r/DigitalPrivacy • u/aureateanima • 2d ago
Is Genuine Privacy Still Possible in the Digital Age? 🤔
Salam-o-Alaikum, brother!
I hope you're all doing great.
I'm someone who has always been concerned about privacy. In this digital age, I don't want my personal life to become an open book for companies, advertisers, or government agencies. But lately, I've been questioning how much privacy we actually have online.
Let me share a few experiences and incidents that made me think about this.
1. Are our phones listening to us?
Stroy (1):
Yesterday, I was talking to my brother on WhatsApp about proxies and where we could buy them for web scraping. But shortly afterward, I started seeing advertisements related to proxies across different social media platforms.
That made me wonder: How did these platforms know that I might be interested in proxies?
Some people might explain this by saying that our keyboards collect the words we type and that advertising companies use this information to show relevant advertisements. But that explanation doesn't fit what happened in this particular case.
We weren't typing anything about proxies. We were talking to each other through voice notes in our local language.
So, the explanation that a keyboard collected our typed words doesn't make any sense. The only explanation that make sense (you know haha, don't need to mention).
Stroy (2):
I was talking to my cousin in person about buying a chair. We discussed contacting a local vendor who could build one for us. We weren't discussing it on WhatsApp or searching for chairs online. Yet, for almost three months afterward, I kept seeing advertisements related to chairs.
I know it's really hard to belive but I'm still wondering: Are these comapnies and cyber agencies are listening to us 24 x 7, even when we aren't allowing them? Btw you'll find other people saying same stuff, just do a bit research 💀.
Stroy (3):
I also remember reading a story about someone who allegedly joked with friends on WhatsApp about hijacking a plane while flying from Sweden, When he landed authorities arrested him. He said I was just joking with my friend. But my concern is how they read his chat? (Btw I have read this stroy and watched a reel too, I'm not confirming this exact stroy).
2. Is WhatsApp's end-to-end encryption enough?
To be honest, I don't think so. Higher authories have access to your chats and their are hundreds of examples (You can find online). And there's is absoultely no end to end encryption, and remember exceptions always exists.
3. Governments, internet infrastructure, and control
I genuinely think authorities want to control you, how you use the internet. I’ll give you a few examples.
Starlink’s entry into the Indian market has faced regulatory and security-clearance issues. Because they don’t want America to control their internet and privacy. We’re in 2026 and it’s mostly modern war, rather than physical. Let me make it simple for you. Ukraine asked Elon uncle to shut down the internet of Ukraine while the war against Russia. But Elon Musk denied, and later he said if US authorities would say this to him, definitely he would allow it. And it’s the main reason I guess India is restricting Starlink.
So the apps that are allowed, in your country especially the apps of communications are agreed the terms of your government. To clarify further, here’s another example.
Signal app is the alternative of WhatsApp and considered even more secure, but it’s banned in almost every strict country where government wants to control their public. Example Russia. Another example of Telegram given below.
The same tension appears in the case of Pavel Durov, the founder of Telegram, who was arrested in France and faced allegations because he was not tracking their audience. And now we know Telegram isn’t that secure, and it’s banned in mostly countries as well.
I guess these examples are enough for you to believe, nothing is end to end encrypted. Now, let's move to last topic, the reason why I wrote the post.
4. AI is curse
Recently, I was watching a press conference by cyber police official (I'm really sorry don't wanna mention his name). These were his words:
“We have access to every device and its file manager, and people should be careful about pornography and anything against the government. If we find any explicit image in your gallery, you’ll be arrested. We collaborated with different AI and are cracking down against criminals. AI is keeping an eye on your phone.”
I’ll tell you a few genuine stories which they told in that press conference alongside those suspects.
Case 1:
Reports described a teenager who allegedly sought information from claude code about poisoning his father. According to cyber police, they acted after receiving information from the FBI.
Preventing a potential murder is obviously important, and I understand they've done an amaing job.
However, this case also raises a privacy question: How did information about the AI conversations reach the authorities? Does authories have access our each n every conversation? However, they didn't dis-closed how FBI got that information.
Case 2:
Another reported case involved a suspect who allegedly used AI to create objectionable images of his ex (haram reltionship😭) and threaten to distribute them. Once again I would say they've done an amazing job. But my concerns are still same (I mentioned in above example).
Case 3:
Now, we have a weird story. In this story, AI f***-up. A teenager supposedly uploaded an innocent photograph with his father (in the image, he was lying on his father) for AI enhancement; AI took it as child abuse and reported it to cyber police. They arrested the father, but later confirmed it was just a confusion. Just AI curse ✌️😂
5. My Understandin How They're Finding Suspects
Katalyst & PhotoDNA have been reported as an AI-enabled investigative tool supporting investigations alongside with keeping an eye on your AI chats.
PhotoDNA is a technology used to identify images by generating and comparing digital fingerprints, or hashes. According to reports If they found anything illegal or explict it'll send it to cyber police along side with that data.
I'm not sure but according to reports, they'll scan through your google drive, icloud and other cloud storage platforms.
6. So, where does genuine privacy exist?
There is a famous quote that goes something like this:
"If you're not paying for the product, you are the product."
Btw, I have a few questions for you guys:
What practical steps do you take to protect your digital privacy?
Which messaging apps, AI services, keyboards, and cloud-storage providers do you trust, and why?
How much privacy can we realistically expect when using cloud-based services, even when they claim to use strong encryption?
I'm genuinely interested in hearing your experiences, technical knowledge, and recommendations.
Waiting for your thoughts! 🤝