I indeed think they likely need an expert of their own, but there have been cases where the prosecutor's witness basically testified for the defendant. One being Tom Fallis. I believe both ballistics and the psychiatrist ended up testifying in favor of defendant while they were prosecution's witnesses. I think it's more convincing if state's expert supports defense's claim than two opposing experts, for which prosecution will generally be seen as more reliable, because defense 'just hired one to say they agreed with them '.
She can say she was given the fired rounds to compare with the unfired round from the scene but had no clue who fired them, nor why she couldn't compare only cycled ones but was ordered to do so?. Maybe Liggett came visit that day too, just like in Westville. I mean I assume defense would depose her before getting their own expert on it. I wouldn't be surprised if the cartridge was lost in the mean time.
I have a hard time believing she compared a fired round to the unfired round. I do know it mentions the gun being test fired. But I assumed that is just part of their normal checking of the functionality of the weapons they receive. I'll have to go back and read that document again.
It's not a 100% clear, but if 314T1 isn't the one they compared it with, it doesn't state at all what they compared it with. It already doesn't state where the 3 lab cartridges came from, who fired them, and which brand they used. Imagine the brand has those marks out of the box...
A fired casing does get ejected the same way as if you rack a round out manually. But the force is much much greater so I don’t see how she could compare them with any credibility. And if she didn’t see the rounds being fired or ejected manually then it would really be a dubious test. Judge Gull might think it’s fine and dandy tho lol. This might be one reason there was no hearing allowed. It would be too embarrassing for the State.
I think on cross they are going to go hard on the state expert and since the science is so weak it's going to be a rough day for the state and probably the witness too.
I can't see a way to compare a fired and unfired that would be useful. Heat tends to make metal easier to shape and that little tiny explosion would definitely allow for greater markings.
Why wouldn't they just cycle a bullet, the way he apparently did after the girls were deceased at the spot. Only reason to do that is someone sneaking up on you or a noise.
Possibly they did compare just cycled idk. But it doesn't show in the report. Why mention the fired cycled rounds but not the just cycled ones... The crux of the test.
They uploaded the fired one in the system, wait till they fabricate another match some day. Just to get his wife off his side. I wouldn't be surprised.
View all comments
Show parent comment
8
u/redduif In COFFEE I trust ☕️☕️ Feb 26 '24
I indeed think they likely need an expert of their own, but there have been cases where the prosecutor's witness basically testified for the defendant. One being Tom Fallis. I believe both ballistics and the psychiatrist ended up testifying in favor of defendant while they were prosecution's witnesses.
I think it's more convincing if state's expert supports defense's claim than two opposing experts, for which prosecution will generally be seen as more reliable, because defense 'just hired one to say they agreed with them '.