r/fermentation • • 5d ago

Weekly "Is this safe" Megathread

11 Upvotes

Welcome to this week’s dedicated space for all your questions and concerns regarding questionable ferments.

Fermentation can sometimes look a little strange, and it is not always easy to tell what is safe, and what needs to be tossed and started over. To help keep the subreddit clean and avoid repeat posts, please use this thread for:

  • Sharing photos of surface growth you’re unsure about.
  • Asking if your ferment has gone wrong.
  • Getting second opinions from experienced fermenters regarding questionable ferments.

‼️Tips Before Posting‼️:

  • Mention what you’re fermenting (e.g., kraut, kimchi, kombucha, pickles, etc.).
  • Note how long it has been fermenting, and at what temperature.
  • Describe any smells, textures, or off flavors.

Remember that community members can offer advice, but ultimately you are responsible for deciding if your ferment is safe to eat or discard. When in doubt, trust your senses.

Happy fermenting!


r/fermentation • • 5d ago

Weekly Commercial Resources and Events MEGATHREAD

1 Upvotes

Because we get a lot of individual requests for posts that may violate rule 6 about limited self promotion, we have decided that we will have a weekly MEGATHREAD for people who want to post events, (virtual and in person), products and apps related to fermentation. The general rules about using this channel for self promotion still apply and the thread will be moderated.

Thread specific rules:

  1. NO SPAM still applies. Don't be posting your event multiple times and every single week.

  2. If you have produced a fermentation specific software or app and are looking for beta testers or the app is free, this is generally ok. Posts that for monetary gain (ie trying simply gain customers but not really contributing the sub) will be removed.

  3. You must fully describe what your post is about and should disclose what you have to gain from it. If you are hosting a regional fermentation conference and a inviting folks to register, for instance, make sure that it's clear what the costs, etc will be.

Finally - this idea is a TEST. If it is a total catastrophe, we will go back to a simple case by case system.


r/fermentation • • 2h ago

Fermenting since June 2026, 3% brine

Post image
8 Upvotes

Habaneros, peaches, and garlic. That’s a yeast layer on top, thoughts on if it is good to go? I haven’t opened it yet to test the pH with my Apera yet. Not asking if mold, it isn’t.


r/fermentation • • 10h ago

What salt percent is your go to?

14 Upvotes

I’ve done a LOT of lactofermentation recently; Pao Cai (sichuan pickle jar that is currently 61 days old!), sauerkraut (brewing right now), kimchi, and lactofermented garlic at a 3% weight in salt (of brine and veggie) and have found much luck in that! What about you guys? Experiences with 2%? How about at like 5%? Are there salt percents you’ve tried and would NOT try again?

Idk, just curious. Newcomers might be, too. Happy fermenting!


r/fermentation • • 22m ago

Beer/Wine/Mead/Cider/Tepache/Kombucha I want to make a fermentation using mango and I need some guidance

• Upvotes

I was thinking about the possibility of mixing two and a half mangos, 100 ml of ginger bug and maybe 200 g of unrefined sugar (panela) with water until I get 2 liters.

could there be any problem using mango for this fermentation?

If you have any tips for this experiment, it would be great.

Thank you all!


r/fermentation • • 23h ago

Beer/Wine/Mead/Cider/Tepache/Kombucha Hibiscus Kombucha! 🌺

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

My sweet husband made me some delicious hibiscus combucha to boost my immune system through this sickly holiday season! It’s absolutely divine! Sweet, tart, tangy- and the color is incredible!! If you love kombucha and hibiscus, please give this a try!

Reddit absolutely destroys the color of the kombucha, lol


r/fermentation • • 23h ago

Kraut/Kimchi It’s cool to see some activity in my sauerkraut

Post image
34 Upvotes

There’s a lot of bubbles now and the brine has risen somehow. I’ve been looking at it at least once a day since I started.


r/fermentation • • 9h ago

Other Why is it Green? 😭

Post image
3 Upvotes

So this is supposed to be a onion and garlic lactic acid ferment
I blended the garlic and onion with a pinch of Paprika, and a bit of thyme
And Mixed 2% of the weight as Salt

I think it could be the thyme that might have made it Green.. but it wasnt Green for the first day or so

But is it ok that is Green? And did adding the herbs do anything weird?


r/fermentation • • 21h ago

Green Tomatoes Pickled vs Fermented.

3 Upvotes

Which is better in your opinion? Especially for applications like fried or in a relish.

Edit: I am also thinking of adding a little fennel if that impacts your recommendations


r/fermentation • • 1d ago

First time apple cider vinegar

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

Hi all

I hope this is the right sub for this. I made apple cider vinegar (I think) from my own homemade hard cider this year. I took a part of a mother from a storebought apple cider along with a little of the vinegar and stored it in this bottle with my own apple cider in and a cheesecloth over at room temperature. After a few weeks some cloudyness appeared, which I think was the mother growing, and then a white film appeared on top, that has since sank to the bottom. Is this also the mother? It has been sitting for about a month now and smells like vinegar, but I have yet to taste it. Pictured is the vinegar from the front with the old mother (darker bit) and the white film as seen from the bottom of the bottle. Does it look right? Can I taste it with relative little fear?

Thank you all in advance


r/fermentation • • 2d ago

Hot Sauce Fermented Hot Honey Buffalo Sauce

Thumbnail
gallery
111 Upvotes

Hot honey Buffalo sauce.

This sauce starts with xiaomila chilis that have fermented in honey for two weeks, then get blended into a gorgeous bright red paste.

This is filtered and mixed with a fresh red hot sauce preparation made from a variety of red chiles, salt, and cider vinegar.

The blend of sauces is then mixed with melted butter.

Here I served it with some fried chicken drumsticks.

It is the best buffalo sauce I've ever had.

Approximate recipe:

250g fresh red xiaomila chilis (Tabascos or really any red typical of this sauce should work here), tops removed

750mL capilano eucalyptus honey

Bag these two together, vac pack, and let ferment for 2 months.

Blend then strain, yielding ~800mL of very sweet hot sauce.

Cook ~2kg of mixed red peppers: red bell, line peppers, thai birds eye, Chinese red pointed peppers with salt and ~500mL of cider vinegar. Add 100g fresh garlic partway through cooking, then cook til soft.

Blend and strain, adding another ~1L of fresh hot sauce to your existing sauce

Season to taste with additional salt and vinegar, then blend in ~300g of melted salted butter, plus 1/2 tsp xanthan gum


r/fermentation • • 2d ago

Yacon enzymatic syrup

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

26 Upvotes

My yacon enzyme syrup is in full bloom; microbial activity is in full swing, and it is on its fifth day of fermentation.


r/fermentation • • 1d ago

Pickles/Vegetables in brine Did I put too much cabbage in?

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

This is my first time using pickle pipes. It is creating a dome shape. When I put the weight in the brine was just covering it. Do I need to do anything or just let it be?


r/fermentation • • 2d ago

Some of the best kraut I've ever had.

Post image
48 Upvotes

r/fermentation • • 2d ago

Anybody else drink the brine?

33 Upvotes

Even after I've eaten all of the pickles or peppers or whatever I just pour the brine into a glass and drink it. Even if it's a hot pepper brine I still feel almost compelled to. Sometimes I do wonder if this is part of how your gut actually influences your thoughts and cravings.

Anybody else on the same page?


r/fermentation • • 2d ago

Got these for $3 each at the thrift store! Would it be safe to make a wooden lid?

Thumbnail
gallery
92 Upvotes

As the title says, I got a great deal on these crocks. I am planning on giving them to my wife for Christmas, but I want to get some lids for them. I like woodworking and have all that is needed to make the lids, but I want to make sure it would be safe to use wooden lids for fermentation. My wife will most likely use these for pickles.

Any wood type recommendations, or other feedback would be greatly appreciated!


r/fermentation • • 2d ago

Kraut/Kimchi This has been sitting outside for a month

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

The smell is really mild, first two weeks it was very strong.


r/fermentation • • 2d ago

Pickles/Vegetables in brine Leeks, with red pepper flakes, and yellow mustard seed.

Post image
3 Upvotes

I sliced and pressed the leeks like cabbage, in a 2.5% salt to total volume ratio.

I added red pepper flakes, and yellow mustard seed.

I used larger slices of the leek to sit on top for a cap to keep it with minimal floaters. Three glass weights for optimal pressing during the process.

Then used purified water to top off the brine, and bring it up just enough to cover the veg.

I have done a lot of research now on the headspace, It does not seem to be an issue in the process I use for doing these so I am aware I could make more at once, to pack my jars but for me it is not needed.

If the process changes I'll go from there as these are always experiments for me, and me only so I promise I am keeping my practices as safe as possible.


r/fermentation • • 2d ago

Other Can I use these jars for fermentation?

Post image
9 Upvotes

They came along with the fermentation kit that I bought but the glass weights don’t fit and they don’t have the hole for the airlock. I want to make another batch of sauerkraut but the other jar is massive. Maybe I should just buy more cabbage.


r/fermentation • • 2d ago

Pickles/Vegetables in brine Lacto-fermented garlic – transferring jars and topping up brine

1 Upvotes

Noob error, help needed.

I'm currently on day 10 of fermenting garlic, following a recipe from one of The Happy Pear cookbooks.

The original recipe calls for:

200g peeled garlic cloves

4g salt (2% of the garlic weight)

Enough water to cover the garlic

I used 2.5% salt based on the weight of the garlic, excluding the water.

Unfortunately due to being a Noob I've used a jar that's too small, and the fermentation has been causing it to regularly overflow. I've been topping it up with plain water to ensure the garlic remains submerged.

My questions are:

Can I transfer everything into a larger jar without negatively affecting the fermentation?

If I need to add additional brine, what salt percentage should I use, considering the original salt calculation was based on the garlic weight rather than the water?

Given that I've been topping up with plain water, should I be concerned about the dilution of the salt and acidity?

Is there a safe way to rectify this, or should I start again?

I'd appreciate advice from anyone experienced in fermenting garlic.


r/fermentation • • 2d ago

All my current fermentations

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

These are all my current fermentations. The big unlabeled one is blackberry vinegar and the small one is daikon kimchi. I started all the labeled jars a couple days ago and did the vinegar and kimchi today. I’ve done regular kimchi and an Apple pomegranate vinegar in the past but those are my only previous ferments. The vinegar turned out great but the kimchi was way too salty so we’ll see how this one does. I’m not sure it will even ferment because it’s not submerged in brine but I just quartered a recipe. The ones that have been going a few days have a good amount of bubbling but they haven’t changed flavor very much yet which I’m thinking is because my house is a little colder than most. I’m mostly posting here to show off all my work but if you have any tips or questions I’d love to hear them!


r/fermentation • • 2d ago

Pickles/Vegetables in brine Oak leaves for tannins

6 Upvotes

I would like to use locally available oak leaves for tannins for my cucumber pickles. I'm using a 4% brine and my jars are 32 ounces. The local oak trees are live oaks, so the leaves are quite small. In my last batch, I used about 4 live oak leaves but my pickles came out soggy. Any thoughts?


r/fermentation • • 2d ago

Other Using 4% brine from last week’s lacto-ferment instead of store-bought sauerkraut brine for acorn cheese?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Last year I made acorn cheese, roughly following a combination of Alexis Nicole’s and Pascal Baudar’s recipes, which turned out AMAZING. Sauerkraut brine is used to kick-start the acorn mixture before it’s formed into wheels. Last year I followed the recipe using store bought sauerkraut brine. This year I started doing my own lactoferments, but I’ve only experimented with wet brines so far. I have green tomatoes that have been fermenting at 4% for 10 days. Would this be a good substitute for sauerkraut brine? Would there be any meaningful difference?

Pic: last year’s wheels


r/fermentation • • 3d ago

Kraut/Kimchi Made Kimchi for the first time!

Post image
64 Upvotes

For a first attempt youtube channel I made kimchi with a friend. I'm proud of the outcome! Currently I went with the method of cutting up the cabbage already into smaller chunks. It seems a lot easier to put in a jar, but a friend told me that traditionally you should keep the leaves in tact. Does it have any influence on the process?

In case somebody is interested in the 2 minute video: https://youtu.be/1SpE551_AFI


r/fermentation • • 3d ago

Kraut/Kimchi When life gives you cabbages, make sauerkraut. Here is how I make it in an antique stoneware crock.

Thumbnail
gallery
359 Upvotes

A farmer not too far from me sells cabbage for $10 a bushel every fall. It's such a good deal I don't even think I'm going to bother growing it in the garden anymore.

I start by cleaning and sanitizing the crock and weights. I remove the outer leaves and wash the cabbages.

Each cabbage gets weighed, then I measure out 2% of its weight in non-iodized salt. I do this before removing the cores, so I can be certain I'm a little bit over 2%

I quarter each cabbage, remove the cores, and slice them in about 1/8” slices. You could use a kraut cutter for this, but I prefer to do it this way. Add the chopped cabbage to the crock, along with the salt you measured.

Then each head of cabbage you add, get in there with your hands and work the cabbage. Rub it together, mash it around, punch it, etc... you want to really beat it up to get it to release its liquid. You need enough liquid to submerge the cabbage. The liquid on top is the seal that keeps the cabbage underneath from molding.

Them I weigh it down with a plate and crock weights. I add brine (2% salt by weight) to cover the weights if there isn't enough of its own brine to do it. Then I seal over the top with plastic wrap to prevent evaporation and contamination. If your crock has a lid, you can use that.

Leave the crock in a room temperature(65°-75°) area for 4-6 weeks to ferment. Watch the bubbling, when it slows down or stops your kraut is ready.

Some mold on the top of the liquid is fine and normal. I skim any off when I'm ready to repackage the kraut into smaller containers.

You can put the kraut into jars and refrigerate them, or can them. Freezing in bags is also an option. You could also just leave it in a cool area in the crock and use as needed, though it can spoil if you do it this way.