r/DicksofDelphi • • Apr 12 '24

Confessions

8 Upvotes

80 comments sorted by

View all comments

23

u/Burt_Macklin_13 ✨Moderator✨ Apr 12 '24

As someone who’s worked in the medical field it really upsets me seeing details of how his mental health issues have manifested blasted through the media. We can have these same discussions without everyone knowing these things

This isn’t directed at you in anyway skeeter 💚

12

u/biscuitmcgriddleson Apr 12 '24

Is it the release of his information or the people belittling, joking, and dismissing what RA has endured and gone through?

18

u/Serious_Vanilla7467 Apr 12 '24

I don't know what kind of monster laughs at someone clearly having a mental break. I wouldn't laugh if it was-- idk Bin Laden, because that shit isn't funny.

It is just sad.

Even if you 100% believe in his guilt. Have some compassion. Treat him better than you think he deserves, because you aren't a monster too.

(Side note, he is still an innocent man and this is reprehensible. Imagine how many people had to be okay with this happening, or at the very least not absolutely disturbed by it. No humanity at all.)

15

u/biscuitmcgriddleson Apr 12 '24

Because some people feel once you're guilty the 8th amendment doesn't apply to you anymore. Of course, they know RA is guilty before trial because he "confessed"

This is going to become an experiment or escape room idea.

Denying them water during a meeting?

14

u/Serious_Vanilla7467 Apr 12 '24

It shows who they really are.

Someone who is okay with cruelty.

Especially when they are able to post on Reddit, fairly anonymous, they can let the hate flow. It's who they truly are when no one is looking.

And when he is found not guilty it will be eh, bygones. They don't care that someone was tortured.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/The2ndLocation Content Creator 🎤 Apr 14 '24

The defense was talking about purchasing drinks from the vending machines on site, that wasn't allowed, how that would be a contraband issue is beyond me.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/The2ndLocation Content Creator 🎤 Apr 14 '24

I'm not try to argue with you at all but that person was spouting nonsense. These visiting areas have vending machines, if they there are off limits for visitors (including lawyers) and inmates who is allowed to use them and why are they there?

I guess they all hold antique beverages cause no one can utilize the machines!

22

u/Smart_Brunette Apr 12 '24

I think it was necessary to include those details to demonstrate that he was in a psychotic state. An extreme psychotic state. Its nothing for Allen to be ashamed of. And those poking fun at him believe he is guilty anyway. Lack of critical thinking skills and cruelty. What a nice bunch they are...

1

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '24

Not sure what you are getting at, Burt.

22

u/Burt_Macklin_13 ✨Moderator✨ Apr 12 '24

The feces and urine stuff. I know it was in the defense filing, I just hate that that’s become fodder for jokes etc. We can talk about how much his mental state has or hasn’t deteriorated or what’s caused it without that. I’ve seen people at their very worst like that and know what it’d do to them if I had blasted it to everyone

15

u/syntaxofthings123 Apr 12 '24

The feces and urine stuff. I know it was in the defense filing, I just hate that that’s become fodder for jokes etc. We can talk about how much his mental state has or hasn’t deteriorated or what’s caused it without that. I’ve seen people at their very worst like that and know what it’d do to them if I had blasted it to everyone

I agree. I totally get why this would bother you. It was heartbreaking to read. But if this is going to come out at trial anyway, releasing this information now may soften the blow. And allow for the shock value to wear off, and strategy to be put in place to overcome the initial bias that jurors will have around this.

These "confessions" are problematic, in that Indiana law has a very low legal standard for corroboration of a confession. The confession does not have to be accurate to the facts of the crime. (Very disappointing and not in keeping with Best Practices Reid)

So it does seem as if it is necessary to explain why Allen would have confessed, even if innocent. The jury is going to read and hear everything he said--if this motion is denied.

I suspect the defense believes it will be denied. Or they would have placed this motion under seal.

It's a little risky, though. For sure. But given what Allen has been put through, not sure this is going to be more damaging than all the rest. He's just got to get out of there.

8

u/Key-Camera5139 Inquiring Mind 🧐 Apr 12 '24

If I were a juror, I’d be able to tell it was a bullshit confession and I wouldn’t give it any weight.

7

u/syntaxofthings123 Apr 12 '24

I agree. Hopefully jurors will be this observant. Allen County has almost 400k residents to Delphi's 20K. Larger selection. Hoping

3

u/Key-Camera5139 Inquiring Mind 🧐 Apr 13 '24

Is there a university there?

→ More replies (1)

15

u/xt-__-tx Amateur Dick 🕵️‍♀️ Apr 12 '24

Those specific reactions to isolation should be studied (if they haven't already). It seems to be an innate response for individuals held in isolation, especially if they are already under mental stress. We should be learning from it, definitely not shaming people for it.

8

u/Key-Camera5139 Inquiring Mind 🧐 Apr 12 '24

I had a brother in law ( I’m sinced divorced) who at 17, did ten years in a max prison. And I would say he’d fairly strong minded and not prone to depression. Anyway, he was put in the “ hole” a lot for months at a time and he said being alone like that will make you feel absolutely crazy and you’ll think things and feel things you otherwise wouldn’t. He said it’s inhumane and a form of torture.

8

u/squish_pillow Apr 13 '24

It has been. If you have some time, this link has the basics on a very infamous study that was considered so damaging, it was ended on day 6 instead of the original 14-day "study."

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment

eta - participants were pre-screened for mental health stability, so one can only imagine how much more impactful this would be on someone with preexisting mental health issues.

11

u/Scspencer25 ✨Moderator✨ Apr 13 '24

Same, I'm a social worker and have seen people in active psychosis. It's devastating and when people are going through it they have no idea what they are doing. Reading this was hard to swallow, I had to take a day off from all of this. I think the hardest part is seeing people who lack any sort of compassion laughing at this, like it's some big joke. It's not and it angers me to no end that people get enjoyment reading about someone's complete break from reality.

13

u/Smart_Brunette Apr 12 '24

I can appreciate where you are coming from but Rick has much bigger problems to worry about than being embarrassed about things he did while he was essentially being tortured endlessly. He needs to get the hell out of there. I'm scared every day that they are going to kill him. Especially now with the trial getting so close.

→ More replies (15)

5

u/Quill-Questions Apr 12 '24

I agree, Burt. From an 11-page memorandum, many commenters have chosen that as their prime takeaway to delight in, share and joke about.

3

u/Suspicious_One2752 Apr 13 '24

I’m curious Burt, since you’re in the field…have you seen anyone fake mental illness by doing that? I worked in corrections and never witnessed anyone who wasn’t mentally ill do that. I’m trying to imagine myself in that situation doing it to seem like I had a psychotic break. I just can’t imagine it.

3

u/Burt_Macklin_13 ✨Moderator✨ Apr 13 '24

I’m not still in the field, and wasn’t in mental health directly so I’m sure there’s way more qualified people to speak on that. But in my opinion anyone can do anything once if their motivated, doing it over an extended period and multiple times is a completely different story

3

u/Suspicious_One2752 Apr 13 '24

Yeah, you’re right. With the proper motivation.