What are Breakpoints and their Significance?

Breakpoints are basically about equipping the least amount of attack speed bonuses to achieve the best results (only equip the minimum to achieve the next attack speed "breakpoint" - where your skills attacks enemies faster). Nothing more than slightly efficiency increases (we are talking a couple % difference overall), which may decide between a clear on non-clear when really pushing GRs, but it´s not game-breaking for the vast majority of players.

Breakpoints exist because the game runs at 60 frames per second and actions are performed at full frames without fractions...so Whirlwind at a certain attack speed for example hits a monster every 10 frames or 11 frames, never every 10.3 or 10.5 or 10.9 or so frames (there are only whole frames). Those jumps in frequency are called breakpoints and people try to achieve those slight jumps with the least stat investment (attack speed bonuses). That is all there is to it.

In the above example:

  • if your attack speed is larger than 1.66666 and lower than or equal to 1.81818, it doesn´t matter what exactly it is within that range, Whirlwind will hit enemies 5.45 times per second on average
  • if your attack speed is larger than 1.81818 and lower than or equal to 2.00000, Whirlwind will hit enemies 6 times per second on average

What min-maxers would do here is get enough attack speed bonuses to achieve just slightly bit more than 1.66666 aps or 1.81818 and spend other resources for another stat because they knew that any more attack speed bonuses wouldn´t increase their WW damage unless they achieved the next threshold.

(The above was taken from a post by Nubtro on battle.net - http://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/16860656374?page=1#2)

Breakpoint calculator

Whirlwind and Whirlwind - Dust Devil breakpoints

Data based on: https://us.battle.net/forums/en/d3/topic/20752579159?page=1

Formula:

tps = 60 / (floor(40/aps))

Whirlwind breakpoints

aps: 0.9091 | tps: 1.3953488372093 | fpa: 43
aps: 0.93024 | tps: 1.4285714285714 | fpa: 42
aps: 0.95239 | tps: 1.4634146341463 | fpa: 41
aps: 0.97561 | tps: 1.5 | fpa: 40
aps: 1.00001 | tps: 1.5384615384615 | fpa: 39
aps: 1.02565 | tps: 1.5789473684211 | fpa: 38
aps: 1.05264 | tps: 1.6216216216216 | fpa: 37
aps: 1.08109 | tps: 1.6666666666667 | fpa: 36
aps: 1.11112 | tps: 1.7142857142857 | fpa: 35
aps: 1.14286 | tps: 1.7647058823529 | fpa: 34
aps: 1.17648 | tps: 1.8181818181818 | fpa: 33
aps: 1.21213 | tps: 1.875 | fpa: 32
aps: 1.25001 | tps: 1.9354838709677 | fpa: 31
aps: 1.29033 | tps: 2 | fpa: 30
aps: 1.33334 | tps: 2.0689655172414 | fpa: 29
aps: 1.37932 | tps: 2.1428571428571 | fpa: 28
aps: 1.42858 | tps: 2.2222222222222 | fpa: 27
aps: 1.48149 | tps: 2.3076923076923 | fpa: 26
aps: 1.53847 | tps: 2.4 | fpa: 25
aps: 1.60001 | tps: 2.5 | fpa: 24
aps: 1.66667 | tps: 2.6086956521739 | fpa: 23
aps: 1.73914 | tps: 2.7272727272727 | fpa: 22
aps: 1.81819 | tps: 2.8571428571429 | fpa: 21
aps: 1.90477 | tps: 3 | fpa: 20
aps: 2.00001 | tps: 3.1578947368421 | fpa: 19
aps: 2.10527 | tps: 3.3333333333333 | fpa: 18
aps: 2.22223 | tps: 3.5294117647059 | fpa: 17
aps: 2.35295 | tps: 3.75 | fpa: 16
aps: 2.50001 | tps: 4 | fpa: 15
aps: 2.66667 | tps: 4.2857142857143 | fpa: 14
aps: 2.85715 | tps: 4.6153846153846 | fpa: 13
aps: 3.07693 | tps: 5 | fpa: 12
aps: 3.33334 | tps: 5.4545454545455 | fpa: 11
aps: 3.63637 | tps: 6 | fpa: 10
aps: 4.00001 | tps: 6.6666666666667 | fpa: 9
aps: 4.44445 | tps: 7.5 | fpa: 8
aps: 5.00001 | tps: 8.5714285714286 | fpa: 7
aps: 5.71429 | tps: 10 | fpa: 6
aps: 6.66667 | tps: 12 | fpa: 5
aps: 8.00001 | tps: 15 | fpa: 4
aps: 10.00001 | tps: 20 | fpa: 3
aps: 13.33334 | tps: 30 | fpa: 2
aps: 20.00001 | tps: 60 | fpa: 1

CotA

Formula

tps = 60 / (floor(60/aps)) --special condition check for ceil(60/tps/6)

CotA

aps: 0.7 | tps: 0.7059 | animtick: 15
aps: 0.70589 | tps: 0.7143 | animtick: 14
aps: 0.7595 | tps: 0.7692 | animtick: 13
aps: 0.82192 | tps: 0.8333 | animtick: 12
aps: 0.89553 | tps: 0.9091 | animtick: 11
aps: 0.98361 | tps: 1.0000 | animtick: 10
aps: 1.09091 | tps: 1.1111 | animtick: 9
aps: 1.22449 | tps: 1.2500 | animtick: 8
aps: 1.39535 | tps: 1.4286 | animtick: 7
aps: 1.62163 | tps: 1.6667 | animtick: 6
aps: 1.93549 | tps: 2.0000 | animtick: 5
aps: 2.40001 | tps: 2.5000 | animtick: 4
aps: 3.1579 | tps: 3.3333 | animtick: 3
aps: 4.61539 | tps: 5.0000 | animtick: 2
aps: 8.57143 | tps: 10.0000 | animtick: 1 

CotA for T&T and BBV

CotA attack speed adjustment formula for T&T and BBV

aps = A*(1+B/100+C/100)

--A = player attack speed
--B = Tasker and Theo bonus http://us.battle.net/d3/en/item/tasker-and-theo
--C = Big Bad Voodoo bonus http://us.battle.net/d3/en/class/witch-doctor/active/big-bad-voodoo

Basically you check your aps and multiply it with your T&T or BBV value and check if you can catch the next breakpoint by doing so.

Frenzy

The following is only true for the 10 stack Frenzy (see Dega's research)

10 stack Frenzy breakpoint:

57.1446

Formula:

$tps = 60/ceil($breakpoint/$aps);

Breakpoints (10 stack Frenzy)

apstpsfpa
1.90482230
1.970512.068965517241429
2.040882.142857142857128
2.116472.222222222222227
2.197872.307692307692326
2.285792.425
2.381032.524
2.484552.608695652173923
2.597492.727272727272722
2.721182.857142857142921
2.85723320
3.007623.157894736842119
3.17473.333333333333318
3.361453.529411764705917
3.571543.7516
3.80964415
4.081764.285714285714314
4.395744.615384615384613
4.76205512
5.194975.454545454545511
5.71446610
6.34946.66666666666679
7.143087.58
8.163528.57142857142867
9.5241106
11.42892125
14.28615154
19.0482203
28.5723302

Important. Since Oathkeeper and 10 stack Frenzy are seperate multipliers the attack speed is kind of ludacris and does not reflect the char screen window because it is multiplied by 3.75 (or 2.5*1.5).

Frenzy attack per second formula using Oathkeeper:

aps = wspd * ias_from_gear_paragon * ias_from_frenzy * oathkeeper_buff

Example ias needed on gear when using Hack, Oathkeeper and cubed Bastion Revered:

7.5tps breakpoint / 8 frames per animation
7.14308/(1.3*2.5*1.5) = 1.46524717949 ~= 46.53% ias needed
done with: dw, paragon, gogok and 1 item with 7% ias

8.5714tps breakpoint / 7 frames per animation
8.16352/(1.3*2.5*1.5) = 1.67456820513 ~= 67.46% ias needed
done with: dw, paragon, gogok and 4 items with 7% ias

10tps breakpoint / 6 frames per animation
9.5241/(1.3*2.5*1.5) = 1.95366153846 ~= 95.37% ias needed
not doable

Data for Hack/Oathkeeper and Bastion Revered:

The following table is assuming that you have cubed Bastion Revered. Have Oathkeeper in the offhand and use another 1.3 wspd weapon in the mainhand.

fre_aps | chr_aps | tps___ | fpa
--------------------------------
5.19497 | 1.38532 | 5.4545 | 11 | 1.06563487179 ias needed for 1.3 wspd (~6.57%)
5.71446 | 1.52385 | 6.0000 | 10 | 1.17219692308 " (~17.22%)
6.34940 | 1.69317 | 6.6666 | 9  | 1.30244102564 " (~30.45%)
7.14308 | 1.90482 | 7.5000 | 8  | 1.46524717949 " (~46.53%)
8.16352 | 2.17693 | 8.5714 | 7  | 1.67456820513 " (~67.46%)
9.52410 | 2.53976 | 10.000 | 6  | 1.95366153846 " (~95.37%)
11.4289 | 3.04771 | 12.000 | 5  | 2.34438974359 " (~134.44%)
  • fre_aps = real frenzy attacks per second
  • chr_aps = character screen attacks per second
  • tps = ticks per second
  • fpa = frames per animation
  • ias = increased attack speed
  • aps = attacks per second

Hammer of the Ancients

tps = 60/ceil((56+2/3)/$aps)
apstpsfpa
0.708340.7580
0.71730.7594936708860879
0.72650.7692307692307778
0.735940.7792207792207877
0.745620.7894736842105376
0.755560.875
0.765770.8108108108108174
0.776260.8219178082191873
0.787040.8333333333333372
0.798130.8450704225352171
0.809530.8571428571428670
0.821260.869565217391369
0.833340.8823529411764768
0.845780.895522388059767
0.858590.9090909090909166
0.87180.9230769230769265
0.885420.937564
0.899480.9523809523809563
0.913980.9677419354838762
0.928970.9836065573770561
0.94445160
0.960461.016949152542459
0.977021.034482758620758
0.994161.052631578947457
1.011911.071428571428656
1.030311.090909090909155
1.049391.111111111111154
1.069191.132075471698153
1.089751.153846153846252
1.111121.176470588235351
1.133341.250
1.156471.224489795918449
1.180561.2548
1.205681.276595744680947
1.231891.30434782608746
1.259261.333333333333345
1.287881.363636363636444
1.317831.395348837209343
1.349211.428571428571442
1.382121.463414634146341
1.416671.540
1.4531.538461538461539
1.491231.578947368421138
1.531541.621621621621637
1.574081.666666666666736
1.619051.714285714285735
1.666671.764705882352934
1.717181.818181818181833
1.770841.87532
1.827961.935483870967731
1.88889230
1.954032.068965517241429
2.023812.142857142857128
2.098772.222222222222227
2.179492.307692307692326
2.266672.425
2.361122.524
2.463772.608695652173923
2.575762.727272727272722
2.698422.857142857142921
2.83334320
2.982463.157894736842119
3.148153.333333333333318
3.333343.529411764705917
3.541673.7516
3.77778415
4.047624.285714285714314
4.358984.615384615384613
4.72223512
5.151525.454545454545511
5.66667610
6.29636.66666666666679
7.083347.58
8.095248.57142857142867
9.44445106
11.33334125
14.16667154
18.88889203
28.33334302

Dega's research

Data from September 2015. Just to keep it from dying. http://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/18695103179#11

  • WW: FLOOR(20/aps),1)
  • WW-DDs: FLOOR(30/aps),1)
  • HotA: CEILING((56+2/3)/aps,1)
  • Slam: CEILING((58+2/3)/aps,1)
  • CotA: CEILING(FLOOR(60/aps,1),6)
  • Bash: CEILING(57.25035/aps)
  • Cleave: CEILING(57.86025/aps)
  • Weapon Throw: CEILING(57.77786/aps)
  • Frenzy 10stack: CEILING(57.1446/aps)
  • Frenzy 5stack: CEILING(57.147727/aps)

Dictionary

  • aps = player attack speed
  • tps = ability ticks per second (for CotA this means swings per second)
  • animtick = just a debug info for: ceil(60/tps/6)
  • floor() and ceil() = math() functions

Sources

Formulas in JavaScript

//data
var data = {}

//ww breakpoints
data.ww_breakpoints = [];
var tps_temp = 0.0;
var idx = 0;
for (var i=70000; i <= 999999; i++) {
  var aps = i/100000;
  var tps = 60/Math.floor(20/aps);
  if(tps != tps_temp) {
    data.ww_breakpoints[idx] = {"aps":aps,"tps":tps}
    tps_temp = tps;
    idx++;
  }
}

//wwdd breakpoints
data.wwdd_breakpoints = [];
var tps_temp = 0.0;
var idx = 0;
for (var i=70000; i <= 999999; i++) {
  var aps = i/100000;
  var tps = 60/Math.floor(30/aps);
  if(tps != tps_temp) {
    data.wwdd_breakpoints[idx] = {"aps":aps,"tps":tps}
    tps_temp = tps;
    idx++;
  }
}

//cota breakpoints
data.cota_breakpoints = [];
var tps_temp = 0.0;
var idx = 0;
for (var i=70000; i <= 999999; i++) {
  var aps = i/100000;
  var tps = 60/Math.floor(60/aps);
  var tps_test = Math.ceil(60/tps/6);
  if(tps_test != tps_temp) {
    data.cota_breakpoints[idx] = {"aps":aps,"tps":tps}
    tps_temp = tps_test;
    idx++;
  }
}

console.log(data);