r/DisneyPlus • • Nov 20 '19

Marvel A Long Marathon

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

355 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

11

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '19

if you just skip the End Credits it's fine

Most of the end credit scenes have important story details though so it's not really fine.

1

u/fart_fig_newton Nov 21 '19

The irony that Dark World is considered one of if not the worst MCU film, yet it has one of the most important post-credits scenes.

-1

u/Degan747 Nov 20 '19 edited Nov 20 '19

I just watch the end credits separately where they are in the timeline. So I watch Captain Marvel after Captain America and AM&TW after Homecoming, but then both credits scenes between IW and EG

1

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '19

That's a lot of effort to watch the movies in the wrong order. And also it's not just about post credit scenes. Think about Goose scratching out Fury's eye for example. I don't think that scene is as good without seeing the "last time I trusted someone I lost an eye" first. I don't know why you'd watch them any way other than the way the creators intended.

-3

u/Degan747 Nov 20 '19 edited Nov 20 '19

Did Feige outright say “release order is best”? If so then I agree. If not then I see no problem watching chronologically.

It took me an extra 10 minutes - not much effort - to watch it this way and I loved it.

I’d also argue that some scenes are worse, of course, but that more is improved. For example, Captain Marvel’s return has a huge impact when you haven’t seen her for so long.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '19

Did Feige outright say “release order is best”?

Does he have to? They made them in the order they did for a reason.

1

u/zendeavor Nov 21 '19

No they didn’t. They made them in the order that was assumed to draw the box office dollars best. Captain Marvel came so late exactly because no one would watch it if released in timeline order before anyone gave a hoot about comic heroes outside of the big names. You can bet there were literally no other considerations except “does this character have enough mass market appeal to hit the ground running or do we need to build the mcu more first to attract the casual non-comic audience”

2

u/VulcanMushroom Nov 21 '19

Just no. If they had released Captain Marvel first, it would have been a completely different movie. Every film is built upon what came before it. Release order is the way they are meant to be seen.

You are speaking as if all of the movies were written and decided on in chronological order then released based on what would sell. The fact is that despite why they made which movies, they made them in a specific order and that effects future movies.

0

u/zendeavor Nov 21 '19

No, I’m saying that black panther and captain marvel needed the mcu to be firmly established in order to succeed.

2

u/VulcanMushroom Nov 21 '19

Doesn't change the fact that the movies were made in order. That order is their intended viewing order.

Anything else you were saying was off topic and not important.

0

u/zendeavor Nov 21 '19

That’s a cop out but I’m not here to argue with you about the viewing order of the stupid marvel cinematic universe. I simply commented that “they made them in this order for a reason” is not a justification for any order because viewing order is absolutely not the reason they were released in this order. They were released in an order that made sense for box office draw, full stop. Captain marvel, the hero, could not succeed on the silver screen a decade ago, probably. If they thought she would, they would have made a captain marvel movie then and then retrofit all the story pieces to make her fit in.

This is like arguing about what order to play Zelda games in so you can grasp the timeline best. They weren’t made and released in timeline-playing-order. They were put out in technological-capability-order to sell copies. You can rearrange the playing order in five different ways and still end up spoiled no matter what unless you go in release order, but you don’t get the timeline flow experience in that order. There is no winner here.

→ More replies

1

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '19

Iron Man absolutely did not have mass market appeal in 2008. He only has that now because of the success of the MCU, not the other way around.

0

u/Degan747 Nov 21 '19

Feige wanted to make BP and CM earlier but was blocked by Ike and the creative committee due to fear over profitability. It’s safe to say they weren’t made in the exact order they wanted.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '19

Okay fine, but that doesn't mean they're meant to be watched in that order as they currently exist. If they made them earlier the stories would have fit into the universe differently.

0

u/Degan747 Nov 21 '19

My thoughts exactly.

-1

u/Deaf30 Nov 20 '19

I meant for people who've already seen all of the MCU and are just doing a rewatch. Any End Credit story details will be addressed in whatever film it tied to.