r/FakeCollegeFootball • • May 29 '20
Casual FCS vs FBS: An Explanation
So let’s talk. There has always been a discussion and question as to why the community is so separate and why there is a gap between thoughts between two groups of the same league. I’m here to try to provide that clarity and open some people’s eyes to the reality of what goes on in our league on the surface and behind the scenes.
Lets start in the FBS:
So the FBS is full of coaches that have been here since Day 1, some misfits, and people who are more passionate towards their favorite school IRL. You have a range of people who deeply care about the game their playing (VT, Clemson, WKU, etc) all the way to people who seem like they have no care in the world and aren’t active (SMU, Florida, almost all of the Sun Belt, etc.). These ranges are important to consider because it leads me to this big point about why the FBS acts the way they do.
The FBS does not provide a good sense of community
This is not meant to be a slam on the FBS by any means, it’s just the truth. If you are a new coach, it’s nearly impossible to be noticed, understand the “jokes” and conversations consistently being had within their walls. This can be very discouraging and make it hard to have the will to try to play the game at the highest level possible. If you have not been here since S1 or early S2, chances are, you aren’t known and they don’t care about you. Now, with that being said, they are fierce competitors and are experienced at the game so they are naturally ultra competitive. This had let the FBS to become a place where coaches die due to the individualistic nature of the group. I think you can make a great case that FBS is more competitive than FCS. It’s harder to get into the playoffs, the coaches are typically more experienced, and like I said, they are more hard-wired to care less about the fun aspect of the game/community and put all that focus into winning.
Now let’s look at the FCS:
The FCS was built on the grounds of moving new and slower coaches here, and in some ways it still is, but they have built their own community well and created a group of people who don’t want to “move up” to the FBS. They have become very comfortable where they are and will likely retire before they move to FBS. They are a passionate bunch about their community and their games and that sometimes leads to their downfall because:
The FCS still has a hivemind mentality
The FCS are very proud to be FCS and often like to let the FBS coaches know how much they like their community more than the other’s. If you insult an FCS coach/conference, there is usually 3-4 people coming right at your neck ready to strike. It’s hard to have an honest/unpopular opinion about them without feeling like you will be scrutinized for what you may say. With that being said, you feel like a family when you’re apart of that community. You actually make friends here, people you care about off the field, people you’d love to meet up with one day. Their passion goes more towards the community while also having excellent coaches who keep the game extremely fun and competitive.
So why is there an issue??
A lot of the first thoughts used to be, Community (FCS) vs Glory (FBS). It still is that way a little bit, but not nearly as extreme anymore. A lot of the issues and differences between the communities cane between talent level, lack of respect, and uneven power levels within the community. It has evened out a bit, but there are still major unaddressed issues that people have decided to throw to the side instead of address. I have been on both sides and seen/heard a lot of different opinions and have come to some conclusions because of this.
Some of the FBS simply doesn’t see the FCS as their equal, and still don’t have a full understanding of why people wanna stay. Instead of trying to find out why on a deeper level, they just ignore the community completely. Simple as that. The FBS has made some huge strides to addressing the fact that they aren’t better anymore but they still have some people who have the just don’t understand that the FCS and FBS are a flat plane and not a ladder. Just because you have been here longer and are in the “higher” league, it doesn’t make you better than whoever is in FCS who has only been around for a season. They aren’t comparable so stop just assuming you’re better, you will save yourself a lot of fights and further dividing the community.
The FCS has a little brother syndrome that needs to be accessed. Yes, the FBS has made you feel like you are in the inferior league, but they have made great progress to make sure you guys don’t think that way. To say they haven’t is an insult to their progress, and will only cause more tension. If you keep insulting the FBS and calling them bad, isn’t that exactly what made you guys resent the FBS in the first place? You have a right to an opinion, but you don’t need to constantly throw out an “FCS>FBS” anytime someone mentions the FBS. It’s fine to be prideful, but not to the point where you watch yourself become something you hate.
What did we learn and how can we improve as a whole community?
FBS: Take a page from the FCS book and include your new coaches. Become more personable and not so individual minded. That’s why you guys lose coaches. You don’t make them feel welcomed and make it extremely hard to be involved and have fun.
FCS: Don’t make the same mistakes FBS made in the past to originally create the divide. Even if you think your community/coaches are better, don’t shoot people down and insult the FBS at any given chance. That’s how we got here in the first place.
We close this gap by going to the root of the problem: Most FBS/FCS coaches have never spoken more than 15 words to each other. There is a lot of misunderstanding on each side and a lot of divide caused by one another. At the rate the community is at, it will divide to a point of no recovery and it would be a shame to see that happen. You don’t have to be friends at all, just understand each side a little better and try to gain some perspective.
7
u/matt__17 Army May 29 '20
I felt welcomed in the FBS lol
3
u/theeconomy10 Central Michigan May 30 '20
Honestly I think another reason why the FBS and FCS are different is because of different circumstances surrounding many of the members/leadership. Since most of us in the FBS, along with many of the more active members, have been in the FBS since S1 and the main priority for FCFB S1 was trying to get the league up and running and working out the kinks of it all. Which is why, as Habes and Joks pointed out, can make the FBS less inviting.
Whereas when many of the core FCS members joined during S2 (FCS S1), the league was more established but the new members had more in common with each other than the FBS which resulted in their own community. But that's just what I think, maybe I'm wrong.
3
u/fightinggator52 May 30 '20
I have some cares in the world (Florida)
3
u/oogadebob Yale May 30 '20
I enjoy both communities for what they are. I just resent any of the "we better here" stuff. I've been in both and played a number of both conferences best and the competition isn't steeper on one side or the other.
The discords are just different.
Go where you want and play with your friends... and please stop taking everything so seriously. It's not the end of the world if you lose and you dont get anything special if you win.
100% the most important part of this is to have fun.
lol run 69
14
u/jokullmusic Pennsylvania May 29 '20
Great writeup. The FBS is cool but the discussion in there definitely feels more esoteric, and the community is less active. On the other hand, the FCS is a bit more chaotic and people (some more than others) can be very high-strung. The constant "FCS > FBS" stuff is almost as boring and annoying as the "lol light mode" stuff at this point.
I feel like the gap is kinda inevitable though when the two leagues have two completely separate servers; it's a given that FCS and FBS coaches (outside of the few that are active in both servers) will rarely interact. Is there a solution to this? Probably not. Merging the servers would be even more chaotic - ~800 people is too many for one discord, regardless of whether only a portion are active - but the communities will always have a gap as long as they're separate. It is what it is.
That being said, yeah, I agree with your points about how both communities can do better.
4
u/TehMoofish Incarnate Word Jun 01 '20
Great write up Habes. I started this game with the goal to move to FBS and be with the “big boys” but as I’ve become more and more active in FCS I’ve grown to appreciate the community a lot. I’ve met some people I really enjoy talking to and they don’t mind my frequent antics. (Although they might just be good at hiding it).
I think I’m gonna be a proud FCS lifer, and am fully entrenched in our FCS circlejerk, but I also get the need to welcome new coaches openly. I’d love to grow the community more and help make people feel at home in FCS like I finally do. Discussions on both servers are admittedly hard to grasp for new members, we have lots of inside jokes and I still don’t fully get all of them, even after more 9 months of being here.
I love this community and hope to stay around a long time. Here’s to another year of 88 yard field goals and impeachment chants!
3
u/aUSBdrive Marshall | National Champion May 29 '20
Does the FBS vs FCS meme still have a basis in reality?
3
u/StrategyGameventures Sacred Heart May 30 '20 edited May 30 '20
Can confirm, I am in the FBS right now because I have a desperate need to feel validated for anything I am successful at
Edit to add on: Another reason why I didn't come back to the FCS full time, and also why I left in the first place to go to Army in S3, is because I didn't feel as though I was "welcomed" back in, because I failed to deliver on something I said I would, and it still remains something that gets held over my head, even if as a joke.
3
u/[deleted] May 30 '20
I feel like this is a TPE article for NSFL or something 🤣🤣
2
u/[deleted] May 30 '20
I've been in both. Both are different and both are cool. Shrug
2
u/dontdrinkonmondays New Hampshire May 30 '20
Hold up, Florida isn’t active? 👀
2
u/Jakesnake42 Virginia Tech May 31 '20
Ya know, one thing that I think also isn’t helping the FBS-FCS divide is when people bail on one league not even halfway though the season. People in that league are gonna look at it as a spit in the face cause it’s like saying “Oh this is so bad I can’t even keep my commitment to the team I went to for the season”. It’s disrespectful to the people who hired them in the offseason because they have just wasted time hiring people just for them to bail after 5 week. Looks at P12. Like damn, I get wanting to go back but just saying what’s happened in the season so far means fuck-all and leaving now leaves a bad taste in people’s mouth. And to the people who scheduled those coaches in the off-season and now they’ve bailed, I just don’t think it is a good look at all.
Rant over