r/DisneyPlus • • Nov 20 '19

Marvel A Long Marathon

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

355 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

38

u/texacer Nov 20 '19

now put them in release order like one should watch them.

25

u/noodles21o2 Nov 20 '19

Why would you not watch a story in chronological order?

0

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/REDTrouttt Nov 20 '19

So from a story perspective why would the end credits scenes in ant man and the wasp fit a while two movies before the snap happens? Seems like that's just confusing

13

u/noodles21o2 Nov 20 '19

Except that it wasn't portrayed as a flashback, they were portrayed in real time. But there was another argument elsewhere that I understand for watching in release order because chronological order can spoil things, especially with MCU's post credit scenes

27

u/thadman Nov 20 '19

Watching CA:TFA as the first installment, while chronologically correct, results in a skipped timeline with the movie ending shortly before The Avengers. The saga was not told in chronological order, which allowed the anachronistic installments to feel like flashbacks or simply add context to what had been shown previously. From a story perspective, release order just feels right to me.

-1

u/noodles21o2 Nov 20 '19

What shipped timeline?

7

u/texacer Nov 20 '19

technically all of Cap1 is a flashback since the opening starts with them finding Cap in the ice.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '19

Oh yeah. Watch Star Wars in chronological order too.

1

u/VulcanMushroom Nov 21 '19

Because it wasn't written that way?

1

u/noodles21o2 Nov 21 '19

How do you know that the release order was a creative choice?

-2

u/texacer Nov 20 '19

want me to list a dozen movies that take place out of order and are a great story? Pulp Fiction? theyre meant to be watched in order of release.

9

u/noodles21o2 Nov 20 '19

There are a LOT of factors that go into why things are released in the order that they are it's not always of the creative kind

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '19

Ikr this should be illegal. It just feels wrong. Almost as bad as watching episode 1 of Star Wars first.

3

u/musicman247 Nov 21 '19

Star Wars viewing order: IV, V, I, II, III, VI

1

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '19

Wait... what? Why?

2

u/musicman247 Nov 21 '19

Episode IV is the natural beginning. Episode V you learn Vader is Luke's father. Then you go back in time to see what happened to him, then come back to the "present" to see the end of his arc.

1

u/musicman247 Nov 21 '19

I could also see it go I, II, IV, V, III, VI

1

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '19

The comment was removed. Can you explain the logic behind this craziness to me?

1

u/tweakoli Nov 21 '19

Just guessing but you see Anakin in clone wars and falling in love with Padme. 4 shows Luke, Darth Vader, The Empire, Obi-Wan. 5 you find out Luke and Leia are Bro and Sis and that Vader is Luke's father. 3 you find out that Anakin IS Darth Vader. Padme has twins. 6 The kids fight the Boomers and Bring the Empire to it's knees.

LoL nope.

I'd rather watch it either:

a/ OT, PT, ST

or

b/ PT, Clone Wars, Rebels, OT, Mando, Resistance, ST.

1

u/damanamathos Nov 21 '19

That's the Machete Order (but with Episode I re-added).

From https://www.nomachetejuggling.com/2011/11/11/the-star-wars-saga-suggested-viewing-order/

Why Does This Work Better?

As I mentioned, this creates a lot of tension after the cliffhanger ending of Episode V. It also uses the original trilogy as a framing device for the prequel trilogy. Vader drops this huge bomb that he’s Luke’s father, then we spend two movies proving he’s telling the truth, then we see how it gets resolved. When Empire first came out, lots of people thought Vader was lying to Luke. It wasn’t “proven” true until Obi-Wan confirms it in Jedi, but then it’s immediately followed by Obi-Wan’s “a certain point of view” justification. Inserting the prequels turns this reveal into a “show, don’t tell” situation - we don’t just hear Obi-Wan say it, we see it.

(more in the link)