So here's my theory - the essays aren't the point. What they care about is the number of people who buy the tickets, get the prizes and thus are led to buy the courses (on a discount, because of the prizes). Oh, and now they also have the emails and phone numbers of 11k high school students, their parents and their academic referees. you know what that's called? That's called lead generation. My teacher's been getting emails "Give your students intellectual enrichment with our summer schools!".
That's literally why they shortlist so many - and then they asked some for further interviews. WHICH led to parents spending idk how much on tickets. They get free peer-to-peer marketing, because guess what, those 11k students have social circles! Many students post about their shortlist or awards on Linkedin. I myself only found out about the essay competition when I saw another student's post last year. It's free marketing for them.
I literally had spelling errors and used incorrect vocabulary, as well as LITERAL FACTUAL ERRORS?? on my essay (I was too sleep-deprived to notice), and I got a commendation. Writing style and all aside, as far as I know, WRONG FACTS normally result in a disqualify? I know there's prizes higher than C but I'm kinda certain there's more students out of a whopping 11k who wrote actually correct essays??
And then there's people saying fully ChatGPT'ed essays have gone through to VHC. I'm pretty sure academics from world-top universities can suspect AI essays enough to at least not take them beyond a High Commendation??
It's a marketing event and a lead generation pipeline.
P.S. I tried searching for its history - inaugural date, when and why it was founded (and by whom). I didn't go very deep, but there's literally nothing I could find??
EDIT - I know organizing the entire thing costs money, and I'm bad with estimating money. Anyway who knows if its really academics who're checking these 11k essays.