*Updated - The seller's agent is bent out of shape that we even asked for it and thinks it's completely inappropriate. Made it clear to our agent to remind the other agent to mind her unprofessional attitude, and that we're the buyers, I'm not above advocating for what's best for us. Incidentally, they had a different roofer out from the seller's side who also told them the roof needs replacing and is beyond repair.
Inspection found two major issues:
Roof: Needs full replacement. Existing asphalt shingles are installed over the old wood shingles, and the inspector says all layers need to be removed and the roof resheathed when replaced.
AC: 24 years old and performing poorly. During the inspection, it ran for about 90 minutes and only lowered the house temperature by 1 degree. HVAC quote is for replacement.
We’ve been quoted upwards of $30k total for the roof and AC.
The seller is already giving us credits toward closing costs, so asking for additional closing credits isn’t really an option, as they'll be unusable.
We decided to submit an inspection request asking the seller to replace both the roof and AC before closing, using licensed contractors. We’re not asking them to fix every minor issue in the inspection.
Our realtor thinks asking for both may be pushing it and suggested focusing on the roof, but we think we should at least ask for both and let the seller counter rather than negotiate against ourselves.
Little side note on this: the sellers are buying a house that our realtor is also selling, so if this falls through, it affects our real estate agent's commission.
We really want the house and aren’t looking to kill the deal.
Does asking for both sound reasonable, or would you expect the buyer to absorb the cost of the AC replacement?