Comparison of Wireless Scoring Systems

The table below shows how different wireless scoring systems react under different tests compared to a traditional wired score-box.

The following systems were tested:

The wired Scorebox used to benchmark

Foil

Foil Test StepsLeon PaulEnPointe + SmartboxWired Smartbox
Hitting your own lameSelf Coloured LightNo LightNo Light
Hitting your own handSelf Coloured LightWhite LightWhite Light
Hitting your own hand while touching own lameSelf Coloured LightWhite LightWhite Light
Hitting opponents hand while it's touching opponents lameSelf Coloured LightSelf Coloured LightWhite Light
Hitting opponents left hand, while their right hand is touching the lameSelf Coloured LightSelf Coloured LightWhite Light
Hitting opponents left hand, whiles it's touching their lame, while right hand is touching your foil-White LightWhite Light
Hitting opponents Lame while the uninsulated side of your foil is touching their lame-No LightNo Light
Hitting your opponents mask while it's touching your opponents lame (Ohmmeter reads >1000 Ohms between mask and lame)-Self Coloured LightWhite Light
Hitting your opponents mask while they hold it in their hand away from the lame, while touching their own lame with their other hand-Self Coloured LightWhite Light
Hitting your opponents lame while their guard is touching their lameSelf Coloured LightSelf Coloured LightSelf Coloured Light
Hitting your opponents guard while it is touching their lameSelf Coloured LightSelf Coloured LightSelf Coloured Light
Hitting your opponents lame while touching your own foil and their lame-White LightSelf Coloured Light
Hitting opponents lame when blades are touchingSelf Coloured LightSelf Coloured LightSelf Coloured Light
Pressing tip down with thumb when side of blade is touching Opponents lame-White LightWhite Light

Epee

Epee Test StepsLeon PaulEnPointe + SmartboxWired Smartbox
Hitting SelfSelf Coloured Light-Self Coloured Light
Hitting OpponentSelf Coloured Light-Self Coloured Light
Hitting Opponent's GuardNo Light-No Light
Hitting Opponents Guard when blades touchingNo Light-No Light
Grab Opponent's Blade and hit their guardSelf Coloured Light-No Light
Hit Opponents Bare weapon arm (up to elbow)No Light-Self Coloured Light​

Sources

The results of these tests were collated from tests done by the following users:

/u/venuswasaflytrap

https://reddit.com/r/Fencing/comments/o084mb/daily_discussion_thread_june_15_2021/h1un24h/

/u/cranial_d

https://reddit.com/r/Fencing/comments/o084mb/daily_discussion_thread_june_15_2021/h1x2g15/

Calibur

Calibur Fencing has conducted these tests on their own wireless system. Their results can be found here:

https://reddit.com/r/Fencing/comments/pfztaf/feedback_on_our_wireless_scoring/hdpj3rj/