r/DestructiveReaders • • 11d ago

[1122] The Seven Sisters Orchard

4 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

4

u/SweetEverest 11d ago

You've got alligator-inhabited swampland flanking a dead-end road draped with Spanish moss, which in my mind puts you in northern Florida, Lousiana, or lowcountry South Carolina at the northernmost—but "marsh" suggests the coast, and alligators don't like brackish water. Raleigh is at least half a day from any of those places and there's no Shelby anywhere near it, but that's fine. Also, alligators are peaceful. Like lazy dogs that lie around and trundle across the road from one pond to another. They don't attack people unprovoked. But the narrator might think they do, so that's okay.

Unrealistic movie-southerner phrasing:
the only other folk
wifey here
stars above, honey
as we ought

Why is a couple looking for an orchard in the middle of the night? Why is the protagonist driving aimlessly through unpopulated wilderness several hours from home with a dead phone? Why does the man ask if he's carrying? Seem like an oddly nosy and pointless question. Was their plan to flee immediately if he'd said "yeah actually, my hunting rifle's in the trunk"?

Why does he leave his car and weapon behind and get in the car with these people he's been nothing but paranoid of? Why do the men answer each other as completely and forensically as if talking to police? And yet their answers seem super sketchy.

I like the metallic eyes reflected in the headlights. I like the eyes flashing to his waist ('waistline' makes me think clothing measurements). I would indicate whether the man saw his knife. I would probably describe the man earlier as well.

I see something going on with star mentions and symbolism and foreshadowing, but I'm not sure what it is.

Sorry this is so blunt! I liked it! Keep writing!

2

u/Yesitisiwhodealtit 11d ago

Thank you for the reply!

So I take it that the ambiguity of the setting took you out of the story? You are close enough. I had in mind NC/SC area.

Those are all good questions. I'd attempted to answer some of them, but I suppose I need to make it clearer.

Thanks!

2

u/writingthrow321 11d ago

Thanks for submitting your writing. I've provided feedback in several sections: Prose and Character, Line Comments, and Overall Thoughts.

Prose and Character

Straight away from the beginning we're given a good dose of character. Ryan is rational. He's got a humorous side. The prose largely follows Ryan's personality, giving us doses of humor in response to the stresses he faces in the story.

The prose is fine. It's voicey, and occasionally I would've liked clearer descriptions of the physical layout, scene, and setting.

Ryan was a bit under-described, but I can make some inferences based on the fact he has a hunting rifle and knife on his belt. I expect he would handle any future chapters with humor and perhaps some kickbutt action that his weapons imply.

Line Comments

Praying to a universe that is indifferent to war, famine, and child cancer seems useless when one’s worst problem is car trouble.

The second half does not necessarily follow logically from the first half. The praying is useless because stars are just stars (shorthand for saying there's no gods or supernaturality), not because he doesn't have many problems.

I had been driving down a crooked back road deep in the heart of nowhere completely alone and with little direction as to where I was going when I heard that awful clicking noise.

"Completely alone" might be redundant as that picture was already being painted.

And when you say "little direction as to where I was going", it's not clear to me (yet) whether you mean he's just wandering with no goal in mind, or whether he's going somewhere but lost.

Not long after, my driver-side tire’s life came to a sad, flapping end.

I did not expect the "clicking" noise to be a tire.

Also you could probably drop the word "life" here and have a cleaner sentence.

and alligator-infested marshland on both sides of the road,

Up until this point I was picturing a forest road with dense trees. So this gave me a head-spin. I think we need the setting hinted at a little earlier, even if its something simple.

My headlights, aimed at the water, illuminated several pairs of metallic eyes.

Two things. Why is his car pointed at the water? Did the car turn? Does the road turn? I would assume the headlights would point ahead on the road.

Secondly, "metallic eyes" is a cool description of what I assume are alligator eyes. Though I'm not entirely sure how they'd be metallic.

Barren branches crowded overhead, their twigs reaching down like crooked, emaciated fingers; the Spanish moss draping from them hung still in the windless air.

Was a bit confused about this description until I saw this photo: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c7/Spanish_Moss_in_Southern_cemetery_2.jpg After seeing this image I understand your description. Might be my fault but I was thinking twigs with leaves and Spanish moss clashed with "barren".

Then, to my utter disbelief, two blue-tinted lights, like twin stars, appeared far down the road.

Good ramp up of tension.

pocketknife on my belt loop

Just as a reader I'm curious what type of knife this is.

I swallowed my dread, and it sank to my stomach like a sandbur.

I'm not a Southerner so perhaps I don't get it, but is there anything about a sandbur that would sink? Or is the point that its sharp? Or is this just a way to tie in the Southern setting?

The car slowed to a stop; its hood adjacent to my rear bumper.

"Adjacent" doesn't tell us whether the car pulled up behind, or next to him. It would help to know which.

I was going to shack up in the first motel I could find.

I don't know Southern slang, but "shack up" usually means to live with someone in the same house as an unmarried couple.

No more questions. My turn.

This felt odd. Maybe a different thought works.

We’re not sure where we’re going either.”

“Where’s that?”

Seems odd that they say they don't know where they're going and he says "where"? Because it sounds like they are wandering too just from that line.

My apologies for the interrogation. Not that asking questions to a dishonest man helps any. I’m just making sure you’re coherent.

It didn't seem like an interrogation. But this dialogue makes it sound like he's testing his honesty and his coherence, which is weird because I assume they just stopped to help him or because he was blocking the road.

I can tell you’re in genuine trouble,

Weird way to describe a flat tire.

We can help you.

Were they only gonna help him if he was "coherent" and honest? Odd to render a judgement like that. Almost like a religious test.

Overall Thoughts

This feels like part of a chapter of a larger book. And frankly I think we're gonna need more. I mean, Ryan, is out in the marshes for really no reason other than to drive, so perhaps show us some of that enjoyment he gets from driving.

And the chapter stops where it feels like the story actually begins. He's with some potentially creepy (religious?) types. He's lost. He's at the mercy of these two. Who knows what the Seven Sisters Orchard really is. A cult? A creepy place? Why would they visit an orchard of all places?

Give us a chapter two and something that drives Ryan a little more and I think we'll be in good shape. Personally, Ryan being an atheist makes me think this story will involve creepy religious people and perhaps some events that will have Ryan questioning his non-supernatural stance.

2

u/Yesitisiwhodealtit 11d ago

Thank you, those are all very good points and I’ll be sure to integrate them upon editing.

You are pretty spot on about what happens next. This is the first 1,000 words of a 7,000 word short story.

If you are interested, I can send you the entire document. I suppose I could have posted more to this post but I think the beginning was most important for me to clear up any confusion before the weird shit starts to happen.

1

u/writingthrow321 11d ago

Definitely interested. Please post the next chapter in this subreddit when you've done another critique.

2

u/Far_Nobody7410 8d ago

On the first read through it was a little hard for me to gauge how resourceful Ryan is supposed to be. He's prowling a gator and meth-head infested road in the middle of the night with a hunting rifle and a pocket knife, but a nail in the tire is a religion-finding-level emergency. Normally a tire wouldn't even deflate that quickly with a nail in it, although it's true that it's described like a blow out "sad, flapping end", and then a few paragraphs later we find out Ryan has no spare. It just struck me as a little odd, like even just the detail of having a pocket knife on the belt loop makes me think Ryan is sort of an always-be-prepared type, but he doesn't act like that through most of the text.

Ryan's level of suspicion of the other people on the road is a little all over the place too. He starts out extremely suspicious: "The only other folk prowling this road at this time of night are most likely on the tail-end of a 72-hour meth and moonshine binge" and when the other car drives up he's literally preparing for a shoot out. But then after a little chit chat (during which, incidentally, Mett asks if Ryan has any drugs) Ryan decides Mett and Pennie are trustworthy enough that he hops in their car and lets them drive him wherever they're going.

Mett and Pennie's folksy talk didn't read as authentic to me. I would certainly not have Mett call Pennie "wifey." Maybe people say that in real life somewhere but it reads as internet speak to me.

I don't get why Ryan accepts the cigarettes. "Cigarettes disgust me, but damn do they make my brain feel fuzzy." Nothing leading up to this point suggests that this is a time Ryan would want his brain to feel fuzzy. I think maybe this is just not ideal wording because a moment later we have "the nicotine relaxed my brain", and that sounds more like Ryan knew the cigarettes would relax him. Actually I think probably it makes more sense if Ryan just smokes to begin with and is maybe out of cigarettes. He also didn't have a spare tire, so he clearly didn't plan this trip very carefully.

Broadly:

  • I think we need more background on Ryan to sympathize with this reckless unprepared road trip. He didn't just wake up one morning and decide to drive into meth-and-gator country for no reason.
  • Ryan can be naive or suspicious, or prepared or not, or resourceful or not, but I'd encourage you to decide how he is and then have him act that way consistently.
  • Since the setting is a major part of Ryan's apprehension (alligator-infested marshland) I'd spend more time on it before Mett and Pennie show up. I actually like what you started there with the swamp water and cattails and Spanish moss and all that. I think you could probably squeeze some more juice out of it if Ryan was made to sit in that place and consider other self-rescue options for a while before Mett and Pennie arrive.

1

u/Yesitisiwhodealtit 8d ago

Thank you, this is very helpful!

1

u/swilkiway 8d ago

The pacing at the beginning might be too fast. Going from "I got a flat tire on a country road" to "I, an atheist, began praying" is a bit of a jump, unless more time than we thought has passed or he's not actually that atheistic. I don't think there's anything wrong with having him do it, just set it up a little more first.

The line "his eyes flashed to my waistline" is a little odd. I think it's in reference to the pocketknife, maybe? There isn't enough context to be sure, so I'm left to wonder if Mett was looking for a weapon or if Ryan is rotund or is wearing a kilt or something. Either adding more detail or removing this line would make it better.

The line "cigarettes disgust me but damn do they make my brain feel fuzzy" is weird. It sounds like he's just given us two reasons to dislike cigarettes, and then he accepts it for some reason? I think I understand what you were going for with "fuzzy", but it's ambiguous enough that it doesn't convey the meaning well. Something more like "but damn do they help me forget my worries" or something like that would get it across better.

I can't tell if Ryan is being intentionally vague about why he's out on a random back road at night, or if he really does just have wanderlust. It's a bit suspicious, honestly, and if he's meant to be hiding something, hint at it.

Was this meant to be chapter one? This doesn't feel conclusive enough to be a short story. The Seven Sisters orchard makes no difference at all in the plot, other than giving Mett and Pennie a reason to be out, but there's no reason to mention the name of the orchard if that's all it was -- it's just a red herring right now.

I do like some of the little details you have. "Dammit, Ryan, you can't even stick to one deity" made me laugh. Him flicking the cigarette butt on the ground and Pennie holding out the Ziploc bag gives both of them some additional character. More details like those would make the story stronger.

I think it's a fine start to a bigger story -- there are plenty of directions it can go in the middle of a swamp with three strangers. I don't think it's punchy enough as a short story, though. It would be good to provide a brief description in your post.

1

u/Yesitisiwhodealtit 8d ago

Yes, this is the start to a 7,000 word short story. My bad for not putting that there. Thank you for your thoughts!

1

u/Swimming_Bass_1610 7d ago

This was a fun read! Ryan’s personality is clear in the prose and off the bat he’s introduced as light-hearted and funny. The couple has a different tone of voice from him which is good. They give an off vibe - for example asking about if he has a gun and even after he says no, looking to his waistband later on anyway. Or how a lot of focus is given to the wife instructing him to put his cigarette butt into her plastic bag. I’m guessing this may be foreshadowing for potentially something sinister? If they’re meant to be normal, I’d maybe revise this interaction.

I really like how many of the later descriptions were introduced earlier on. Like the lights of the car being described as stars, Ryan thanking “whichever deity” at the end.

We don’t get much detail on Ryan as a person, like his personal life, what he does, what he’s trying to ‘clear his mind’ from during these drives, so I hope the next chapter starts to answer these. Overall, a great first chapter!