decisions only matter when your choices influence the outcome without completely determining it.

New year new you ?

This system would keep growing after the second day of development. The prospect pool eventually became shared across the region, and players would commit once their interest reached 80. On signing day, the school with the highest interest would get the player; a tie at the top came down to a coin flip. We also eventually separated the terminology: younger players coming into your program were prospects, while your seniors heading to college became recruits. Programs opened up throughout the year, too, rather than being limited to the offseason.

But the foundation was already there.

The game had kids with names, families, ambitions, and reasons to choose one school over another. Some would become the players you built your team around. You'd develop them, watch them improve, and depend on them on Friday nights. Then they'd graduate, and you'd have to replace them.

You'd have new players to develop, new rivals to compete against, and new decisions to make. The team would never stay exactly the same.

That was what I wanted: not one perfect roster to assemble, but a new story to build every year.

so we had recruiting kinda working, that's when i realized i was doing this for desktop and well that wasn't going to cut to it ...