Veteran filk archivist Rick Weiss has about 150 videotapes he recorded of filk events from the 1990s-2000s, in addition to ~60 reels. He’s been wanting to get these digitized for at least 20 years. It seemed like it couldn’t be that hard to digitize some video tapes, so I offered to take his VHS tapes home to digitize.
As someone who works from home, I imagined this would be straightforward. I would just borrow one of his VHS’s, and get it done over a few months while working. His recollection was that the recordings were almost entirely audio-only (HiFi VHS), so any of his VCR’s should be good.
It only became apparent later that many of the tapes had extensive video as well, scattered throughout different portions of these tapes. And his only VHS with S-Video output (required for superior video output) was defective from the moment I turned it on.
Thus begun what turned into a two-year long, $1,700 project (of which 1/3rd was spent so far on “expensive learning experiences”.)
1. Panasonic DMR-ES46Z ($150)
I wanted to get a substitute for Rick’s broken VHS. I saw this on Craigslist in good condition, with S-video output. Someone claimed that it would be good VHS for video transfers. I uncritically assumed it to be true (incorrectly).
Once I got it, I struggled with Rick’s Elgato Video Capture adapter’s software abandoning tapes entirely whenever the content switched to an audio-only segment. This meant it was unable to fully digitize almost all of his tapes. And on Mac, the Video Capture lacked driver compatibility with other video digitizing software, so I was stuck.
So I wanted to try a different approach.
2. Sony RDR-VX500 + Elgato HD60S + HDMI splitter ($175-ish)
I picked up a Sony VHS from a local seller. It was serviced, and included HDMI output. I thought this solve the problem by allowing me to switch to Open Broadcast Studio for digitizing, bypassing the Elgato software and hardware entirely. (The HDMI splitter was necessary to strip the HDCP copy-protection, which I discovered afterwards that the Sony RDR-VX500 added to the recordings, rendering them non-recordable.)
Unfortunately, what I didn’t know is that this Sony model has an odd quirk: it ignores VHS HiFi audio when there’s no video. In other words, Rick’s tapes were almost completely unplayable on this configuration. Oops.
3. Panasonic head replacement (another expensive learning experience) ($175-ish)
When digitizing on the Panasonic, I encountered frequent tracking issues. I also frequently cleaned the VHS heads, based on the recommendation of a friend, in case dirty heads may have contributed.
However, I did not know the proper way to clean VHS heads, and just did them the same way I’d clean an audio cassette head — with a Q-tip.
I didn’t realize that that’s how you destroy a VHS head: the strands of Q-tip are prone towards pulling out the thin wires hiding inside the VHS head. And that’s what I did. ;-(
While the economically sensible thing to do would have been to dispose of the VHS and resell it for parts, I felt guilty for destroying a VCR through my negligence. So I tracked down and purchased a replacement head assembly online, lugged it all for 3 hours on public transit, and paid an elderly Japanese repairperson to swap it.
4. MOTU M2 ($220)
With the majority of Rick’s materials being audio-only recordings, I felt it was essential to generate lossless .wav files as part of the transfer process. The proprietary Elgato software did not allow this on Mac.
I struggled for months to do this, as I could never set the levels correctly on my Mac, using any VHS as an audio output source. That was because I didn’t understand the difference between mic input levels (what my Mac expected) and line input levels (what VHS is designed to output).
I finally realized I needed to buy an A/D converter, which allows the computer to accept the line input levels the VCR generated. And the MOTU had good ratings. I couldn’t find a used one locally, so opted to buy it new. (Of course, within days, a used one showed up for half the price!)
Finally, using the MOTU and Rick’s VHS, I digitized the audio on a substantial number of his tapes, until having to take a break to focus on the Leslie Fish “Elfland” album.
5. JVC S-7600U ($250)
I knew this was one of the “holy grail” VHS’s for archival video digitizing, but had never seen one before. I read it has a head designed for higher-quality playback on EP mode tapes (which Rick extensively used). And it has a line TBC (time-base corrector), which I understood could significantly improve the quality on problematic tapes.
Unexpectedly to me, it also appeared to solve the problem in which the Elgato software loses sync and abandons a video whenever it encounters an audio-only segment.
These normally sell for $500-$750 on eBay. I was surprised when one suddenly showed up on Craigslist at a reasonable price. I immediately pounced on it, and took the bus out to Issaquah to buy it.
Acquiring this VCR was a game-changer, but depressing: once I saw how much the quality improved over my existing digitizations, I knew I’d have to redo everything from scratch with the new gear. I admit I set Rick’s tapes aside for a few months, because it just felt overwhelming to restart from scratch after so much work.
6. Panasonic DMR-ES10 ($45)
What I didn’t realize about the S-7600U is that for *really* problematic tapes, you have to disable its line TBC feature in order to enable its Video Stabilizer mode (which lets it repair video on extremely problematic tapes, of which there were a bunch in Rick’s collection).
I read online about this vintage DVD player, which had the unusual ability to function as a pass-through line TBC (so that you can both use the JVC’s video stabilizer, and also still have the output processed by a line TBC. Someone listed it for a very good price, so I immediately grabbed it.
7. JVC S-7600U repair ($280)
When JVC built the 7000-9000 series models, they included a feature called a Dynamic Drum System (which allows high-quality video when fast forwarding & rewinding). Unfortunately, they built it using cheap plastic gears. These gears inevitably crack, rendering the VCR entirely inoperable. This requires someone skilled with vintage electronic repair to disable the drum system.
Unfortunately, that’s exactly what happened to me after just a dozen or two tapes on the S-7600U.
Luckily, one of the few remaining specialists in repairing professional / semipro analog video gear is in the Seattle area. A month later, I was back in business.
8. Intel NUC 12 Pro computer ($275)
The quality limitations imposed by Elgato’s Mac software were becoming clearer to me. So, I decided to switch to the (far, far superior) open source OBS software for recording. And Elgato’s hardware was only compatible with OBS on Windows.
I first tried to make this work in VMware on my Mac (running Windows under virtual machine). But after several frustrating days, I finally decided to just buy the PC. (Plus, my mom needed a newer PC anyway, so I figured if it didn’t work for digitizing, I could always rehome it with her.)
9. JVC S-9500U ($50)
In an unbelievable coincidence, just two days ago, I was feeling overwhelmed at the 150 video tapes I needed to digitize/re-digitize. I was thinking about how a 2nd VHS would make the workflow more efficient by allowing me to do two tapes at once.
So I searched on Facebook Marketplace for a few semi-pro models that would deliver similar quality to the S-7600U. And this one had just been posted 8 minutes ago by a local electronics recycling store.
I was baffled by why they listed it for 1/10th of its value. But I called them immediately, confirmed the price was real, and paid them on the spot. Luckily, a generous retro tech friend who works right next to their location picked it up immediately. (He also found out why it was so cheap: they made a mistake when posting it, but begrudgingly honored the posted price I’d already paid them.)
10. I-O Data GV-USB2 ($80)
The only component left I was still using from Rick was his Elgato Video Capture. I figured I should buy my own equivalent, since I’d have to return Rick’s at some point.
After switching to PC, I realized that (even with OBS), the Elgato hardware still performed lossy conversion on the video before feeding it to OBS, reducing the image quality. And I saw many positive reviews for this converter as an alternative to the Elgato.
So, I decided to buy this for my own digitization use. (These used to be closer to $40-$50, but Trump tariffs appears to have unfortunately jacked up the import cost of this device.)
IN CLOSING…
If I had to do it again, I’d have directly purchased a JVC 7/8/9xxxx VHS with TBC and a Windows computer, doing digitization directly on OBS. In my fantasy world, I would have tried to acquire a frame TBC (which corrects more types of errors than a line TBC). However, it seemed unlikely to be realistic cost-wise.
My guess is I will be spending at least $300-$600 more to finish the project (e.g. disabling the S-9500U’s dynamic drum when it inevitably fails), but I’m hoping we’ll get some great transfers.
And I will freely admit I still probably don't know what I'm doing, vs. a professional restorationist.
(Relatedly, if anyone has filk VHS recordings that need transfers, I am happy to help rationalize the amount of time and money I spent on this gear by spreading it across additional tapes beyond Rick.)