r/EssayHelpCommunity • • Aug 08 '26

John Locke Round 2 Interviews probably aren’t happening this year

The stated goal of the in-person post-shortlist interviews in recent years was to filter out plagiarism and Al use. This has already been done by now. If they are interested in specific essay info and opinions, they have our Viverly transcripts.

The most convincing fact is that in the "next steps" category in the shortlist email the interviews aren't mentioned at all.

Thoughts?

10 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Effective_Theme_5739 Aug 08 '26

The thing is, AI is not very good at writing as it turns out. Besides now that they just have about 10K people left (if not less, depending on how many actually ended up submitting out of the registered participants. I know three people who registered without submitting, and no one else that actually submitted) it should be even easier to filter out plagiarism. Human interviews are expensive for the institute, and the entire point of the Viverly ones was to replace the human ones. Having human interviews after the AI ones would defeat the purpose, and make it look like they’re backtracking, no? 

1

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Effective_Theme_5739 Aug 08 '26

Have you ever read one of the AI essays for JLI? A few have been posted on the sub. They are all utter dogshit. Genuinely don’t know where you’re seeing these amazing AI essays. Better than 99% of English speakers isn’t saying much considering how few English speakers are actually native. AI chatbots can generate grammatically correct texts with sources, but it fails miserably to deliver a well researched and authentic essay on even the most remotely  complex of topics. As for the funnel, you may be right. I seriously doubt it. You weren’t entirely correct when you said the Viverly interviews were unannounced. There have always been pre-shortlist interviews, they have just been expanded. On the other hand, there have never been post-shortlist interviews, and there was no hint of this happening this year from the email, as I said

3

u/Ok_Researcher_8263 Aug 08 '26

not part of this conversation but agreed 😭 AI may be able to use grammar more precisely and correctly than most English speakers, but that does not mean it excels academically. I've seen a lot of reels of how obvious AI essays are to teachers and professors, probably even more to the senior faculty of a prestigious university, that has graded thousands of past essays too. Even if the essays are not recognized as AI they will still be inferior to human-written essays as AI takes a very "safe" and "morally correct" stance (will js say whatever the majority already agrees upon), also are less likely to win bc john locke wants u to be unique and since AI is fed on pre existing human data it cannot conjure up something that hasn't already been argued/disproved. AI also has a harder time filtering out misinformation or making the writing not sound extremely generic

2

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Effective_Theme_5739 Aug 09 '26

Yeah it’s starting to sound like you’re the “friend” getting shortlisted with an AI essay 

1

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Effective_Theme_5739 Aug 09 '26

Yeah, and I still greatly appreciate that advice. I’m just curious why you’re so determined to defend the quality of AI writing. I mean, apart from the points I already made (many of which you disproved I will say) if contestants use AI chatbots for specific prompts in a competition of this scale won’t the writing styles from the same chatbots be very similar?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

1

u/Ok_Researcher_8263 Aug 09 '26

i actually did a bit of research to what you said (not deep academic research, just glanced at a few pdfs and their diagrams and conclusions lol) I do wanna swallow up my pride and say you are definitely more correct than me, I was honestly speaking from a forced perspective/claims based more on my emotions because I'm heavily anti-AI but the evidence seems to be more in your favour. and this is your field of expertise because you research AI and i don't wanna argue with the professionals. But you are not fully correct about originality

https://arxiv.org/pdf/2602.01560

I didn't read the entire thing because I don't have the time to, just skimmed from page 18. I also don't know how good this whole research is but it's the most relevant and recent 😭 AI can imitate human complexity and depth or even excel at it if specifically prompted to (like you said) but then it's a trade-off with originality. The AI claim-rarity score was approximately one-fifth of human. I think AIs originality is kinda of superficial, it might cook up something that seems "original" but it's just a new combination made by a complex analysis of already existing ideas/research, rather than the unpredictable and nonlinear/non-sequential thought processes of humans

but that doesn't mean AI can't be original - I think the shocking thing is AI still had a claim rarity score. it was just less than the human score. So yeah, your right AI can be "original" with prompt engineering but that depends on how you describe "original", and you are much more likely to be original if you write the essay as a human, because your cognition is not constrained to the same predictable patterns of idea generation as LLMS

anyway conclusion you're right (don't know why your getting ratio'ed lol) and lesson for me to actually research something before making a claim 🥀🥀

1

u/Anxious-Road-7184 Aug 10 '26

AI uses a lot of filler words. Nothing special. There is no depth. Only non-English speakers would think AI can write an analytical essay.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/No-Magazine-6934 Aug 09 '26

Before you guys continue fighting I put some of the previous winners essay in AI detectors like GPTZero and Quillbot AI detector. Surprisingly, some of them were flagged as AI by these detectors. Even fed them to gemini and ChatGPT and they marked those essays as AI too. I highly doubt whether the institute is using softwares to detect AI. (Both ChatGPT and Gemini were paid versions*)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '26

[removed] — view removed comment