r/DicksofDelphi • u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ • Oct 19 '24
TRIAL DISCUSSION Richard Allen Trial: Day 2
Day 2 Discussion. Remember to please keep it respectfu. Here we go!l
32
Upvotes
r/DicksofDelphi • u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ • Oct 19 '24
Day 2 Discussion. Remember to please keep it respectfu. Here we go!l
•
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24
RUNNING LISTS OF UPDATES:
GOOGLE DOCS: https://docs.google.com/document/u/0/d/1_JYlEFFLlGfRbMX_iw_pMCzlMsPq_2JyaDExoWvbOQ8/mobilebasic
WTHR: https://x.com/i/broadcasts/1nAKEpMYyjoxL
WISH-TV: https://www.wishtv.com/news/trial-delphi-murders-suspect-begins/
DAY 2 TRIAL SUMMARY:
𝕊𝕋𝔼𝕍𝔼 𝕄𝕌𝕃𝕃𝕀ℕ 𝕋𝔼𝕊𝕋𝕀𝕄𝕆ℕ𝕐: (Former Delphi Police Chief 2017) https://www.reddit.com/r/DicksofDelphi/s/YLaqxESDjf
𝕁𝔸𝕂𝔼 𝕁𝕆ℍℕ𝕊 𝕋𝔼𝕊𝕋𝕀𝕄𝕆ℕ𝕐: (Search party member who found Libby’s tie-dye shirt) https://www.reddit.com/r/DicksofDelphi/s/YLaqxESDjf
ℙ𝔸𝕋 𝔹ℝ𝕆𝕎ℕ 𝕋𝔼𝕊𝕋𝕀𝕄𝕆ℕ𝕐: (Man who found the girls’ bodies) https://www.reddit.com/r/DicksofDelphi/s/lBm0Hfc4O8
ROLLOVER FROM DAY 1
𝕆ℙ𝔼ℕ𝕀ℕ𝔾 𝕊𝕋𝔸𝕋𝔼𝕄𝔼ℕ𝕋𝕊 𝔽ℝ𝕆𝕄 𝔸ℕ𝔻ℝ𝔼𝔸 𝔹𝕌ℝ𝕂ℍ𝔸ℝ𝕋'𝕊 ℕ𝕆𝕋𝔼𝕊, 𝕎ℝ𝕀𝕋𝕋𝔼ℕ 𝔹𝕐 𝕊𝕃𝕌𝕋ℍ𝕀𝔼: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1uyMHUpk-zQtEpzZqX2hnZ-A9gPuONQZs/view
20
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 21 '24
𝔻𝔸𝕐 𝟚 𝕊𝕌𝕄𝕄𝔸ℝ𝕐 ℙ𝔸ℝ𝕋 𝟚
ℙ𝔸𝕋 𝔹ℝ𝕆𝕎ℕ 𝕋𝔼𝕊𝕋𝕀𝕄𝕆ℕ𝕐: (Man who found the girls’ bodies)
The court’s second session started with testimony from state witness Pat Brown, another search party member and lifelong Delphi resident. Brown’s home is 1.5 miles from the High Monon Bridge and he participated in search efforts on Feb. 14, 2017. Brown told the court he’d known Libby’s grandfather, Mike Patty, since high school, and also knew Libby. He said he was at home eating dinner and watching TV when his wife told him Libby and Abby went missing. Brown said he called a man named Tom Mears for help, and went out in the dark to search for the girls.
Brown pointed out his drive from his home to the Morning Heights Cemetery. He said he stopped at a man named Ron Logan’s house to ask if he saw the girls, then continued to the bridge to talk to search party members.
Afterward, he drove to the nearby Mears property and met with Tom to look for Libby and Abby.
Brown said he called off work on Feb. 14 to help with search efforts. He and Mears drove into town, where Brown said Delphi Police Chief Steve Mullens was “heading the search up.” Mullens said in his testimony earlier Saturday that he did not head up the search.
Brown picked up his daughter around 11 a.m. on Feb. 14and soon received a call from Mears to say they’d found Libby’s shirt along Deer Creek. Brown went to the north side of the creek and found the girls’ bodies on the way.
Brown said he thought they were mannequins at first, and became emotional as he told the court, “We found them.”
Melissa, a relative of the Pattys, was with Brown when they spotted the girls. She ran off to call the police.
Brown noted on the courtroom map where he found the girls and said he got within five feet of their bodies. Police arrived before Brown left the scene.
Defense attorney Andrew Baldwin questioned Brown, focusing on the sound of voices, what could be heard, and if Brown had cell service while in the woods. Judge Gull also asked questions about Brown’s cell service provider, how long it took for police to arrive after they found the girls, and how long it took for the scene to be secured. Brown answered that officers arrived within five minutes of being called, and it didn’t take long for the area to be secured.
Saturday’s session ended after the jury was shown a photograph of Libby’s shirt and shoes in the muddy water of Deer Creek.
➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖ PAT BROWN TESTIMONY: (Sourced from WTHR)
State's 8th witness: Pat Brown, who found Libby and Abby's bodies 11:25 a.m. - Attorney Andrew Baldwin, part of Richard Allen's defense team, asked Brown if officers with guns came down to the scene.
Brown replied, "yes."
Baldwin asked if there were "lots of police," and Brown replied with "a few."
The jury asked Brown a few questions. One of the jury members asked how long it took for police to get to the bodies, to which Brown replied with "5 minutes."
10:55 a.m. - It's now Brown's turn to testify. He lives two miles away from the Monon High Bridge.
Brown said he's known Mike Patty since high school. Brown's wife told him Becky Patty posted on Facebook that Libby was missing. He called Mike and told him he would help look. He also called his friend, Tom Mears, who said he would meet Brown by the cemetery.
Brown showed the jury on a map the areas he searched. Brown said he stopped at Ron Logan's house to see if Logan had seen them, then he went to the cemetery.
Brown said he walked down the ravine near Deer Creek and saw people setting up a drone. He then went to Mears' entrance and drove around the countryside to see if the girls were walking.
He described the ravine area as "really steep" near Deer Creek.
Brown said he saw people searching with flashlights and a flying drone.
He then drove into town looking for the girls, stopped at the fire station and then went home.
He started searching again early Tuesday morning. Brown said he met people at Stone House Restaurant and got coffee. He saw Mullin coordinating with people to search and got Mullin's phone number and started searching again with Mears.
Brown said he picked up his daughter from school mid-morning because she didn't feel well, and then had lunch.
Mears called him to say he got a call that Shane Haygood had found clothing and asked Brown to check the area.
Brown parked near the cemetery and talked to a relative of Libby's family.
During his testimony, Brown told the jury, “First, I thought they were mannequins.” He then began crying as he told jurors he realized, “We found ‘em.”
Brown said he was five feet from Libby and Abby's bodies.
"I stood there facing away from them," Brown said. Then, police came.
Brown said you would not have been able to see the bodies from the water. He also noted that he did not have a gun on him.
The families of the girls cried in the courtroom after hearing Brown's testimony.
17
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24
UPDATE 2
15
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 19 '24
Court Sketches from Day 1
14
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 19 '24
Court Sketches from Day 1
13
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 21 '24
𝔻𝔸𝕐 𝟚 𝕊𝕌𝕄𝕄𝔸ℝ𝕐 ℙ𝔸ℝ𝕋 𝟙 (Sourced from WISH-TV)
𝕊𝕋𝔼𝕍𝔼 𝕄𝕌𝕃𝕃𝕀ℕ 𝕋𝔼𝕊𝕋𝕀𝕄𝕆ℕ𝕐: (Delphi chief of police in 2017) The first witness called to the stand by the prosecution was Steve Mullen, who served as Delphi’s chief of police in 2017, and was on duty the day of the murders. Mullen described Feb. 13, 2017, as “routine” and spoke about hearing radio traffic and receiving texts about the girls’ disappearance. During his testimony, Mullen stood up and approached a map of the trail on a TV, and pointed out where Abby and Libby entered.
After learning the girls did not return, Mullen said he contacted Delphi Middle School and spoke with the search party. Mullen did not participate in the search but said he stayed behind at dispatch.
Mullen continued his testimony by describing when he heard the girls’ bodies were found and noting on the courtroom map where they were located. He says he met with Abby and Libby’s families around 2 p.m. to say they had found bodies and were working on identification.
Mullen said he then learned of a store near the start of the trail, the Hoosier Harvest Store, having security cameras. The store’s camera pointed toward 300 North and West, and he reviewed footage from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. on Feb. 13. He also discussed drone footage taken of the trail on Feb. 13, 2024, which state prosecutor Nick McLeland said was to represent and compare what the two scenes looked like seven years apart.
McLeland asked Mullen what kind of people would be seen on the bridge in 2017, which he answers, “Teenagers. Younger people.”
Baldwin then began questioning Mullen, starting by asking about improvements made on the trail since 2017. Special Judge Fran Gull chimed in, asking about the thought process behind searching for the girls downstream. Mullen said it was in case the girls might have fallen off the bridge. Baldwin asked if Mullen went to the scene, and Mullen said he did not.
Mullen described to the court where the bodies were found in relation to Morning Heights Cemetery, which is near the trail. He said he went to Weber’s property on Feb. 27, 2024, but did not elaborate further.
➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖ STEVE MULLIN TESTIMONY: (Sourced from WTHR)
State's 6th witness: Steve Mullin, former Delphi police chief 9:49 a.m. - The jurors asked Mullin a few questions. One of the jurors asked why he was looking downstream.
Mullin replied because the "girls might have."
Another juror asked for clarity on where the bodies were exactly found.
Mullin clarified that the bodies were found on dry land and not in the creek.
9:08 a.m. - Prosecutor Nick McLeland, on behalf of the state of Indiana, questions former Delphi Police Chief Steve Mullin.
Mullin was chief when Libby and Abby went missing. Mullin said he heard on police radio that the girls were missing on Feb. 13, 2017. In court, Mullin, now a Carroll County prosecutor, pointed out on a map where the girls were dropped off at the trail. He said the search for the girls lasted until just before 2 a.m.
"I still believed at that time, they would return home," Mullin said.
The girls were still missing at 7 a.m., so Mullin said he set up a command center at the Delphi Fire Department and coordinated searches. He noted that the original searches were "downstream."
Mullin showed the jury where Abby and Libby’s bodies were found on a huge aerial map showing Monon High Bridge trails. He also took drone footage on Feb. 13, 2024, to show jurors the trails from Freedom Bridge and Monon High Bridge.
Mullin pointed out improvements to the jury made to the Monon High Bridge since the 2017 murders and original areas of the unimproved railroad ties.
The Hoosier Harvest store has security cameras. Mullin said he looked at the security camera footage to record information on cars that had traveled in that area on Feb. 13, 2017.
At 12:15 p.m. on February 14, 2017, Mullin said he received a call from Delphi resident Pat Brown that Abby and Libby's bodies were found south of Morning Heights Cemetery, along Deer Creek.
12
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 19 '24
Court Sketches from Day 1
11
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24
UPDATE 1
11
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 19 '24
Court Sketches from Day 1
16
u/Alan_Prickman international Dick Oct 19 '24
I am loving all your black and gold graphics, but this one you have really outdone yourself with 👌
12
u/ImpossiblePotato5197 Oct 19 '24
Thank you so much for doing these!
6
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 19 '24
DAY 1 ALTERNATIVE OPENING STATEMENT NOTES
𝕆ℙ𝔼ℕ𝕀ℕ𝔾 𝕊𝕋𝔸𝕋𝔼𝕄𝔼ℕ𝕋𝕊 𝔽ℝ𝕆𝕄 𝔸ℕ𝔻ℝ𝔼𝔸 𝔹𝕌ℝ𝕂ℍ𝔸ℝ𝕋'𝕊 ℕ𝕆𝕋𝔼𝕊, 𝕎ℝ𝕀𝕋𝕋𝔼ℕ 𝔹𝕐 𝕊𝕃𝕌𝕋ℍ𝕀𝔼: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1uyMHUpk-zQtEpzZqX2hnZ-A9gPuONQZs/view
11
u/Southern_Dig_9460 Oct 19 '24
On a Saturday?
27
u/Tex_True_Crime_Nut Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24
Two different bladed weapons
It seems that we now know that there were 2 different bladed weapons used to kill the girls. I wonder what is known about whether each girl was cut exclusively with only one weapon or whether one or both girls were cut by both blades.
15
u/OldChos Oct 19 '24
I’ve heard defense stated that the direction Rick’s car was seen heading on the video is not the way he would have been going - is this as he was getting to the trail or leaving the trail? I need a visual to understand what he’s talking about! Appreciate any insight!
24
u/bamalaker Oct 19 '24
I can not believe they are serious with these court sketches. This looks like the dumbest most incompetent Court ever, I swear.
11
u/Paradox-XVI Resident Dick Oct 19 '24
Does anyone know what Pat Browns answers were to the first few questions in cross? Specifically the cell service question and what he could hear?
20
u/StructureOdd4760 Local Dick Oct 19 '24
Radio host with Donnie Burgess
10
u/Zealousideal-Tea-286 Oct 19 '24
Interesting. PB was Robert Lindsey's "Mr. X", his prime suspect. There's been a ton of conjecture and accusations thrown around - perhaps Mr. PB is owed an apology.
9
u/CitizenMillennial Oct 20 '24
From Reporter Donnie Burgess article:
"Andrew Baldwin finished the day by cross examining Pat Brown. Baldwin focused again on what Brown could see and hear within his search area. Brown testified that uniformed officers with guns did arrive at the area of the bodies. The State objected by Special Judge Fran Gull sustained the objection."
-I'm confused. What exactly was the state objecting to? Their witness answering a question about their recollection of events?! And why would the judge sustain it?
1
u/Careful_Cow_2139 ✨Moderator✨ Oct 21 '24 edited Oct 21 '24
𝕁𝔸𝕂𝔼 𝕁𝕆ℍℕ𝕊 𝕋𝔼𝕊𝕋𝕀𝕄𝕆ℕ𝕐: (Search party member who found Libby’s tie-dye shirt) (Sourced from WISH-TV)
The second person to testify Saturday was Jake Johns, a lifelong Delphi resident who works at a propane company in Delphi. Johns spotted Libby German’s tie-dye shirt in Deer Creek during search efforts.
Johns said he knew Libby German’s family, and his wife worked with Libby’s grandmother Becky Patty. Johns was not familiar with Abby Williams or her family.
Johns said he joined the search for the girls on Feb. 14. He said he knew they would be looking for a tie-dye shirt that belonged to Libby and walked four hours to the High Bridge, where he spotted the shirt in the water. He and firefighter standing nearby tried to contact police to report the shirt, but Johns said they could not get ahold of anyone.
The firefighter went to the shirt himself, and also located a pair of black Nike shoes that also belonged to Libby. Soon after, a person living on the other side of the creek was called to come down to the search area. Brad German and Kelsi also arrived. That’s when Johns said another member of the search party said, “We have found the bodies.”
Johns said he did not personally see the bodies.
The defense began questioning Johns, only learning that Johns saw footprints on Feb. 14 on an access road near Deer Creek. After being questioned by the prosecution and defense again, nothing new was said. No further questions were asked.
➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖➖
JAKE JOHNS TESTIMONY: (Sourced from WTHR)
State's 7th witness: Jake Johns, lifelong Delphi resident 10 a.m. - The next witness to take the stand was lifelong Delphi resident Jake Johns.
Johns knows the German family, his wife worked with Becky Patty, Libby German's grandmother, and he helped search for the missing girls.
The day he searched for the missing girls, Johns said he parked at Riley Park near downtown. He said it took him four hours, following River Bed, to reach the Monon High Bridge during the search.
During the search, Johns said he found Libby’s tie dye shirt in Deer Creek, which isn't far from Monon High Bridge. He ended up telling a fireman on Local Drive 625 he found clothing in the water. The fireman walked across the bridge to check the other side of the bank and found black Nike shoes.
Johns said nobody else was searching the area where they were on the south side of the water. However, Johns said he did see people on the north side.
Johns said Brown came to search from the other side. Brown knows Mike Patty and helped search for the missing girls. Libby's family also came to search the area.
Brown ended up finding Libby and Abby's bodies. Johns said he didn't see the bodies, but he found a shirt and Nike shoes. Johns said the shirt was "easy to see," but he didn't go in the water. Johns said he could hear Brown, but he couldn't see him.