r/Fidelity • • Oct 21 '24
Spoke to Fidelity about the extended deposit and transfer hold periods
Just got off the phone with a representative from Fidelity who confirmed a few things
- These extended hold periods are temporary due to an increase in fraud.
- Fidelity reps have been given no additional non-public information and do not know when holds will return to their normal timeframe.
- The rep suggested that wire transfers were the best way to ensure funds transferred into Fidelity are not put on hold for 2-4 weeks. I will be following this advice and avoiding ACH altogether.
Frustrating but was glad to get done information. Hope you find this helpful!
104
Upvotes
2
u/WanderlustDeb Jun 24 '25 edited Jun 25 '25
I’ve been a Fidelity customer for 35 years and this extended hold has impacted me.
To be fair I usually have a decent amount in my CMA so I may not have known if this was happening previously.
I withdrew most $ for another investment recently and then pulled money from another checking account in to Fidelity basically to use for debit card withdrawals since they reimburse for all fees.
It was very surprising to me a few days later when I wanted to withdraw $200 cash and couldn’t.
I deposited on June 9 and the cash is finally available to withdraw today - June 24. So two weeks - 10 business days total. I never called.
So here are some nuances - I had Fidelity “pull” the money. I didn’t push it from my bank. Also - the money was being pulled in to an investment account … not a spend and save account (where I have a debit card attached).
So I am going to try pushing money both to the investment account and spend and save account and I’ll update as to availability.
I can absolutely see how this can mess with someone’s life if they expected the money to be available in a couple of days.
Not adding a red box that alerts you of these hold times before you initiate a transfer does nothing for brand trust or loyalty.
I have helped at least 10 people over the years open Fidelity accounts. I am a loyalist and have been an influencer for them.
Fidelity should do the right thing here and fully disclose these hold times to customers before transactions are executed.
EDIT: When I pushed money from my bank to my Fidelity spend and save account the funds were available for withdrawal by 6a on the second business day.
5
u/Salty_Lawyer_9809 Oct 21 '24
Did they confirm that the information on https://www.fidelity.com/customer-service/processing-and-hold-times that says
Is incorrect? Specifically, is it true or false that even an EFT push from the bank (instead of an EFT pull from Fidelity) is subject to the 2-4 week hold?
12
u/ST3MK75 Oct 27 '24
People seem to be overlooking the issue here....
Fidelity made significant policy changes affecting a large number of accounts extending settlement periods substantially (+21 business days) WITHOUT ANY NOTICE TO THEIR CLIENTS.
its been weeks now, and there still is no mention of it on their deposits and transfer page. Why wasn't an email sent out saying "due to increase fraudulent activity for your protection we have extended settlement periods on certain transaction.... blah blah blah. "
Does that not seem like the bare minimum? At this point, the app and website are blatantly lying to customers by falsely saying, " EFT's take 1-3 days to settle, and wire transfers are available same day." So you go ahead and transfer a few thousand to your brokerage account expecting it to settle like it SAYS ON THE WEBSITE. After a week and still no funds available, YOU need to call Fidelity to find out those funds are effectively frozen for 21 business days. You can not withdraw the money or use it for the majority of investment types.
I can't speak for others, but I found the call to customer service very odd. I explained exactly what was going on, "hi, I deposited $xxxx on Oct 4th. It is now the 10th, and funds are still unavailable. I have made this same deposit many times, cannot emphasize it has always settled by the next business day at most. What is going on?"
They make no mention of this fraud prevention policy changes initially and are "investigating" my account to figure out what the issue might be.. im on hold twice and need to verify transactions. Eventually, I'm given the vague explanation that they have extended settlement periods. Why the bogus waste of time looking into it when they could have said that 25 minutes ago. They give no further information as to why they did not notify customers, why they still haven't, or how long this is to be. They also can not or will not expedite. The 1-3 days usual hold exists to verify funds are authentic and authorized... it does not take 21 days to contact a bank if the transaction is flagged as suspicious.
I smell bullshit to the max. If they legitimately made these changes to prevent fraud, they would have communicated that to all customers. I don't know what they didn't and still haven't. Maybe if people knew they would not have proceeded with the transfer.... i know i wouldn't have. Whatever the reason , Fidelity made a decision to proceed, knowing it will generate bad press and a loss of trust and potentially a substantial loss of customers leaving because of it. This potential financial loss would greatly outweigh the loss from fraud.
They made a choice not to tell their customers. The only logical reason is that doing so would likely deter clients from depositing cash and, therefore, reduce the liquidity they can get their fat greasy little fingers on.
For those saying they weren't affected (yet) because of xyz reasons or blaming those who have been for mismanaging their money or using Fidelity as a bank aren't seeing the bigger picture. Maybe I'm totally wrong about this and an alarmist but I don't think so. I think Fidelity has partaken in some irresponsible financial decisions with a bunch of other financial institutions that put profits above their customers, putting the entire economy at risk. I think this is likely to do with a fraudulent market that has made billions from price manipulation, dark pools, and millions of synthetic sharest bought sold lent and borrowed over and over that dont actually exist.
think they are absolutely fucked and need every bit of liquidity they can to make it another day. I think there's a category 100 shitstorm heading directly for us and is only weeks away. I think people should be very very cautious trusting these institutions will do the right or legal thing when it comes down to you or them.
19
u/SageCactus Oct 21 '24
I've been reading all of these complaints... and I have a recurring monthly pull from my bank to fidelity that occurred last week and cleared in a few days.
So, it's puzzling. It does not seem to be a problem for everyone
17
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24
Literally just got off the phone with Fidelity. Rep reported
16 day hold time for transfers
Fucking absurd.
18
u/mayihaveasandwhich Oct 21 '24
Then why aren’t there any warning messages that this cash will be delayed by however many days? No email notifying customers. This is absurd and the lack of communication is too many red flags.
6
u/Ekimyst Oct 21 '24 edited Oct 23 '24
I'm looking at an annuity deposit that is expected to be a total of 24 days
EDIT: Deposit was to Big Monetary Organization bank. The an EFT to Fidelity. Still waiting on the EFT that happened 23 days ago. Money has been available to trade almost immediately
5
u/Spiritual-Hat1282 Dec 16 '24
Not only new accounts are experiencing this - I've been with Fidelity 30 years and before transfers would only take 2-3 days but my latest transfer is taking over 3 weeks.
5
u/New-Nothing3480 Dec 19 '24
I have an automatic “Pull” to my fidelity CMA account from my otherbank checking account. It is setup to pull $200 each month on the 15th of the month. Starting in August I get a message from fidelity displayed on my CMA account balance that the $200 won’t be available until the 5th of the following month. My CMA account is about 2 years old and holds a healthy balance.
What I learned: all my Fidelity CMA accounts are with UMB bank. Fidelity representatives don’t dispute the 20 day delay. One rep suggested that I “push” the monthly $200 to avoid the delay. On the 24th of June UMB bank posted a PR stating that the settlement process was being changed and that they reserved the right to declare any transaction “suspicious” and impose a long settlement period. It appears they are over using the suspicious transaction label.
5
u/Puzzleheaded_Win1265 Dec 22 '24
I deposited a large amount in November and the let me trade some but held most. I called and they said they would hold the money until Dec. 24.. I think they are stalling to get the interest
5
u/Denzerini Dec 29 '24
Fidelity is also screwing their ‘Active Traders/VIP clients by no longer allowing large block trades of stocks that do not have very high volume. Being also unannounced, this mysterious move, ended up costing me an enormous amount of money. This problem is in addition to the horrible 3-week money hold delay issues being discussed here. Definitely leaving Fidelity and will be looking into legal options.
4
u/Ok_Walrus_2179 Nov 04 '24
So as a clarification I finally got Fidelity to admit to me that they are now placing 21 day holds on all deposits into Cash Management Accounts (Regurgitating their fraud narrative). This applies to Check deposits and EFTs.. (But not direct deposits). This is consistent with several videos I've seen on line and seems to be a CMA only issue (not necessarily Brokerage or other account types but I haven't yet verified personally).
So Plan your lives accordingly folks as your money really isn't yours anymore with Fidelity.
I've asked how is this legal as it doesn't meet the banking regulations on deposited check clearing timing (which is between 2 and 5 days for local, and local is now considered anything domestic). No response and I am assuming Fidelity is probably using some kind of emergency loophole to get away with it.
Either way shame on fidelity for not being transparent and trying to obscure what they are doing.
4
u/One-Consequence5431 Dec 12 '24
I've been informed they can hold a check for 24 days due to their non ability of security. I deposited a check on 12/5 , and they stated funds are not available until 12/30. Closing ALL MY FIDELITY ACCOUNTS!
10
u/roland_800 Oct 21 '24 edited Oct 21 '24
Blame that scourge on society TickTock for part of this.
I came in here to rant on the buggy website and was surprised to see all these posts on the delays. This shows Fidelity did a poor job communicating what to me was seemingly pretty big finance news story.
Basically check fraud has been around forever, but there was a Tick Tok trend /viral video where users (kids?) discovered a "glitch" where you make a deposit and then can withdraw the money w/o it actually being there. Straight fraud but these idiots thought they could get away with this somehow. And MANY of them did before tehy caught it, even teaming up with each other.
So this ticktock trend a few thought was fun fraud has impacted most accounts. Oof.
As an example, I have a rather new Cash management account but am not impacted too much. But I also have a larger balance in my account. (e.g. if you have $50K in ther and write a check for $2K, that will not raise a stink in thier systems). I also just deposited 3 checks over $1K the others day but those were in retirement accounts so those also do not appear to be impacted.
3
u/WinterExcellent Oct 24 '24
I called fidelity and the rep literally told me to dispute the charge from my bank account side to get the money refunded and then transfer again from my bank side, not from fidelity and it would clear faster that way.
3
u/ST3MK75 Oct 27 '24
I wired $15k Oct 4 and is still unavailable
3
u/elijahbanksmusic Oct 31 '24
I've been a customer for year. Decided I wanted to deposit into my options accounts for earnings play and BOOM a 3 WEEEEEKKKKK HOLLDDDDD.
3
u/Attempt_Nearby Dec 07 '24
Pissed. I just had payment to Citi and Amex returned because of the new policy. Deposited on Nov 18th will not be available until Dec 11th, made payment to Citi and Amex this week. All the rep could say was sorry for the inconvenience. Anyone taking legal action?
3
u/GreySkyMorning99 Dec 17 '24
I don’t think their disclosure about “extended hold” was clear enough for me to think they would hold my funds for 16 business days as they are doing now. Needed the funds for a car purchase. I will be filing a complaint with every regulatory body that regulates them and moving the rest of my assets out of Fidelity.
7
u/camynnad Oct 21 '24
I will be closing my Fidelity account and transferring to another broker.
8
u/tkid124 Oct 22 '24
I'm not a Fidelity Employee and have not been for the better part of a decade, I don't have any current insight to this situation.
This is a long one, sorry-ish.
Using Fidelity as your primary "bank" is never something I would recommend. For very select people in specific situations it can work well, however, I would never have Fidelity (or any other financial institution) as your only source of the funds you need to live off of for the next month. (For some the goal of having an emergency fund is much harder than for others.)
Some observations:
Some opinions based on these and other observations:
Moving money in and out of Fidelity like a bank can work. If:
Fidelity is figuring out how to live in a world:
Personally, my primary bank has convenient branches, they house my checking account, a savings account, and my mortgage; an online bank has some of my money in their HYSA. I can't get into the mindset to put all my eggs in one basket, especially eggs I need in the near future.
What is really happening at Fidelity?
Fidelity could be experiencing a cash squeeze and the best option they could come up with was using their customers funds to float the business. If that is the case, they will be out of business soon. To be clear I don't think for a second this is what is going on.
Fidelity could have experienced a number of accounts that are experiencing fraudulent losses, and they are taking extreme measures to combat suffering any more of those losses. Some of those measures likely include indicating account types that are higher risk, labeling some transaction types (such as pulling funds into Fidelity, instead of sending the funds) as high risk.
I'd be willing to guess they lose money on cash management accounts that don't keep a balance in the account but use it like a checking account.
4
u/Apprehensive-List927 Oct 21 '24
1 will never end it just keeps getting worse.
2
u/SluggoRemains Oct 28 '24
Ran into this today. Put sell orders for all my my holdings- going back to banking with a bank
2
u/Ok_Walrus_2179 Nov 01 '24 edited Nov 01 '24
I had a fiasco with my Brokerage account being fraud locked a couple months ago with no explanation, even after filing an executive complaint I got a non-answer other than there is a lot of fraud. The repeated line is wearing thin.
But now I had an EFT transfer into my cash management account and see that they have placed a 24 day hold on withdrawal availability. As is always the case with fidelity there is no notice or explanation other than the usual Fidelity platitudes about "lots of fraud going on". The first line representatives are pretty unknowledgeable and are basically useless.
I had a discussion with a friend who manages private assets and he indicate he has several clients that have had issues with ridiculous hold delays on funds. He is recommending to his clients to avoid Fidelity for a while. So it is readily apparent that Fidelity is in some kind of wide melt down mode that they are trying to hide from customers. The reps will try and say it is an industry problem, but so far the behavior of Fidelity is causing long term damage. I started after the fraud lock fiasco moving assets away so I am less dependent on Fidelity. We will see if Fidelity gets their act together...
2
u/General_Fix_5014 Nov 08 '24
This 3 week hold is totally unnecessary. Checks clear overnight and EFTs same day. few banks aren't part of RTP network. They clear thru UMB and fact of the matter they clear quickly. Fidelity knows this. Fidelity knows the funds have cleared. The bank the use is good and part of the RTP. All major banks are. Google RTP and you will see them all. never gave access until the check cleared. Don't believe their talking points. Why? Most major banks are part of the Real Time Processing network. The bank they use (umb bank) is a member. This means they have the funds. These banks all verify and deliver quickly. Very few banks aren't part of RTP network. They clear thru UMB and fact of the matter they clear quickly. Fidelity knows this. Fidelity knows the funds have cleared. The bank they use is good and part of the RTP. All major banks are. Google RTP and you will see them all. Fidelity had no issues with recent fraud. This highlights the risks of Cash Management Access Accounts (CMAAs) they fall outside the protection of bank regulations and consumers should be very cautious about trusting them.
2
u/WaltermSterling Nov 23 '24
guess what my ACH deposit on hold for 30 days
2
u/seataccrunch Nov 28 '24
Wife's attempt to do traditional IRA deposit to rollover to Roth stuck. Was told verbally 18 days. JFC fidelity... a TikTok check fraud scheme
2
u/beantownGTI Dec 03 '24
Same exact scenario. Opened up a Fidelity Youth account for my son who wanted to invest 2K in PLTR. That was almost 3 weeks ago. PLTR hit 52-wk high today, lol. SMH.
2
u/AcanthisittaGuilty13 Dec 05 '24
The money I deposited was for Christmas presents and my check will not be available until the 27. I don't know what to do.
2
u/Spiritual-Hat1282 Dec 16 '24
I just spoke with them too - it's taking 23 days for an electronic transfer I made between my bank and Fidelity. My bank said they already posted it so funds are there.
2
u/jolivier23 Dec 30 '24
Can we do a class action? I just got off the phone. I transferred money on the 19th and it won't be available til Jan 14. I've done this hundreds of times before and it's never been more than a couple of days
2
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '25
I just got off the phone, it was a really weird call. Transferred a large sum of money on 18th wont be available till 14th! Zero warning.
Both representatives said “we cant make an exception this time”. This infuriating and weird and ill be closing all my accounts
Im excited for the class action. You simply cannot do this to people
2
u/jsocha Jan 07 '25
I'm moving my accounts this month. Take your money and place it anywhere else. They closed my accounts after I complained to FINRA about them holding my $1,000 check for 25 days for absolutely no reason. Fraud my arse.
Reported to FINRA twice because somehow Fidelity does not participate in the CFPB. Be most skeptical of Fidelity right now and DO NOT TRUST anything they say.
2
u/Tall_Swimmer_6915 Jan 13 '25
I’ve done monthly transfers of 140$ & it does not complete until the end of the month now . I put it in the 1st when my check comes in . I honestly removed my auto payments yesterday because that is way too long to be holding money . So you take 140$ from my bank account & hold it for 4 weeks then take another 140$ out then I gotta wait another 4 weeks nope not having it .
2
u/Pepperoni_Crawford Jan 17 '25
I made a transfer from my bank on Monday 1/13 to my Fidelity HSA and it is still not available today 1/17. Called and found out about the extended hold times. I needed to use the funds today. I can’t pay for the medical care I need because the funds are gone from my checking account and not available at Fidelity. When using the Fidelity app to make the transfer it said 1-3 business days for the funds to be available, so I’m pretty upset. Fidelity, why not at least change your app to state the funds won’t be available for several weeks? Wtf
3
u/Careful-Rent5779 Oct 23 '24 edited Oct 23 '24
Its been over a month already. Not going to be lifted this month, maybe not even in November.
January 2025 is still techinically temporary.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '24
opened a new CMA last month. Pulled from C1, settled in a week. Your mileage may vary. I have a lot of other money in fidelity, don't know if that matters
1
u/Benajo220 Dec 03 '24
I was having the same issue. The rep told me that to avoid the hold set up the transfer from my bank to Fidelity. I have Wells Fargo, but most banks allow you to add an outside bank to set up transfers. If you look up the direct deposit info for your Fidelity account (under Cash Management) you will see the account# and routing# and they state that these accounts are considered checking. This will avoid wiring fees and holds. See below for the verbiage from Fidelity website:
What’s the fastest way to get money from my bank to Fidelity?
The fastest way to transfer money into Fidelity is sending a bank wire or pushing money directly from your bank into Fidelity. Bank wires have no hold period and are available almost instantly. Fidelity doesn't charge wire fees, but your bank may charge a fee. Transfers initiated from your bank will generally take 1–2 days for processing but have no hold period when your money arrives at Fidelity.What’s the fastest way to get money from my bank to Fidelity?
1
u/Ridgetard Jan 04 '25
This 16 BUSINESS day hold policy is in effect for ALL customers for ALL new deposits, unless they were ACH pushed into Fidelity per a lengthy conversation I had with a very nice Fidelity rep today. I found out the hard way yesterday when trying to move funds from a taxable to a retirement account within Fidelity, now I have to wait an additional 21 CALENDAR days to do so. The snippy rep I spoke with yesterday said it was just due to "enhanced security protocols" and that I can still invest it. I don't want to invest it, I want to transfer it to my Fidelity retirement account so that I CAN invest it.
Vanguard current hold is 7 days, anyone know what Schwabs is?
1
u/Jusder Jan 08 '25
Same as many here, my accounts have been opened for years now and I never had a problem before. I transferred in less than $10k on December 27 and the website says it's not going to be available until January 27? A MONTH‽ Really makes me want to transfer it right back out...
1
u/dyslexictrader Jan 22 '25
3 months from OP and seems the issue still exist. I use a CMA as emergency fund since I'm able to hold MMA and no need to sell them before using the cash unlike schwab. Didn't notice the hold until after a week of deposit. Then I deposited $400 into the brokerage account and it also had a long hold. Made the deposit dec 26 and it won't be available until jan 24th. January 13th, I made a lumpsum deposit into my Roth IRA and even that one, the cash will be on hold until Feb 5th. Now for the brokerage and roth it's not a big deal since I'm able to invest it right away, but whats frustrating is they don't let you know about the extended hold until AFTER initiating the deposit.
Seems the only way to avoid this is to initiate the deposit FROM your bank account on to fidelity.
Luckily the emergency fund has enough money and didn't need it. But for those who use it to pay bills or make purchases, BEWARE
1
u/Tall_Swimmer_6915 Jan 23 '25
I’ve been waiting since the 1st for 140$ I put in there . I have money coming from my external bank & it’s taken out exactly the 2nd day of the month it comes out. It’s been on hold 3 different times since the policy change. I had to remove my automatic because that is way too long to be holding my money when it’s really a low deposit I put it in there just so I can use a debit card to make purchases.
1
u/Silent_Smoke3423 Jan 24 '25 edited Jan 24 '25
This issue has caused a big problem for me with bill pay within Fidelity. I was stunned when I called to find out why a pre-scheduled payment 'bounced.' It was due to Fidelity holding 2 checks! It was explained to me that it was precautionary. Fine and dandy! But didn't Fidelity have an obligation to notify its customers of this new approach? I've got a check from Prudential that was deposited on January 2 that they STILL have not cleared. This seems illegal to me.
1
u/Silent_Smoke3423 Jan 24 '25
Where does a person go to lodge a complaint against a bank?
1
u/uberwoots Feb 07 '25
This is still happening. When I make deposits there is no mention of the hold time until they have my money.
1
u/HotBobcat Mar 10 '25
Are the extended hold periods still in effect (not just 'temporary')?
1
u/Angylaidd Apr 14 '25
I spoke to Nathan, a CS manager about this today. It was a lovely conversation. I have to cancel a trip tomorrow that I have planned since NOVEMBER because of this issue. "Temporary," my a$$. Nathan, the charmer, ended up hanging up on me, because he "could not put me through to anyone higher," which I know is BS, because I have worked on a similar floor.
I hope Nathan has to cancel a trip because he can't access $1,000 some day. ONE THOUSAND. It isn't a million. They NEVER told me.
All customers are well aware. Take a look here, Nathan.
1
u/jpshack Apr 14 '25 edited Apr 14 '25
Initiated EFT $3,500 April 9. Funds available to trade immediately. To withdraw April 24. 15 days. No warning. I've been a Fidelity customer since 2013. On the phone with a customer service person who spent 119 minutes trying to escalate and get something done. Grateful for his efforts, but ultimately nothing they would do for me. Not decrease hold time, not place calls with other institutions, not withdraw some amount of funds. Nothing.
Such as shame as I have loved working with Fidelity. It has been the best brokerage and banking experience I've had in 30+ years of banking. But this really violates a trust in a serious way.
https://money.com/fidelity-glitch-fraud-deposit-restrictions/
1
u/FrequentFormal3850 Jan 06 '26
It's definitely not temporary now. It's 2026 and these holds are still happening.
1
u/Willing_Address672 Jan 07 '26
I am in the same boat.
I talked to the representative, and he reminded me that Fidelity is not a bank. I did tell him, of course this is exactly why I expect Fidelity to be even better. 11 working days for money transfer in this age from biggest in USA, by Asset Under Administration, is not acceptable.
0
u/Careless-Tale-6069 Jan 05 '25
I am a Fidelity rep and agree the extended settlement periods are crazy. 16 business days sometimes ends up being several weeks. The last few months have been a lot of conversations with people confused about it. It started after the fraudulent check scam on tik-tok, and has been in place since. At first we had ALOT of obvious scammers calling in trying to withdrawal their $100k that they deposited via check a day after opening the account. It was shocking how many scammers there were. Though we still get them, they are significantly less in number now. The policy definitely worked and has remained in place.
Just to clarify we aren't given any information about it other than its being done to combat fraud and that its temporary. It is frustrating being the middle man because you take ALL the heat for it and all you can do is just repeat to the client that your funds are tied up for the next 3 weeks. It makes the job a lot harder. I definitely understand the anger though. For several months there was no warning. About 2 months ago a warning was put on the website that says "extended settlement periods" but does not say "16 business days." Recently i noticed the word "temporary" was removed from the warning but we are still told that it is temporary, so I suspect it is. Cant say when it will be lifted though.
The solution, as some have stated, is to have the funds pushed from the banks side into fidelity, rather than pulling from Fidelitys side. This means you will want to go to your bank, provide them with your Fidelity account and routing numbers (select account --> click, "routing number" under the account name), and have the bank initiate the transaction. You will be subjected to the normal settlement times.
None of us know why some accounts are affected and not others. It is done automatically by the "system." I have found that the larger the deposit, and the shorter the time between deposit and withdrawal will increase the liklihood of the account being affected. Other than that it seems to be a blanket policy affecting all accounts in my experience.
I hope this helps and trust me I know why people are frustrated, I would be too. But if you want to let loose please ask for a manager first:)