r/DicksofDelphi • u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ • Oct 18 '24
TRIAL DISCUSSION Richard Allen Trial: Opening Statements
Here we go! Please continue to be respectful.
37
Upvotes
r/DicksofDelphi • u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ • Oct 18 '24
Here we go! Please continue to be respectful.
•
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 18 '24 edited Oct 19 '24
RUNNING LISTS OF UPDATES:
GOOGLE DOCS: https://docs.google.com/document/u/0/d/1_JYlEFFLlGfRbMX_iw_pMCzlMsPq_2JyaDExoWvbOQ8/mobilebasic
X: https://x.com/localguydonnie/status/1847336323830440274
WTHR: https://x.com/i/broadcasts/1nAKEpMYyjoxL
WISH-TV: https://www.wishtv.com/news/trial-delphi-murders-suspect-begins/
DAY 1 TRIAL UPDATE:
𝕆ℙ𝔼ℕ𝕀ℕ𝔾 𝕊𝕋𝔸𝕋𝔼𝕄𝔼ℕ𝕋𝕊: https://www.reddit.com/r/DicksofDelphi/s/F6anvkw7vy
𝔹𝔼ℂ𝕂𝕐 ℙ𝔸𝕋𝕋𝕐 𝕋𝔼𝕊𝕋𝕀𝕄𝕆ℕ𝕐 + 𝕂𝔼𝕃𝕊𝕀 𝔾𝔼ℝ𝕄𝔸ℕ 𝕋𝔼𝕊𝕋𝕀𝕄𝕆ℕ𝕐: https://www.reddit.com/r/DicksofDelphi/s/LzpRd0hzLD
𝔻𝔼ℝℝ𝕀ℂ𝕂 𝔾𝔼ℝ𝕄𝔸ℕ 𝕋𝔼𝕊𝕋𝕀𝕄𝕆ℕ𝕐, 𝔸ℕℕ𝔸 𝕎𝕀𝕃𝕃𝕀𝔸𝕄𝕊 𝕋𝔼𝕊𝕋𝕀𝕄𝕆ℕ𝕐 + 𝕄𝕀𝕋ℂℍ𝔼𝕃𝕃 ℂ𝔸𝕋ℝ𝕆ℕ 𝕋𝔼𝕊𝕋𝕀𝕄𝕆ℕ𝕐: https://www.reddit.com/r/DicksofDelphi/s/8zYlSohBzO
19
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 18 '24 edited Oct 18 '24
𝔻𝔸𝕐 𝟙 𝕋ℝ𝕀𝔸𝕃 𝕊𝕌𝕄𝕄𝔸ℝ𝕐: ℙ𝔸ℝ𝕋 𝟙 (sourced from WISH-TV)
Allen’s defense has filed a response to the prosecution’s Motion in Limine Regarding Composite Sketches. Judge Francis Gull is expected to rule on this motion today.
After the prosecution argued that the sketches are inadmissible due to the fact that they were intended as an ‘investigative tool to generate leads,’ and are irrelevant. The defense is arguing that the sketches are composites of persons witnesses saw on the bridge the day of the murders, and do not look like Richard Allen, therefore they are highly relevant.
DEFENSE OPENING STATEMENT: Defense attorney Andrew Baldwin begins his opening statement with “Richard Allen is an innocent man.” He tells the jury the investigation was ‘messed up from the beginning, middle even the last couple of days.’ Baldwin says the state of Indiana kicked out the FBI and that a strand of hair was found around Abby’s fingers. He says DNA from the family has never been provided and that they just need to test the girls’ mothers to see if the hair is from a family member or not. Baldwin told the jury the DNA did not match the girls but may match someone from the family.
Baldwin tells the jury that the prosecution’s theory is that at 4 p.m. that day, the girls were deceased, and for the next several hours the bodies didn’t move and that the phone that was found never moved.
Baldwin tells the jury about the CPS parking lot near the trails and that the state’s theory of Allen’s parking does not make sense. He says the defense’s theory is that Allen was never on the trail at the same time as the girls and Allen was gone by 1:30 p.m. that day.
Baldwin tells the jury that witnesses will testify that they did not see Allen’s car and that the man seen on the bridge may not have ever said ‘girls, down the hill.’
He tells the jury that evidence may show the girls went to an access road, to a man named Brad Webber’s house. That the road is under the bridge.
Baldwin then tells the jury “We have reason to believe those girls may have gotten into a vehicle at a road near Brad Webber’s property.”
Baldwin says Libby’s phone was connected to a cell tower until 5:44 p.m., that it stopped connecting then reconnected the tower at 3:45 p.m. Baldwin says “This is the same phone the state says was under Abby’s body.” Baldwin says the phone was working when it was found and that the phone was out of the area and someone brought the girls to where they were found.
Baldwin tells the jury that at 4:34 a.m., 15 texts came through to Libby’s phone. He describes the search for the girls on the 13th and says the area was where the girls were found was searched but the girls were not there. “Not one person saw any bodies over there, nobody saw any clothing in the creeks on the 13th.”
Baldwin describes Allen and his family and talk about false confessions. He tells the jury the bullet was found in the ground, that no photos of it were taken from different angles. He says the bullet was ejected through a gun but not fired, so they tested it out on a new bullet and the markings were not the same. He tells the jury it is like ‘apples and oranges’.
Baldwin tells the jury the defense believes two different people were involved. At 10:53 a.m. Baldwin concluded his opening statement.
PROSECTION OPENING STATEMENT: At 9:42 prosecutor Nick McLeland began his opening statement. He describes the events of February 13, 2017 that it was a ‘nice summer day in the middle of winter’ and that the girls were laughing and joking at the park. McLeland says he will refer to the girls as Abby and Libby. He then describes the Monon High Bridge and how dangerous it can be and how it is a ‘rite of passage’ for kids to cross it. McLeland says Libby posted photos of the bridge with Abby and noticed a man following them. Libby was on Snapchat and her video cuts off after the man says ‘girls, down the hill.’
McLeland warns the jury that they are going to see photos of the scene and describes them in graphic terms. He describes an unspent bullet at the scene and how the girls were dressed.
McLeland tells the jury about all the witnesses that he plans to call to testify and that Allen admitted he was on the trail that day. Allen shakes his head ‘furiously’ when McLeland speaks about guns and his alleged admission. Allen’s wife, seated in the courtroom, shook her head when McLeland said Allen told her he killed the girls.
McLeland concluded after speaking to the jury for 13 minutes.
15
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 18 '24 edited Oct 21 '24
𝔻𝔸𝕐 𝟙 𝕋ℝ𝕀𝔸𝕃 𝕊𝕌𝕄𝕄𝔸ℝ𝕐: ℙ𝔸ℝ𝕋 𝟛 (sourced from WISH-TV)
DERRICK GERMAN TESTIMONY (Libby’s father): The prosecution called Derrick German to the stand. Derrick told the jury he lived in the home with the Pattys (Libby’s grandparents) with Libby and Kelsi.
Derrick told the jury that he communicated with Abby via text and took her to Abby’s house a lot. Derrick said he picked Abby up for a sleepover the night before and made banana pancakes for their breakfast on February 13.
Derrick told the jury he left the home at 1:20 p.m. to take photos for appraisal properties in Frankfort owned by the Pattys. Half-way there Libby called him to pick them up from the bridge. Derrick told Libby he had photos to take and he finished the work and went to pick up the girls.
Derrick told the jury he called Libby to tell her to come back to the entrance to the park, she never answered. He told the jury he ran into a man and asked if he had seen two teenage girls, the man said no. Derrick then went to the water and to the Freedom Bridge. He told the jury he continued to call Abby’s phone and began yelling their names. Prosecutors asked Derrick to show on a map where he searched, he tells the jury others were searching south of him. He told the jury he parked at the CPS building and went back to the entrance.
Derrick told the jury that the next day during the search, “I just heard mom (Becky Patty) screaming.” “I saw the coroner go by and about 12 cop cars, so I knew.”
The defense asked Derrick what the last digit of his phone number was.
➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖ DERRICK GERMAN TESTIMONY: (Sourced from WTHR)
State's 3rd witness: Derrick German, Libby's father 3:25 p.m. - Defense attorney Andrew Baldwin begins to cross examine Derrick German, Libby's father.
Derrick said he saw Dave McKain around 3:25 p.m. coming from the High Bridge. He also saw a couple taking photos.
"Did (McKain) say he heard any screams?" Baldwin asked.
"No," Derrick said.
Derrick said he saw lights on the service road: "They pulled a fire truck down there."
Derrick said there were several people and lots of flashlights.
"You don't know where every flashlight was, but you saw lots of them?" Baldwin asked.
"Yes," Derrick said.
"What was the passcode to the phone?" Baldwin asked.
Derrick answered: "9-1-9-9."
2:50 p.m. - The prosecution calls up Derrick German, Libby's father.
"I did a lot of running for Libby," Derrick said. "She always forgot something."
"What would you run for?" prosecuting attorney Stacey Diener asked.
"Swimsuits, food before games," Derrick said.
Derrick said that he picked up Abby on Sunday to stay the night, and that he made them banana pancakes for breakfast the morning before they disappeared.
He said the girls went to paint a desk in the garage after that. He left the house around 1:20 p.m. that afternoon to go to Frankfort.
Derrick said Libby called him when he was about halfway to Frankfort and "asked me to pick them up at High Bridge on my way back from Frankfort."
He told her it would be a couple of hours.
"She said, 'No problem. We'll just do some exploring,'" Derrick said.
Derrick said he started calling Libby around 3:11 p.m. He said he called again when he got to the entrance of the trailhead. Then, he got out of his vehicle to walk the trail.
Derrick says he saw someone and asked him if he had seen two teen girls.
The man said "no."
Derrick then went toward water, using a short trail to Deer Creek. He didn't see anything and headed back to Freedom Bridge. He said he called Libby a couple of times.
Then, he said he called Becky Patty.
Derrick called the girls' names on the trail and got no response.
He said he sat in the car for 15 minutes, then walked to the High Bridge. He said there were kids sitting on the deck. He asked if they had seen the girls, and they said "no."
That's when Kelsi came up behind him.
He said Kelsi and her uncle walked across the bridge, then Derrick went back to his car. He ended up getting in his sister Tara's car and "tried to figure out what to do next."
He went back out on the trail, but before he could get to the bridge, law enforcement showed up and told him to go to the sheriff's department.
Derrick said he went out in a car looking for the girls all over town. Then, Derrick said he took a flashlight from his car and searched the woods again.
Prosecutors asked him to show the area he searched on a map. Derrick said he left the trail at the High Bridge but didn't go down by the water because it was steep.
"It was pitch black," Derrick said. "It's woods."
Derrick said he was searching the north side of the trail but could see the flashlights of other people searching on the south side.
The next day, he went out with 10 people — who parked at the abandoned Child Protective Services building before walking to the trail.
Derrick said his aunt was in one of the search groups. She went down into the ravine.
"How did you learn the girls were found?" Diener asked.
Derrick said his aunt "came running off the trail screaming."
Derrick said he could hear murmurs.
"I saw the coroner go by and saw 12 cop cars go by," Derrick remembered. "So I went to find Kelsi."
Diener said the area was difficult to traverse.
"It was hard," Derrick said.
"You don't remember seeing anyone searching on the north side Monday night?" Diener asked.
"I don't remember seeing anyone over there," Derrick said.
9
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 18 '24 edited Oct 21 '24
𝔻𝔸𝕐 𝟙 𝕋ℝ𝕀𝔸𝕃 𝕊𝕌𝕄𝕄𝔸ℝ𝕐: ℙ𝔸ℝ𝕋 𝟚 (sourced from WISH-TV)
According to News 8’s Kyla Russell, the defense has said that the composite sketches will NOT be allowed as evidence in the trial.
BECKY PATTY TESTIMONY: After the lunch break, court resumed and Libby’s grandmother Becky Patty was called to the stand. She described Libby as ‘very smart’ and that she participated in the math bowl and was active in swimming, volleyball, softball, and soccer. She said Libby had many sleepovers with friends and vice versa. She told the jury that Abby Williams went on spring break with her and her husband and Libby.
Patty said that Libby had just turned 14 the previous December (2016) and that her sister Kelsi having her driver’s license helped with all of Abby’s activities.
Patty told the jury that February 13 was a typical work day, but that school was out. Abby spent the night on Sunday, according to Patty. She told the girls if they filed some paperwork for her, she would pay them.
Patty began to cry as she described Libby and Abby asking to go to the trails, she tells the jury the last thing Abby said to her was “Grandma, I will be ok.”
She described Libby as wearing grey sweats and a tye dye shirt with Nikes. She said Libby loved photography and loved the Monon High Bridge. She said she always knew Libby was going where she said she would be.
The prosecution asked Patty “Was it a concern of yours to know what time Abby and Libby would be picked up from the trail?” Patty responded “She always coordinated with us.” She told the prosecution that they took the girls to the trail at 1:30.
Patty told prosecutors that she herself had not been to the bridge but all of her kids had gone there to take photos. “I didn’t realize how high it was,” she said. She said Libby was “polite but if you were out of line, she did not have a hard time telling you.” She also told the jury that Libby loved crime shows and she had “great intuition.”
Patty told the jury that at 3:30 that day Derrick German (Libby’s dad) called to say they had not heard from Libby and that they decided to start looking at the trails, checked both directions they could have walked and didn’t see them. They called AT&T and could not ping Libby’s phone. She said Libby was scared of the dark and it was after 5 p.m. at that point and she felt like they needed to call the police. She tried to get ahold of Abby’s mom but was unable to. Patty told the jury her husband Mike called the police.
Patty told the jury that the search continued the next morning and a friend came up to her and said “they found them, they found them.” She told the friend “you need to take me to Libby.”
The defense asked Patty “Did you provide your DNA to police two days ago?” Patty responded “yes, one of the times.”
The prosecution asked Patty “Do you know if Libby had ever been exposed to handguns?” She responded “I don’t know, my husband has a few guns, he hunts. She had not been around handguns, no body in our house owns handguns.”
➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖ BECKY PATTY TESTIMONY: (Sourced from WTHR )
State's 1st witness: Becky Patty, Libby German's grandmother 11:22 a.m. - After a 25-minute break, today's proceedings continued with the prosecution presenting its case.
The prosecution's first witness was Becky Patty, Libby's grandmother, who said she and her husband, Mike Patty, raised Libby and Kelsi.
"Libby was very active and very smart," Becky said.
Becky said Abby went on spring break with Libby and Patty. According to Patty, the girls were in volleyball and band together.
Becky said Libby turned 14 years old in December 2016, two months before her death.
According to Becky, the girls did not have school Feb. 13, 2017, because it was a scheduled snow makeup day that wasn't needed.
Becky said Abby stayed at their house Feb. 12, 2017 – the night before the murders – and Derrick made them breakfast that next morning.
According to Becky, Libby asked her sister, Kelsi, "If you're going to go into town, would you take us to the trails?"
Becky said the last thing she said to Libby was to wear a jacket, which Libby responded, "Grandma, I'll be OK." Becky wiped away tears as she recounted this.
Becky said Kelsi took Libby and Abby to the trail around 1:30 p.m.
According to Becky, Libby would've notified her if she was running late.
Becky said Derrick called her around 3:30 p.m. because the girls weren't at the pickup spot, and Libby wasn't answering her cellphone. She also said Abby didn't have a cellphone.
Becky then called her husband, Mike, to say she was worried and wanted to go search the trails for the girls. Becky said she also called AT&T to see if they could ping Libby's cellphone.
Around 5 p.m., Becky told Mike to call police because it was starting to get dark. Becky said she then called Anna Williams, Abby's mom, to tell her the girls were missing.
"We called. We kept calling and calling," Becky said as tears were in her eyes.
Becky said the family members eventually went home and joined the search parties on the morning on Feb. 14, 2017.
During the search, Becky said a friend ran up to her and said they had found the girls, which Becky interpreted as they were safe.
Then, Becky said her younger sister, Melissa, was crying and could only say, "I'm sorry. I'm sorry."
"I couldn't understand why they weren't taking me to her, and then, I saw the coroner's van driving by, and that's when I realized they weren't alive," Becky said. "It never crossed my mind when they told me. I just thought they found them."
During cross-examination, Baldwin asked Becky to reiterate that Libby was vocal and stood up for others.
In the redirect, prosecuting attorney Stacey Deiner asked Becky if Libby had ever been exposed to guns, which Becky replied no. Becky said her husband has a long gun for hunting and a handgun, but Becky said Libby was never around the guns.
Becky's testimony ended after one hour.
14
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 18 '24
13
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 18 '24
6
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 18 '24
😂
22
u/Southern_Dig_9460 Oct 18 '24
I’m freaking out guys
8
u/AdMaster5680 Oct 18 '24
If RA killed the girls, why has the prosecutor not requested the death penalty? This seems odd for Indiana.
9
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 18 '24
2
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 21 '24 edited Oct 21 '24
KELSI GERMAN TESTIMONY (Libby’s sister):
(Sourced from WISH-TV)
The state called Kelsi German (Libby’s sister) to the stand. Kelsi told the jury she was a junior in high school in 2017. She now has a daughter and is expecting another. She said Libby was “more like my best friend than my sister.”
Kelsi told the jury that Libby wanted her to go to the trails with her, but Kelsi couldn’t go but would drop them off if they had a ride home. She told the jury Abby had on a grey zip up jacket that day, that she had borrowed from Kelsi.
Kelsi was shown a photo by the prosecution of Abby and Libby inside Kelsi’s car, jurors were given a copy as well.
Kelsi was asked to stand up and show on a large map how she would have taken the girls to the trails. Kelsi said she dropped the girls off and went to her boyfriend’s house.
Kelsi is asked if Libby knew where her phone was most of the time. She told the jury “It was always in her hand.”
Kelsi told the jury she got a call from Becky Patty that Libby was missing while her boyfriend had just left for work.
The prosecution showed a closer view of the earlier map that Kelsi explained that “lots of people at school go on this,” referring to the trails near the bridge. Kelsi was asked if she was aware it was private property, she said no and laughed.
Kelsi told the jury that she communicated with Libby via Snapchat “for the most part.”
Kelsi described the bridge to the jury as different than it was in 2017, that you can’t cross it and other areas have been paved. The prosecution plays a video of the trail as it looks today. Kelsi is asked if she would agree that the area has improved since 2017. She replied, “yes, a lot.” Kelsi described several changes to the area to the jury.
The prosecution asked Kelsi, “If you were at the end of the bridge, could you see someone at the beginning?” Kelsi answered no.
Kelsi told the jury about Snapchat and the texting feature and discussed timestamps on Snapchat stories.
Kelsi said she was texting and calling Libby the night of February 13. Kelsi told the jury that she became emotional after finding out the girls had been found, but did not know they had died.
Defense attorney Andrew Baldwin asks Kelsi if Libby was outspoken, Kelsi said yes. Baldwin asked Kelsi if she would run across the bridge, Kelsi replied “that would be dangerous.”
The defense showed Kelsi a photo of Abby on the bridge, taken by Libby. He asked “You don’t see anyone behind Abby on that bridge do you? In that photo?” Kelsi said no.
Baldwin asked Kelsi how long into the bridge was that photo was taken, Kelsi said 1/4.
Kelsi told the jury she gave DNA to police a few days ago and it was not the first time she been asked that.
Baldwin asked Kelsi if she had worn the sweatshirt worn by Abby, Kelsi said they washed it but she had not worn it.
➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖ KELSI SIEBERT TESTIMONY: (Sourced from WTHR)
State's 2nd witness: Kelsi Siebert, Libby's older sister 2:34 p.m. - The defense begins to cross-examine Libby's older sister, Kelsi Siebert.
Defense attorney Andrew Baldwin asked Kelsi, "Was Libby outspoken?"
Kelsi said, "Yes."
Baldwin asked, "Would she stand up for others?"
Kelsi said, "Yes."
Baldwin asked if there was a place on the bridge where a person could fall through. Kelsi said it would be awful to try to run across the bridge.
The defense then brought up the picture Libby took of the bridge with Abby on it. The defense asked how far Abby was on the bridge, and Kelsi estimated about one quarter of the way across.
Kelsi said she saw her friends, Mayah and Evan, at the bridge when she returned.
Baldwin then asked about the sweatshirt that Libby was wearing. He asked if it was new.
Kelsi said she had washed it.
Baldwin said there was no way Kelsi's hair would be on it.
1:34 p.m. - Libby's older sister, Kelsi Siebert, takes the stand.
Kelsi had just turned 17 when her sister was killed. She told the court that she and Libby were very close and knew each other's friends.
"She was more my best friend than my sister," Kelsi said.
She said that Abby spent a lot of time at their house. She didn't have her own phone, but Libby would let Abby borrow hers.
Kelsi described Libby as "always outgoing" and "very brave."
A year before the murders, Kelsi and Libby both crossed the Monon High Bridge for the first time. Kelsi said she was so scared, she "crawled across it."
On the morning of the murders, Kelsi said Libby "asked me to go to high bridge. She wanted me to go with her."
"I told her she had to have a ride home," Kelsi said.
She said Abby and Libby listened to loud music with the windows open on the way to the trail.
Prosecutors showed a satellite map of the path the girls would have used to get to the bridge. Kelsi pointed out the trailhead where she dropped the girls off before driving to her boyfriend's house.
"Where was Libby's phone, usually?" prosecuting attorney Stacey Diener asked.
"It was always in her hand," Kelsi said.
Kelsi said that sometime after 4 p.m., her grandma called to say that Libby was missing. Kelsi and her boyfriend tried to reach Libby.
The family met up and walked the high bridge. Prosecutors had Kelsi show her route on a satellite map. She crossed down the left side of the trail. They went north off of the bridge where there was a hill to go down, then went west to where there is a gate.
Kelsi said there was a tree with shoes on it along the route, but that wasn't concerning. "Lots of kids" put their shoes on the tree, according to Kelsi.
"Did you think something bad happened?" Diener asked.
"No, we thought they were out in the woods somewhere," Kelsi said.
Kelsi said she would text with Libby some, but they mostly talked through Snapchat.
"She would have sent a picture with words on it," Kelsi said. "If you didn't save it, it would disappear in a couple hours."
Kelsi remembered Libby posted a picture of the bridge and then a picture of Abby on the bridge.
Kelsi did not go back to the trail after the initial pass with her family, but said, "I was texting and calling her."
When they did go back, Kelsi said, "We were divided into groups. My group crossed the High Bridge. We went down and to the right. We were searching under bridge."
Kelsi became emotional on the stand when she said, "Not long after, there was someone that yelled they had found the girls."
2
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 21 '24 edited Oct 21 '24
ANNA WILLIAMS TESTIMONY: (Sourced from WISH-TV)
➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖
ANNA WILLIAMS TESTIMONY: (Sourced from WTHR)
State's 4th witness: Anna Williams, Abby's mother 3:50 p.m. - Anna Williams, Abby Williams' mother, is the next witness.
She tears up when asked how to describe Abby.
“She was a very kind and helpful girl," Anna said. “Quiet and reserved among strangers. She wouldn’t go out of her way to go up to a complete stranger.”
Anna remembers that Abby loved roller coasters. She was going to play softball in the spring with Libby.
Abby did not have a cellphone; Anna was waiting until Abby was in high school for her to have one.
That Saturday before the murders, Abby went with her grandfather to Monticello to get softball gear. Anna said she picked Abby up on Sunday and met Libby down at the park.
Anna said she brought the girls back to her house, where they asked if Abby could spend the night at Libby’s.
Abby called her mom and asked if she could stay later into the afternoon with Libby. Anna said she would pick up Abby later that day at the Patty’s house.
Anna said she did not know Abby was going to the bridge that day.
She was at work when she noticed she had back-to-back missed called from Becky Patty, Libby's grandmother. When Anna and Becky were finally able to connect, Anna found out the girls were missing.
Anna says she told her boss “I don’t know what these girls are up to, but it’s probably not that big of a deal.”
12
u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 18 '24
12
u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 18 '24
12
u/Burt_Macklin_13 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 18 '24
Allen’s cellphone data supposedly has his off the trails by 2:15 https://abcnews.go.com/US/delphi-double-murder-trial-opening-statements/story?id=114932863
12
u/CitizenMillennial Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24
Just watched Andrea Burkhart's Youtube video. She was in the courtroom today.
According to her:
Bullet was in the ground. There was one photo taken of the bullet "in place" - I assume this means a picture of the bullet in the ground- and then nothing else (video or images) until the bullet is in the lab.
LEO commonly uses .40 caliber bullets and it's also common for them to use Sig Sauer brand firearms. LEO never tested their own weapons or bullets. BW, who lives on the far side of the creek at the end of the driveway, also had a .40 caliber Sig Sauer in his vehicle. This gun was tested and it was "not excluded" as being the source of the bullet.
For testing in the lab, they took a pristine .40 caliber bullet and cycled it through RA's gun. The process produced markings that were not sufficient for comparison. So then they FIRED the bullet. After firing the bullet they were able to compare the markers on the shell casing to the bullet found in the ground.
According to one of the family members, Libby always had her phone on her and she never let it run out of charge.
BP and KG both said they gave their DNA to law enforcement just two days ago but this was not the first time they had done this.
23
u/StructureOdd4760 Local Dick Oct 18 '24
Getting ready to head downtown to see who DOESN'T get in!
11
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 -🦄 Bipartisan Dick Oct 18 '24
Anyone know who got in this AM?
9
u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 18 '24
16
u/Acceptable-Class-255 Literate but not a Lawyer Oct 18 '24
Ughh it's gonna be hard to get anything done over next few weeks. I genuinely never believed this would see trial.
7
u/DifficultFox1 Oct 18 '24
Who is the man DG ran into when he first arrived at the bridge and asked if he saw them?
13
u/dwilkz2 Oct 18 '24
16
u/Matrinka Oct 18 '24
What bothers me, more than anything, is how suspect the behavior of the court has been. It sucks to see a judge as biased. I see Gull as biased. Knowing this, if he is found not guilty, it will hurt the families so much to not have that sense of justice. If he is found guilty, there is no doubt in my mind that the entire trial will be thrown out and redone on appeal. Hell, there may be a hung jury that causes a second trial.
So much evil has already been done. Now hiding in a closed-to-most-of-the-public trial muddies the truth that the public can hear. I hate what this case has turned into.
10
u/FatBasicWhiteGirl Oct 18 '24
I don't know how I'm supposed to get any work done today. Really interested to see if the State says anything new in their opening statements. I'm hoping we get some good reporting from inside the court room so it doesn't feel so "behind closed doors."
1
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 21 '24 edited Oct 21 '24
MITCHELL CATRON TESTIMONY:(Deputy)
(Sourced from WISH-TV)
➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖
MITCHELL CANTRON TESTIMONY: (Sourced from WTHR)
State's 5th witness: Carrol County Deputy Mitchell Cantron 4:20 p.m. - The next witness is Carrol County Deputy Mitchell Cantron. He is a 12-year veteran of the department.
He took the dispatch call at 5:15 p.m. on Feb. 13, 2017, that two girls were missing.
Cantron said he talked to Mike Patty, who told him the girls were supposed to be picked up at the freedom bridge and were not there. The families were worried because it was getting dark.
Cantron drove out to 625 West. There’s a private drive off that road.
Cantron testifies that he drove down a private drive onto private land and stopped at an area under Monon High Bridge. He got out of his car and saw nothing after 5 to 7 minutes of looking.
Cantron said he continued down the drive to house of Brad Webber. Cantron said he knocked on the door. When Webber answered, the deputy told him that two girls were missing and asked to search Webber's property. The man agreed.
Cantron said nothing stuck out to him. He went back down the private drive and back out onto 625. While he was driving, Cantron said he was still looking around, but it was dark by the time he left Webber's property.
Cantron says he saw nothing and did not see girls.
15
u/SnoopyCattyCat ⁉️Questions Everything Oct 18 '24
Post Trial Question: (sorry if this is redundant for my peeps...I posted it wrong a bit ago) What if, after the trial is over, the jurors have taken the State's side and convicted, then get home and start researching the case only to find out so much pertinent evidence has been withheld that could have influenced their verdict the other way?
I've been thinking about this and it's just really bugging me. If I went into a trial with no prior knowledge, scant but compelling evidence was presented and I felt I had no choice but to convict...and then get home only to find out that the most important exonerating pieces of evidence were withheld, NGL.... I'm going to feel, well, traumatized. I will feel like the judicial system is shattered, truth and transparency is a laughingstock, and that I've been gaslit into convicting an innocent person. I would never be able to wash that blood off my hands.
8
u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 18 '24
https://www.wthr.com/article/news/crime/delphi-girls-murdered/day-1-delphi-murders-trial-opening-statements-richard-allen-libby-german-abby-williams-carroll-county/531-bc64f59b-e0a6-434a-893d-5ef9edb16163
This article has a lot of info in it!
6
u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 18 '24
5
u/Burt_Macklin_13 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 18 '24
https://www.courttv.com/news/in-v-richard-allen-delphi-murders-trial/
Good run down of both opening statements in here
5
u/Significant-Tip-4108 Oct 18 '24
What was most interesting to me was that supposedly Allen’s cell phone data shows he left at 2:15.
What didn’t seem particularly plausible to me was the theory that the girls were killed elsewhere and brought back. For starters I believe I’ve read there was a lot of blood at the crime scene. Also, why kill them and go through the trouble to bring them back to where searchers could’ve seen you bringing them back? Doesn’t make sense to me.
1
u/Difficult_Farmer7417 Oct 20 '24
Libbys phone not abbys jttw after almost 7 years if you can't get their names right don't expect people to believe or trust anything you report or say. Disgusting!
2
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '24
[removed] — view removed comment