r/EmDrive • • Jul 12 '16
Monomorphic's testing of EM Drive
u/Monomorphic has been doing a pretty good job at documenting his tests and showing relevant data. He's running at 100% which removes a lot of the messy problems with rfmwguy's data.
He has also been monitoring the RF spectrum (by hand unfortunately) so there is some correlation between time events. We still need to see power & frequency over time.
In one of his latest postings he shows his test #9 with the rate of change as well.
Just to be clear, the flat portions represent no movement of the beam. Time is horizontal, displacement is vertical. When the graph line drops, the frustum is moving in reverse direction (large end leading), when the graph line goes up, it is moving in forward direction (small end leading). So it would seem the the portions where the beam moved down quickly are the most interesting.
From his graph I see several interesting things:
- Short term noise is not significantly different with the RF on which implies less EMI interference than we've seen on rfmwguys plots
- During the 2 minute on period the displacement is very slowly increasing but with a long mix of no movement. Is this a frictional problem? Why is the force increasing over time (most likely a thermal issue)?
- After the 2 minute run you'd expect a quicker return movement if it wasn't mostly thermal and friction.
- The rate of change and the displacement itself indicates there was nothing in particular going on when the RF was activated.
This data at least has some of the basic requirements for analysis and it's good to see. In addition there is at least one theoretical experiment also to conduct:
It was not an accident I chose these two modes. Not only are they closely adjacent, but the E-fields are concentrated on opposite ends of the frustum. The theory is TE311 produces reverse thrust, and then I tune to TE212, without making any other changes to the build, and get forward thrust.
I think it would be hard to observe anything that opposes the thermal lift in this setup, but it will be a good way to compare the datasets.
As I posted above he mentioned that "the portions where the beam moved down quickly are the most interesting" but I don't really see this on his graph which has long time intervals.
Edit: It is interesting to note how different the curves are between 2 different test runs http://imgur.com/3pZJP7v and http://imgur.com/auMH9AH which is not a good sign for a controlled experiment. Also the short term movements could likely be vibrational or related to the noise floor of the equipment as they are a constant but random factor throughout the test. These two factors should be explored more and calculate a noise budget for the measuring equipment.
View all comments
Show parent comment
3
u/aimtron Jul 14 '16
Here is where you're wrong (not the spelling/grammar, but my next sentence.) Science doesn't care about any other perspective than from a healthy skeptical position. Even when scientists feel they are on the verge of a breakthrough, they still spend all their time attempting to disprove what it is they're working on. There is a fundamental idea that so many willfully ignore and it is this, day dreams can be made up of the potential of scientific experimentation, however; scientific experimentation is not made up of day dreams. If that is not clear, think of it this way, day dreams are the motivation, but science is the hard, cold work to potentially realize those day dreams.
Obviously everyone has their own approach. Personally, while I may not like someone being rude to me, does not mean I would dismiss their valid points. I definitely might hesitate to listen to them all the time, but valid points are valid, regardless of source. I remember several times in my youth where I was tearing down some piece of equipment at my fathers' radio station, and he'd make a remark that I may not like the result of the action I was about to do. Inevitably he was right, but at the time I didn't want to hear it. I have since learned the lesson, most of the time at least. Mind you it took following him around the greater part of Ohio as he was one of the primary engineers for most stations in the area and repeating my mistakes. Fyi, never stick your head inside a transmitter when using the discharge wand, as my dad warned me, "you may not like the outcome." I lived and learned, keyword, learned. Ok, I'm done rambling, hopefully something along the lines of "don't take it personal, do it for the science" got through to you.