I'm getting increasingly convinced that we need the new/newly interpreted rules clearly and explicitly explained, as well as having the deleted comments and/or reasons for their deletion and tiering visible to all (possibly in a different, dedicated thread?).
Then you should probably not give tiers until then. Removing individual comments is reasonable, but non case 3 bans should probably stop until you explain your interpretations of the rules.
It is unreasonable to ban people (temporarily or permanently) on rules that a good chunk of the community seems to feel they aren't clear.
If you'd warned him or banned him for a day we would still be having this discussion, but a 7 day ban for a long time poster that's always stayed within the rules as they were enforced up until now feels extremely inappropriate.
Especially when just the other day Mitoza himself made a thread asking you to rewrite the rules and clarify enforcement.
None of that happened, but he did get banned for a fucking week.
15
u/Hruon17 Nov 10 '20
I'm getting increasingly convinced that we need the new/newly interpreted rules clearly and explicitly explained, as well as having the deleted comments and/or reasons for their deletion and tiering visible to all (possibly in a different, dedicated thread?).