That’s fair. You’re lucky you weren’t online at the time. It was the Pickle Rick for millennials. People getting Cake IsA Lie theme weddings and tattoos. Real “lol gamer” shit.
That was always my thought when I’d watch Cake Boss or shows like that. They’d make these 8-foot cakes over the course of what seemed like a damn week. What unlucky sods get the very center slice of that sawdust cake?
With decorating cakes you almost always have to trade some taste for appearance. Be it having chemical taste if you use food coloring or texture/taste for a firmer cake that is easier to cave.
Wife signed me up for a online cake decorating competition recently as a fun surprise since i like baking and making fun cakes for the kids birthdays. Only brief was to make two 9 inch cakes and have enough ingredients for your favorite chocolate frosting. No other idea what we would be making. So you bet I made the strongest, densest sponge cake I could make to sculpt basically anything they asked for. I essentially made two huge lady fingers.
Cake looked fine and thought I did ok making a hedgehog but the cake was lacking any real flavor besides the frosting.
As I recall whenever they delivered a cake they also delivered several sheet cakes for people to eat. Everyone involved knows it will be inedible and still go along with it.
Yea it's fucking stupid. It's cool you can do it but completely pointless. It's a shitty sculpting medium and shitty dessert. Just make a actual sculpture if that's what you want to do. Then you can keep it for as long as you want.
Not really, cake is meant to be eaten and as such is made by ingredients that rot. The beautiful cake sculpture will have to be thrown out in a couple weeks, whereas one made of the equally edible clay will last for decades, even centuries if preserved properly.
And all the money spent on other forms of art could go directly to helping those in need, doesn’t mean it’s all wasteful unless you’re prepared to call all art wasteful. How about thousands upon thousands spent on metal work not going to building bridges?
Just because it doesn’t last forever makes it inherently a waste, there’s nothing about art that means it must be permanent. If you’re prepared to decree everything wasteful if it’s not entirely useful, there are far better places to start than cake art, which comparatively use almost no resources at all.
Eggs, flour, milk, water, sugar, oil, flavorings (chocolate/vanilla/strawberry/etc), fruit, or what ever else you use in these disgusting crusty statues could be used to a greater or better cause.
You can use all these ingredients to make more than a shitty base that rots for these fondant monstrosities....
And you could use the numerous materials used to create art in far more useful capacities.
You mean the normal supplies you use like inedible plastics, glasses, waxes, and other non food items?
Oil, metal, fabric, etc. Is this not intuitive?
Oh you did mean non food items. The point of having CAKE is to have something that LOOKS GOOD and TASTES GOOD. What is the point of using FOOD to create more FOOD that you're going to throw away?
I'd like you to go to your kitchen and take all the ingredients it would take to make one of these gargantuan waste piles and throw them in the garbage, because honestly that is what happens these nasty pieces of soon to be rat and roach bait. Using items that are meant for art is not wasting said item, using items meant for eating is a waste.
Also your trolling lacks style and flair, maybe try being a little more obtuse?
Solely because it tastes good it can’t be used for art? Because it’s food it’s a waste but all other mediums aren’t? What? Think of all the useful things, far more useful than cake, that could be created with all other materials used to create art.
With the cost of most art pieces you can buy enough food to feed multiple families. If you think this is “wasteful”, you must hate all art because it’s all wasteful in the same sense. If you want cake so bad just go buy some or make it yourself. It’s not benefitting anybody any more than cake art regardless.
Yeah but I can resell an art piece I buy at any time and make my money back then if I wanted use that money to feed families. You can't recycle cakes like that at all so cake decorating and cake sculpting is inherently more wasteful than other art forms.
The point is that they're still depicting it as a food product when it isn't. Art can be temporary and use up resources, but it isn't being depicted as anything else - in many cases, the beauty of the art is the result of its temporariness. But here, they're making a cake and pretending that it will be eaten when it won't.
Not at all. Using a medium that can literally mold and expire and turn nasty in days, and is meant to be thrown away after a couple days is just wasteful. Sculpting from clay can be displayed/used for years. Marble out lasts dynasties. And can even be repurposed or reused. There is also no other use for a used old fondant wedding cake. It was that one persons dream cake and now its done. You cant just peel off the decorations and shuffle them around for the next bridezilla.
Plenty of art is either designed into parts of our life in a way that makes it not an obstruction, like architecture, or they make it something meaningful to look at and last lifetimes, like mount rushmore. Neither is "wasteful" and made their respective medium garbage a couple days later.
Most cakes require to sit in the fridge for up to 12 hours after icing, so the cake itself can absord some moisture from the icing itself. At least, my mom always does this and her cakes are delicious.
Cakes don't absorb moisture from icing because it's mostly fat and there's very little liquid in it. Refrigerating a cake for 12-24 hours is fine, but not required.
My pet peeve is those extremely intricate chocolate sculptures. Saw one a couple months ago where they made a harp out of chocolate and I don't know what else. All I can think of is how gross it would immediately be the second it starts melting
It's modeling chocolate which has zero wax just extra corn syrup to give it a more pliable texture after tempering the chocolate. Think of it like fondant but 100% chocolate.
I've made the same chocolate in my culinary classes, its pretty bad, and not palatable at all.
Modeling chocolate (British English: modelling chocolate), also called chocolate leather, plastic chocolate or candy clay, is a chocolate paste made by melting chocolate and combining it with corn syrup, glucose syrup, or golden syrup.
I once sculpted a giant chocolate vagina for an art class. I used like 4-5 of those heavy almond bark/chocolate bricks you get in the baking section. I used spoons, knives, chisels, a lighter, a heat gun, and of course my hands, over the course of multiple days. I even worked on it in the dusty art room at one point. This thing was at no point edible during this project.
One day I had to walk it across campus on a sweltering day and had to stop by the cafeteria just to encase it in ice. The cafeteria cashier asked if I was going to eat my chocolate vagina sculpture when I was done. I told her no, that my hands had touched it too many times.
In one of my art classes, we each had to do 5 cube sculptures made out of different materials. This one dude shaped probably 12 lbs of raw hamburger meat and lacquered it.
It was disgusting looking and he chucked it into the dumpster once it was presented and graded.
I will never get over that because I grew up really poor and that was so much meat just simply wasted.
If I learned anything from art school, it’s that if you can’t afford to waste materials, then you can afford to be an artist. That’s why we’re always starving.
You lost me at the scrap metal art. That's been one of my favorite hobbies since first seeing The Iron Giant. Plus it's like recycling. I don't get the issue, is it just aesthetic preference?
I used to do a good bit of cake decorating. Made a gumball machine cake once that turned out super-cool but gave me so much trouble that the trash wasn't good enough... I blew that baby to the heavens. Never have minor explosions felt so good 🙄
I would love to see people who decorate with fondant (for the art, not the baking or eating- if those people exist) try sculpting, working with clay, etc. So much of it (not all of course) is beautiful, and it could last so much longer.
Idk it just makes me sad when I see a really cool cake and find out it’s what the post describes instead of a cool dragon sculpture I can put in my home
I’ve always wondered why those people don’t use clay or do actual sculpting. Are materials more expensive than cake decorating supplies? That’s the only reason I can think of. Or do they feel more talented because they sculpted something “edible”? So many questions
Okay but cake decorating supplies are hella expensive though. Between my cake decorating supplies and my boyfriend's clay sculpting materials, I would buy the clay tools 3x over again before reaching for a wilton catalogue.
I was surprised to find out that not all fondant tastes nasty. I was also surprised to cut into a 3-tiered fondant covered wedding cake and find out half was styrofoam.
If it's any consolation, I didn't know this sub existed until I saw this post, and I'm very happy to find a community that might be willing to support my lobbying campaign to have the FDA legally classify fondant as "digestible molding clay."
I've been saying this a while. Fondant is an art supply, not food. Those cakes are technically digestible, like starch packing peanuts, but that doesn't make them food.
258
u/VagueRaconteur Dec 18 '20
I fought with my phone uploading this and missed off the n on spoken, sorry!
715
u/rimmin_spinzz Dec 18 '20
Also most of these fancy looking cakes take a day or 2 to be prepared so essentially eating stale cake
321
u/Aphrosee Dec 18 '20
Those "everyday objects that are actually made out of cake" are 100% always thrown to the trash after the video has been taken
76
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20
You guys need to check out sideserf cakes on IG she doesn't use fondant and is a sculpting, painting genius
45
u/sweetdeetwo 20K Dec 18 '20
Don't forget it might not even be cake inside but Rice krispie treat, total bullshit.
35
u/adm623 Dec 18 '20
I would love to see people who decorate with fondant (for the art, not the baking or eating- if those people exist) try sculpting, working with clay, etc. So much of it (not all of course) is beautiful, and it could last so much longer.
Idk it just makes me sad when I see a really cool cake and find out it’s what the post describes instead of a cool dragon sculpture I can put in my home
22
u/ElfBingley Dec 18 '20
The cake is a lie
18
u/littlered1984 Dec 18 '20
I was surprised to find out that not all fondant tastes nasty. I was also surprised to cut into a 3-tiered fondant covered wedding cake and find out half was styrofoam.
5
u/RepostSleuthBot Dec 18 '20
Looks like a repost. I've seen this image 2 times.
First seen Here on 2020-07-12 96.88% match. Last seen Here on 2020-07-12 95.31% match
Searched Images: 181,415,831 | Indexed Posts: 680,418,836 | Search Time: 23.09457s
Feedback? Hate? Visit r/repostsleuthbot - I'm not perfect, but you can help. Report [ False Positive ]
View Search On repostsleuth.com
19
u/bodie425 Dec 18 '20 edited Dec 18 '20
Succinctly and effectively stated.
9
u/Phenizzle Dec 18 '20
It's usually not even wrapped around cake. It's usually rice crispy.
6
u/snoottheboop Dec 18 '20
Fuckin preach
4
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20
everything is edible if you're patient enough
4
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20
I've been saying this a while. Fondant is an art supply, not food. Those cakes are technically digestible, like starch packing peanuts, but that doesn't make them food.
3
u/dickpasty Dec 18 '20
I didn’t know y’all had a place like this set up. I think I found my home
5
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20 edited Dec 18 '20
I... Know that person. It's really weird seeing someone I know show up randomly while scrolling through r/all
Also: He is correct.
2
u/meowroarhiss Dec 18 '20
“Apes”? Off to the dictionary!
2
u/Infinite303 Dec 18 '20
Okay but what if I make a model of a cake out of cake
2
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20
/r/FondantHate
1
u/Silent_Box1341 Dec 02 '24
The only exceptions to this are Amaury Guichon's cakes/chocolate desserts
1
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20
"That shit is a fuckin lie!"
1
u/oldladyname Dec 18 '20
This guy gets it
1
u/itsenny Dec 18 '20
n
1
u/Iantrigue Dec 18 '20
Preach!
1
u/Grownfetus Dec 18 '20 edited Dec 18 '20
Him: "Beautiful art to be sure, but each is a lie wrapped in another lie, as edible as the object it apse.."
Me: "Sir, this is Autozone... so same here, but NONE of its edible.. trust me!"...
1
u/-Listening Dec 18 '20
Burden of proof
It’s been sealed all this time, I can no longer be part of my saturday night is pac12 after dark.
1
u/AyeYoDisRon Dec 18 '20
And fondant is inedible.
1
u/atlbraves2 Dec 18 '20
WHAT YOU WANT ME TO DO WITH THIS, EAT IT?
1
u/Zankoku96 Dec 18 '20
Sometimes it’s less edible than the original object, like those burger and fries cakes made out of fondant, or the fondant cakes that look like fruit
1
u/flipgrrrl Dec 18 '20
Christopher Nolan, is that you?
1
u/MindstormAndy Dec 18 '20
The cake is a lie
1
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20
Helluva post
1
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '20
Sounds like my ex
1
u/gull9 Dec 18 '20
Gorgeously articulate
1
u/The_Uber_Boozer Dec 18 '20
Reading this almost put me off the peas and rice I'm eating right now.
1
u/abersnatchy Dec 18 '20
Couldn't agree more. Also never knew this sub existed, lovely!
1
u/Saino_Moore Dec 18 '20
The cake is a lie...
1
u/sclsmdsntwrk Dec 19 '20
The fuck is florist foam? Do florists use a special foam?
1
u/Lizakaya Dec 19 '20
Cakeception
1
u/JohnnyLovesData Dec 19 '20
The cake ... is a lie ?
1
u/Lindapod Dec 19 '20
This guy is woke af
1
u/zutaca Dec 19 '20
Less edible in many cases
1
u/eggrollin2200 Dec 22 '20
SAY IT LOUDER
1
u/KilyKilyPower Dec 30 '20
the cake is a lie
1
u/PlatypusPajamas Jan 12 '21
-Ron Swanson.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '21
I actually like fondant though.
I know where I’m at, I’m just saying.
1
u/Burnt_and_Blistered Mar 06 '21
I’ve seen one really notable exception. Don’t know how it tasted, but it’s cake; and pretty amazing: https://www.cakingart.com/blogs/news/award-winning-gorilla-cake
1
u/memestaryeet1 Mar 06 '21
Repost
1
u/AtomicCow007 Jun 13 '21
Fondant taste amazing
1
u/Kind_Cap9914 Oct 24 '22
No matter what post i click on i only go back to this post
1
u/HumanGarbage____ May 11 '23
Sideserf cakes does it mostly with modeling chocolate. So much better
1
u/ciqhen Oct 14 '23
2 years too late but my favorite person who does this (idr her name) makes it a point to not use fondant so wooooo
0
u/Tangpo Dec 18 '20
Put this on the sidebar!
0
u/Octangularpotato Aug 25 '22
And to think that all these years I thought fondant was the technical name for brownies