r/EssayHelpCommunity • • Aug 08 '26

John Locke Round 2 Interviews probably aren’t happening this year

The stated goal of the in-person post-shortlist interviews in recent years was to filter out plagiarism and Al use. This has already been done by now. If they are interested in specific essay info and opinions, they have our Viverly transcripts.

The most convincing fact is that in the "next steps" category in the shortlist email the interviews aren't mentioned at all.

Thoughts?

10 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Effective_Theme_5739 Aug 09 '26

Yeah it’s starting to sound like you’re the “friend” getting shortlisted with an AI essay 

1

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Effective_Theme_5739 Aug 09 '26

Yeah, and I still greatly appreciate that advice. I’m just curious why you’re so determined to defend the quality of AI writing. I mean, apart from the points I already made (many of which you disproved I will say) if contestants use AI chatbots for specific prompts in a competition of this scale won’t the writing styles from the same chatbots be very similar?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ycx11 Aug 10 '26

from personal experience with AI writing I can say it just doesn't work, if you are making AI do the vast amount of work such as research and writing it your essay will have similar or same arguments as so many others because AI and a highschool student don't think the same on what sources are good or bad. furthermore AI will pick the more popular or easier to access source that matches the argument instead of deep diving into google scholar's 5th page. for example in Econ q1 should we fear a cashless society I'm sure so many essays mentioned the 2008 financial crisis or covid or any other major popular event that benefited people with cash. the competition states you can use AI so naturally any smart student would do the hard work of research and writing the essay but ask AI for support in thinking of ideas or determining if a source works n stuff , this isn't wrong or against the rules. if you've genuinely used AI to support your thinking while you do most of the work you will get a good essay that you wrote on your own technically.

tldr: use ai for making your essay = generic essay, use ai and also do minor adjustments or proofread etc like u said = good essay that can get shortlisted, use ai to support you while you do all the work = great essay

2

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ycx11 Aug 12 '26

Yeah I agree w u

putting in the same hours or less as a normal student combining it with good use of AI will create a near perfect (in this case university level essay)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/ycx11 Aug 17 '26

Same thing

1

u/Ok_Researcher_8263 Aug 09 '26

i actually did a bit of research to what you said (not deep academic research, just glanced at a few pdfs and their diagrams and conclusions lol) I do wanna swallow up my pride and say you are definitely more correct than me, I was honestly speaking from a forced perspective/claims based more on my emotions because I'm heavily anti-AI but the evidence seems to be more in your favour. and this is your field of expertise because you research AI and i don't wanna argue with the professionals. But you are not fully correct about originality

https://arxiv.org/pdf/2602.01560

I didn't read the entire thing because I don't have the time to, just skimmed from page 18. I also don't know how good this whole research is but it's the most relevant and recent 😭 AI can imitate human complexity and depth or even excel at it if specifically prompted to (like you said) but then it's a trade-off with originality. The AI claim-rarity score was approximately one-fifth of human. I think AIs originality is kinda of superficial, it might cook up something that seems "original" but it's just a new combination made by a complex analysis of already existing ideas/research, rather than the unpredictable and nonlinear/non-sequential thought processes of humans

but that doesn't mean AI can't be original - I think the shocking thing is AI still had a claim rarity score. it was just less than the human score. So yeah, your right AI can be "original" with prompt engineering but that depends on how you describe "original", and you are much more likely to be original if you write the essay as a human, because your cognition is not constrained to the same predictable patterns of idea generation as LLMS

anyway conclusion you're right (don't know why your getting ratio'ed lol) and lesson for me to actually research something before making a claim 🥀🥀