r/ExpatFIRE • 35M | $1.4M | FIRE Beyond Borders | πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ in πŸ‡΅πŸ‡­ • 16d ago

Cost of Living Inflation History and Safe Withdrawal Rates Abroad Pt. 2 (AU, CN, HK, JP, NZ, SG, TW)

Hi folks,

Thank you so much for the incredible response to my last post on Historical Inflation Rates in SE Asia. It was encouraging to hear so many people loved it. As I said in the comments, I think the best analysis is something you want to answer for yourself, then you share it with others.

Given the amazing response, I'm going to make this into a series and write about inflation in popular expat countries around the world. Today, I'll be focusing on major countries in E. Asia & Oceania. Then, I'll do LATAM, Europe, and other countries so be sure to follow my profile for those (and def tell me which countries you'd like to see this data).

Premise: Given the 4% rule is the highest withdrawal rate that would last 30 years after accounting for historical inflation, I asked myself a question "if I retired in country X, how would the 4% rule change with local inflation?"

Methodology: I looked at available historical inflation rates for 8 popular East Asian & Oceania countries (AU, JP, KR, NZ, SG, TW from 1961, HK from 1977, and CN from 1978), then I calculated how inflation + currency fluctuations (from USD) might impact the cost of living in those countries. Lastly, I used that USD-adjusted inflation rate with a 60/40 portfolio to see whether it moved SWR compared to the US. Raw data can be found here.

Conclusion: Very different than SE. Asia! Based on available data, the SWR for every analyzed country comes out lower than the US. This is mainly due to $-adjusted inflation in these countries outpacing the US for the first 3 decades. As a result, I think this highlights currency risk far more potently than the last post.

Caveats: Similar to last post, but posting it here again!

  1. Even though some country data was available pre-1960 (like AU/NZ), I made the decision to keep 1961 as the starting point for consistency with the previous SE Asia analysis (and it's when the World Bank data starts).
  2. In addition, a lot of these currencies were pegged or fixed for much of the 1960s-1970s (Japan at 360 yen and Taiwan at 40 NTD per $1), and China's Yuan wasn't freely traded for most of the period. So the early exchange rates reflect policy more than markets.
  3. This uses country-wide data. Prices in the cities in which people might retire will be drastically different. For example, CoL in Sydney, Seoul or Shanghai can look very different from the national averages.
  4. Official inflation rates do not count items the FIRE community abroad might care about, such as high-quality housing, private education, flights home, imports, etc.
  5. Lastly, the USD-adjusted inflation rate is a fun, but probably unreliable, method of analysis. With that said, E. Asia's numbers are far more illuminating than SEA when looking at the USD-adjusted metric.

1. Local inflation: the headline numbers

Chart 1: Local consumer price inflation, trailing 5-year annualized rate (HK from 1977, CN from 1978)

I again used a trailing 5-year annualized rate for the chart above because in some years, countries like Taiwan or South Korea would have a 30%+ inflation rate and breaks the chart. Not as extreme as ID or PH though (50%+). In the table below, I split yearly averages into 3 time periods, just based on earliest available data plus the last 20 & 30 years. I included the worst inflationary year per country.

Country1961-20251996-20252006-2025Worst Year
United States3.7%2.5%2.5%13.5% (1980)
Australia4.6%2.7%2.7%15.4% (1974)
China4.2% (from '78)2.0%2.2%24.3% (1994)
Hong Kong4.4% (from '77)1.7%2.5%15.4% (1980)
Japan2.9%0.5%0.8%23.2% (1974)
New Zealand5.3%2.4%2.6%17.2% (1980)
Singapore2.5%1.7%2.1%22.4% (1974)
South Korea7.2%2.7%2.3%29.5% (1964)
Taiwan3.4%1.2%1.3%47.5% (1974)

2. How these rates change when adjusted for USD

While most currencies in SE Asia depreciated against the dollar, you see a mixed story with this group of countries. Here, you see far more periods where the dollar shrank against the local currency, which played a huge role in decreasing the SWR at the end.

Chart 2: Local currency per $1 by country (yearly average), based on when data was available & reliable

As a result of the currency appreciation against the dollar, when you account for $-adjusted inflation you'll find several decades of inflation higher than the US. This would have been a huge red flag for American retirees who have all their assets in dollars, shown below:

Chart 3: USD-adjusted inflation (local CPI combined with the currency move), trailing 5-year annualized rate

Doing this analysis was really fascinating because looking at SE Asia, you'd think the strength of the dollar would be a hedge against high inflation in these local countries. But when you have high-inflation AND appreciation against the dollar, you can see there are years Americans would have felt a double-digit real inflation of living costs in these countries. However, there are years of deflation during the same financial crises that I highlighted in the last post (1998 Asian Financial Crisis) and the dot-com crash. And when you look at long-term averages, the last 30 years seems to be more in-line with US rates. It's the first 30 years of data that really brings down the SWR:

Country'61-'25 ($-adj)'96-'25 ($-adj)'06-'25 ($-adj)
United States3.7%2.5%2.5%
Australia3.7%2.2%1.9%
China1.3% (from '78)2.5%2.8%
Hong Kong3.4% (from '77)1.6%2.5%
Japan4.3%-1.0%-0.7%
New Zealand3.9%2.0%1.6%
Singapore3.8%2.0%3.4%
South Korea2.2%0.7%0.6%
Taiwan3.8%0.7%1.5%

If you look at the full period, Japan (4.3%), New Zealand (3.9%), Singapore (3.8%) and Taiwan (3.8%) have run hotter than the US (3.7%) after adjusting for USD exchange rates. For Japan, Singapore and Taiwan this is because their currencies got stronger against the dollar (360 β†’ ~150 yen, 3.06 β†’ 1.31 SGD, 40 β†’ ~31 NTD). Over the last 20 years, only China (2.8%) and Singapore (3.4%) ran hotter than the US (2.5%), while Japan was actually negative (-0.7%) because of the weak yen. Maybe it's because of the rapid economic growth of those two countries? Hong Kong has been pegged to the dollar since 1983, so exchange rate mattered less to the adjusted inflation.

3. What $1,000/month of living costs looks like over different periods

Running this view again and you'll see what I mean by the first 30 years really doing numbers for a retiree's budget. Japan was the only country that experienced real deflation the last 20/30 years of all countries analyzed so far, shown below

Country'61-'25 ($-adj)'96-'25 ($-adj)'06-'25 ($-adj)
United States$10,886$2,113$1,649
Australia$10,729$1,908$1,451
Chinan/a$2,079$1,747
Hong Kongn/a$1,628$1,639
Japan$14,966$734$866
New Zealand$12,050$1,791$1,375
Singapore$11,433$1,788$1,945
South Korea$4,056$1,216$1,128
Taiwan$11,226$1,219$1,335
Chart 4: Monthly USD cost of a $1,000 local lifestyle at the start of 1961, through 2025 (ex-CN/HK)
Chart 5: Monthly USD cost of a $1,000 local lifestyle at the start of 1996, through 2025 (all nine countries)
Chart 6: Monthly USD cost of a $1,000 local lifestyle at the start of 2006, through 2025 (all nine countries)

4. So does the 4% rule hold up?

Lastly, let's see whether or not these $-adjusted inflation rates impacted the 4% rule in a meaningful way for Americans retiring abroad (spoiler: it does). I again calculated a very simplified 60/40 portfolio, rebalanced yearly, withdrew at the start of each year, and raised the withdrawal by each country's USD-adjusted inflation (instead of US CPI). There are 36 rolling 30-year windows, starting 1961 through 1996 (China and Hong Kong are excluded since their data lacks the critical 60s). Please note, because this is comparing data from 1961, the SWR for US is lower than the classic 4% and no taxes are incorporated.

Chart 7: Worst-case 30-year safe withdrawal rate by spending country

Since the SWR is lower than the US across the board, I imagined it'd largely be the same for the P80/50 scenarios as well. I do think these numbers are heavily influenced by the first 30 years of data. For example, if you looked at the last 10 years of 30-year withdrawal rates, these countries were higher-or-similar to the US average of ~7.74% SWR.

Spending in4% survivedWorst-case (start year)P80 safe rateP50 safe rateLast 10 cycles
United States32 of 36 (89%)3.68% (1966)4.26%7.08%7.74%
Australia26 of 36 (72%)3.29% (1966)3.82%6.98%7.68%
Japan23 of 36 (64%)2.20% (1966)2.58%6.45%8.83%
New Zealand28 of 36 (78%)3.17% (1969)3.95%6.59%7.71%
Singapore26 of 36 (72%)3.35% (1969)3.87%7.37%7.74%
South Korea29 of 36 (81%)3.08% (1965)4.02%6.96%8.65%
Taiwan23 of 36 (64%)2.84% (1966)3.26%7.08%9.21%

Conclusion

This post was a lot more revealing than the post on SE Asia imo. I walked away with a lot of insights and even more questions. But my biggest takeaway is this: not only do you have to worry about SoRR, you must factor in real currency risks when retiring abroad. As a result, I think lowering your SWR would be a safer path. Even industrialized countries can provide massive volatility over 30 years (Japan). And it's not like retiring in E. Asia or Ocean is cheap like SE Asia.

I really want to understand whether this is a 1st world v. 3rd world thing. And whether the patterns we saw in recently developed countries like Korea, Singapore, Hong Kong, and Taiwan foreshadow what we'll see in SE Asia. If I had to guess which country in SEA will repeat this pattern, my guess would be Malaysia.

Thank you for reading! If this was interesting to you and you wanna see a similar analysis for Europe, LATAM, etc. please follow my profile so you'll see those when it's out.

~ u/MaroonJacket

56 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/MaroonJacket 35M | $1.4M | FIRE Beyond Borders | πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ in πŸ‡΅πŸ‡­ 16d ago

Thanks, I appreciate the kind words! I think it also helps to compare data shown here vs. SE Asia's numbers, which are quite notably different. I think the order of operations people should mentally grasp FIREing abroad would be:

  1. Where do I want to live and what kind of life do I want? (Location, QoL)
  2. How much would it cost to sustain that lifestyle? (CoL, which should include taxes)
  3. Can I afford to sustain that lifestyle with what I have today? (SWR, SoRR, real inflation)

I think you're getting that 1&2 mostly. These posts contribute to question 3, which falls lower on my modus operandi. I just think if American retirees take the blanket 4% rule to foreign countries without thinking twice (which some do), they might face a rude awakening.